The Ancestor is Incompetent! - Reviews

The Ancestor is Incompetent!
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about the whole drinking scene with Ruan Jinghu and Qi Hongzhi because my skin is literally crawling. On the surface this is supposed to be a wholesome friendship moment, right? Junior brothers bonding after the Deacon ceremony, sharing wine, opening up about life philosophy. Classic cultivation novel bro bonding vibes. But something about it felt... off. And I think it's because Li Yuan's internal narration contradicts his external behavior so perfectly. When Ruan Jinghu slings his arm around Li Yuan and says 'Let's drink three jars dry in your Small Courtyard today,' Li Yuan is thinking 'Li Yuan immediately grew guarded in his heart, but his face still maintained a slightly reserved appearance.' GUARDED. He's guarded against his own friend. The person who celebrated with him. Who called him a rascal with genuine warmth just moments before. And then the conversation pivots to 'what's most important in this world' and suddenly it's not philosophy anymore, it's a pitch. Ruan Jinghu is selling Li Yuan on a cave abode like a used car salesman. 'We are all trustworthy brothers. Brother Qi and I have a life-and-death friendship, and Junior Brother Li and I share the bond of classmates.' Life-and-death friendship with Qi Hongzhi but Li Yuan just gets 'bond of classmates.' The hierarchy in that sentence alone is brutal. But what really got me was Li Yuan's performance. He actively lies about having PTSD from a mortal swordsman. He deliberately demonstrates his Spiritual Power Dissipation to make himself look useless. He's manipulating his 'friends' back, playing the weak little brother they can exploit. And honestly? It kind of broke my heart a little. This is a guy who can't afford to have enemies, can't afford to seem weak in cultivation terms, so he weaponizes weakness itself. He's performing incompetence to survive in a world that eats the incompetent for breakfast. The emotional intelligence here is terrifying and impressive in equal measure. I keep replaying Li Yuan's line 'If you don't believe me, I'll demonstrate it for you.' He's volunteering to prove how useless he is. Who does that? Who actively seeks to be seen as worthless by people they're trying to impress? Only someone who's been burned before and knows exactly how the game works. The tragedy is that I don't know if Li Yuan even realizes how alone he actually is.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is almost entirely ceremonial, and that's the point. Every conversation Li Yuan has follows the same pattern: someone offers him something (instruction, permission, advice), and he accepts with excessive politeness. But beneath the courtesy runs a current of calculation so constant it becomes its own voice. Elder Feng's opening lines set the tone immediately. 'Kid, of this batch of twelve Jia Wood Puppets, you'll be responsible for carving three. That will be enough.' Short, functional, slightly dismissive. The elder doesn't ask Li Yuan what he wants or what he's capable of - he assigns and moves on. And Li Yuan's response is perfect in its submission: 'Many thanks, Elder, for your generous instruction! This disciple will do his utmost to complete the task!' The exclamation marks are performative. We know he's thanking the elder, but we also know he's already calculated that three puppets means ninety-six restrictions to carve instead of thirty-six, and that he's going to finish them anyway because speed is his only advantage. The gate disciples are the funniest dialogue in the section precisely because they think they're being helpful. 'Junior Brother Li, be careful going down the mountain alone. Why not ask a few fellow disciples to go with you?' And Li Yuan's reply - 'This Junior Brother doesn't have a wide circle of friends and has always preferred to cultivate diligently, so I'm used to traveling alone' - is one of those lines that sounds humble but actually hurts. He's not declining because he's antisocial; he's declining because he literally cannot reveal his capabilities to anyone, even seemingly friendly ones. The second gate disciple offering talisman advice is genuinely warm, and that's what makes it painful. 'Remember to buy a few to keep on you for emergencies, lest you get injured by those mortal warriors again.' This person means well. They've probably seen disciples hurt before. They're giving advice that comes from care, not strategy. And Li Yuan has to accept it graciously while knowing that mortal warriors are the least of his problems if anyone discovers what he's hiding. What strikes me most about the narrative voice is its chronic unreliability when it comes to Li Yuan's internal state. The narrator tells us Li Yuan 'kept the smile on his face' but never tells us what he was actually feeling. Li Yuan 'steelying his heart' before the stone stele pledge - that's the closest we get to raw emotion, and it's framed as a decision, not a feeling. The narration treats vulnerability as something to be managed, not expressed. The few lines where the narrative voice breaks from Li Yuan's perspective to deliver exposition about the cultivation system - the explanation of why the sect shares restrictions so freely, the description of the three-part versus four-part puppet refinement process - feel almost clinical. They read like textbook entries inserted into a personal journal, which is exactly what this novel seems to be: a record of someone documenting a world they can't fully participate in. And yet there's poetry in the restraint. 'Snow fell before the court, and great cold covered the thousand mountains. Winter passed and spring returned. Snow melted into flowing water, and the birds gradually began to sing in the mountains.' That's not dialogue. That's the narrator breathing, letting the seasons pass in four sentences while Li Yuan's cultivation progresses in five years. The voice knows when to speak and when to let time do the talking.
... Read More
There's a scene in here that I keep coming back to, and it's not the dramatic stone stele transformation or the spirit wood world. It's the moment after Li Yuan finishes thirty days of carving restrictions and walks out of the secret hall. His face is haggard. Seven or eight other disciples from his rotation are with him, all dragging their exhausted bodies. No one has energy to chat. They just go back to their cave abodes separately. That image of collective exhaustion, of people who share a grueling experience but don't even have the strength to acknowledge each other, captures the isolation of this cultivation world better than any description of the sect's politics ever could. The spirit wood world itself is described with an almost religious reverence. Hundred-year spirit woods, countless and inexhaustible, with deeper forests beyond that are clearly even more precious. The text doesn't just tell us the value - it makes us feel the weight of standing in a treasury that could buy kingdoms and having absolutely no way to spend it. Li Yuan's laughter in that forest, wild and unrestrained, is the only time in this entire section where he lets himself feel something without calculating the cost. The stone stele transforming into an arched gate is one of those moments that feels cinematic without trying to be. The text simply says it moved and became a gate, and Li Yuan walked through. No fanfare, no explosion of light, just a door opening onto infinite possibility. The description of the thousand-year inheritance of the Grand Heavenly Sect - how even the Linglong School with Golden Core Perfected Masters could only call themselves a 'School' while only a True Monarch could establish a 'Sect' - that worldbuilding detail does heavy lifting. It tells us about the power structures in this universe without a single exposition paragraph. The Wenshan Market section is sparse but functional. Two-to-three hundred li away, reachable by foot in a day, serving a ten-thousand-li radius. The fact that the Grand Spirit Gate is the closest sect to this market isn't accidental worldbuilding - it establishes Li Yuan's position in the ecosystem. He's peripheral but not isolated, close enough to opportunity but far enough that he has to plan carefully. The visual of the jade-green treasure leaf carrying twenty to thirty children across the sky, led by an Old Daoist with Late-stage Qi Refining aura, is stunning. It's color (jade-green), scale (twenty to thirty children), and hierarchy (the elder leading them) all compressed into one flying snapshot. Li Yuan just stands there and watches, bowing respectfully while his own power level hasn't moved in half a decade. The cave abode with weeds and moss growing in the rarely visited courtyard - five years of neglect captured in botanical detail. The osmanthus tree in the courtyard withering day by day while he cultivates, snow falling before spring birds returning, the seasons cycling while his body purifies itself internally. This is worldbuilding through environmental change rather than description. The world isn't just a backdrop; it's a measuring stick for how much time has passed. And that final image of Li Yuan heading south past the main gate, two Mid-stage Qi Refining Deacons standing watch beside enormous dormant Jia Wood Puppets - the security theater of a sect that reveres ancient ways and punishes internal harm with Soul-Drawing and Spirit-Refining. The world feels governed, ordered, and deeply dangerous for someone like Li Yuan who has to navigate it all while carrying mountains of secret wealth he can never touch.
... Read More
This guy is fascinating in the most understated way possible. I love how carefully he manages his entire existence. He doesn't just wear a mask and change clothes at the market—he actively plays the part of a rogue cultivator so perfectly that even shopkeepers have no idea who he really is. When he says his surname is Wang and sells himself as someone preparing to break through to Mid-stage, nobody questions it. That's not just caution, that's performance art. What really got me though was this line: 'In truth, he had very little experience in Magical Combat, and his actual fighting strength was pitifully weak. He was self-aware.' You know what? I respect him more for admitting that than any arrogant MC who brags about their strength. He knows exactly what he is, and he doesn't try to fake it when it matters. Instead of pretending to be some hidden master, he literally borrows the tiger's might by putting on his sect robes on the way back—just enough to make people give him a wide berth. And remember six years ago? Nearly stabbed through the throat by a mortal swordsman. That one incident shaped everything about how he moves through the world now. He carries a Vajra Talisman constantly, like an emotional scar turned into practical habit. There's also something kind of touching about how humble his goals are. He's not dreaming of conquering the world. He just wants to break through to Mid-stage. And when he finally does? He goes back to the sect and plays it off as 'just lucky.' Meanwhile everyone else is losing their minds. His relationship with the other disciples is telling too. He greets them politely, smiles, plays the harmless junior brother. No drama, no showing off. I just keep waiting for the day this level of careful planning is tested, because someone who moves this quietly is either already prepared for anything or dangerously blind to what's coming.
... Read More
This is the kind of setup that keeps me up at night — not because of flashy battles, but because the stakes are quietly devastating. Li Yuan just gained a cultivation speed that should make him a prodigy. His Qi Refining will advance years faster. And the very next scene? He can't even jump off a plank of wood without his own feet betraying him. He's literally weaker than he was five minutes ago. What does he stand to lose if he's assigned to a mundane duty while his arts are dormant? Not just embarrassment — in a world where 'magical combat is forbidden in the mountains' but respect is earned through power, looking weak is a survival problem. The mockery from those disciples isn't humor; it's social predation. And Ruan Jinghu stepping in isn't pure kindness either — the text tells us directly: Li Yuan helped him with schoolwork. This is transactional loyalty, and it's the only kind available to someone with no family connections and a spiritual root that may never fully recover. Elder Yun's announcement compounds everything: the rotation shortens from three months to two. More labor, less cultivation time, but the compensation increases only marginally — half a jin of Spirit Rice and free access to a book. It's a bargain dressed as mercy. The Death Cave threat hanging over evaders turns every idle moment into calculated risk. And the ending — Li Yuan, vulnerable, heading into a scorching hall full of puppets and restriction-carving work, assigned the 'good' duty that's actually isolation — I'm genuinely worried for him. The next battle won't be physical; it'll be political. And he's walking into it with half his weapons offline.
... Read More
There's a layer of meaning running through all of this that most readers probably glide right over, and I can't stop thinking about it. Li Yuan literally cannot cultivate Magical Arts—his body rejects them, the green bricks tremble beneath his feet. But he's incredibly good at building puppets. Puppets that follow his commands. Puppets that don't have the capacity to betray him, to be tempted by profit, to make selfish choices when treasures are distributed. He crafts controlled extensions of himself in a world where every other cultivator is an unpredictable variable. That quote about not betting his life on what people would do when tempted? It's not just pragmatism—it's philosophy. In a world where cultivation amplifies desire and power corrupts, the puppet is the only honest companion. It wants nothing. It fears nothing. It only obeys. Then there's the Profound Origin Myriad Wood World itself—this pocket dimension that grows stronger each time he uses it, that rewards him with furnaces and fire, that contains hundred-year Qingchen Trees waiting to be harvested. It's basically a metaphor for accumulated advantage. The longer he plays the long game, the richer his private world becomes. While others chase quick power through exploration and risky expeditions, his secret grows in silence. And the Stone Stele line—"Received the rites and the seal, gained the Sect's Fortune"—that connects personal cultivation to institutional belonging. He's not just getting stronger; he's being absorbed into the system. But the system is also feeding him. There's a transaction here that hasn't been fully revealed yet.
... Read More
I am obsessed with the Deacon Assembly scene. The way the author builds this whole sequence from the ground up — it starts with disciples rushing to Fengxian Myriad Immortal Plaza, and then the visual unfolds like a camera panning across a painting. Eighteen Crimson Gold Giant Pillars stood tall in the plaza. That image alone — eighteen pillars, crimson gold, towering over everything — and I immediately understood the scale and importance of this event. This isn't some casual gathering. This is architecture as power. Then the Peak Masters arrive and the author gives us two contrasting portraits in one breath: Wang Qiu, stern and solemn in his fifties, radiating authority, versus Helian Wei, a young handsome scholar in his twenties wearing white, making female disciples 'reluctant to look away.' The visual contrast between these two peak masters tells you everything about the sect's structure — Qi Peak is old guard, traditional, martial. Spirit Peak is... something else. Glamorous, maybe younger energy, but also clearly less respected given how Wang Qiu immediately corners him about having only one disciple at the assembly. But the moment that really sold me was the blood oath ceremony. Five disciples kneeling, bit their index fingers, drops of essence blood absorbed by a treasure decree that functions like a soul lamp tracking their life status from tens of thousands of miles away. This is the kind of detail that makes a cultivation world feel REAL. It's not just 'they became正式 disciples now.' There's a spiritual contract, a tracking mechanism, a permanent bond to the sect written in their blood. The line 'Only after undergoing this procedure were they considered true disciples of the Grand Spirit Gate' hit me like a statement of fact — this is just how the world works, and the horror of it is understated to perfection. And then the puppets. Five green spiritual lights transforming into puppets holding wooden swords and magic bows. A free mid-stageQi Refining puppet for every new deacon. The worldbuilding implication here is massive — the sect distributes combat power through artificial means, puppets are so normalized that they're basically graduation gifts. This is a cultivation world where your fighting ability might literally be crafted by someone else's hands, given to you as a rite of passage. The entire ecosystem of the sect — its economy, its power structure, its traditions — all compresses into scenes like this without a single info-dump paragraph.
... Read More
That opening image hits me so hard I literally sat up straight reading it: glowing script swimming into his palm 'like tadpoles' — living, wriggling, impossible. The author makes a cultivation technique feel biological, almost invasive. You don't just read a manual; you swallow it alive. And then the backlash — Divine Sense snapping, consciousness plunging — followed by the most tender cut to black I've seen this year: no dramatic music, no narration, just the sun crossing the sky and a single osmanthus petal landing on his face, tickling him awake. It's a full day compressed into one gesture. The courtyard at dusk, petals in his hair, hands instinctively reaching for tea — that mundane habit returning as an anchor. I re-read that transition three times because it's flawless. Then later, the Spirit Peak Grand Hall materializes through temperature and architecture: 'a blast of scorching heat' pouring out as he steps into the Secret Hall, 'puppets, each a zhang tall,' eight or nine disciples bent over them in near-meditative concentration. The heat becomes a sensory shorthand for the whole industry below — fire furnaces, refining, urgency. And of course the Death Cave gets its one sentence and it's enough: 'teeming with Yin Spirits and Ghosts,' fate worse than death, Three Hun and Seven Po devoured. The author doesn't describe the cave at all and I somehow know exactly what it looks like. The world feels earned. Every location has a smell, a temperature, a reason for existing. I can map this sect in my head.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is genuinely excellent. Let me trace the rhythm: We open with Li Yuan refusing the cave invitation—low stakes, character moment. Then it drops into a detailed puppet-crafting sequence that could easily become tedious, BUT the author saves it by having the Divine Sense exhaustion create a natural time skip. Two days of sleep. Wake up refreshed. The rain outside. The osmanthus petals on the ground. A full sensory reset. "It's autumn again"—what a tiny line but it does so much work. It tells us time has passed, that Li Yuan has been grinding in isolation, that the world outside keeps moving while he cultivates. And then immediately after: his Divine Sense grew stronger. So the time skip serves double duty—pacing breath AND power progression. Then the chapter shifts gears entirely to the Mundane Duties Rotation, and we go from quiet courtyard introspection to a grand hall full of political undercurrents. The transition isn't jarring because Li Yuan's walk there—practicing Light Body Technique, arriving early, seeing the other five disciples—acts as a bridge between the personal and the institutional. The elder's dialogue at the end carries that dual rhythm: surface-level warmth, underneath-strategic assessment. And the closing exposition about the Wang Clan and the 60-year cycle? That's a cliffhanger disguised as world-building. It raises the stakes from personal survival to institutional survival without ever showing a single fight scene.
... Read More
I need to talk about this marketplace scene because it's honestly one of the most atmospheric passages I've read in this genre. Let me set it up for you— 'The night was even livelier than the day. All sorts of lanterns were hung up, and various colorful spiritual lights flickered, illuminating the shop signs as if it were daytime.' That image alone is enough to paint the whole picture. A fortified mountain peak, flattened by force, now glowing with artificial daylight made from spiritual energy. It feels ancient and magical but also deeply practical—like a border town between the mortal world and the cultivation world, exactly the kind of place where information, contraband, and danger all converge. And the political map underneath it all! Four powers running this thing like a corporate joint venture. Grand Spirit Gate gets 20%, Clear Wind Pavilion gets 10%, Xu Clan gets 20%, and the Wang Clan—oh the Wang Clan gets fifty percent. Half the profits, and they're not even the closest landlord. 'No one dared to say anything about them taking a larger share of the profits than the others.' This one sentence tells you more about the power structure of the entire region than half the exposition dumps I've slog-reading through. There's a whole economy here. Demon beasts are dwindling. Spirit herb prices are rising. Pills that should cost 50-60 stones now go for 74-88. This isn't just background flavor—it's worldbuilding that makes you feel the economic pressure on ordinary cultivators like Li Yuan. He's budgeting every stone. He can't even afford an inn because 'spending Spirit Stones for a night's rest was far too extravagant.' Even the wealthiest powers can't escape inflation here. By the time he's sitting in that old tree meditating at midnight, the whole world feels alive and breathing. Not a single sect hall or mystical mountain peak—just a struggling guy in a tree, sharing shade with a stranger, both of them too poor for better accommodations. And yet it's still beautiful.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is doing some serious heavy lifting, and I want to zoom in on Ruan Jinghu because his voice is so distinctly constructed. Ruan Jinghu speaks in booms. 'Junior Brother Li, you rascal! You actually became a Deacon Disciple!' — rough voice, table-slapping energy, immediate physical contact (the arm-slinging later). He doesn't have conversational nuance, he has volume and impulse. And the author never lets him sound smarter than he is: 'I have a High-rank Human Grade Spiritual Root, and with the help of Spirit Pills and a compatible Cultivation Art, that's how I was able to enter Mid-stage Qi Refining so quickly.' That's not a humble brag, that's an accidental confession of exactly how the system works. Ruan Jinghu doesn't even realize he just handed Li Yuan the cheat code to understanding the sect's power structure. Qi Hongzhi is the foil, and his dialogue is calibrated differently. Every sentence comes with a smile. 'I am Qi Hongzhi. Congratulations, Junior Brother, on becoming a Deacon Disciple!' Polite, measured, but there's always something slightly off about it — like the courtesy is armor. When he chimes in about Fortune being the most important thing, it's not random philosophy, it's setup. His dialogue is always three steps ahead of the conversation. But Li Yuan's voice is what surprised me. The author gives him this remarkable range between internal monologue and external speech. Internally: sharp, calculating, hyper-aware of every implication. Externally: sheepish, hesitant, stuttering ('Th-this...', 'I-It's true', 'Th-This...'). The speech impediments that appear when he's performing weakness are a stylistic choice that pays off — they make his lies physically manifest in his voice. And then there's the direct quote that perfectly captures his narrative voice: 'Li Yuan naturally understood their intentions.' No elaboration needed. Three words and we know he sees the trap forming. The drinking scene conversation is essentially a verbal sparring match where everyone is speaking two languages at once — the surface conversation about philosophy and fortune, and the subtext about power, utility, and exploitation. That's masterful dialogue writing.
... Read More
Let me just say it straight: this is why I can't look away. The entire sequence from Li Yuan entering Wenshan Market to the moment he emerges as Mid-stage Qi Refining is a masterclass in sustained tension. Not because there are explosions or betrayals, but because the stakes feel genuinely real. He enters the market with limited funds. Demon beast populations are declining. Pill prices have skyrocketed. He negotiates with Shopkeeper Xu, who's not a villain—just a businessman doing his job—and Li Yuan still walks out poorer than he came in. Then he can't even afford the talismans he originally planned to buy. Budget crisis. That's a problem you feel in your gut. Then comes the breakthrough itself. This is where it gets nail-biting. He swallows that Black Smoke Python Heart Pill, and the text says: 'A pure, warm, and cool water qi rushed into his heart, carrying his Spiritual Power through the nine Key Apertures, finally entering the Heart Acupoint.' But before that—'the resistance suddenly increased dramatically.' His entire cultivation is on the line. If he fails here, everything he's saved for, every stone, every calculated risk, goes down the drain. Six years of near-death caution, all compressed into one irreversible moment. And you know what? He succeeds. But the author doesn't let him celebrate. No, instead we get: 'It was more than ten days later before he finally opened his eyes.' Ten. Days. He's locked in a cave, vulnerable, possibly unconscious, while the outside world keeps spinning. Someone could break in. Someone could find him. The narrative never forgets that danger exists even in success. But here's the thing—the most terrifying stakes aren't external. They're social. He returns to find disciples震惊 at his breakthrough. An Elder notices him personally. These are the people who could help him, yes—but they're also the people who could see through his carefully constructed ordinary facade. He's gained power, but he's also become visible. And visibility in this world is dangerous.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or