Naegi Makoto's Introduction to Drinking Studies - Reviews

Naegi Makoto's Introduction to Drinking Studies
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
'I'm disqualified as a disciplinary committee member! I can't bear it! Naegi! I'm so pathetic I can't stand myself! Hit me with all your might!' — said NO ONE normally but somehow ISHIMARU absolutely NAILING it here. This man walks into Naegi's room, sees the whiskey bottles everywhere, and instead of lecturing him like a proper disc comm member he just... hugs him and starts WAILING. Then does DOGEZA. KNEELS ON THE FLOOR apologizing for prejudicing someone. The emotional whiplash in this chapter is incredible. Naegi's inner monologue is giving me life though — 'As expected, Ishimaru seemed to be in such great shock that he couldn't form proper words, and his face twisted into an indescribable expression, as if he'd just seen a pile of excrement lying blatantly on the street.' My stomach hurts from laughing. And then he offers Ishimaru brandy to 'clear his head' like a bad parent. The dialogue between them is so natural — Ishimaru going from furious to devastated to prostrate in like thirty seconds. Meanwhile Naegi is just internally screaming 'Could this be some kind of hidden camera prank from Ishimaru?' while watching a grown man cry into his floor. The contrast between Naegi's deadpan internal voice and everyone else's dramatic energy is chef's kiss. Also Monokuma's pun at the beginning: 'instead of drinking alcohol, make sure you do some drinking (alcohol)' — that man has no soul and I respect it.
... Read More
The atmosphere in these chapters is so meticulously constructed, I keep going back to how the physical space mirrors the psychological state of everyone involved. The 2nd floor opening isn't just a new area—it's a literal elevation of tension. Monokuma frames it as 'a new world has opened up' and that's exactly what it feels like. The students have been surviving on the 1st floor with relative stability, and now the ground beneath them has shifted again. But the real standout scene is the bathhouse changing room. Steam, no cameras, enclosed space with one exit—and Naegi positioning himself right there, ready to bolt. The setting does so much heavy lifting. You can feel the humidity, the vulnerability of a bathing area, the absence of Monokuma's surveillance creating this rare pocket of private conversation in a world where privacy is the ultimate luxury. It's intimate and threatening at the same time. The envelope scene is another masterclass in atmospheric tension. Monokuma produces this stack of envelopes, each with a student's name, and the way he stops them from opening them immediately—'Kyao! Don't look now! If you look now, you'll get a penalty!'—creates this shared moment of suspended dread. Fifteen people, fifteen secrets, all held in their hands but forbidden from reading. The visual of everyone frozen, envelopes in hand, staring at Monokuma like he's lost his mind? Cinematic. Even the classroom assembly where Monokuma explains everything has this oppressive quality. He's performing for an audience of terrified students, pacing around, making grand announcements, and they're all just... trapped. Listening. Having no choice but to absorb every word. The setting reinforces the powerlessness, and that's exactly what makes the world feel so suffocatingly real.
... Read More
I cannot stop thinking about how Monokuma's dialogue in this section is absolutely perfect. He starts with this ridiculous 'drumroll please' energy, talking about the 2nd floor opening like it's some grand celebration. And then he just casually drops 'Upupu, and the grand bathhouse is open too, so how about some erotic mixed bathing?' Like, buddy, we are NOT in the mood. The tonal whiplash is intentional and it works so well because it makes you simultaneously want to laugh and want to scream. His explanation of the class trial rules is delivered with this mocking, educational-philosophy angle—'It's my educational philosophy to give a reward for passing a test!' That voice, that gleeful cruelty, it's so distinct from every other character. He treats murder and graduation like they're part of a school festival. The contrast between his cheerful tone and the horrifying content is what makes him unforgettable. But what I really want to highlight is how differently the students talk to each other. Oowada's all aggression—'You damn bastard, what are you planning?' Kuwata's pure panic, Fukawa's hyperventilating, and then Kirigiri cuts through all of it with this calm, precise logic: 'There are fifteen of us. Do you really think you can find and hide your note with a 1 in 15 probability?' She doesn't raise her voice, she doesn't panic, she just dismantles everyone's fear with math. That's her voice, and it's so satisfying. Naegi's internal monologue is quieter, more uncertain, which makes his external voice feel earned when he finally speaks up. 'First, how about we all cool our heads?' Not a command, he specifically frames it as a request. That's who he is—he leads by asking, not by ordering. Even Ishimaru's military-tone insistence on following Naegi feels right for his character. Everyone sounds like themselves.
... Read More
I am literally unwell right now. Let me just say that first. The flashback portion from Mukuro's perspective is the kind of character work that makes you put the book down and just stare at the wall. Here's this girl who spent TWO YEARS not talking properly to Naegi, not because she hated him, but because she couldn't stand the thought of lying to his face. Think about that. She was trained as an Ultimate Soldier, she was part of the Ultimate Despair, she had every reason to play along—but she couldn't bring herself to look him in the eye and give him a fake smile. And then he stopped trying. And her heart ached. Two full years of quiet avoidance, and she thought it was for the best until she realized it wasn't. When Naegi confronts her in the present, she's wearing Junko's face—a disguise that represents everything she's supposed to be—and he calls her out on it. But here's what destroys me: she's NOT pretending anymore when she grabs his arm. She throws off the wig. She drops the act. For the first time in two years, she's speaking as Mukuro, not as someone hiding behind a mask. And Naegi? His reaction is so genuinely painful. He's not cruel, he's just... tired. Disappointed. He thought she'd be different from Junko. That line—'I thought you'd at least be someone I could talk to'—that cuts both ways because it shows that Naegi had held hope for her. He hadn't written her off completely. And when she breaks down and he holds her anyway? That's not just kindness, that's the culmination of two years of unspoken connection on both sides. The relationship between these two is one of the most quietly devastating things in this entire story.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or