A retired factory director who was on an inspection tour with several accompanying officials. He observed Ning You's public performance and commented that she had a nice voice and would probably sing opera beautifully. He expressed sympathy for the girl's rough treatment. He criticized Ning Zhongyi's character, stating that while Ning had ability, he was too muddled in personal matters and not fit for important responsibilities. He stated he would choose someone with good character for promotion over those with similar abilities but questionable morality.
