Wouldn't It Be Better to Marry the Eldest Son Instead? - Reviews

Wouldn't It Be Better to Marry the Eldest Son Instead?
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The stakes here are actually terrifying and I love it. Flora is in a foreign land, stripped of her maid, forced to wear these ridiculous nun-like outfits, and locked in a house full of people who want her dead. But the real kicker is the heir situation. If she doesn't bear a child, she dies. If Emeric doesn't want a child with her, she dies. It's framed as 'that's just how things are done here' by Tanya, which somehow makes it even worse because it's presented as normal. Flora even asks 'what if Emeric doesn't want a child with me?' and Tanya just says 'that too will be blamed on you.' This is the kind of setup that makes you grip the book tighter because there's genuinely nowhere to run. Even when Emeric comes to her room that night—after saying he wouldn't—he's not warm or kind, but he does warn her about poisoning, about how Blois can't protect her just like Charllon couldn't protect his aunt. The conflict is layered: Flora vs. the Blois family, Flora vs. her own circumstances, Flora vs. the political machinery that sent her here. And the worst part? She's attracted to him despite everything, or at least drawn to him in that helpless way you get when you're alone in hostile territory. When she walks toward him in her thin chemise thinking 'if it means survival, what wouldn't she do?'—chills. Absolute chills.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about Emeric because THIS man. His two letters alone tell you everything you need to know about who he is and how he operates. The first one—where Flora's letter is opened in front of everyone, humiliating her before she's even arrived in Blois—that's not just cruelty, that's strategy. He's establishing dominance before the wedding even happens. But the real masterpiece is his second letter. It's only three sentences and it destroys her completely. "I hope we meet in Blois while you're still alive." Read that again. That's not a threat of violence—that's something worse. That's him treating her survival as the uncertain variable, as if HER living through this marriage is the surprise he's skeptical about. He's been waiting for her to break and she just handed him the proof she would. Then there's Pascal. This man who's never laid a hand on his daughter before, who treasured her her whole life, and then—smack—he slaps her. And the reason? Not hatred. Fear. He's teaching her coldness before she goes to the cold east because he knows he can't protect her anymore. The scene where he leans against the window watching the sunset afterward? That's a father mourning his daughter while she's still alive. It broke me. And Yvonne—oh, Yvonne is such an interesting character. She knows Emeric called Charllon's blood "filthy" and she tells Flora anyway. Is she being honest or is she testing her? Flora grips her hands like she's desperate for any thread of hope, and Yvonne's response is basically the truth delivered like a knife.
... Read More
Let's talk about the nuclear bomb dropped in Chapter 10 because I am SHAKING. "He wondered if, perhaps, it would bring more honor to the family if you ended your own life, rather than being mercilessly abandoned by Blois." HER FATHER. HER ACTUAL BLOOD FATHER asked her future father-in-law to help her kill herself. Not divorce her—DIVORCE would've been almost merciful in this world. He specifically framed suicide as the MORE honorable option. The betrayal isn't just emotional, it's existential. She's trapped in a country where divorce is unthinkable, trapped in a castle where everyone wants her dead, and the person who was supposed to love her unconditionally basically signed her death warrant. What makes this hit harder is how casually Christophe delivers it. He mentions it almost in passing, like he's discussing the weather. "What followed 'cast her aside without mercy' was even more important, but I didn't mention it at the banquet for your sake." For HER sake. He protected her from hearing this at dinner, and then tells her alone on a balcony like it's gossip. The man has no concept of human fragility. And Emeric—oh Emeric. He storms into her sickbed accusing her of hosting secret meetings, completely missing the fact that she's barely conscious, shivering, covered in cold sweat. He's part of the problem AND she has nowhere else to go. The stakes aren't just "will she survive the wedding" anymore. The stakes are "does she have any reason left to want to survive at all." I'm not okay with this.
... Read More
Okay so I need to geek out about the atmosphere in these chapters because the author clearly understands how to use setting as emotional punctuation. The evening banquet scene—"everyone at the table stopped talking about Charllon and resumed their conversations with laughter. It seemed the earlier silence wasn't a family custom, but rather caused by Flora's presence." That's one sentence and it paints the entire social landscape. Flora isn't just unwelcome; her presence itself is a mood killer. She's the live mouse at a dinner party and everyone's pretending not to stare at it. Then there's the bath scene, which is such a small domestic moment but carries so much weight. "Tanya wore a worried look as she poured hot water into the bathtub." Flora forcing herself through this ritual while sweating cold and feeling nauseous, and Tanya—sweet Tanya, the ONLY warm person in this entire story—hauling boiled water THREE TIMES. The contrast between the hostile castle and this tiny act of kindness is devastating. But the balcony scene is where everything comes together visually. Early morning, hazy clouds, muted sunlight, the lake sparkling in the distance. Flora blowing vapor into the cold air and doing it "again and again" like a child discovering something new. The world is unfamiliar, the weather is biting, her body is failing—and yet there's this quiet beauty in the scene that makes it feel almost sacred. Then Christophe appears beside her like a ghost, and the mood shatters. The author keeps shifting between brutal social cruelty and these moments of almost tender isolation, and it creates this atmosphere where every quiet scene feels like it could be the last peaceful moment before everything collapses again.
... Read More
Let's talk about this breakfast scene because WOW. The author really went all out here and I am not okay. From the moment Flora walks in and sees Mikael—description hits you immediately: he's thin, small, light brown hair, gray eyes, looks completely unlike the rest of the Blois family who all have blonde hair and blue-tinged eyes. It's like the camera pans around the table and you see every reaction. The maids snickering, Claudie asking 'how was your first day' with that fake kindness, Emeric mocking her from across the table while pretending to be concerned about her eating. And then Mikael speaks—just one line, 'I want to end my studies abroad now'—and the entire room goes SILENT. Even the servants stop moving. The atmosphere practically crackles. Then Emeric's line about 'what are you up to?' with his eyes burning like flames, and Flora just... collapses. I could feel her heart pounding. The contrast between the warm candlelight of a breakfast setting and the cold hostility of everyone in that room is *chilling*. And then she wakes up alone with just a water pouch on her stomach? The imagery of her sitting there, disheveled, wondering if she'll survive long enough to even get married, is haunting. This isn't just a marriage plot anymore—it's a survival story wrapped in silk and poison.
... Read More
The way the author builds tension across these chapters is masterful. We start with Flora arriving, already depleted from the journey, and the very first conflict is about her maid Ellie being taken away. That's Chapter 6 territory and it establishes the power dynamic immediately—Flora has no one, no support, no control. Then we get the carriage ride where Emeric keeps nitpicking her manners, which is tedious on purpose because we're supposed to feel Flora's exhaustion and irritation. The author makes us sit in that discomfort. And then—BAM—Tanya tells her about the witch-hunt threat. The pacing shifts from slow-burn annoyance to genuine dread in a single conversation. The banquet scene follows and it's like a pressure cooker: the grandmother insults her, Emeric's father reveals her own father told them to discard her, and the room turns hostile. But then the author pulls back. We get the quiet night scene, the dream, the alcohol, and that ambiguous moment with Emeric where nothing definitive happens. It's a breath of relief that quickly becomes its own kind of tension because now we're wondering: what DOES happen between them? The chapters don't rush, but they don't drag either. Each section advances either the plot or Flora's understanding of her danger, and the structure keeps her increasingly isolated while slowly revealing the depth of the threat.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is genuinely exceptional and I keep going back to quote certain exchanges because they're THAT sharp. Let me start with Emeric's most devastating line: "Showing tears is something unheard of in our household." He says this while she's literally crying. Not in anger, not in frustration — in pure wounded pride. And he watches her say it with that blank face. The contempt isn't even emotional on his end, which makes it worse. He's not enjoying her pain, he's just stating a fact the way someone might note the weather. But what's fascinating is how Flora's voice develops through the dialogue. She starts off reactive — protesting, shouting, trembling — but she has moments of genuine wit. When she asks "Are you always so rude?" and he responds "Hearing that from someone who was rude first puts me in a difficult position" — that's actually clever banter. She's not a passive victim here, she fires back. The narrative voice itself is excellent too. It stays tightly close to Flora's perspective without becoming suffocating. Lines like "Her self-mocking reply made her father call out her name loudly" carry so much emotional information in such a clean sentence. The author trusts the reader to understand subtext. Ellie's dialogue is appropriately simple and childlike — "Why do you think so?" "My Lady, you always wear fine clothes, so you might not notice" — which contrasts perfectly with the sophisticated verbal sparring between Flora and Emeric. Even her accidental hiccups when he calls her name tell us more about his presence than any description could. And that final exchange where he offers his hand and she takes it? No dialogue needed. The entire power dynamic of this relationship is contained in that single gesture. She hates him, she fears him, she resents him — but she takes his hand. Because she has to. Because this is her life now. The silence speaks louder than any line either of them could deliver.
... Read More
'Were you running away earlier?' he said, and I swear I laughed out loud at that line because of course he remembers that. Of course he does. This man notices everything and pretends he notices nothing. The moment where he undresses himself instead of calling servants—because apparently he remembered she was flustered and didn't want her uncomfortable—is the most quietly devastating thing I've read in months. He doesn't announce it as kindness. He doesn't say 'I thought of you.' He just... does it. And when she offers to help him undress, his immediate deflection with 'Lady Flora, are you out of your mind?' is pure comedic timing but underneath it there's something real. Here's what gets me: they're about to be married by royal decree and already they're negotiating proximity like strangers learning the rules of a game neither of them chose. She curls into a ball in his enormous bed because even his room is colder than anything she's known, and he lies at the opposite end and asks her if she's ever felt something warm in her heart. That's not small talk. That's two people who have never been treated like human beings trying to figure out if the other one is capable of warmth. The nanny stories sequence ruined me. She lists them all—picnics, sunsets, compliments—and then stops mid-sentence because suddenly she's embarrassed that every single happy memory she has involves someone who isn't Emeric. And he says 'It's the first time I've heard only happy stories come from your lips' and I physically cannot. He's been watching her. He's been *listening*. And the tragic irony is that he probably thinks his own life contains zero warm memories worth sharing, which means Flora just accidentally gave two people their first real conversation in years.
... Read More
Okay so I need to process what just happened with Mikael because my brain is still reeling. He's the ELDEST son of Blois but he's NOT the heir. Emeric is the second son and he's the next Duke. This family is SO secretive about it — Flora's trying to figure out if he's illegitimate and the reader is right there with her, desperate for an explanation. And then Emeric shows up out of NOWHERE like 'I really can't stand this' and suddenly we're witnessing a three-way confrontation that reveals MORE questions than answers. The royal connection hit me hard too. Flora had no idea the Blois family was related to the royal family. That's why her father couldn't refuse the marriage — it's not just a royal order, it's a marriage to a ROYAL RELATIVE. This changes everything about why Flora was sent here. She's not just some political pawn, she's part of a much larger game. And then there's Vivian — the girl who was supposed to marry Emeric, now reduced to saying 'You promised me before, remember?' to his face at the breakfast table. Emeric's reaction was... interesting. He spoke kindly to her, then wiped the gentle expression off his face when he looked at Flora and made a face like he'd seen something unpleasant. WHAT does that mean?? The plot is moving so well — every revelation pulls back one curtain only to reveal five more doors.
... Read More
There's a symbolism in these chapters that I can't stop thinking about, and it starts with the color of Emeric's eyes. Flora reads somewhere that blue flames are the hottest, and that detail about him being 'cold, but strangely hot at the same time' is doing so much thematic heavy lifting. He appears cold and distant — the royal decree, the arranged marriage, the refusal to be physically close — but underneath there's this intense heat that flares up the moment Flora threatens to leave. Then there's the dowry versus wedding meal comparison, which is essentially the book telling you in plain numbers that Flora is property with a price tag. Claudie saying 'We paid dearly for you' and then revealing the meal cost twenty times more is the story's economic thesis statement in one conversation. And finally, the cold wind Flora walks through at the end — Blois itself is this frozen, inhospitable place where women need permission to leave, and the 'jungle' metaphor Flora uses the next morning confirms it: this isn't a home, it's a survival environment, and she's still learning which predators are real and which ones might actually protect her.
... Read More
Let me just say — the dialogue in this book is absolutely delicious. Every conversation is a minefield and I love it. Flora and Emeric? Their exchanges are so sharp you could cut glass with them. The way people here speak is completely different from the West. Claudie, for example — she says something like "Emeric is never talkative" and then immediately follows with "He must despise you." Who talks like that?! But also... it's kind of brilliant because it reveals the entire family dynamic in two sentences. Nobody says what they actually mean. They circle around each other like wolves. And Emeric's voice — the narrator specifically points out it's "low, heavy, so different from Mikael's gentle and ordinary tone." That contrast between the two brothers isn't just described, it's woven into how they speak. Mikael says things like "I'm sorry I'm such a powerless eldest son" — self-deprecating on the surface but there's definitely something underneath. You can't trust a single word this family says. The aunt-in-law is my new favorite though. "No matter if it's the king, isn't this marriage just too rude?" She comes in swinging and Flora literally has no idea how to respond. That scene at breakfast where everyone is politely trying to murder each other with their words? Chef's kiss.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—this opening absolutely grabs you by the collar. You have this ridiculous premise: two feuding noble families, zero overlap in personality, zero mutual affection, and the KING just drops a marriage edict on them like it's nothing. The Charllon-Blois feud has been building since the previous generation, right? A love story that ended in death and mystery, and now the kingdom wants to paper over all that trauma with a wedding? The inciting incident hits in Chapter 1 and it's devastating for Flora—not because she doesn't want love, but because she's been lied to her entire life about her own power. Her father told her he was basically the king, and then the king showed up with a decree and Pascal just... folded. That moment where Flora realizes her father was boastful nonsense is such a sharp narrative beat. It's not just about losing a husband. It's about losing your entire worldview. Then Emeric's reply letter arrives and it's exactly four lines. Four. Lines. "Respected Lady Flora. I received your letter a few days ago. However, as it was such an absurd request, I am only replying now out of courtesy. There will never be a change of groom. From Emeric Blois." That's not just cold— that's weaponized brevity. The plot has already set up two people who seem utterly incompatible being forced together, and I am HERE for it. Also the flashback structure in Chapter 2, revealing the origin of the feud through Pascal's memory while he travels to meet Duke Blois—that's textbook expository weaving. You get the history without it feeling like an info-dump. The Blois daughter who died after three years, the suspicious circumstances, the soldiers showing up at the castle gates demanding answers... this feud is built on genuine tragedy, not just petty nobles being jerks. Which means any reconciliation between these families has to actually earn its resolution. The plot stakes are already layered.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or