With Someone Other Than You - Reviews

With Someone Other Than You
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Oh my god, the engagement situation here is actually painful to watch. Let me just say this first: Cyril Frey is the most desperate romantic in literature and he doesn't even know it. The man has been engaged since he was ten years old. Ten. And what does he do for the longest stretch without seeing his fiancée? He sends her flower invitations to every single social event. Every. Single. One. With a polite letter. And she stacks them up unread. The errand boy thinks she's cruel and Cyril is pitiable. I'm on the boy's team but also—not entirely. Meanwhile, Danielle is lying in bed, drenched in cold sweat, thinking about a man she spent one night with while wearing a tortoiseshell mask—and her first instinct is to reassure herself that Cyril isn't someone she should be thinking about because "he was her fiancé, someone she could marry and share a bed with at any time." Like that's a comforting thought and not a horrifying one. She's actively suppressing thoughts of another man by reminding herself she could technically have sex with her boring fiancé whenever she wants. That's not repression, that's a cry for help. And Cyril! He's out there investigating the white-masked woman (who is Danielle, obviously, but he doesn't know that yet) while simultaneously sending her flowers to events she never attends. His hypothesis that the woman is high-ranking nobility because of her black hair and green eyes—he checks every salon, every tea party—and Danielle "never accompanied him to any of these gatherings." Sir, HAVE YOU LOOKED AT YOUR OWN FIANCEE? The tragicomedy of two people who clearly care about each other (in whatever confused way they understand it) missing each other at every turn while one of them is literally sleeping with the other under a mask.
... Read More
This chapter opens with Danielle tying ribbons on a magic mask and ends with a man stepping toward her in a dark garden saying she'd find nothing even if she searched him. That is a THREE-PARAGRAPH journey from getting dressed to facing a threat, and I need to sit down. The pacing here is absolutely ruthless and I respect it. Ivan demonstrates the mask → Danielle tests it herself → cut to the ball → immediate sensory overload (crowds, heat, masks everywhere) → Princess Cléran's entrance → the mosquito repellent speech → the quadrille begins → Danielle escapes → meets the cat-masked man → waltz hijack → West Garden confrontation. Every beat propels you forward. There is nowhere to pause and reconsider whether to keep reading because the chapter doesn't let you. But what's smarter is what the author does with tempo changes. The quadrille in 4/4 time is specifically called out because it lets Danielle move – and then the music shifts to a waltz in 3/4 time, which is when everything changes. The tempo switch mirrors the narrative tempo switch. One moment she's blending in, the next she's forcibly partnered with a stranger and moving toward a confrontation. The structural awareness here is impressive. The 3/4 shift isn't decorative; it's a plot device wearing a musical disguise.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is honestly masterful and I want to break it down because the author knows exactly when to slow down and when to sprint. Let me start with something that caught my attention — the opening of this section. We drop right into Cyril's disoriented state, no transition, no "previously on" nonsense. Just: he's clutching his chest, his head is spinning, and we're immediately in his messy headspace. That's a bold structural choice. The author trusts us to keep up. Then there's the chapter break. Chapter 5 starts with what feels almost like a prologue — a whole exposition dump about the Royal Knights, their declining status, Marcelan's leadership philosophy. On paper, that sounds boring. But the author earns it by immediately pivoting to “Rebellion.” Two words. That contrast — slow worldbuilding → sudden shock — is pure pacing perfection. It's like the author is breathing slowly and then slaps you in the face. The scene with Count Emerich and the duty roster is another pacing gem. It's supposed to be a serious mission briefing, but instead we get this almost comedic moment where the Count admitted he didn't check the roster and his best investigator got assigned to ferry dock mosquito duty. It lightens the mood right before we dive into the darker stuff — the drug, the rebellion, the betrayal. That tonal shift keeps you from getting exhausted. And the structure of the ferry dock reveal? Maurice doesn't just explain everything. He makes Cyril promise secrecy first, struggles to say it, Cyril already understands, and they communicate through looks. The author could have had Maurice give a full paragraph of exposition, but instead压缩成几个沉默的眼神。It's restraint, and it works beautifully.
... Read More
Let's talk about the ending of this chapter because I am STILLrecovering. Danielle thinks she's the predator here. She has the mask, she has the mission, she has the element of surprise. She follows the contact, uses a waltz as tactical cover, leads him to the West Garden, and demands the item. She's in control. Or so she thinks. Then the man says: "Even if I searched you, I doubt I'd find anything." And he steps forward. One step. Then another. Close enough to grab her arm. In that moment, the entire conflict flips. Danielle is the one sweating. She took an instinctive step back. The professional handler became the one being handled, and the author makes you feel every inch of that power reversal through body language alone – no internal monologue, no explanation, just two people in a dark garden and the space between them shrinking. What's terrifying about this scene is that the stakes were already high (undercover at a royal ball, potential compromise, her identity on the line) and then they just multiplied. If THIS man – her contact, supposedly on her side – is capable of this kind of physical positioning and psychological pressure, what does that mean for the smuggling ring she's investigating? What does it mean for the client who sent her? Every question she had going in gets answered with a worse question coming out. The chapter doesn't end with a traditional cliffhanger. It ends with a man mid-step and a woman mid-retreat, and somehow that's even more gripping.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this Lovron Clause because honestly it completely reframes every single interaction Danielle and Cyril have had up to this point. The author just casually drops this whole historical backstory about the Countess of Lovron—conspired with her lover to murder her husband, uttered the words 'irreparable love' before execution—and suddenly your brain goes back rewinding through twelve years of arranged marriage setup and you realize what kind of legal weapon they were born into. What I find brilliant is how the narrative structure works here. You have Danielle walking beside Cyril, they have this awkward silence, he says his father is the only one who believes they'll actually get married, and then later her own father drunkenly tells her he could invoke the clause to set her free. These two revelations bookend each other perfectly—one from Cyril's side, one from hers—and neither of them actually believes the clause is going to save anyone. Danielle literally thinks to herself 'There's no such thing as irrecoverable love in this world.' That line hit me like a truck because it shows how differently she processes romance versus how the contract was written. The plot twist of the chapter isn't even dramatic—it's domestic. It's about cufflinks and shopping trips and accidentally getting warmer to someone over twelve years. But that makes it so much more powerful. The marriage plot has been grinding along like a machine, and suddenly the mechanism itself is shown to have an escape hatch that nobody actually trusts to work.
... Read More
There is a moment in this chapter where Danielle does something that completely betrays who she actually is beneath all that professional training. She's being escorted out of the ballroom by a man she just grabbed off the dance floor. They're moving through shadows, away from light, away from everyone. And she thinks: "If not for the circumstances, she might have considered this an enjoyable moment… one she wouldn't have wanted to end mid-waltz." That's it. That's the entire emotional earthquake. No dramatic confession, no lingering gaze, no hand-holding romance. Just a trained operative who is so accustomed to suppressing everything that even a single unauthorized thought feels like a crisis. And then she recovers. Instantly. She changes her expression, puts on a smile, and goes back to questioning him like nothing happened. But the reader saw it. The reader saw the crack. What makes this hit so hard is the contrast with Cyril. This is her fiancé – the man she's supposed to be with, the man who should be standing beside her at events like this – and yet her involuntary thought during an intimate waltz with a complete stranger is that she doesn't want it to end. The author doesn't moralize about this. Doesn't judge Danielle. Just presents the fact and lets the reader sit with how devastating that fact is. I'm not okay.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or