(Exclusive) Which Family's Young Miss is So Arrogant? - Reviews

(Exclusive) Which Family's Young Miss is So Arrogant?
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me just say—the stakes in this book are NO JOKE. You've got a group of seven traumatized kids, a woman who clearly doesn't belong in this era, sleeping in a half-collapsed house with no door and a roof that might not hold, and EVERYWHERE they go people are hostile. The village shuts gates in their faces. The old man warns her about the beggars—people who stole savings and tried to assault women, martial artists apparently—and the yamen won't even investigate because apparently dead bums don't count as dead people unless someone files a report. This is a world where survival itself is the main quest. But what really got me was that scene with the mouse hole food. Hong Xiaoduo immediately says DON'T EAT THAT, throw it away, because mice go into sewers and graves and carry disease. She has no food to offer them in exchange. No bargaining chip. She's telling seven starving children to go hungry rather than risk poisoning. That's the kind of love that comes from pure protection, not obligation. And then her dream sequence? The Technology Experience Hall, the old curator, the 'cross-timespace contact problem'—something is pulling her somewhere but she can't reach it. She's stuck between two worlds and neither one is holding her safely. The stakes aren't just survival anymore. They're existential.
... Read More
Hong Xiaoduo asks the little girl: 'Look at the stick you're holding, what can it do?' And the girl 'finally loosened her tightly clenched hand.' She picks up the stick and breaks it. The text says: 'the little girl's face immediately showed some embarrassment. She didn't dare to look at Hong Xiaoduo, as if she had done something wrong, but when she saw her brothers looking for weapons, that was all she had.' This dialogue — or rather, this NON-dialogue — is the most devastating thing I've read in months. No words needed. Just a broken stick and a child's shame.
... Read More
Okay so this whole Mu Zitao sequence had me wheezing. Let me just say this: the man is so vain about his looks that when Hong Xiaoduo pointed to his chin to tell him there was wonton wrapper stuck there, his brain went straight to... you know. Shy ladies covering their faces. Blushing women pressing handkerchiefs to their chests. He literally interpreted her practical gesture as flirtation and then felt DISGUSTED when he realized she was just pointing at food debris.
... Read More
The pacing in this section is absolutely relentless and I have zero complaints. We go from a quiet scene of kids roasting wild game to a full-blown confrontation where someone loses teeth and a mysterious master speaks from behind a carriage curtain, and it all happens in one continuous encounter on a mountain road with no other pedestrians around. The author doesn't let us settle. First there's the hunger and warmth of eating together, then Fu Gang's jealousy and rude commentary, then the bone-throwing incident, then the master's voice cutting through like thunder, then Fan Wu's complete tonal shift into apology mode, and finally the weird business negotiation over roasted meat. Each beat escalates naturally from the last — no filler, no dragged-out exposition dumps. But here's what I appreciate most: the author also gives us tiny breathers. Hong Xiaoduo sitting on the stone, the wind blowing, the cold sweat realization. That single moment of stillness after all the chaos is perfectly placed. It's the narrative equivalent of letting your character — and the reader — catch their breath before the next wave hits. The chapter ends with Fan Wu riding back toward them, and we're left wanting to know what the master actually wants. Perfect cliffhanger energy without being cheap about it.
... Read More
Can we just take a moment to appreciate how good the dialogue is here because I am obsessed with the way the author distinguishes voices. The children each speak differently—Piglet is careful and practical,Fan Wu is formal and subservient,the mysterious carriage person is sharp and dismissive. But the real dialogue gold is in Hong Xiaoduo's internal monologue. When she's negotiating she thinks in rapid-fire calculations: 'should buy each a set of clothes,didn't know prices in ancient times,what can ten taels do?' That stream-of-consciousness style makes her feel like a real person panicking through a situation rather than a plot device. And the line 'A mother is not someone to lean on, but someone who makes leaning unnecessary'—that quote she remembers from somewhere in her past life hits different when you consider she's standing there about to become someone's mother whether she planned to or not. The dialogue between the children about their names is where it really shines though. The oldest boy asking tentatively if she can give them new names because 'a mother's heart is soft'—that's dialogue that does three jobs at once: it reveals character,it advances the plot,and it breaks your heart.
... Read More
Okay so this whole encounter is wild and I love how it plays out. Hong Xiaoduo is just trying to eat her roasted wild game in peace with these seven kid beggars, right? And then these two guys show up on horseback and Fu Gang just goes off on her with some deeply unhinged assumptions about her being involved with the Beggar Sect. And she — she just throws a bone at him. Not a fancy throwing knife, not a magical projectile, just a raw chicken bone she was eating. The fact that it takes out his front teeth is honestly one of the funniest moments in the whole book so far. The plot here is doing something really smart though. This isn't just a random fight scene. It's establishing who Hong Xiaoduo is in three beats: first she's kind and generous (feeding the kids), then she's sharp-tongued and doesn't take nonsense (the bone toss), then she's morally conflicted about violence (she's scared but also doesn't want to kill anyone). The master intervening from the carriage is also a great plot move because it raises the stakes — this isn't just two guards, there's someone important behind closed curtains. And then Fan Wu turning around and asking to BUY the meat instead of getting angry? That twist is gold. He comes back polite, says sorry, asks nicely. The power dynamic just shifted completely and neither Hong Xiaoduo nor the readers saw it coming.
... Read More
Everything was going so smoothly — she's in the woods, hunting, proving her skills, taking care of the kids, and then a carriage appears. Not just any carriage, but one with armed guards and someone important inside. And the horseman doesn't even try to negotiate properly. He's like, "I want your food, give it to me." The tension shifts from "can she survive the wilderness?" to "can she survive a power imbalance?" And the best part? She refuses. Not just once, but twice, with increasing sass. "I won't sell the roasted ones no matter how much silver you give." The horseman's face goes from smug to furious in two seconds flat. This is where the plot goes from cozy survival story to full-on conflict — and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
Okay, so let me just say — that old man's reveal absolutely wrecked me. Like, we've been following Hong Xiaoduo on this hunt-and-protect journey, right? And then BAM, she just remembers: "This plot wasn't the one she chose. The beginning of the plot had gone seriously off track." That's not a minor detail, that's a PLOT NUCLEAR BOMB. She's not just in a strange world — she's in the WRONG STORY. She thought she was playing by the rules, picking her own adventure, and some creepy old man tricked her into someone else's narrative. What does that even mean for the story going forward? Is she gonna try to escape? Rewrite it? I need to know what happens next.
... Read More
The image of Tian Shu burying the beans and corn kernels and then smashing the jar stayed with me. It's such a small act but it's loaded. Those beans were their survival - they dug them from a mouse hole, they washed them, they were going to cook them. And then he buries them alive with soil. He's burying the old way of surviving, the scavenging, the desperation, the mouse-hole economy. And his pants - tied at the ankles to carry grain - that's literally their entire livelihood in fabric form. Both get buried together. But here's what got me: he makes sure to cover it so the villagers won't pick it up and eat it. Even in throwing away their old survival strategy, he's still protecting everyone from going backward. This kid is carrying the emotional weight of six other children and he does it without anyone asking him to. And Hong Xiaoduo's reaction - she doesn't praise him, she doesn't give a speech. She just lets him bury it and moves on. The relationship between them is built on these tiny gestures, not declarations. Even the ending of the batch with her asking about which inn has the best attitude instead of the best price - it's a small detail but it signals that her priorities have completely shifted. She's not just surviving anymore, she's trying to give these kids something better than survival. The question of identity keeps ticking under the surface too - they keep calling her Mother, and each time it lands differently. Sometimes it's hope, sometimes it's fear, sometimes it's just practical. What happens when she can't be the mother they need?
... Read More
"Mother?" The two bald girls called out a little shyly. I need to sit with this line for a second. TWO LITTLE GIRLS — freshly washed, newly clothed, heads buzzed short — looking at Hong Xiaoduo and calling her MOTHER. Not asking. Not hesitantly wondering. Just... saying it. Let me rewind. Earlier, when Tian Xuan whispered "Mother, why don't you run away first," she felt her heart warm and teased him back: "Oh, now you're not afraid that I'll run away and never come back?" This isn't performative. This is genuine. She's not just their guardian — she's become the person they trust most in the world. And watch how she handles it later when Wan Quan makes a joke: "Fortunately, even if they shout randomly, no one will believe it, otherwise, the young lady's good marriage fate might be affected." Hong Xiaoduo just chuckles and moves on. She doesn't correct him aggressively. She lets it slide because she knows — the kids don't do this randomly. Tian Shu even warns them: "try not to call Mother in crowded places." This is a protected word between them. The innkeeper's wife is another relationship I can't stop thinking about. She's crying while scrubbing the kids, seeing wounds she wasn't meant to see. "How can there be such cruel people in the world?" This older woman, who barely knows these strangers, is visibly shaken by what she discovers. It creates this quiet bond — Hong Xiaoduo thanks her, and the wife leaves changed, carrying a secret about these children that will presumably shape how she treats them going forward. What strikes me most is the hierarchy of care. Hong Xiaoduo gives orders — "Everyone listen up, take your new clothes" — but she also negotiates: "I remembered that she should first ask the children whether they would allow their hair to be cut." Even in a crisis, she checks in. These kids have been failed by adults their whole lives, and she's doing something radically different: treating them like people who get a say. The constellation of relationships in this chapter is: Hong Xiaoduo as the reluctant but devoted mother figure, the children as survivors learning to trust, the constable as an accidental ally, Wan Quan as neutral-to-kind infrastructure, and the innkeeper's wife as the moral witness who sees too much. Nobody here is simple.
... Read More
There's a recurring image that won't leave me: the empty space. She chose to have a spatial ability, some kind of cheat power, but she forgot to fill it with anything. No gold, no food, no weapons. Just a bare room. And I think that's the central metaphor of this entire novel. She chose the role of a female swordsman—the fantasy, the adventure—but she forgot the practical stuff. She's living someone else's dream without understanding the cost. The autumn leaves, the purple-red shrubs, the beautiful scenery she can't appreciate because her mind is in chaos—it's all symbolic too. She's surrounded by a world that should feel magical but feels like a prison. And those seven children? They're not just dependents. They represent everything she lost—her identity, her past, her certainty. They call her 'Mother' because they need someone to believe in, and she needs them to have purpose. The most haunting image is the children eating bones off the ground while adults walked by. It's a statement about complicity, about watching suffering and choosing to look away. And now Xiaoduo, who also looked away initially, has to decide if she's going to keep running or start fighting. The story is asking: when nothing is real except your choices, what do you choose to be?
... Read More
Can we just talk about how these children look at her? From the very first moment she appeared from the woods with all that game, the oldest boy didn't run — he pointed and said 'It's Mother! Mother didn't abandon us!' That word 'mother' hit me so hard because she literally just found these kids yesterday. She didn't choose this role. But watching her slowly slip into it? Chilling. She patted her pockets looking for a fire starter like she's completely unprepared, and these kids — these TRAUMATIZED kids — have one. They know how to build fires, clean game, season meat. She's the adult and they're the ones taking care of everything.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or