Weird Live Broadcast: I Can Deduce Endlessly - Reviews

Weird Live Broadcast: I Can Deduce Endlessly
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There is a scene where Yao Yao is chasing Gu Yi around the backyard after he pretends she ate his brain and turned him into a ghost, and she's laughing — actual pure, childlike laughter — and it absolutely destroyed me. Think about the context. We've just watched this character die four times in increasingly gruesome ways. His head gets chopped off. He becomes a transparent ghost. He gets bit at the neck. The reader is sitting there absolutely stressed out, heart pounding, and then suddenly — laughter. Bright, clear, echoing through the backyard. It's almost jarring how happy the scene becomes after all that terror. But that's the emotional genius of it. The laughter isn't fake. Yao Yao genuinely loves playing with Gu Yi. For the first time, someone is playing with her. Someone is engaging with her on her level instead of fighting her or fearing her. That laugh is the emotional payoff of the entire arc — all those deaths weren't just plot mechanics, they were Gu Yi slowly learning that the way to reach her wasn't through logic but through play. And the moment she falls asleep in his arms afterwards? After all that energy, all that giggling, she just... drifts off. Exhausted. She said her dad never plays with her. So whoever is taking care of her in this place — whether it's the shop owner, her dad, or whatever force put her here — no one ever just sat with her and played. Gu Yi giving her that simple thing, that ordinary childhood experience, is somehow more powerful than any sword or spell ever could be. I've read a lot of horror where the monster is sympathetic but I don't think I've ever felt it hit this hard.
... Read More
I need to talk about how this author structures the tension, because the deduction sequences changed everything for me. Every time Gu Yi closes his eyes and starts a new simulation, the whole rhythm of the chapter shifts. You go from the present—Gu Yi watching a patient convulse—to his mind racing through possibilities, step by numbered step. And each time it ends in death. That's the pacing: not a straight line forward but a spiral getting tighter and tighter. The first death was quick—a chef grabbing his collar and dragging him away. Then the spider. Each time he learns something new, and each time the stakes feel heavier because he's burning through his limited deductions. The reader is right there with him, realizing that every wrong path gets more elaborate and more gruesome. What's brilliant is how the author breaks the pattern at the end. After the second failed deduction, instead of immediately starting a third, we get this raw moment—Gu Yi holding his chest, sweating, the black fur on his hand—and then he makes a choice. No simulation. No safety net. Just him deciding to act despite having no guarantee of survival. That's when the book went from clever puzzle-box to genuinely gripping. The pacing before that moment was methodical, almost clinical, and then suddenly it became desperate. And honestly? That shift mirrored exactly what Gu Yi was feeling inside.
... Read More
Okay so the specimen room moment is just *chef's kiss* atmospheric writing. Let me paint this for you — moonlight pouring into a dark room full of giant animal specimens, and there's this frog sitting right in the middle like it's the centerpiece of some deranged natural history exhibit. The text says: "The room was filled with specimens of various animals, but without exception, these animals were several times larger than their real-life counterparts." That's it. That's the vibe. You can just feel the wrongness of it. It's not scary because it's dark and creepy (though it is), it's scary because everything is *almost* normal but slightly off. Like your brain keeps trying to place it and failing. And then the monster — a humanoid thing with heart-shaped eyes that moves like a penguin but at absurd speed? That image is burned into my skull. The fact that it only becomes active after moonlight exposure, curled up like a sleeping child holding its knees, one eye heart-shaped and one a black X... I need to sit with this visual for a minute. It's simultaneously grotesque and almost pitiful. And the hospital itself — this building that's apparently a front for a research institute studying humans as rare animals? The worldbuilding here is doing heavy lifting without ever stopping to explain things in a boring way. You piece it together through Gu Yi's deductions, which makes it feel earned. The basement scene with the black hairy monsters barking like dogs and multiplying out of the shadows? Also terrifying in the best way. It's the escalation that gets me. First it's one scary monster in a specimen room, then suddenly you're surrounded by a pack. The architecture of this place keeps rewarding curiosity with danger, which is exactly how a good dungeon should feel.
... Read More
The author really understood how to build dread through settings. Let me talk about the cafeteria scene because it's one of the most suffocating sequences I've read recently. Think about it—eight hours a day for three meals, strict rules about when you can enter, when you can leave your seat, how much you spend, what you eat. Clang! One sound from a dropped tray and the pig-headed chef is on you. No loud noises. No talking. Just eight people sitting in silence eating their one meat, one vegetable, one staple, each costing exactly 12 yuan and 50 cents. It felt like a prison, and that's exactly what it was disguised as a hospital. The contrast between the bright, clean hospital aesthetic and the absolute horror underneath—that's what made it creep out so much. And then the emergency room! Chainsaws, patients screaming, doctors in bird beak masks wheeling out a guy who got ALL his limbs removed. Who does that? And the black fur growing on Gu Yi's wrist, spreading toward his elbow. The imagery of transformation happening slowly while he's trapped in this place, unable to verify anything on a phone because there are no phones... these details made me feel the walls closing in. I kept wanting to shake Gu Yi and say just run, but the windows have fences, the walls are three meters high, and there's no outside help coming.
... Read More
"The toad is the natural enemy of the spider." That's the clue. Just six words, and it opens up this entire thematic labyrinth about how nature works in this world versus ours. Think about it — in our world, frogs eat spiders. In this world, the rule is reversed or at least remembered through a specimen label that only patients can read. Gu Yi has to take off his mask to see the handwriting, and as a doctor he can't read it, but as a patient he can. The mask isn't just protection — it's a lens that changes what you're allowed to know. Every identity in this story comes with its own blindness. The spider in Room 0 is a human-eating spider. The toad is its natural enemy. But the toad is a specimen — dead, frozen, immobilized. You can't use a dead thing to fight a living threat. Unless... the live toad from the shop? The one they sell to players? That's the connection. The world is giving you tools but wrapping them in layers of impossibility. Every answer creates new questions. And the bigger symbolism — humans being studied as rare animals, the hospital as a research institute, the whole economic system of buying and selling humans — it's all turning our world upside down. The title card says it basically: "Perhaps in the real world, these specimens are all monsters, but in the dungeon, they are common creatures. Instead, oneself and the other patients are rare animals." That's not just worldbuilding, that's a philosophical statement about perspective and value. Who gets to be the subject and who gets to be the specimen? The text keeps asking this question without ever answering it directly.
... Read More
Okay so this whole 'perspective determines reality' thing Gu Yi figured out? Chef's kiss. Absolutely brilliant. When he realizes that the toad is useless to a doctor but essential to a patient—because in the patient's worldview, toads eat spiders—that single revelation unlocks basically everything about how this scenario works. The author built the entire puzzle around subjective truth coexisting with objective truth, and watching Gu Yi connect the dots was genuinely thrilling. Then he goes to the archive room, finds his own medical file, and BOOM—this isn't a hospital, it's a research institute running experiments on humans across parallel universes. Socialization Transformation, Language Adaptation, Brain Modification. The file confirms everything but raises a dozen new questions. And then the movie 'Monster Siege'? It's just a cheesy sci-fi flick… until you watch it through the bird beak mask and a fur-covered monster literally claws its way OUT of the screen. That transition from 'this is a movie' to 'this is a portal' was insane. But the sickest part? The dead end. He deduces his way into the second basement, starts transforming, gets caught by the chef, and then—chainsaw. Death. The deduction loop closes on him getting butchered. This plot doesn't let you breathe.
... Read More
I keep coming back to one question this book won't stop asking: what makes someone human? The text literally has a character screaming "I'm not sick! I'm not sick!" in blood on the back of a handbook, and then right below it, "I am human! I am human! I am human!" These aren't just spooky messages—they're the thematic heartbeat of the whole thing. The hospital treats patients as expendables, amputates limbs to stop some mysterious "virus," and then burns them alive. But who decided they were sick? Who decided they needed amputation? The medical records say "severe cognitive impairment and mania" but the treatment is pure torture. And then there's Gu Yi himself, watching the black fur spread on his hand—the physical manifestation of guilt turning him into the very monster he's trying to survive among. The masks everyone wears are another layer of this: bird masks for doctors, pig masks for chefs, dog masks for security. Everyone hides behind a face that isn't theirs. Even the conflicting rules—what's written on the front versus the bloody back—represent the gap between what authority tells you and what your conscience demands. The dungeon isn't just trying to kill you. It's trying to convince you that being human is a liability.
... Read More
The setting in this whole sequence is deceptively simple — a small shop, a backyard, a big tree, a wall that apparently someone is selling lamb kidneys outside of. But every detail in this space feels loaded with meaning and unease. Start with the backyard itself. It's where all the action happens, where Gu Yi and Yao Yao interact, where the five deaths and ultimately the one success all take place. It has a big tree with a bird's nest, a small table for playing house, open enough for hide and seek but enclosed enough to feel trapped. It's a child's playground that's also a death zone, which is exactly the tone of the whole story — innocent surfaces hiding impossible danger. Then there's the smell of barbecue drifting over the wall. In a remote hospital area, why is someone selling lamb kidneys? It's such a specific, grounded detail that makes the weirdness feel real. It's the kind of thing that only exists in a dream or a haunted space — mundane details placed in impossible contexts. The moment when everything turns transparent after Gu Yi agrees to be the ghost in hide and seek is pure visual storytelling. One second he's standing in a backyard, the next his own body is lying on the ground and he's become a spirit. The world literally reconfigures itself around the rules of the game. That's worldbuilding at its finest — the environment isn't just a backdrop, it's an active participant that enforces the logic of this place. And the shop owner watching from the window, completely unfazed, eating his meal like nothing unusual is happening? That mundane reaction to supernatural chaos is what makes this world feel lived-in. Everyone here has their role, their routine, their accepted horrors. It's unsettling precisely because it's so ordinary.
... Read More
This dungeon is basically a philosophical minefield dressed up as a horror story and I love it. Let's start with the masks. Everyone wears animal masks in this hospital—the bird mask, the kangaroo mask, Dr. Gui's disguise. At first it reads as purely functional (hiding your identity from security), but the specimens on Level -2 reframe everything. Phase Three Subject: 'Fully successful transformation of the subject; only an injection of the corresponding medication is needed to immediately become the desired Petz.' The masks aren't just hiding what humans look like underneath—they're the first step toward becoming what the indigenous people want. Animal = lesser creature = acceptable pet. The deer-headed doctor telling Gu Yi 'the purpose of wearing a mask is to maintain your humanity' is either deeply ironic or the single truest sentence in this entire nightmare. Then there's the pill. The pill is the ultimate symbol of compromised survival. Take it and die immediately by rule violation. Don't take it and die slowly by transformation. It's every dystopian choice compressed into one white tablet. 'I am human' appears in bloody hints because the whole game is about whether you can say those words and mean them when your body is turning against you. And the Dean walking a Petz like a dog—this is about power and dehumanization at its most literal. The indigenous people see humans as 'low-level creatures.' The hospital produces compliant monsters. The whole system is designed to strip humanity away until only the mask remains.
... Read More
This is going to sound weird but the most emotionally raw scene in these chapters isn't even a big dramatic moment—it's Gu Yi standing in the hospital bathroom at 6 AM shaving black fur off his arm with a razor while his hands probably shake. Just look at what the text says: "He felt an unbearable itch in his hand." He rolls up his sleeves and the black fur has spread to his elbow. He's sitting there with a razor, cutting off the parts of himself that are turning into something else, watching the fur turn into maggots in the sink. And then it grows back in minutes. That's the visual equivalent of Sisyphus rolling his boulder up the hill except the boulder is his own body and the hill is a hospital basement full of unspeakable horrors. "If he didn't take the pill, he would be gradually consumed by the unspeakable and turn into a monster. But if he took the pill, he would violate the rules of 'I' and die on the spot." This is the most claustrophobic dilemma I've read in a while. There's no winning. The pill is a trap designed to make him lose. Every choice leads to death—either slow transformation or instant execution. And he has to navigate this for THIRTY DAYS. Thirty days of waking up with more black fur, thirty days of swallowing pills he can't swallow, thirty days of pretending everything is fine while his body betrays him. Xu Nian watching him spit out the pill and understanding instantly... those two have something real between them. Not romantic, not quite familial, but this desperate survivor bond where one glance says 'I know what you're doing and I won't tell.'
... Read More
I need to process what just happened with the little girl scene because my heart is still racing. One moment she's a sweet kid playing with dolls, the next her teeth are fangs and she's saying "I want to eat your liver" like it's a normal request. The text describes it perfectly — "Dark shadows appear on the little girl's head, and her white teeth turn into crimson fangs." And then: "You see a blood-red scene before your eyes. You died." What gets me isn't even the gore, it's the betrayal. She's a CHILD. She's supposed to be innocent. The shop owner hands her to you like, hey watch this kid, and you lower your guard because she's small and quiet and playing with a doll. And then she reaches INTO your stomach. That violation of trust is what makes it hurt. It's not just danger, it's emotional manipulation dressed up as sweetness. And Gu Yi's response? He doesn't get angry at the reader or at the game. He just sweats, comes back to reality, and keeps thinking. There's something deeply lonely about that. He's the only one in this dungeon who actually cares about understanding what's happening, and that isolation is its own kind of torture. The scene with the security guard too — when the guard says "Why do you have Dr. Gui's access card?" and then turns to face the monster and says "Go back to your specimen room!" — that moment of confusion and sudden betrayal hits different. The guard isn't an ally, he's another piece of the environment that might turn on you. Nothing is safe. Nothing is friendly. And yet Gu Yi keeps going back anyway. That's not courage, that's something deeper and stranger.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or