Tried Too Hard to End a One-Sided Love - Reviews

Tried Too Hard to End a One-Sided Love
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Can we talk about how Leticia basically confesses her entire emotional situation to a guy she just met by talking about a fictional relative?? This is one of the most realistic scenes of awkward vulnerability I've ever read. She starts with 'it's not about me—it's about a relative' like that's going to help her hide anything. And then she basically summarizes her entire unrequited love situation: 'My relative likes someone, but that person only sees them as a close younger sibling.' Dante has zero idea she's talking about herself and he's just sitting there giving relationship advice to a stranger about the exact problem she's experiencing. The dialogue is so natural and unpolished—she stammers, she sighs, she gets distracted, she trail offs. There's no clever banter or witty repartee here, just two tipsy people fumbling through something real. And Dante's responses are equally grounded: 'Honestly, I've never been in a relationship, so I'm not sure I'll be much help.' He doesn't pretend to be some romance expert. He just offers what little he has. The author's dialogue style in these quieter moments is deceptively simple—on the surface it's just people talking, but underneath every exchange is carrying enormous emotional weight. I also love how the eavesdropped conversation cuts in naturally: 'Is it true Lady Valentina intends to get engaged?' No dramatic announcement, just two random ladies chatting nearby, which makes it feel even more devastating because the world keeps spinning while hers stops. Perfect. Just... perfect.
... Read More
Okay, I need to just sit with this for a second because Leticia is absolutely wrecking me. The entire chapter is basically one long gaslighting session — except she's gaslighting herself. She tells Enrique she likes someone else, she goes through this whole elaborate performance about needing to lose her virginity, and yet... every single detail screams that it's ABOUT HIM. She brought up the confession on her twentieth birthday. The balcony scene. The drunk confession that got brushed off as drunkenness. All of it. And the most painful part? When she's crying in the carriage and actually regrets going to Enrique instead of the man she supposedly likes. She thinks if she'd gone to him after being dumped, he would've accepted her — but she wouldn't have won his heart. Only later does the reader realize: the man she liked didn't dump her. This is all a constructed narrative to get close to Enrique. The irony is devastating. Then she kisses him. Clumsy, awkward, salty from tears. And he just... freezes. Doesn't push her away. Doesn't pretend it didn't happen. Just stares at her like he's seeing her for the first time. That moment when he says "I'm not angry at you, Leti. I'm only angry at the person who said such nonsense to you" — he knows. He absolutely knows. But he can't say it. He can't acknowledge that the "someone she likes" is him, because she's been hiding behind this fiction the entire conversation. And then the bathrobe scene. She tries to escape to the tavern, any man will do, she's given up, and he catches her in the doorway. "It's basically pajamas." BRO. He's still treating her like a little sister while her robe is falling open and she's trembling in front of him. The tension here is absolutely suffocating in the best way.
... Read More
I need to talk about Enrique because THIS MAN. On the surface he's everything—Duke's second son, top of the Academy, handsome, kind, gentle, protective. The textbook perfect male lead. But the text keeps giving us these tiny cracks in his perfection, and I'm obsessed with reading between them. The way he ruffles Leticia's hair and says "I like you too" while treating her like a cute little sister? That's not cruelty, that's something worse. That's genuine, unthinking platonic love. He genuinely doesn't see her as anything other than family. And Leticia knows this. She's known this for ten years. That's what makes her desperation so tragic—she's not fighting against someone who's actively rejecting her, she's fighting against someone who simply cannot conceive of her romantically. But here's where it gets interesting. When Enrique says he likes someone "mature," and Leticia immediately punches the bed—that moment changed everything for me. Because maybe Enrique IS saying something real. Maybe he's not being deliberately cruel by seeing her only as a sister. Maybe he genuinely can't imagine her that way, and that's a problem that isn't entirely about her. Johan is also doing SO MUCH work in these chapters. His dynamic with Leticia is genuinely sweet—he teases her but also takes her requests seriously, promises to keep her secret, and his joke about "making sure Enrique doesn't get a girlfriend before I do" feels like genuine protectiveness. The Roberts family tradition of saying "I love you" daily is such a small detail but it explains so much about why Leticia is the way she is—she grew up expressing affection freely, which makes her confusion about romantic love even more painful. The most chilling part? Leticia's decision to use physical intimacy as a tool. She's not naive about what she's asking—she knows this could destroy their friendship, she even blames herself. But the line "isn't it Enrique's fault for not noticing my feelings?" shows how far desperation can warp someone's moral compass.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author structures the recovery period because this is masterclass pacing that most writers completely miss. The actual sex scene — which admittedly is pretty explicit and goes on for a while — ends around the middle of the chapter and then... the author just LETS it breathe. Instead of wrapping up neatly, we get this long slow morning-after sequence that somehow carries MORE emotional weight than the scene itself. Think about it: the physical encounter is intense, visceral, almost frantic. But then she wakes up alone on the bed, checks the time, finds him on the sofa, and the entire emotional ground shifts. She thinks "The bed was wide enough, why not sleep together?" and immediately drifts back to sleep. That one thought — so simple, so loaded — says more than a hundred pages of internal monologue could. Then the car ride home. Two hours of silence where neither person addresses what happened. He asks if she's hurting. She says no. He holds her hand. He reminds her of the promise. He suggests a group outing. And she understands — REALLY understands — that this was a one-time thing for him. The structure here is brutal in the best way. Night = raw desire and connection. Morning = reality and distance. The author takes the reader on that exact emotional journey with her, and by the time Leticia is back in her room alone, we've already felt the entire arc. We know she's not going to get what she wants. We know Enrique isn't ready. And the pacing makes us sit in that uncomfortable space instead of rushing to the next plot point. Also the bit where she tries to recreate the feeling alone and fails?? That's not filler. That's the thematic capstone of the entire section. The author could have ended it right after the car ride but chose to give us this quieter, sadder moment that lingers.
... Read More
The stakes here are stacked so high and I can barely breathe thinking about them. On the surface, Leticia has orchestrated this entire situation around a fictional romance — she made up a guy who rejected her for being inexperienced, she's asking her childhood friend to help her lose her virginity, and she's trying to use physical intimacy as a way to make him notice her. The internal conflict is devastating: she loves Enrique but can't tell him, so she wraps her confession in a lie so convoluted it could only come from someone who's completely lost. But the external stakes are just as intense. If Johan finds out — and Enrique literally thinks about this — it won't just be disappointment. Johan would "smack her on the back and send her off to their aunt's villa." This isn't a mild family reaction; it's exile. And Enrique knows it. Every moment he spends with her in that inn room, he's walking a razor's edge between protecting her and enabling something that could destroy everything. The carriage scene raises the tension to a breaking point. She's sobbing, he's frustrated, and then she bolts into the rain. Not metaphorically — she actually opens the door mid-journey and jumps out. That's not dramatic for no reason; that's someone whose emotional containment has completely shattered. And he follows. Of course he follows. Because the alternative is letting her run into a dark street alone. The final image — her in a bathrobe, trying to leave, him catching her wrist in the doorway — is the exact moment where every thread of conflict tightens to its breaking point. What happens next changes everything. Whether he reveals he knows, whether he crosses the line, whether she finally tells the truth — the stakes have never felt this personal or this dangerous.
... Read More
Okay so this entire section absolutely DESTROYS whatever dynamic they had before and I need to talk about it because the shift is SO subtle but also so devastating. Before all this, Enrique clearly viewed her as a child, a little sister figure, someone to protect. But right here in the scene when she grabs his hand and says "hold my hand" — that's not a little sister asking for comfort, that's a woman asking for connection, and he KNOWS it. He KNOWS what's happening. And instead of pulling away, he takes her hand. His palm is "hot from holding himself" — that detail alone says everything about what he's feeling even if he won't admit it. But then the morning after... ugh. The car ride home. He literally says the thing that broke me: "You remember what we promised last night, right? I granted your request, so you have to stop liking that man." GRANTED YOUR REQUEST. Like it was a favor. Like he did her a kindness. Like their bodies connecting meant NOTHING to him beyond obligation. Meanwhile Leticia is sitting there knowing full well that sleeping with him didn't fix anything — in fact it made it infinitely worse. Her own thoughts: "Her desire hadn't lessened; her feelings had only grown stronger." And Enrique?? He's already planning group outings. "Let's go out soon with Johan and try the new restaurant." He's normalizing it. Pretending it was just one night. Meanwhile she's in her room touching herself trying to recreate the feeling and realizing that NONE of it works without him. Who is the emotionally stunted one here?? She risked EVERYTHING and he treats it like a transaction she's so pathetic honestly but also I genuinely think he's scared because if he admits this meant something he has to face the fact that he's wanted her this whole time too.
... Read More
I need to talk about stakes because on the surface this is a romance and underneath it is a TERRITORY WAR. Leticia knows Enrique might marry Cordelia. She has receipts - she saw him enter the ball WITH her as his partner. The rumors are circulating. And what does she do? She doesn't confront him. She doesn't demand clarity. Instead, she weaponizes intimacy. She reminds him 'all my experience is with you' while asking him to help her practice kissing for some hypothetical future husband. This is not a girl playing it safe - this is a girl who has decided that if she can't win him with words, she'll win him with his own body remembering hers. The stakes are catastrophic because nobody is being honest. Enrique thinks he 'granted her wish' and she's being grateful. She thinks he might actually propose to someone else and she's running out of time. Dante thinks she cried because of HIM and offers to take her to dinner as compensation. Johan thinks nothing is wrong and happily pinches his sister's cheeks while calling her 'the little one.' Every character is operating on incomplete information and the tension compounds with every scene. The moment that broke me emotionally was when she stood in the garden and thought 'How could she make him see her as a woman?' That's the core question. If Enrique sees her as a sister forever, she loses him completely. If she pushes too hard, she loses him because he'll feel manipulated. She's trapped between honesty (which might repel him) and performance (which keeps him close but never truly sees her). And Enrique? His stake is different. He's giving up his principle of her 'stopping liking someone' in exchange for physical intimacy, and he genuinely believes this is helping her. His conflict is between his desire to protect her and his refusal to see what's right in front of him. That 'I'm not the little kid you used to protect anymore' line? She's not confessing - she's WARNING him. And he misses it entirely.
... Read More
The pacing here is deceptively slow. On paper, this section covers maybe four hours of real time - the end of the ball, the carriage ride home, Leticia falling asleep, waking up, the garden encounter. Four hours. But the author stretches the garden scene into what feels like an entire chapter of its own, and I respect the hell out of that decision. Here's what works: the author establishes a clear arc within this section. Leticia arrives at the ball already wounded (crying in the garden), tries to compose herself through dancing and social performance, retreats to the carriage where she can't maintain the mask, and finally explodes into the garden scene where everything breaks open. Each environment is progressively more private, more intimate, more dangerous for her emotional state. The structure is basically: public → semi-public → enclosed → private → INTIMATE PRIVATE. It's a funnel and we're heading straight for the bottleneck. The beat where she stumbles into Enrique's lap is perfectly paced. You can feel the author holding back - Leticia walks faster, he follows, the hallway stretches, she pulls him inside. Each action is a micro-escalation. The physical proximity increases by inches with each sentence until they're alone in her bedroom and she's pressing her body against his. What I want to critique: the Dante dinner invitation scene feels slightly rushed compared to everything else. It's a major plot development - he's asking her out explicitly - and it gets resolved in about four paragraphs while the garden encounter gets pages of attention. I get that it's meant to show how little her heart is in it, but structurally it feels unbalanced. The chapter ending is a soft cliffhanger. She's made this ridiculous request about kissing practice. We know Enrique won't say no. We know this changes everything. And the text just... trails off. 'if she could worm her way into...' I need the next part immediately.
... Read More
Okay I need to just… sit with this for a minute. The entire arc of Enrique realizing his own feelings in these chapters hit me like a freight train and I am not okay. Let me explain. So Leticia has been in love with him for like ten years. Ten. YEARS. And she's willing to pretend to date his best friend's cousin to make him jealous. That is devotion bordering on tragic. But here's the thing that got me — Enrique. Enrique didn't even realize he felt something until Dante literally spelled it out for him in a carriage at sunset. "It's the first time Leti's gotten close to a man besides me." — Dante says this and I literally screamed. That's not friendship. That's not sibling energy. That is PURE TERRITORY. And then Enrique's face? His lips trembling? I swear to god the author wrote that like a painting. "His lips trembled, and he couldn't seem to smile." I keep coming back to this line. The man who has always controlled his emotions perfectly — the perfect knight, the composed hero — is having a CRACK in his armor and it's because some girl he's known since childhood might choose someone else. Also can we talk about the fact that he immediately shut down talking about Leti when she wasn't there? "Talking about Leti when she's not here doesn't seem respectful." BRO. You don't even know what you feel yet and you're already protecting her honor. That's love. That's devastating, inconvenient, confusing love. And Dante — sweet, scheming Dante — he saw this coming from a mile away. "There was nothing more amusing than being with someone who was just about to realize their feelings." This man is a MENACE and I love him. The whole 'practice kissing with me so you can practice with someone else' subplot haunts me. ENRIQUE KNEW SHE PRACTICED THINGS WITH HIM FOR ANOTHER MAN. The fact that he said 'Wait, are you close enough to call her by name?' with that tone?? I'm dead. I'm actually deceased. "Enrique is a little ways off." — Dante brushing her hair back while secretly keeping watch. This scene made my heart do things it shouldn't be doing at 2am.
... Read More
Okay so this section hits hard on atmosphere and I need to talk about the contrast between the ballroom and the garden. Both scenes are set at the same event but they feel like completely different worlds, and the author uses setting as a mirror for Leticia's internal state without ever being heavy-handed about it. The ballroom is described through movement and noise - the crowded entrance, the music drowning out smalltalk, the quick switching of dance partners. But the real star here is the garden at night. You get this gorgeous moment where Leticia can't sleep, throws on a thin robe, and wanders into moonlight. The text says 'the bushes were full of flowers, making it a favorite spot for Leticia.' That's such a small detail but it tells us everything - she's been coming here before, this is HER place. When she runs into Enrique there, the intimacy of that space amplifies every awkward touch, every hesitation. The insect sounds filling the silence are almost painful to read because we know what she's not saying. And honestly the carriage scene? Chef's kiss. Three people squeezed together in a closed carriage, 'everyone seemed tired, and soon silence filled the carriage.' The enclosed space forces proximity. Leticia shifts her eyes and suddenly speaks - that 'suddenly' matters. In public she can perform normalcy with her brother and Enrique, but in that darkened box, something cracks. I kept imagining the dim interior, the sound of hooves on cobblestone, the slight bump of the carriage as they head home. It felt so cinematic. The one location I want to call out specifically is the hallway walk after she falls into Enrique's lap. 'Through the dimly lit, silent hallway' - she grabs his sleeve, pulls him into her room. That transition from public garden to private bedroom space is where the power dynamic completely shifts. The setting isn't just backdrop here, it's doing psychological work.
... Read More
Okay so Dante Milton is absolutely stealing this chapter and I am here for it. This guy barely has any lines throughout the whole excerpt but when he's on screen he's doing ALL the work. He notices Leticia is struggling during the dance, he suggests making Enrique jealous (which is honestly kind of clever advice even if it comes from a place of zero romantic experience), and then when she breaks down in the garden he doesn't flinch. He just pulls her into a hug and holds her while she sobs. The fact that he's worried people will misunderstand—'If anyone saw, they'd think I made you cry'—shows he genuinely cares about her reputation. Meanwhile Enrique is out there winking at her like nothing's wrong, treating her like the friendly sister he's known forever, while Dante is the one who actually sees her falling apart and does something about it. And the author makes this contrast crystal clear: 'Anyone seeing this would think they weren't just acquaintances.' The visual of them in the garden, him wiping her tears with a handkerchief, her holding a cold water bottle to her swollen eyes—it's intimate in a way Enrique has never made her feel. I keep waiting for Leticia to realize that maybe she's been looking at the wrong person this whole time.
... Read More
Can we talk about how the author uses the setting like a weapon? The custom dress shop isn't just a backdrop—it's basically a character in this whole sequence. Let me explain. First, we get the setup: "a new custom dress shop in the capital's market, My Lady. A friend working for another family told me." The fact that this is a POPULAR new shop, crowded with ladies, many with fiancés or lovers—"the atmosphere was sweet. She wished others would see her and Enrique that way." The author is telling us this space is loaded with romantic symbolism, and Leticia is acutely aware of it. Then the fitting room itself: "Since it was a private fitting room, she didn't have to rush. Such rooms were often used for secret meetings; she remembered blushing when she first heard that." BLUSHING. She's already imagining this space as romantic. And then the author confirms it—the room IS well soundproofed. Later when Enrique teases her "...People outside might hear" and she knows it's fake, that only heightens everything. The entire sequence takes place in this tiny private space that feels worlds apart from the bustling shop outside. Hena even brings dresses to the door but can't come in. The world keeps moving normally outside this room while Leticia and Enrique are having this entire alternate reality inside. That contrast between the mundane shopping trip and what happens in that fitting room—this is worldbuilding through atmosphere, not exposition dumps. And the after! Enrique opening the window to let the scent escape, fixing his hair in the mirror, looking at Leticia. The domestic normalcy of it all—like they just shopped for clothes like any normal couple. The fact that he slips out the back door like lovers always do? Chef's kiss.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or