The number mismatch hit me like a truck. Eight albums exist, but only four can be traced back to manuscripts. Fang Yinnian's guess that the other four might be Catherine's isn't just a plot twist—it's a thematic statement about erasure. Women's work, women's voices, women's creations, all absorbed into a man's name and legacy. Allen became famous BECAUSE of Catherine, and she got a basement apartment and eventually death in return.
The teddy bear keeps showing up in this story. First on the second floor, then in the hidden room, covered in blood. It's become this symbol of corrupted innocence, of childhood turned into evidence. Every time it appears, the story gets darker. It's the one constant through all the puzzles and murders, almost like a ghost watching everything unfold.
And the gallows in the basement—tied up, tortured, skeletal. Catherine didn't just die; she was punished. For what? For loving too much? For being useful and then inconvenient? The deeper you dig into this story, the more it's not really about who killed whom. It's about who gets to be remembered, whose art survives, and who gets buried—literally and figuratively.
The villa itself is a character. Upstairs is where the parties happened, where the bodies were displayed like exhibits. Downstairs is where the truth was hidden, where the real crime took place. And those four unsung albums? They're Catherine's ghost, still singing even after she's been silenced.