To You, Who Were Unkind Only to Me - Reviews

To You, Who Were Unkind Only to Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
"This kind of thing…" He went to open the carriage window, clearly intending to toss it out. He didn't know how it had come back to his sister, but the sight of her sitting there, slumped like a lost puppy and staring at that handkerchief, infuriated him. I am not okay. I am genuinely not okay. Daniel is the best brother in fiction and I will die on this hill. Here's the scene: Aisha is devastated. She was mocked, she couldn't stand the party, she begged to come and now she regrets everything. She's clutching this embroidered handkerchief that Ian told her to THROW AWAY. And Daniel sees her like this — "slumped like a lost puppy" — and his FIRST instinct is to literally throw the object of her suffering into the outside world. But then she says "Don't. Please?" in a trembling, tearful voice and he PAUSES. Of COURSE he pauses. He's a softie underneath all that gruff energy. He closes the window, starts folding the handkerchief — and here's the moment that wrecked me: "He said nothing as he began folding the handkerchief, but soon his brow furrowed. He couldn't quite line up the corners neatly. After a while wrestling with it, he just gave up and handed it back, still crookedly folded." A CROOKEDLY FOLDED HANDKERCHIEF. Daniel — this towering, muscular, revenge-taking, puddle-shoving protective brother — cannot fold a handkerchief properly and just HANDS IT BACK like "here, deal with it yourself." And Aisha says "I'm sorry, brother" because she knows he's upset on her behalf. And he snaps back "What are you apologizing for?" This is a WHOLE Romance of sibling love right here. No exaggeration. And then the cherry on top: he lies and says "I don't need to get ready to look perfect, okay? Just look at this face" — but the text says his words were "wrapped in gruf[f]" implying he was cut off mid-sentence, probably by Aisha's reaction. He's trying so hard to make her laugh, to lighten the mood, and it shows. Meanwhile Ian — cold, commanding, telling her to throw away a precious gift — hasn't done ONE thing like this. He gives orders; Daniel gives his sister a crookedly folded handkerchief and claims his face is good enough without trying. Who's the real MVP here. Also can we discuss the handkerchief ITSELF? Blue sage embroidery. Ian told her to throw it away and she CAN'T. It's become this symbol of everything unresolved between them — her attachment vs. his rejection — and Daniel, of all people, is the one who understands what it means. "Daniel knew exactly what it meant to her." UGH. I'm a mess.
... Read More
I need to talk about the handkerchief. The BLUE SAGE EMBROIDERED HANDKERCHIEF. Because this object is doing more thematic work than half the dialogue in the book. Let's trace its journey. Aisha pricked her finger sewing it — that's significant. She BLED into this object. It's not just fabric; it's a piece of her physical self, her time, her careful attention. And then Ian tells her to throw it away. "Throw it away." Three words that carry the weight of dismissing something she created with her own hands, something that represents her feelings, her effort, her hope. She can't. Of course she can't. "There was no way she could." And Daniel — who "knew exactly what it meant to her" — tries to throw it away FOR her, not understanding that the problem isn't the handkerchief, it's what it represents. His attempt to destroy it is actually an attempt to PROTECT her from keeping attached to something that hurts her. Think about that paradox. The blue sage itself — what does it symbolize? Sage is a herb of wisdom, clarity, purification. Blue sage specifically is associated with calm, spiritual cleansing, emotional healing. Aisha embroidering this symbol onto fabric while pining after someone who tells her to discard it… the irony is almost painful. She's literally stitching longing onto something that represents the peace she'll never have with Ian. And then there's the broader symbolic layer: the handkerchief as a stand-in for Aisha herself. She's being told to EXIT the scene — by Sophia ("someone like you wouldn't have even been fit to draw my bathwater"), by the old nobility ("commoners just a hundred years ago"), by Ian ("throw it away"). But she CLINGs. She folds it awkwardly. She carries it home. She refuses to let go. The blue dress she wears to the party matters too — sky blue, from Fidelis Atelier, expensive enough to draw mockery. It's her armor, her declaration of presence in a space that tells her she doesn't belong. But it's also vulnerable — a bright color in a room full of people who want her invisible. And here's the deepest symbolic reading: the crooked fold. Daniel couldn't fold it neatly. The handkerchief comes back to Aisha imperfectly, still bearing the marks of someone else's clumsy attempt to help. Is that not exactly how her life feels right now? Everything around her — her engagement, her social position, her relationship with Ian — crooked, uneven, barely holding together, but hers nonetheless.
... Read More
'Unlike the lush, flower-filled Parden gardens, which Marisa favoured for their natural style, the Lloyd gardens were perfectly manicured, as if every plant had been measured and placed in line.' I need to sit with this sentence for a moment. This is one paragraph and it contains an entire thematic argument about two families, two mothers, two philosophies of living, and Ian's personality—all through a description of gardening. The Parden gardens are LUSH and NATURAL and grown by Marisa. The Lloyd gardens are MEASURED and CONTROLLED. And Aisha notices the gardener trimming every stray branch. Stray. Not untidy, not wild—STRAY. As in, anything that doesn't fit the predetermined pattern gets cut down. This is Ian's world. Everything has its place. Nothing grows freely. And Aisha is sitting in the middle of this perfectly arranged emptiness, drinking cold tea, wondering if she'll ever be able to speak her truth. The atmosphere of the Lloyd mansion itself—the maid who clearly doesn't know how to handle a guest sitting for three hours, the polite but strained small talk about cold tea, the clock hands circling twice like time itself is mocking her—creates this suffocating sense of isolation. The world outside is perfectly ordered but inside, Aisha's heart is in chaos. The contrast between the external order and internal turmoil is the author's signature move and they execute it flawlessly here. There's also this quiet brilliance in the dining hall scene at the Parden house—the sunlight through drawn curtains, the family scattered around the table, Graham setting down his fork with a loud clatter to assert dominance, Marisa's gentle but firm intervention. It's domestic and intimate, completely different in texture from the cold precision of the Lloyd estate. Two homes, two atmospheres, and Aisha is choosing which one to step into. The visual storytelling here operates on so many levels simultaneously. I keep coming back to that final image of Aisha gazing out at the trimmed hedges while her tea goes cold. It's a painting almost—compositionally perfect, emotionally devastating, and it says everything without a single word of exposition.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or