To You, Who Are Not My Enemy - Reviews

To You, Who Are Not My Enemy
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
What did I just read?? Ahazan is genuinely the most chaotic person I have ever encountered and I love it honestly. Let me break this down because this man has created an entire system of psychological torture that is so unhinged it's impressive. First, he threatens to kill Pellier if Clodine doesn't eat. Then when she finally relents, he turns around and says everything she eats goes to the prisoners. So now she's trapped in a loop - she HAS to eat or her people starve, but she can barely stomach anything because she's in such psychological distress. She's literally making herself throw up because she can't handle the food, and Merian knows and calls her out on it. The stakes keep escalating with every scene. And the best part? Clodine keeps finding ways to resist. She asks the servants not to record her food honestly. She threatens the law of war. She screams at him. And Ahazan just sits there like a damn menace watching her struggle. The tension in that room is suffocating. I couldn't look away. Every time I thought the scene was over, something else got worse. Pellier's note at the end? MERIAN is clearly playing a double game. The stakes are climbing and I am OBSESSED.
... Read More
Let me just say this out loud—the fountain in the outdoor garden. The way the author describes Ahazan watching Clodine and Yuri from a distance, "as though part of the painted beauty of the garden." PAINTED BEAUTY. Do you understand what this means? He's been reduced to a decorative element in his own empire's landscape. The person he wanted most is standing with someone else, and he's literally frozen like a figure in a painting, unable to move, unable to intervene, just... observing. And then the contrast. The garden is this luminous, almost dreamlike space—fountains, greenhouses, moonlight. It's beautiful enough to betray you. You forget for a second that this is a prison. Clodine is WALKING FREE in the garden. Searching for her maids. Talking to Yuri. And then AHASAN appears out of nowhere like a ghost, draping that coat over her shoulders like some kind of possessive angel. But the REAL worldbuilding genius is in the bedroom scene. The heavy gilded door that needs no explanation. The ornate curtains. The blue moonlight. This isn't just a fancy room—it's a cage disguised as luxury. Every detail screams that this is where emperors keep the things they can't bear to lose. The soldiers waiting outside. The locked door. The fact that Clodine doesn't even need to look at the door to know whose chamber it is. I also love how the author uses the ANEMIA as environmental storytelling. Clodine's body is literally failing her in this space—the虚弱ness, the dizziness, the way her vision blurs. Her own biology is another lock on this cage. Even her blood won't let her escape properly.
... Read More
Okay, first of all—Yuri is the ONLY sane person in this entire mess and honestly I need him in my life. The guy shows up, tries to reason with Clodine, gives her an actual out, and gets absolutely destroyed for it. But here's the thing—he's not WRONG about his brother, right? Like, we SEE it in the dream sequences. Ahazan didn't do any of this to hurt her. He did it because he's fundamentally broken in a way that makes him grab everything instead of ask for it. The whole dynamic between Ahazan and Clodine is... god, it's terrible and beautiful and I can't look away. They were CHILDREN when they met. She put a crown on his head and told him she loved him at first sight. And now? Seven years later he's literally holding her captive and calling it protection. The scene where he hears her say his name in her sleep—his whole face changes. Just a fraction. But that's ALL we get, right? Because this man cannot survive a single moment of actually being soft with her while she's awake. And Clodine! She's not some passive victim here. She THROWS his coat at him. She calls him a despicable bastard. She runs into the dark like a maniac. But then her body betrays her—the anemia, the weakness—and suddenly he's catching her again. The power dynamic is so uneven it makes my teeth ache, but the way she keeps fighting despite having NOTHING to fight with? That's the kind of character writing that stays with you. I also need to talk about how the author uses physical touch as language here. In the memories, it's gentle—adjusting seats so the sun doesn't hurt her, sharing candy, letting her rest her head on his chest. In the present, it's violent restraint. Same hands, completely different meaning. Ahazan's body language tells the real story every time.
... Read More
I need to talk about the Abel Mine scene because something about it consumed me. When Clodine says 'I need it now, Father'—she doesn't even look at Ahazan. She deliberately doesn't. That detail made me so angry and so sad at the same time. She's asking for the one thing from her mother's legacy because it's the only thing she can control. Everything else—her body, her marriage, her reputation—is dictated by men. The mine is hers. Hers alone. And the flashback? God. 'I already feel like I have everything.' What a devastating line to echo back at you. She said that when she had faith that love was enough. She doesn't say it anymore. The emptiness Ahazan feels isn't just about losing her romantically—it's about realizing the girl who loved him without condition no longer exists, and he's the one who killed her.
... Read More
I need to talk about the stakes here because this book does NOT play around. Clodine literally says it: "I'd rather die! If I must suffer this shame, I'd rather die!" And Ahazan's response? "You're mistaken." Thud. She hits the door. He pins her there. "I have no intention of letting you die peacefully. Not even death will take you from me." This is the core conflict of the entire story compressed into three sentences. Every external conflict—the conquered nation, the political imprisonment, the missing maids—branches off this single, poisonous truth: Ahazan will not release her. Not alive. Not dead. Not ever. And Clodine's entire struggle is against that absolute certainty. But here's what makes the stakes so genuinely tense: we KEEP seeing that underneath all this violence and captivity, there's a man who once shared his last candy with a starving twelve-year-old girl and meant it as an act of love. The author doesn't let us forget this. The dream sequence interrupts the present-day torture precisely when things get most unbearable, reminding us that the person doing the hurting is the same person who once made her feel safest in the world. That's what makes the suspense unrelenting. It's not just "will she escape?" It's "can this relationship be salvaged when the foundation is built on conquest and captivity?" Every scene raises the stakes because we know that both of them are losing something irreplaceable—Clodine is losing her autonomy, her home, her trust. Ahazan is... what is HE losing? His ability to be honest? His chance at the love he clearly still wants? Because if he just asked her nicely, would she stay?
... Read More
I cannot stop thinking about Cal. 'You know, Your Majesty… women don't like it when you act so violently.' This man rides behind the Emperor who just threw his wife across a dining room and his advice is essentially 'be nicer to ladies.' THE AUDACITY. But then Ahazan destroys him with 'And you, who knows women so well—have you ever properly held a woman's hand?' And Cal is like 'I HAVE!' The comedy is perfect but it also highlights how isolated Ahazan is. There's literally no one who can tell him how to be human with this woman. Everyone around him either fears him or serves him. Cal tries because their survival depends on it, and Ahazan almost kills him for giving advice. The stakes here aren't just about whether they'll reconcile—they're about whether either of them can survive this marriage without destroying themselves completely.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this one plot beat absolutely wrecked me. Clodine asks for her mother's inheritance—the Abel Mine—out of nowhere, and then we cut to Ahazan remembering why she originally REFUSED it. The flashback hits like a truck. He was leaving for war, wanted to give her something that would protect her, and she turned it down with this line: 'Why? Don't you believe you'll protect me for life on your own?' And now? Now she needs it. She needed him to protect her and he couldn't. The irony is so thick you could cut it with a knife. This isn't just a random request—it's the entire marriage crisis distilled into one economic decision. She rejected the mine once because she believed in their love. She's reclaiming it now because that belief is dead. Every time I re-read that sequence my stomach drops.
... Read More
Okay so this is the moment I've been waiting for. Seven chapters of Ahazan being this cold, calculating emperor who weaponizes everything—and then he breaks down in a stable. Not dramatically, not loudly, but this quiet, trembling "I was afraid. Afraid you would reject me to the very end." That's the line that wrecked me. He admits he used Clodine's people as leverage. He says the apology. And he still can't stop himself from pulling her into his arms like some desperate man. The plot structure here is brilliant because it doesn't let us write Ahazan off as a villain. He's neither—he's a man who has spent seven years building walls around this one feeling and then spent every scene since either testing them or rebuilding them harder. Charlotte's thread is also doing heavy lifting in the background. We get this gorgeous tragic image of her repeating "It's all right, Charlotte" to herself while crying over tea. She chose this. She chose Clodine over her own happiness. That's not a side plot—that's the thematic counterweight to everything Ahazan and Clodine are going through. Charlotte loves without demanding. Ahazan loves like a conqueror. Clodine is caught between both. Three different models of love in one story. The part where Ahazan says "I have no intention of hurting them. As long as you stay by my side... I want nothing else" hit me like a truck. Because we know he's lying to himself. He already hurt them. He already used them. But he means it too. That contradiction is the whole story.
... Read More
Let me just sit with this for a second. Every single character in this passage is making a choice that destroys something they love. Clodine chooses her people over herself. Ahazan chooses to marry the woman he loves through coercion, knowing it poisons everything. Charlotte chooses to accept the second-best life so Clodine can have the first. And Cal—bless him—shows up at midnight with news about missing maids and the Ramier family, and Ahazan immediately shields Clodine's family from suspicion even though those soldiers might be involved. That's the highest-stakes conflict in the entire passage: Ahazan protecting the very family connected to the crime because their honor is tied to hers. The external conflict—the missing maids, the political conspiracy, the Ramier family involvement—is lurking underneath everything like a dark current. But the real stakes are interior. Clodine's fear of horses isn't just a phobia; it's the physical manifestation of every trauma she carries. When she kneels beside Seth despite trembling, she's confronting the thing that paralyzed her. And Ahazan? His stake isn't power or territory. It's whether Clodine will look at him and see a monster or see the boy who was scared that day too. "To me it feels like yesterday"—twenty years and he still carries it. That's the real war here. Not empires or marriages or territories. Two people who've been bleeding since they were ten years old, finally meeting in the middle of a stable.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about what Ahazan just did at the beginning, because honestly I am still recovering. He cuts himself. On PURPOSE. And then turns to Clodine all bloody and says 'At this rate, who could tell who the enemy is?' Like that's not the most manipulative, unhinged thing I've ever read. He's forcing her into a corner where she has to CHOOSE — revenge or submission — and she can't sit in the middle. And the terrifying part? He might be right. But then the banquet scene hits and the plot keeps twisting. His people can't even introduce her properly — she's neither 'queen of the conquered kingdom' nor 'wife of the late king.' They've rewritten her identity so completely that she doesn't even have a title that fits anymore. That's not worldbuilding, that's erasure, and I love that the story is making that visible through something as small as a herald's announcement. And THEN the maids disappear. I literally gasped. Because obviously this wasn't some random kidnapping — Clodine's maids would NEVER abandon her willingly. Which means someone deliberately intercepted them. And Ahazan already knows this. He says so outright: 'Lack of motive simply means we haven't found it yet.' That smile on his face? The one described as belonging to someone who survived countless betrayals? Yeah. That's not a good sign for whoever did this. The plot is layering conspiracies on top of conspiracies and I am here for it.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the white dress. All that lace, all that weight, and she looks 'absurd' in it. The author specifically calls out that she looks absurd rather than beautiful—and I think that's the whole thesis of this chapter right there. She's being dressed up as a queen for a coronation that isn't hers, by a man who conquered her country, at a banquet celebrating TWO things that should never be celebrated together: military victory and forced marriage. White. The color of mourning. Of surrender. Of a virgin bride. Everything wrong about this image. Then there's the blood. It's EVERYWHERE in this chapter, isn't it? O'Neil's blood on Ahazan's sword and clothes. The memory of it haunting Clodine's dreams. Then Ahazan's OWN blood when he drives that hairpin into his chest. The red matching the red she said would suit her. Two kinds of blood—his and hers—being spilled in the same room, over the same body, for the same impossible love. The hairpin itself is such a loaded object. A small, fragile thing. Something a woman uses to hold her hair in place, to keep herself composed. And she tries to use it as a weapon. Fails. Because she can't even do that much. She HESITATES. And that hesitation—that loathsome, human hesitation—is what saves him and condemns her all at once. And Charlotte's line about being freed from 'foul hands' after six years of marriage to a king who kept mistresses—this entire story is about women whose bodies are battlegrounds for male power. Clodine's infertility didn't save her. It just changed who got to use her. Ahazan wants her empire and her obedience and somehow convinced himself that owning her completely was justice for loving her. The real question this chapter is asking: what happens to a woman who loved too much in a world that rewards exactly that?
... Read More
This chapter wrecked me. I'm not even being dramatic. I read the scene between Clodine and Ahazan in that room and I literally put the book down and stared at the wall for ten minutes. Let me just say this: the tragedy of these two is so perfectly constructed that I can't decide who I'm more sorry for. Clodine, who spent ten years surviving a marriage to a grotesque king because she thought it would help THE MAN SHE LOVED, only to find out that he was the one who orchestrated her ruin from the beginning? That her devotion was used as a weapon against her? And Ahazan, who clearly still loves her in some broken, incomprehensible way but has convinced himself that the only language she'll understand is violence and domination? The letter. The letter that ended everything. 'I do not believe I will ever love you.' Those five words. She clung to them for YEARS. Ten years of waking up in hell and telling herself it was worth it because he needed her. And it wasn't just political necessity—it was his CHOICE. He chose to break her heart. He chose to give her away. And then he had the audacity to ask her to pretend she'd done it willingly. 'I would have loved you to the end. If you had [pitied me], I would not have become another man's wife. An innocent man would not have lost his head by your hand.' She's right. She is so right and it kills me that she's sitting there realizing it. And Ahazan—god, the way he looks at her when he thinks she's not paying attention. The way he flinches when she actually tries to stab him. He wants her to kill him and he's terrified she won't.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or