To the Top-Ranked Person I Despise - Reviews

To the Top-Ranked Person I Despise
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The dialogue in this text is deceptively simple, and that's what makes it so effective. Kartan speaks in short, surgical bursts. "Just ten times." "With me." "Graduating as valedictorian." Each line is deliberate, each pause calculated. He never explains, never justifies. The economy of his words makes him feel dangerous — he doesn't need to persuade because he knows she's already half-convinced. Delia's dialogue, by contrast, is reactive. "You're insane." "With you?" "What do you think?" She's always responding, never initiating. Even her silence — the way she turns and opens the door sharply — is a kind of dialogue, a communication of her fury and shame. But my favorite exchange is practically invisible. The orphanage director and Delia's father: "Has this child shown any signs of being particularly bright?" "Bright, you say...?" "I'm asking if she's exceptionally intelligent." The director stammers. The father is impatient. Neither of them asks Delia how SHE feels about any of this. She's a subject being inspected, not a person being consulted. This pattern repeats everywhere — even Delia's father's tenderness feels scripted, rehearsed. "Come. Let's go home." Not "Would you like to come home with me?" Just... imperative. Command disguised as kindness. The narrative voice itself is omniscient but deeply anchored in Delia's perspective. We get her internal monologue in italics — her fears, her calculations, her desperate bargaining with herself — which creates this haunting layer where the reader sees everything Delia refuses to admit out loud. The gap between what she says and what she thinks IS the story.
... Read More
The structure of this passage is absolutely masterful in how it layers revelation. We open IN MEDIA RES with Kartan's proposition — this shocking moment that grabs you by the throat — and then the narrative pivots to Delia's backstory, which recontextualizes EVERYTHING. Without the flashback, Kartan's offer would just be... creepy guy makes creepy offer. But with the backstory? It becomes a devastating trap. We learn she was orphaned at ten, surviving on barely anything in a terrible orphanage, and then her "miracle" day — her father arriving in a carriage that alone was worth more than the entire orphanage. She thought she was being saved. She was being acquired. The parallel structure is brutal: the orphanage director who never cared about her suddenly groveling for money vs. the father who only sees her as "Acremen blood" and intelligence. Both treated her as a transaction. The only difference is one paid in cash and the other pays in fine rooms and tutors. And then we get the gut punch at the end — five years of grinding, studying, cutting sleep, believing in the dream — and the result: SECOND PLACE. The text deliberately withholds the full aftermath of this revelation. It ends mid-sentence almost, like we're still trapped in that moment of devastation. The plot isn't just about Delia wanting to be valedictorian. It's about the system that made her believe this was the only way to be loved, and now that system is handing her a poisoned apple on a silver platter.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or