Nie Yinzhi's dialogue is doing SO much work here and I keep pulling random lines out. 'Zou Chenghua was disrespectful, I was teaching him how to respect his fellow disciples. What's wrong with that? Is there a need for such a big fuss?' She says this to a formal sect hearing like she's explaining to a nosy neighbor why she yelled at a stray cat. The deflection is instant, lazy, almost bored. Then when the elder gets mad she goes 'Wait, did Zou Chenghua die?' with this little head-tilt described, and it lands because of the casualness. She's not panicking. She's not calculating. She's genuinely clocking new information mid-conversation. And the 'Perhaps he was so ashamed after hearing my words that he exploded and died' line. The ELDER. In front of the Punishment Hall official. She just... shrugged and blamed his shame. I re-read that three times because it's either incredibly stupid or incredibly arrogant and I think it's both. Her voice in the Zou Chenghua fight was different though, more physical, more amused. 'I'm not worthy, but you are.' Short, cutting, no follow-up. She doesn't need to explain. Then the willow leaves scattered all over the ground, branch broken, and she just says 'Alright, you can leave now.' Like she's ending a dinner party. The contrast between her spoken lines and the narration describing her is interesting. Narratively she's being set up as this untouchable genius, sword-energy-infused willow branches, spiritual bone, five-year Golden Core. But her actual VOICE in dialogue is snarky, slightly bored, never raising her volume. She's never yelling. Even when she's been hit by his pressure and is kneeling on the floor spitting blood, she changes her posture, sits down properly, and goes 'You dare not.' The mockery is in the posture change, not the words. Sang Wumian's dialogue is the opposite. Short, clipped, authoritative. 'Ah Yin, you have taken it upon yourself to punish a fellow disciple. Do you understand your crime?' 'Nonsense.' 'Presumptuous.' He doesn't elaborate. Every line is a hammer. And that's why her casual tone is so effective against him. She refuses to match his register. Meng Jin's lines are the most 'normal' human, full of sorrow, 'How could you be so ruthless for a mere verbal dispute,' which makes Nie Yinzhi's answer even funnier by contrast. I'd say the author's style here is very lean on dialogue, letting the subtext do the heavy lifting, and I'm here for it.