The Sin of Daring to Abandon Me - Reviews

The Sin of Daring to Abandon Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so I need to just... breathe for a second after that training yard scene. Everything was fine—swords clashing, political tension, whatever—but then Hilbardo says it, right? "She endures this wretched farce of a marriage to you." And the way he's basically threatening to kill Raian with his bare hands after that? I was on the edge of my seat. But then—the absolute gut punch of it all—Violetta arrives and what does she do? She tends to her HUSBAND. She offers Raian a handkerchief like some proper duchess should. And Hilbardo? He's standing there, bleeding from his own hand, hiding it so she won't see. Hiding it. From her. And she doesn't even notice. She just looks at Raian. "And for Hilbardo, that hurt more than the pain in his body." That line alone destroyed me. It's not even dramatic, just stated flatly like it's a fact of the universe, and yet it's the most devastating thing I've read all year. Then Violetta goes to bring Raian medicine and bandages—still doing her duty, still trying to be the good wife even though he clearly doesn't deserve it—and finds out he's already left to see Sola. And the box sits there. Unused. The bandages and ointment still exactly as she packed them. This woman is pouring everything into a marriage that is one-directional as hell, and I just... I can't. Hilbardo on the other hand, we know his side now—he sacrificed the iron mine, he gave up his chance at betrothal to protect his household from political destruction. He's trapped by his own position. The tragedy is that both of them are losing to circumstances they can't control, and Violetta is the one paying the price with her heart every single day.
... Read More
"You'll manage perfectly well without me. You always have." I need to sit with this line for a second. On paper it's cruel—Raian says it and literally walks away. But read it again. Who says that to someone they don't care about? That's not dismissal. That's the verbal equivalent of someone who has to leave a room because if they stay one more second they'll collapse. He's projecting confidence onto her because he needs her to survive without him. There's a difference. And then the way he behaves after—tap-tap-tapping his fingers, clearing his throat, following her with his footsteps like he wants to say something but can't find the shape for it. The author doesn't give us internal monologue for Raian, which is honestly the smartest choice. We're forced to read him through action, and every action is contradictory. He hires a future-seer on a whim. He won't visit Violeta after the accident. He brings the strange man to meet her anyway. What is this man actually feeling? Meanwhile Violeta is sitting there counting every slight like bruises. She wants him to ask after her—just once, just out of duty—and he doesn't. Not because he doesn't care, I suspect, but because caring is exactly the problem. If he shows concern, the carefully constructed wall between them cracks. And then there's Hilbardo, who waited three years for a letter that never arrived. Three years. He thought he was buying her freedom with a war, and instead she was handed to someone else. That betrayal is so specific and so sharp it made my chest hurt.
... Read More
Let me be clear: the duel between Hilbardo and Raian is NOT a sparring match. The text tells us this directly—'This would be no gentle exchange; no sparring match softened by restraint.' And they prove it. What starts as clashing blades escalates into a bare-knuckle brawl because Hilbardo loses control the moment Raian mentions Violetta. And then Raian throws his sword away too, which is arguably the more dangerous choice—now there are no rules, no distance, just two men who want to hurt each other as close as possible. The stakes here are layered like an onion and I love it. On the surface, it's about who gets Violetta. Deeper, it's about honor—Raian refusing any special treatment because 'what Raian despised most was the very notion that Hilbardo might go easy on him.' His pride is his armor. For Hilbardo, it's about possession and desperation masquerading as justice for Violetta's suffering. 'His heart burned with the urge to spill blood—blood to match every tear Violetta had shed.' That's not just anger. That's grief weaponized. But the REAL stakes are political. Hilbardo reveals the entire chessboard: if he'd been betrothed to Violetta, 'Pardia would have been torn to pieces by the Imperial faction and the Crown Prince's nobles.' The border war tomorrow isn't just a military campaign—it's a vehicle to get Hilbardo killed, or at least away, so the power dynamics can shift. And Raian, sitting in that crumbling slum house, says the quiet part out loud: 'I wish Hilbardo would die. His arrogant manner... Above all...' He doesn't finish the sentence. He doesn't need to. He wants Hilbardo gone so Violetta can't be taken from him. The border war is someone else's battlefield, but these two are already fighting to the death over who gets to love her.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Hilbardo's letter because this is the moment that completely shifted my emotional axis for this entire arc. You have Sola standing there, post-departure ceremony, trying to convince herself she loves Raian and doesn't care about Hilbardo—all that rationalization about choosing the man who can embrace her—and then BAM, a laundry maid delivers a letter with Hilbardo's handwriting. The details are so painfully specific too: he left a sturdy chest on her balcony and promised to return before the end of winter. She reads it, puts it in her desk drawer, and the narration tells us she does it 'so that I could take out and read it again, anytime.' That's not casual behavior. That's the kind of thing you do with something precious that you're terrified will disappear. And then immediately after that deeply private moment, we get the confrontation with the duchess in the corridor. Sola shows up in that yellow dress—when she was supposed to be confined to the annex—and asks to take care of the young master. Like that's not the most audacious thing I've ever read. The duchess absolutely dismantles her with 'How can I trust you with my child?' and then drops the line about people who endure harsher circumstances and still choose honesty. The structural placement of these two scenes back-to-back is not accidental at all. First we see Sola hoarding private sentiment, then we see her publicly overreaching. The plot is building this picture of a woman who thinks she can have both emotional intimacy with one man and social security with another, and the duchess is about to make that impossible. Also the subplot of Raian's paranoia about the child—'If that child bears not a single resemblance to me, how can I be certain they're mine?'—this thread is still loose and I am genuinely worried about where it's going. He's trusting Sola with budget permits and demanding loyalty while harboring doubts that could destroy everything.
... Read More
The opening paragraph is basically the thesis statement for everything: all her relentless work gets recorded under her husband's name. The rumors paint her as greedy and lazy when the reality is the opposite. This touches on something real and sharp — how women's labor gets absorbed into men's legacies, how reputation becomes a weapon used against people who actually hold everything together. But the symbol that keeps coming back is names themselves. The protagonist's name in this world is Sola — the same name as the novel's transmigrated protagonist. And then there's the title "Duchess of Stroud" which is really just a label attached to someone else's power. Her son Jaive is named but already his future is being projected onto him as a vessel for her hopes. The whole concept of lordship, of legacy, of who gets remembered — it's all tangled up. The war with the barbarians looming in the background adds another layer. When the empire sends reinforcements and the duke's illegitimate lineage makes him feel insecure next to Barnes Hilbardo — the legitimate heir and her childhood friend — you start seeing how systems of power operate on paper and in blood. Who deserves credit. Who gets erased. Who gets to speak and who just listens.
... Read More
'The alleyways of the slums were worn and filthy. In some places, the stench was so foul it defied imagination, and he had to cover his nose and mouth with a handkerchief as he walked.' God, the contrast here is killing me. You've got the imperial training grounds—cheering knights, steel clashing, the whole glorious spectacle of noble combat—and then immediately we cut to Raian navigating a slum so horrific it makes him physically recoil. The world-building in this author's hands isn't some glossy fantasy backdrop; it has texture. You can SMELL that alleyway. And the detail about the poor people! 'The poor he had known until now were either openly aggressive or so weighed down by hardship that they remained indifferent to others.' That's one sentence that tells us everything about Raian's entire life experience. He's never actually encountered genuine poverty before Sola. The mansion, the training grounds, the political circles—those are gilded cages, and Sola's little crumbling house is apparently the only real place he's ever stepped foot in. Yet it's also the most dangerous place for him, emotionally. The training ground scene itself is equally vivid—the knights dividing themselves instinctively into Stroud and Imperial factions, the way the yard falls silent when Raian steps forward, the physicality of the duel. You can hear the steel, feel the heat and the exhaustion. But what really sells it is that moment when Violetta enters and the whole atmosphere shifts. The officiant declaring the duel ended while everyone stands frozen, Baron Christie hauling Raian away, Violetta offering that handkerchief. It's cinematic, absolutely cinematic.
... Read More
I need to talk about one specific moment because I cannot stop thinking about it. The milk cup tipping over during the confrontation with the mother-in-law. Just this tiny domestic detail — milk spreading across the floor, dripping, ruined — and it becomes this enormous symbol of her entire existence in that house. Something pure and nourishing, knocked over by someone else's greed and vanity, left unworthy of even being consumed. But the world itself is genuinely impressive. The Duchy of Stroud having the most beautiful port in the Empire, thriving maritime trade, merchant ships going to foreign lands — you can see it. And then contrasting that with the slums where the male lead apparently operates? The inspection trip they're forced to take, the relief supplies, the knights riding out — it all feels grounded and lived-in. This isn't some generic fantasy palace with floating towers. There's actual infrastructure, actual work, actual logistics being managed. The carriage ride to the slums with Raian sitting beside her in total silence, the chill seeping "beyond the carriage" to affect even the knights — that's atmosphere done right. You don't need descriptive paragraphs about the weather or the road. The emotional temperature tells you everything.
... Read More
What strikes me most about the dialogue here is what's NOT being said. Raian and Violetta's exchange before the banquet is nearly flawless in its cruelty: ‘You are dressed as radiant as a flower.' → ‘Is it because you wished to impress the prince?' → ‘I am only doing my duty as the hostess of the banquet.' → ‘Of course. You would want to do your best. Unlike me—the emperor's half-blooded son—my brother is the rightful heir.' Every line is a knife wrapped in silk. He's not angry—he's resentful, and the distinction matters. He's using her words against her ‘Unless, perhaps, I struck a nerve?' as if HE's the one being wronged. But the most devastating dialogue comes from Hilbardo, who says almost nothing. ‘The duchess sent it back.' ‘Yes, Your Highness.' ‘What expression did the duchess wear when she gave you this letter?' ‘No different from usual, Your Highness.' ‘I see. That will be all.' That's it. Four exchanges. In twenty words, we learn he's freshly washed, he's alone, he opened the box himself, and he's breaking. The maid's平淡 response—‘no different from usual'—is the only thing louder than his silence. Sola's conversation with the physician is the opposite: rapid-fire, urgent, overlapping. ‘How did you come here?' ‘Why are you here?' ‘You could have sent a letter. Why come here and put me in trouble?' ‘Because your brother looks close to death. I couldn't waste time.' No punctuation polish, no elegance—just panic and love colliding. And then Violetta's letter: ‘I know this breaks decorum, but I must ask you to understand. Official gifts are welcome, but personal ones are better left unsent.' That's the most painful sentence in the entire chapter because it's so careful, so proper, and it's the equivalent of a door slamming.
... Read More
"There are those who endure in far harsher circumstances, yet still choose honesty even knowing how much easier the other path would be. Unlike you." I read this line three times and I am still not over it. The duchess's dialogue throughout this entire confrontation is absolutely lethal and every single word is precisely calibrated. She doesn't raise her voice. She doesn't lose her composure. She just... cuts. Deep. And the contrast with Sola's dialogue is what makes it hit even harder. Listen to Sola: "Wouldn't it help if I did?" "I had my reasons too. I needed money for my younger brother's treatment, so I had no choice." This is a woman who spent chapters deceiving an entire household and is now showing up in the duchess's corridor asking to care for her child, wrapping it in this fragile excuse like it's somehow morally equivalent. Her voice is soft, yielding, performative. She's always performing. The duchess doesn't perform anything. Her dialogue is stripped bare. "I've no reason to concern myself with you." "How can I trust you?" "You deceived everyone in this house." Period. Full stops. No hedging, no elaboration, no room for negotiation. And then the closing line—"Unlike you"—that's the knife twist. That's the mic drop. Even Raian's dialogue has a distinct voice, just a different flavor of poison. His sentences are wrapped in gentleness but the meaning underneath is ownership and threat. 'So you must never betray me.' Said while stroking her hair. The narrative voice itself—Sola's first-person perspective—has this quality of someone who is constantly narrating her own suffering to make it feel more bearable. 'Or so I told myself.' That phrase alone tells you everything about a narrator who knows her own rationalizations but can't stop making them.
... Read More
The symbolism in this chapter is SO heavy I almost couldn't breathe. Raian burning his brother's letters to his wife—"the first time he had burned one of Hilbardo's letters had been less than a month after their wedding"—this man has been hoarding and destroying evidence of affection directed at his wife for months. The candle flame, the ashes, the cigar he lights afterward. It's not just jealousy, it's about POWER and possession. He needs her because the Emperor gave him Pardia, and Hilbardo represents everything Raian can't control. Then there's the Duchess walking through the garden seeing birds in formation, harmonious together, and thinking "So very different from me—a blemish marring the ducal house of Stroud." She's literally comparing herself to a disrupted flock. And the boy she brought in, Morant, who claims he can "see the future"—is that a gift or a curse? Is he actually prophetic or just reading the story like Sola does? The whole setup feels like a chess game where everyone thinks they're playing but some pieces might know the board better than the players. And that ending where the Duchess catches them in the garden, the unspoken everything hanging in the air, and she just leaves before things escalate—that's not weakness, that's strategy. I'm just sitting here wondering who's actually manipulating whom.
... Read More
The banquet scene is SO vividly rendered it actually made me feel tired reading it. ‘Beautiful candlesticks, each the work of a master craftsman, had been placed upon the tables. The musicians tuned and checked their instruments before the banquet began, while maids and pages bustled about, carrying platters of food.' That's the surface—grand, polished, perfect. But then you cut to Violetta's body: ‘so taxing it was to spend an entire day in a tight dress, with my hair pulled so high and tight my temples ached.' The physical discomfort grounds the entire scene. You're not just watching a party—you're feeling the corset, the heavy makeup, the exhaustion. The contrast between the candlelit hall and the cold chill clinging to the couple entering together is such a simple but effective detail. The household staff think ‘they must have quarreled again'—that casual dismissal is worldbuilding through gossip. But the REAL scene that haunts me is the apple moment. ‘The crisp autumn night air carried with it the sweet-tart fragrance wafting from within.' Just that one sensory detail—the smell, the red apples, the wooden box—and suddenly you're standing on that balcony with her. Then ‘he would often send me gifts in just this way. Once, by chance, I caught him hauling such a box up to the balcony himself, straining with the effort.' That flashback is embedded in a single paragraph and it carries years of history. And Hilbardo's chamber later: ‘Droplets fell from his hair, soaking into the thin white fabric of his shirt, dampening his shoulders as heavily as his heart.' Water on fabric as metaphor for grief—quiet, absorbing, unavoidable. The slammed lid is the only sound in the entire scene.
... Read More
Raian carrying Sola to his office. That's it. That's the scene. He storms in looking like he wants to murder someone, sweeps Violetta aside like she's nothing, pulls this trembling, half-undressed person into his arms and just holds them. Close enough to see the bindings. Close enough to know. And he doesn't say anything about it in that moment—he just carries them. Like his body already made the decision before his mouth did. And Sola's internal monologue is simultaneously the funniest and most heartbreaking thing I've read. She's pressing her face into his chest, crying, and her brain is like: okay focus, this is the scene where he finally loses control and claims me, this is my favorite part. Meanwhile the reader is over here absolutely losing it because we can SEE that he already knows. He's carrying you through his hallway with your shirt half open and his heart is literally hammering against your ear and you're thinking about romantic climaxes?? Then there's Hilbardo, who I just—man. The man drank glass after glass on that balcony while remembering every single gift he never managed to give her. And when the child appeared, when he saw her smile at that baby... it broke something in him. He couldn't unsee it. So he swallowed his resolve. One drink to bury the house. Another to hide the gifts. His heart though, that he can't burn away. He's the tragic option who loves her enough to let her go and it makes me want to shake him. And Violetta—cold, calculating Violetta who ordered Morant stripped—and yet she's the one weeping alone with an empty apple box on her balcony. This story has built a house of mirrors and every reflection shows a different kind of pain.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or