The President I Have a Contractual Relationship With Has An Amnesia - Reviews

The President I Have a Contractual Relationship With Has An Amnesia
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is doing a LOT of heavy lifting and I think the author found a really specific voice for Xianwen that I both love and loathe. His lines are short, calm, almost gentle, and completely threatening. 'Getting bold, are we?' Four words. Said with a smirk while she's wearing a spaghetti-strap nightgown and he's looking toward Jiaran's room like he saw a ghost. You know exactly what he means and you know he means to say it in front of her so the shame lands. 'Who gave you the nerve to toy with my little brother like a fool?' The 'like a fool' at the end is so dismissive. She's not a rival, she's a child playing dress-up. Then in the study: 'Ning Zhen, how old are you? Where did you learn these tricks? Who taught you?' Three questions in rapid succession, each one stripping away another layer of her dignity, and he's not raising his voice. He's not yelling. He's ASKING. And that's worse. And then the car scene with Jiaran where he goes 'I realized today that my brother is actually very fragile' and she just internally fires off a single question mark. 'Ning Zhen: ?' The author literally gave her one character of dialogue and it's PERFECT. She has nothing to say because the statement is so absurd it defies verbal response. The narration voice for Ning Zhen is also really funny when she's in panic mode, 'babbling nonsense without even knowing what she was saying,' 'she was done for. Completely finished.' The repetition of 'completely finished' is very her. She thinks in absolutes. Either she's fine or she's finished. There's no middle ground. And Xianwen's final offer in the apartment, the whole 'a number' moment. He doesn't even say the number. The narration just says 'slowly and calmly saying a number.' I can't tell if that's his company valuation, a debt she owes, the price of her freedom. It doesn't matter WHAT the number is, it matters that he just... says it. Casually. Like reading a grocery list. And she 'swallowed her words.' The voice of this book overall is sly, a little mean, very much on Ning Zhen's side even when she's being pathetic. It's the voice of a friend who's drinking too much wine and going 'babe, you idiot, why did you do that.' I keep wanting to yell at the page. 'DON'T agree, just walk out!' But I know she won't, and the author knows I know, and that's how the tension is built.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say — this is one of those plot devices that is absolutely DIabolical and I love it. The concussion isn't just a medical condition, it's a NARRATIVE WEAPON. Meng Xianwen wakes up and immediately sends Ning Zhen away. She's standing outside the door, practically vibrating with the need to eavesdrop, and meanwhile his own brother has to play messenger because apparently direct communication between the two of them is too much to handle. But here's where it gets GOOD — and I mean genuinely good plotting, not just dramatic — Ning Zhen's internal monologue when she first hears about the memory loss. She CRIED. Happy tears. Because she knew he had forgotten THAT NIGHT. The night three months ago when he caught her in the act, when they had this romantic agreement between them. If he remembered any of that, he wouldn't have treated her like a stranger today. He forgot. The concussion did its job as a great equalizer. And then Meng Jiaran drops this bomb about the grandfather's withdrawal slip incident — which I assume is some earlier plot point we haven't seen yet — and suddenly the stakes shift from romantic drama into corporate family intrigue territory. The plot is layering itself like an onion and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
I want to give Meng Jiaran a moment because I feel like the reader's eye just glazes over on him and I'm not having that. He's the brother, sure, he's the sidekick to the main couple, but look at what he's actually doing in this batch. He drives to the hotel, sits across from Ning Zhen, pours water, listens to her cry, and delivers this speech: 'I think that if he liked you once, he'll like you again, even with the memory loss. Feelings can be rebuilt slowly.' And then he finishes his water, stretches, and says 'I'll sleep at the hospital' and leaves. No lingering. No moralizing. Just... showing up, doing the job, and going. That's a complete character portrait in like twelve lines. I love that he's irritated, that he has red veins in his eyes from not sleeping, that he snaps at Ning Zhen a little when she deflects. He's not a supportive-bro cliché, he's a tired man running errands while his brother's brain is literally rewiring itself. And the way he and Xiao Xuezhen exchange looks in the car when they spot the hickey? They don't say a word. They just... look at each other and look at their son and say nothing. That's more loaded than any dialogue could be. Now Ning Zhen herself, I'll be honest, she's the one who's hard to root for and I don't think that's a bug, it's the point. The whole batch is basically her internal monologue rationalizing. She's lying to her mom on speakerphone, playing the aggrieved girlfriend, curling up on a sofa in a presidential suite she probably didn't pay for, and thinking 'scheming against him was like pulling a tiger's whiskers. She could only psych herself up silently: the bigger the risk, the bigger the reward.' That's not a love interest, that's a con artist with a heart-shaped target. And the fact that she can sit in a warm bath and think 'Being Meng Xianwen's girlfriend was way too enjoyable' while planning to walk away the second it stops being convenient? The author is letting us hate her and want her to fail and feel guilty for wanting her to fail. Which is more interesting than any 'boyfriend slowly falls back in love' beat could be. Does Meng Xianwen see any of this? The text says his gaze was 'calm, without a single ripple' and I keep wondering if that's the amnesia or just him deciding to let her play the game because he already knows the score. Not sure yet, and I want to be not sure a lot longer.
... Read More
The suitcase lock. Think about what that actually is thematically. A combination lock on a suitcase is the most intimate barrier in the world. It's not a house door, not a phone, not a vault. It's the thing you carry. The small, personal container of your self that follows you everywhere. And the password for it is six zeroes — the laziest, most default, "I don't actually care who gets in" setting. Meng Xianwen apparently just... set it to the factory default and forgot. And that detail becomes the entire load-bearing wall of Ning Zhen's fake relationship. She's standing on a six-zero foundation. And then there's the layer of the memory loss itself, which I think is doing way more thematic work than it needs to. He lost his memory (or is performing it) and now every little fact he used to take for granted — who his girlfriend is, what his passwords are, how he shaves — has to be renegotiated. Intimacy becomes a performance. She performs "girlfriend" through packing for him, offering to shave, drying his hair. He performs "the version of me who remembers" or "the version who doesn't," and we as readers are just... watching two people do improv in a hospital room and seeing who blinks first. It's a thesis on how identity is mostly just a set of small rituals you've internalized, and pull one thread and the whole thing unravels. The New Year's Eve flashback also ties into this. She learned the password by accident, eavesdropping in a crowd, in the middle of chaos. Knowledge about another person shouldn't come from overhearing a phone call while traffic is gridlocked and fireworks are going off. It should come from trust, from choosing to share. And yet here she is, two years later, using that stolen-trivia as her proof of love. Is that love? Or is it just the closest approximation she can manufacture from fragments? I think the author is asking that question without ever saying it out loud, and it's quietly unsettling. Also the mahjong joke. Five people, one mahjong set, one leftover. "I'm at the bottom of the food chain, I'll serve tea." That's a whole social hierarchy compressed into one line. Who sits where, who gets to be the joke, who gets to be the one left out of the game. And Ning Zhen posting nine photos, six selfies, "Family together, nice and neat!" — she's constructing a narrative of normalcy, of chosen family, of everything being fine. The exclamation marks are doing a lot of emotional labor. Everything is NOT fine. But the performance of "fine" is what keeps the whole structure from collapsing. Passwords, masks, the gap between the real and the performed — it's all in these chapters and I'm slowly going off the deep end.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or