The NPC Was Once Again Frightened By Me - Reviews

The NPC Was Once Again Frightened By Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let me just... start by saying the coin flip scene on the rooftop had me absolutely wrecked. Like, I read it three times because I couldn't process what was happening. Lin Huai flips tails five times in a row and still keeps going, and then on the LAST coin—heads. But then he tells Xu Chi 'It's you who let me win.' What does that even mean?? Is he saying Xu Chi subconsciously wanted him to win? Or is this some manipulation tactic? The whole sequence feels like Lin Huai is playing some long game where he controls outcomes while pretending it's chance. And honestly? It's terrifying. The way the narrative builds from Xu Chi's quiet confession about his dead friend to this coin-flipping moment on the rooftop at sunset—that structural pivot is masterful. One minute it's melancholy, the next it's surreal and almost threatening. Then BAM, four days later we cut to another death. Feng Zilu. The class monitor. Dead in the cafeteria. And suddenly the stakes go from personal grief to a body count that's climbing like a horror movie. The plot is weaving these threads—Yu Xingjian's guilt, Yan Xi's diary, the haunted restroom, the peeping tom backstory—and it all feels like a trap closing tighter with every chapter. I need to know what happens next because this author knows how to keep the pressure on.
... Read More
Okay so this whole sequence is just... chef's kiss for tension-building. You've got Shao Wei going all heroic "I'll go alone" even though we all know he's terrified, then getting absolutely wrecked by the atmosphere once he's solo. The shift from confident hero-walk to full-on screaming panic is painfully funny but also really well-paced. And then BAM — Lin Huai appears out of nowhere, completely unfazed, dissecting the fake ghost props like a forensic scientist. Meanwhile in the other room Chen Shu is watching monitors and thinking stuff like "it's almost as if he has killed someone himself" which is such a delicious narrative thread. Who IS Lin Huai exactly? Is he some kind of serial killer or just brutally pragmatic? The way the monitors go dark right after his intense stare is giving major thriller vibes. Then we cut to the group struggling with a door, Shao Wei passed out, and now they're trying tosqueeze through a DOG HOLE. The stakes feel real because there's a literal three-minute timer ticking. But the funniest part is how they manipulated Shao Wei into crawling through — "this is your chance to show off in front of the girls" — like bro you're being used as a human tool and you agreed to it for SPICY HOT POT.
... Read More
The mirror scene hit me on re-read and now I can't unsee it. Lin Huai spends fifteen minutes every night facing a mirror practicing his smile. Why? A normal person practices a smile for a photo or a job interview. A normal person doesn't need to rehearse basic facial expressions as a nightly ritual. Combined with his description of living through years of foul winds and bloody rains yet wanting nothing more than an ordinary peaceful life, it paints a picture of someone who has learned that survival depends on performing normality. The app itself is a symbol of this—the supernatural terror has been transformed into consumer goods, into something you browse and add to cart. Water Ghosts' Hair Tonic, Painted Skin Foundation. The titles alone reference some of the most iconic Chinese ghost folklore, and reducing them to beauty products says something devastating about a world where horror has become commerce. Even the room assignments, with people being sorted like merchandise, echo that same logic. And Lin Huai's theory that the evil spirit set all this up to advertise its own app without caring about innocent people—whether he's genuinely believes this or is deflecting from his own suspected nature—the theme remains the same. In this world, identity is the first thing consumed.
... Read More
I need to talk about that smell. “A scent that is a little moist and peculiar.” The narrator doesn't say “rotting” or “decay.” They say the odor is moist. There is something deeply intimate about that word choice—moist suggests life, not just death. It's the smell of something that was recently alive and is now stopping being alive. It made my skin prickle. Lin Huai's emotional arc in these four chapters is devastatingly compressed. He arrives terrified, pale, cold—his body temperature literally described as ice cold. But instead of pure panic, his mind races to practical concerns: “I only arrived today, if I knew something like this would happen I should definitely continue living at the school dorm.” The humor is a defense mechanism, and it breaks my heart. He is performing normalcy while surrounded by the impossible. The interaction between Lin Huai and Chu Tian carries a strange undercurrent of vulnerability. Chu Tian sits beside the newcomer without explanation, asking what's going on. He holds a murder weapon and smiles like a model who wandered onto the wrong set. For someone who has never played a game, Chu Tian is the first person who doesn't treat him like a suspect. That matters more than the text lets on. Huang Lu's protective instinct toward Lin Huai is quietly moving. She explains the rules patiently despite everyone else's suspicion. “Cocky people usually don't live long.” She is giving him survival advice wrapped in a warning. There is a tenderness in how she shields the newcomer from the crowd's hostility—she is a veteran who remembers what it was like to arrive alone. The deepest emotional moment for me is Lin Huai's internal calculation about his roommate's smelly feet: “even if his roommate's feet smelt like the rot of a pile of thousand year old corpses.” He would rather endure his roommate's stink than stay in this apartment. The mundane versus the horrific creates an emotional whiplash that I couldn't stop thinking about. It's funny, it's sad, it's profoundly human.
... Read More
There's a line in here that I keep returning to: 'When someone who was always worse off suddenly has good fortune, people's jealousy and resentment are endless.' That's not just plot exposition. That's the thesis of this entire novel. The Ren family's tragedy isn't caused by a ghost or a cursed lottery ticket—it's caused by PEOPLE. The villagers who brought bad wheat, the managers who cut corners, the security guard who drank on the job, the debt collectors, the ones who heard Ren Chun screaming and said nothing. The village is complicit in every single disaster. And this symbolism runs deeper than I initially realized. The lottery ticket represents false hope—the thing that promises salvation but actually accelerates destruction. The flour mill represents trust exploited—Ren Chun's father built something meant to help everyone, and everyone used it to destroy him. The water in which Ren Chun drowned represents the buried truth—she went under and the village covered it up like sediment settling at the bottom of a pond. And the heart-removal incidents? That's the ultimate theft. These villagers already took everything from the Ren family—their livelihood, their safety, their justice—and now the ghosts are taking their hearts literally. The title of this whole arc might as well be 'What We Owe Each Other' and the answer is nothing because they chose to take instead.
... Read More
Okay first of all can we talk about how each character's dialogue is instantly recognizable? Like, I could read a line and know who said it without any attribution tags. Lin Huai has this gleeful, razor-edged cadence—"Isn't it fun?" after making peasants flinch, and then the deadpan villain reveal about picking five victims to die. That's not someone performing evil; that's someone who genuinely finds it amusing, and the casual delivery makes it ten times worse. His line about Chu Tianshu turning this into Detective Conan? Chef's kiss.
... Read More
I'm not okay with what the author just did to Du Xiaoran and honestly I'm not okay with myself for caring this much about a side character's subplot. This girl has a nightmare about Ren Chun's corpse floating in dark green water weeds and the very next thing we know she's awake at 3 AM carrying a lamp, wondering if Ren Qiu is sad. The text says 'she thought aimlessly' but nothing about that was aimless—that's devotion disguised as concern. And then her mother basically tells her Ren Qiu is dead and what kind of good person can a ghost be, and Du Xiaoran gets mad and goes back to bed fuming. She's protecting someone who might already be gone, and she won't even admit it to herself. Meanwhile back in the Sun household, Ruan Tian is staring at the moon wondering about Cheng Xin while Yan Chuchu tells her to sleep. Separated for 'good reasons' and both pretending they're fine with it. This novel keeps putting people apart and making me furious about it. The most devastating line in this whole batch is Du Xiaoyou telling her sister that 'Fierce Ghosts take their relatives away, sooner or later she will come back and take Ren Qiu away'—and then Du Xiaoran losing her mind over it. A kid telling the truth and the only person who could do something about it is too scared to say it out loud. I genuinely cannot wait for the next time these characters are in the same room again.
... Read More
I need to talk about this scene on the rooftop because it hit me like a truck. Up until now, Xu Chi has been this quiet, intense, somewhat impenetrable character—the top student, the guy who follows rules, who seems completely controlled. And then Lin Huai just casually drags him out for an afternoon, buys him clothes, takes him to a newspaper office, cracks jokes about his future hairline—and somehow, all of that is what it takes to make him finally tell her about Yan Xi. About the day he almost jumped. About meeting Yan Xi on a rooftop just like this one, the day before Mid-Autumn Festival, when his parents had just divorced and no one wanted him. The image of him leaning on that railing thinking about what would happen if he fell, wondering if it would be a pity to die without ever leaving Yangshui... and then Yan Xi just appeared. This is the kind of moment that makes you realize these two characters have been carrying so much silently, and the friendship between them and Yan Xi is built on something way deeper than surface-level connection. Lin Huai didn't force it out of him—she created a space where he actually wanted to talk. That's some next-level empathy disguised as mischief.
... Read More
Let me just be honest—I did not expect this chapter to hit this hard on the conflict front. You have Lin Huai dealing with supernatural threats (the ghost, the mysterious notebook, the warnings about mirrors) AND this parallel storyline about systemic cruelty in the school environment. That girl running with stomach pain getting beaten by a security guard while her classmates watch silently? That is not just dramatic filler—that is the author showing us what kind of world these characters actually live in. Meanwhile the notebook contains phrases like "Don't look back" written four times and "Leave this place" in red ink. The stakes feel real on every level. Will Lin Huai survive the supernatural threat? Will that girl be okay? Who is writing in the notebook and why does it seem to know what will happen next? And what is with this YX person—the name is blacked out but clearly important? I am invested in all of it simultaneously and that is rare.
... Read More
Okay, this scene with Lin Huai and Chu Tianshu is absolutely peak dynamic. The way Lin Huai takes that iron rod and just *presses* it against Chu Tianshu's head—cold sweat and all—while casually asking about his real motives? Chilling. But then Chu Tianshu flips it into some tragic romance monologue about 'you handed me the power to hurt me and you stabbed my heart' and Lin Huai is just done. The subversion is everything. They're not just two guys destroying a van; it's a power negotiation. Chu Tianshu keeps offering up pieces of his past (Qin Jiang abroad, the manuscript chasing, the rainstorm) as if listing receipts, while Lin Huai listens but clearly doesn't buy any of it. The relationship here isn't built on trust—it's built on the *suspicion* of trust. Chu Tianshu wants to play the loyal, slightly absurd friend who followed him into this death trap, but Lin Huai sees the strings. And yet, he doesn't just shut him out. He keeps the rod on his head. He forces the conversation. That's the whole knot, right? They're stuck together because they're both hiding something, and the only way either of them knows what's real is by applying pressure. 'Don't call me Lin Pinru anymore. Call me Chu Shanshan.' What does that even mean for their history? How many names has this guy worn? And Lin Huai's entire body language screams he's still weighing whether Chu Tianshu is a liability or an asset. This isn't friendship. This is a tense, theatrical standoff where the script keeps changing mid-scene.
... Read More
I need to talk about Chu Tian because this character is doing SO much with so little. The moment that got me was when Lin Huai walks away and Chu Tian calls out 'Crow.' Then immediately backpedals with 'I just mistook you for someone else.' Bro. You did NOT mistake him for someone else. Your own narration tells us 'his expression clearly showed he hadn't mistaken anyone.' And then — and THEN — Chu Tian closes his eyes and bit his thumb, which the text tells us is a habit when he's deep in thought. Two figures slowly overlapping in his mind. What does that mean? Who was he thinking of? Who does Lin Huai remind him of? The text refuses to answer and I am HERE FOR IT. But what's devastating is the WeChat exchange. Chu Tian knows the rules. He knows he'll forget. And yet he makes sure their connection persists in the one place the Game can't touch. That's not casual. That's not 'you're still young you don't understand the importance of WeChat friends for forwarding votes.' That is a man finding a loophole to keep someone in his life, dressed up as a joke. Lin Huai sees right through it though — he calls out the contradiction immediately. Their dynamic is this gorgeous push-pull of knowing and not-knowing, caring and pretending not to. And the physical gesture at the end, the thumb-biting, the quiet observation... this is someone who just let the most important person in the Game walk away and is already planning how to find them again. "I need to find a way." Four words that carry so much weight.
... Read More
Lin Huai's dialogue in this chapter is so good I had to pause and read it three times. 'Do you really think I am that kind of pervert?' coming after he literally reached into a haunted television to grab a ghost's head, is peak comedic writing. The sheer audacity, the casual delivery, the absolute gaslighting, it is perfect. Then he follows up with 'I haven't killed a ghost in a long time' as a reassurance, which is simultaneously the most threatening and wholesome thing anyone has ever said in a horror story. The old TV ghost's voice is wonderfully pathetic, trembling, sniffing, crying 'ying ying', while Lin Huai treats him like a malfunctioning appliance that needs to be reset. 'Shut up' followed by pouring mineral water over his head, it is domestic violence but for ghosts, and I cannot stop smiling. The contrast between how terrifying Lin Huai sounds when he speaks and how mundane his complaints are, running low on in-game money, the store is too good, he just wants more credits, creates this bizarre comedic voice that is entirely his own. No other character in this story could deliver those lines. It feels like someone wrote dialogue for a supernatural being who accidentally picked up the personality of a bored millennial shopping online.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or