Oh my god, let me just sit with this for a second because I am actually emotionally compromised right now. Andrea walked into that room thinking she was with the person she confessed her feelings to, and then she wakes up and realizes it was some completely different man the whole time. THE BETRAYAL of her hopes. Like, she had worked so hard to accept that Priscilla was a woman and to love her anyway, and then apparently God granted her wish in the most cruelly accidental way possible—Priscilla's face on someone else's body. I couldn't stop reading that moment. The way she mutters to herself, "Is this a dream..." and then rubs it against her cheek like it's some kind of miracle she can't quite believe—is that not devastating? She wanted this. She wanted so badly. And it was built on a misunderstanding.
And Gillian! Don't even get me started on him. He was fighting himself the entire time, trying to be noble about Andrea being Theodore Ulrich's daughter, trying to stop himself, telling himself it would just be a kiss—but his body clearly had other plans. Then he finds out she was only touching him to CONFIRM it wasn't Priscilla, and you can literally feel his irritation snap into place like a switch flipped. He gets petty and teasing and almost cruel in the worst possible way, forcing her to verify things, making her look, making her touch. But then... then he keeps going anyway. He doesn't stop. He tells himself all these moral reasons why it's fine because to Andrea, Priscilla and Gillian are different people, and honestly? That self-justification is so painfully human. He's conflicted and horny and trying to rationalize and failing at all three simultaneously.
The morning after kills me though. Andrea fleeing like a raccoon caught in a spotlight, tiptoeing around the bed, writing that note—"I'm sorry. Thank you."—and then Gillian tossing it aside like he's irritated by her politeness when clearly he's the one who's been tossed around emotionally too. She thinks he's still sleeping and she runs out, legs shaking, and the poor girl is just trying to process the fact that her confession led to a night she didn't expect with someone she didn't plan for. Meanwhile he's lying there aware the whole time, listening to every step she takes, pretending to sleep because he's probably as confused as she is. This is not a clean romantic setup, this is a beautiful mess.