The “Non-Lady” Lessons - Reviews

The “Non-Lady” Lessons
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so this whole situation with Gillian and Andrea is giving me whiplash in the best way. Like, you've got this guy who's been disguised as Lady Priscilla the whole time, living some secret life, and then BAM—Andrea stumbles into his chambers and things get REAL physical, REAL fast. And what I love is how Gillian is clearly losing his mind here. One minute he's trying to maintain composure, the next he's swallowing his reason entirely. But the moment that knocked me over was when Andrea ran away afterward and he realized... she wasn't thinking of him AS Gillian. She thought she was with Priscilla. That 'I wasn't Priscilla' line hit so hard because it means all those intimate moments were built on a foundation of mistaken identity, and Gillian's left there wondering what the hell just happened. And Andrea's internal monologue about hugging her pillow and feeling 'strange' whenever she thinks of Gillian? Chilling. She literally confessed her feelings to someone pretending to be a woman, fell for that woman, then had an affair with the real man behind the disguise, and now she can't process any of it. The fact that she immediately worries 'Am I perhaps substituting for Lady Priscilla?' shows she's sharp enough to suspect something but too overwhelmed to confront it. These two are walking around each other like blind people in a room full of broken furniture.
... Read More
Okay so the train scene—where Gillian is disguised as Priscilla and Andrea gently flicks that damn scarf—was absolutely DEVASTATING in the best way. Andrea touches the scarf without thinking, drawn in by something she can't name. And then Gillian pushes her back and traps her hand, breath on her lips, and Andrea TURNS HER HEAD AWAY. Not because she doesn't want him, but because she can't face it. She's confused. She says sorry to Priscilla for touching the scarf like it was something improper. AND THEN later, when she's with the REAL Gillian in the carriage, she's wondering if she was ever attracted to Priscilla or just drawn to someone who LOOKS like Gillian. The line that wrecked me: "It's not like Gillian and I have any particular relationship." SHE'S LYING TO HERSELF AND WE BOTH KNOW IT. She just had an intimate moment with Priscilla on that train—her heart racing, breath caught—and now she's trying to convince herself it was nothing because the alternative is too complicated. But here's what I can't stop thinking about: Andrea says she felt something "spiritual" toward Priscilla, but then Gillian shows up in his male form and she's FLUTTERING. Is it possible her feelings were always for Gillian, and the resemblance just made it more confusing? Or did Priscilla genuinely touch something in her? And Gillian—poor tortured bastard—lying there on the sofa afterward going "this bastard, is she playing games with me?" while also admitting he couldn't do that to Andrea because her eyes sparkle with pure affection. He's torn between wanting her and knowing he can't give her anything real right now. I'm not okay.
... Read More
Okay so here's the thing that's been driving me absolutely insane about this chapter sequence — the entire setup is just one elaborate lie that somehow keeps getting thicker and thinner at the same time. Gillian has to pretend to be Priscilla. That's the baseline. But then Jerome shows up with wine and it's like the plot itself is going, 'yes, but what if we make this worse?' Because obviously the solution to 'I need to hide my gender' is 'let's get your companion blackout drunk.' Classic writing move, honestly. But then the genius part kicks in. Andrea wakes up half-aware, sees Gillian, and instead of screaming or calling guards or whatever a rational person would do, she decides this must be a DREAM. And since it's a dream, rule number one is 'you can do whatever you want.' Gillian's whole identity is a carefully constructed house of cards and the moment she starts unbuttoning his robe, those cards are already toppling. He kept saying to himself 'this is just to keep her asleep' but then his hands are already everywhere and he's like 'I really wasn't trying to get caught, okay?!' except he totally was, in a way. And then the morning after. Priscilla shows up with a scarf wrapped around her face like she's some forest fugitive, claiming she has a scar and can't do makeup, and Andrea is sitting there like 'oh I didn't do mine either' and I swear to god if they don't just look at each other and burst out laughing at some point, I'm going to lose it. The dramatic irony is so thick you could spread it on toast.
... Read More
The description of that club is so vivid. Poor sunlight, smoky decadent air, corridors that connect in all directions—it feels oppressive and dangerous. Andrea in her fresh mint-colored walking dress and bonnet looks completely out of place, which makes the scene even more tense. When the doorkeeper looks at her with rotten teeth and says 'I'll call for you later,' you can practically feel her goosebumps. The setting reflects her desperation and the risky world she's navigating. It's not just a backdrop; it's actively shaping her choices and heightening the stakes. And Gillian appearing in that grimy place creates this incredible contrast between his composed demeanor and the seedy environment.
... Read More
There's this ONE image in this entire passage that I cannot stop thinking about. After everything—after the passion, the knocking at the door, the frantic dressing—Andrea is still wearing her BONNET. The author specifically notes: 'He hadn't realized until now, but she was still wearing her bonnet.' And then later, she's gripping both sides of her bonnet brim tightly while her heart pounds. That bonnet is everything. It's her symbol of respectability, of being a proper unmarried young lady, of the social armor she wears daily. And it's still ON her head while she's lying on a bed having lost her reason completely. The contrast between the demure accessory and the wild act it witnessed is DEVASTATING. She can literally keep up the appearance of propriety while internally shattering. And then there's the mirror imagery with Gillian—powder falling from the mascara, him checking his eyelashes in the mirror, Jerome admiring how he's transformed into Lady Priscilla. Mirrors everywhere, reflection after reflection, but NEITHER character truly sees themselves. Andrea sees Priscilla and falls for her, then feels guilt for potentially substituting. Gillian sees himself in makeup and knows he's surviving, not living. The novel keeps asking: who are you when no one's watching? And the answer keeps being 'nobody stable.'
... Read More
Oh my god, let me just sit with this for a second because I am actually emotionally compromised right now. Andrea walked into that room thinking she was with the person she confessed her feelings to, and then she wakes up and realizes it was some completely different man the whole time. THE BETRAYAL of her hopes. Like, she had worked so hard to accept that Priscilla was a woman and to love her anyway, and then apparently God granted her wish in the most cruelly accidental way possible—Priscilla's face on someone else's body. I couldn't stop reading that moment. The way she mutters to herself, "Is this a dream..." and then rubs it against her cheek like it's some kind of miracle she can't quite believe—is that not devastating? She wanted this. She wanted so badly. And it was built on a misunderstanding. And Gillian! Don't even get me started on him. He was fighting himself the entire time, trying to be noble about Andrea being Theodore Ulrich's daughter, trying to stop himself, telling himself it would just be a kiss—but his body clearly had other plans. Then he finds out she was only touching him to CONFIRM it wasn't Priscilla, and you can literally feel his irritation snap into place like a switch flipped. He gets petty and teasing and almost cruel in the worst possible way, forcing her to verify things, making her look, making her touch. But then... then he keeps going anyway. He doesn't stop. He tells himself all these moral reasons why it's fine because to Andrea, Priscilla and Gillian are different people, and honestly? That self-justification is so painfully human. He's conflicted and horny and trying to rationalize and failing at all three simultaneously. The morning after kills me though. Andrea fleeing like a raccoon caught in a spotlight, tiptoeing around the bed, writing that note—"I'm sorry. Thank you."—and then Gillian tossing it aside like he's irritated by her politeness when clearly he's the one who's been tossed around emotionally too. She thinks he's still sleeping and she runs out, legs shaking, and the poor girl is just trying to process the fact that her confession led to a night she didn't expect with someone she didn't plan for. Meanwhile he's lying there aware the whole time, listening to every step she takes, pretending to sleep because he's probably as confused as she is. This is not a clean romantic setup, this is a beautiful mess.
... Read More
Let me be real—the dialogue in this chapter is what made me laugh out loud at least twice. Jerome is a force of nature. The way he transitions from watching Gillian fall apart on the sofa to casually dropping "What if you married Miss Ulrich?" like it's the most normal thing in the world? Iconic. And then Jerome's logic, delivered with zero shame: "Who do you think Priscilla is?" Jerome, who was literally laughing his ass off at Andrea's confession earlier, now pivoting to "actually this is kind of brilliant." The man's adaptability is unmatched. But the real dialogue gem is between Andrea and Gillian in the carriage. This exchange: "Come to think of it, what do you do for work, Gillian?" "I'm a wastrel." "That's it?" "Yeah?" "Don't you work?" "You don't either." "I do work." ... "Being pretty. Staying pretty to get married is a woman's job." Andrea saying this with an "unusually expressionless" face is such a perfect character moment. She's being darkly comedic while simultaneously revealing how trapped she feels by societal expectations. And Gillian's response—pivoting to "if you became a man, is there something you'd want to do?"—shows he's actually LISTENING to her, really hearing her for the first time. The Kirak language discussion at the end is pure gold too. Andrea calling Kirak "a land of opportunity" and Gillian immediately shooting it down with facts about agriculture and livestock, and then Andrea countering with "that just means there's more potential for development." That's not just good dialogue—that's two smart people testing each other intellectually.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or