The Gossip-Lover Wants to Stay Anonymous - Reviews

The Gossip-Lover Wants to Stay Anonymous
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Xu Baoying is honestly the best character written in this entire book and I will die on this hill. Like, think about it—she's this seemingly normal classmate who happens to be reading a boys' love manga during MORNING READING CLASS, giggling to herself, and when Zhu Yaya catches her she just casually offers to share like it's no big deal. 'Want to join, Yaya?' And then afterward she's all righteous about how 'boys love is true love!' I laughed so hard I nearly fell off my bed reading that. But then she tries to give Zhu Yaya actual intel about the male lead Murong Beichen and what does she get? A note that basically says he's definitely got something going on with his best friend Ling Yiming and she's just GENUINELY EXCITED about it. Two men fighting over one man—she loves it! Meanwhile Zhu Yaya is just sitting there like... sis, I'm trying to survive a novel transmigration and you're shipping the male lead. The dynamic between these two is everything though. Zhu Yaya is this overly serious, mission-focused scholar type who frowns at manga reading, and Xu Baoying is this chaotic energy who treats the entire situation like she's living her best life. There's also this weird triangle forming with Yan Heng—who apparently isn't even in the original plot but keeps coming up. The teachers throwing shade at each other in the office scene was the side content I didn't know I needed. Chang Wen vs Qiao Wei is giving so much tension and I'm concerned about nothing. Also the male lead—whichever one is ACTUALLY the male lead at this point—didn't even acknowledge Zhu Yaya when she shouted across the room. Just frowned, glanced at her, and went back to sleep. That's commitment to the role of invisible protagonist. I'm obsessed.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Yan Heng and Zhu Yaya because this whole thing keeps escalating in the most annoying way. Like, they get on the same bus, they walk the same route, they enter the same dilapidated building, and THEN he works at her breakfast shop? What are the odds?! I kept thinking there had to be some deeper connection I was missing, but the text just goes with the coincidence angle and really leans into it. What got me though was the way Yan Heng's gaze is described when he spots her in that tiny shop. 'He wore a transparent plastic mask and disposable gloves on his hands. His bangs fell over his forehead, and his narrow, long eyes held something inscrutable.' Inscrutable. The author doesn't even commit to whether he's angry, amused, confused, or any of that. He's just... looking at her. And she immediately feels cowardly, which is SO in character for Zhu Yaya. She can tail people through three districts but the moment he's on the other side of the counter she's fumbling and forcing a smile and saying 'haha, so early!' like a total weirdo. And then their fingertips accidentally brush when he hands her the buns. His eyelashes tremble slightly. That's it. That's the whole beat. No dramatic music, no inner monologue explosion. Just a tiny physical flinch from a guy who apparently hasn't let anyone into his personal space since we met him. I love that it's restrained. But here's what bugs me: Xu Chun. She's the female lead, she's the one Zhu Yaya is tailing, and yet in all this text she's basically a head on a stick. We watch the back of her head on the bus. We watch her walk 'in a very well-behaved manner, neither too fast nor too slow.' She stops at the breakfast shop for like thirty seconds and comes back out. That's it. She's a silhouette. And meanwhile Yan Heng, who I think is supposed to be the male lead, gets more interiority in two lines than she gets in an entire bus ride. The relationship dynamics are all front-loaded onto Zhu Yaya and Yan Heng, and Xu Chun is just... scenery with a rich-family contrast function. I wonder if later chapters fix this or if she stays a plot device forever, because right now the 'relationship' I'm actually tracking is Zhu Yaya's paranoid tailing mission and Yan Heng's unspoken surveillance from that fourth-floor window, and Xu Chun is the MacGuffin they're both orbiting around.
... Read More
So the Imperial Capital is split into four zones by money. North and East = rich, South = normal middle-class, West = old-city-mess where nobody wants to be. And I noticed the author never actually *shows* us the West District yet, just name-drops it as where Xu Chun lives with her uncle. But the way it's described — 'out-of-towners, older generations unwilling to relocate, and people from poor families' — that one line does more than any actual scene could. It's basically saying 'the people here are invisible to everyone else.' And then Grandpa Hua, some rich sick old man, gets knocked down by a motorcycle specifically in the West District, and a frail girl carries him all the way to the South District hospital, and the narration is like 'Don't ask why. That's the power of plot and protagonist halo.' Which is... hilarious? I kept a running mental list of 'things I will absolutely not question' and it got to like nine items by the end of this section. Also the very very first image is just... a flowerpot hitting you in the head. Upper left corner of the info panel. Zhu Yaya: 'Hmph, this damn system.' I don't know why that's stuck in my brain. It's such a small, stupid, visceral little picture — you just see a pot swinging down and a girl going *thump* onto the ground. Very cinematic. Very 'oh she died and got reincarnated and her first memory in the new body is getting potted.' I want a poster with that as the key art. Then there's the golden leaves line for October 9th — 'treading on a ground covered in golden fallen leaves' — and it's so aggressively standard C-indramed stuff that I thought it'd be cringe, but because Zhu Yaya is literally the one who's got to say 'This girl is so pretty!' while standing on those leaves, it becomes this weirdly self-aware little tableau. You can see the camera angle. It's a movie shot. Golden light, falling leaves, one girl in frame being looked at, and Zhu Yaya off to the side going 'wait that's ME I'm the one speaking.' The scene sets up the whole book in one image and I kind of respect the economy of it. Random tangent: 'Imperial Capital' as a city name for a modern high school setting just keeps making me lurch every time I read it. Is this fantasy-adjacent? No, there's a bus system and a phone and a kitchen knife. Just... the imperial capital. In an apron. Making sour-spicy shredded chicken.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or