The Captain Who Specializes In Treating Disobedience - Reviews

The Captain Who Specializes In Treating Disobedience
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There's a recurring visual language in these chapters that I think the author is building toward something deliberate, and it keeps circling back to the same set of images. White sneakers. An immaculate jersey without a single wrinkle. Clean, pale hands. A faint scent of soap. All of these details construct river as this almost ethereal figure—untouched by the grime of the world that chewed him up and spat him out. The transparent glass bottle metaphor is doing serious thematic work here. 'No matter what it held, its truest colors would always shine through.' This isn't just a pretty comparison—it's the thesis statement for the entire novel, I'm pretty sure. River is transparent because he has nothing to hide. Three years of betrayal, of being sidelined, of watching Alike become the 'god' everyone worships—and somehow he never became bitter. Never turned dark. The bottle stayed clear. But the question the author is really asking is: how long can transparency survive in a world that rewards opacity? Then there's the cap, pulled low over his eyes. Every time river appears, his face is partially hidden. Eyes obscured. The girl backstage notices this instinctively—'maybe what he was really trying to hide… was his pride.' But I wonder if it's something else. Maybe he's not hiding his pride. Maybe he's hiding the fact that he's still looking. Even as a substitute, even after three years, he's still watching, still learning, still present. The cap is both armor and a signal that he hasn't fully left. The contrast between God A and river is where the symbolism really pays off. Alike commands rooms with his presence—he's mix-race, tall, charismatic, perpetually aloof. He steals light. River, meanwhile, is nearly invisible until you look closely. His 'slender frame' makes him seem non-threatening. The girl initially misses him entirely. One is a supernova, the other is moonlight—quiet, reflected, easily overlooked until it illuminates everything. And the meeting room. Cold. Air-conditioned. Frosted glass. The executives behind sealed doors making decisions that will make or break a human being's life, while river sits in a corner checking his equipment like it's just another Tuesday. The architecture itself is symbolic—those partitioned spaces, the separation between those who wield power and those who absorb its consequences. The whole novel seems built on this architecture of visibility and invisibility, of who gets seen and who gets used, and I have a feeling river's return is going to shatter every one of those partitions.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about how the author describes river as having 'clean, pale hands' and how that somehow makes everything SO much more painful? This boy is a former legend who got reduced to a ghost in his own team's hallway, and the most powerful thing the author does is make us fall in love with him through the smallest details. The scene where he helps the girl up—'On his jersey, words were written inconspicuously: KUG_river / Lin Jiang'—and he says 'I'm not qualified to play' with this faint smile? I literally paused reading and stared at my screen. Who does that? Who carries the weight of three wasted years and still apologizes to people for bumping into them? My heart actually hurt. And then there's Alike. Oh god, Alike. He's supposed to be the protagonist, the 'God A' everyone worships, but every time he looks at river, he's 'pressing his lips into a thin line' or 'clenching his fists.' Something is rotting inside him and he doesn't even know what it is yet. That moment when he watches river agree to play and feels shame—his pupils narrowing, the internal war happening behind that frosted glass—this is the emotional core of the whole story and I'm not even sure Alike understands it himself. The short-haired girl's perspective is genius too. She's this ordinary person who just wanted to glimpse her idol, and instead she witnesses something far more profound. 'For some reason, she felt a pang of sadness thinking of those clean, pale hands, and the cap he wore, pulled low over his eyes. Maybe what he was really trying to hide… was his pride.' That line. That DAMN LINE. She sees through him when nobody else does—not even the people who share a locker room with him every day. I keep thinking about the 'transparent glass bottle' comparison. No matter what it held, its truest colors would always shine through. River's kindness isn't performance. It's who he is, even when the world treated him like trash. And that's both the most beautiful and the most devastating thing about him.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this outright — the author is playing 4D chess with us here and I am HERE FOR IT. The reveal that OT is basically Shen Ju plus four decorative accessories is devastating and hilarious at the same time. I literally said out loud 'four accessories' because what else do you call them? The plot setup is so clean. We get Lin Jiang arriving, we get the team analysis, and suddenly everything clicks into place. This isn't just a new captain joining a team — this is someone walking into a house of cards. And the best part? The author doesn't spell it out for us. We have to read the data sheet, see that Shen Ju carried FOUR MVPs by himself last split, and connect the dots ourselves. That respect for reader intelligence? But what really got me was the subplot thread with Song Zhixu's lie. He tells Lin Jiang that Shen Ju was 'thrilled' about his arrival. Shen Ju overhears this. Of course he does. And then he walks away in silence. That's not just a cute moment — that's a plot bomb. Because now Lin Jiang knows something is off about Shen Ju's feelings, and I am absolutely convinced this is going to come back around. The author is laying groundwork like a pro.
... Read More
The pacing in these opening chapters is wildly confident and I need to understand how the author does it. We get maybe two thousand words before learning river's entire backstory—three years as a substitute, the crucial loss, Alike's rise, the sidelining—and it's delivered through casual hallway gossip like it's absolutely no big deal. But it's a HUGE deal and the author knows exactly how to make it feel that way. Chapter one basically operates on two tracks simultaneously. You've got the present-tense tension of the bubble match hanging in the balance, and then you've got the past-tense tragedy of river's fall, woven in through background conversations. The author doesn't stop the match to give us a biography—river is just there, walking down the corridor, while his entire ruined career gets explained around him like ambient noise. That's sophisticated structuring. It means we absorb the tragedy organically while the clock is ticking on game five. The match itself? Sixty-five minutes of description compressed into paragraphs that somehow feel longer than they are. 'Both sides fought fiercely... losing all three high grounds... ultra-late-game... victory hinged entirely on a single, decisive team fight.' The author strips the prose down to its bones at this point and every sentence is doing heavy lifting. No wasted words. The tension is so thick you could cut it. Then the cliffhanger. The text cuts off mid-barrage comment with river's name trailing into nowhere. I have to assume the next chapter picks up from that exact moment of impact. The whole setup has been priming us for this—the three years of absence, the 65-minute grind, the executives sweating, Alike's guilt—and now we're right at the edge of the decisive moment. The pacing is basically a spring coiled as tight as physically possible, and I'm convinced the next chapter is going to release it all at once. What I appreciate most is that the author never lets us forget the stakes. Every time the narrative drifts toward character or atmosphere, it snaps back to 'if they lose, the team fails to qualify for Worlds for the first time.' The personal and the professional pressure are layered on top of each other like tectonic plates, and somewhere in there, a career is about to be made or destroyed.
... Read More
I need to talk about Shen Ju for a second because this character is EVERYTHING. Here's this guy who can't stop flaming in chat, gets his accounts suspended left and right, drops to Diamond I despite literally being a top-tier AD carry, and yet—he's the only one who doesn't even LOOK UP when Song Zhixu brings up Lin Jiang. Cold aura, cap pulled low, walks out without a word. That's not arrogance, that's exhaustion. And then we find out his dad gave him an ultimatum: win this year or go study abroad and never touch esports again. He's a crown prince who ran away from his family's expectations and now he's running out of time. Meanwhile, Lin Jiang—the guy everyone's gossiping about across the room like he's not even there—is carrying the exact same weight but in silence. Four years of competitions, never lost his temper once, smiled through red-eyed devastation at Worlds. Two characters, both drowning, both hiding it differently. And I just KNOW they're going to collide eventually. The fact that OT needs a mid laner and somehow both of their paths are drifting toward each other? Chef's kiss.
... Read More
Can we just take a moment to appreciate that Lin Jiang, apparently the best player in the game, is also the best at typing absolutely ruthless messages in League of Legends chat? Because this passage: '[Jungler, stop sightseeing. If you're that eager for a stroll, bring your girlfriend next time.]' '[Mid, quit showing off. Your plays aren't impressing anyone.]' '[Support, why the rush? Rushing off to the civil affairs bureau for a divorce? Wait for me to say OK, got it?'] '[It's been 25 minutes, and the top laner's still harping about something that happened at 7. Why don't you start from the dawn of time while you're at it?'] This is not just funny. This is genuinely creative, culturally grounded humor that works on multiple levels. The civil affairs bureau reference for divorce registration is specifically Chinese—it shows the author knows their culture and is using that knowledge to make Lin Jiang's character feel real and localized. The 'dawn of time' callback to the ancient Chinese creation myth (开天辟地) for the top laner's grudge is equally sharp. And the delivery! Lin Jiang types just as fast as Shen Ju. His 'slender fingers' move across the keyboard with the same speed. The implication is clear: this guy is mechanically gifted in every sense, not just in-game. Compare Shen Ju's rage typing—'What's the jungler doing? Is the mid laner brain dead?'—to Lin Jiang's version. Shen Ju's is pure anger, generic insults. Lin Jiang's is precision wit. One is someone losing control; the other is someone who has total control and is using words as a weapon deliberately. The narrative voice throughout these chapters also deserves praise. Lines like 'The league had already penalized Shen Ju countless times for this behavior. Some of the more serious incidents even came with threats of suspension. Still, he did as he pleased, leaving the officials gnashing their teeth in frustration' have this wry, observational quality that makes the prose feel alive. It's not dry—it's playful. And Song Zhixu's internal dialogue is genuinely funny: 'He'd already started mentally rehearsing how to grovel in apology—only to hear Lin Jiang let out a soft laugh.' The specificity of 'grovel' tells us everything about Song Zhixu's relationship with Shen Ju. He's been here before. He knows the script. Nobody ever deviates from it until now. The author's voice in the narration also has this wonderful tendency to understate. 'OT didn't have a proper coach—they couldn't afford a decent one.' Said so casually, but it paints a whole picture of institutional neglect that makes Lin Jiang's investment in their improvement even more significant.
... Read More
The pacing in this section is absolutely surgical. Let me break down why it works so well, because I've been thinking about it nonstop since I finished reading. The chapter opens with Du Lun running around like a headless chicken for nearly a week trying to finalize the transfer. That's the setup—the friction, the complications, the stakes of getting this wrong. Then you cut to the roster announcement, and for a beat the author deliberately makes everything feel flat. The fans glancing past it. The half-hearted messages. The normalcy of it all. This is the calm before the storm, and the author knows exactly how to use that stillness. Then thirty minutes later—BAM. Someone notices. The hashtag trends. The comments shift from confusion to disbelief to outright frenzy. The transition from [Impossible, absolutely impossible] to [!!! This is insane!] is so quick it hits like a physical blow. What's really clever is the contrast between the external chaos and Lin Jiang's internal state. While the internet is losing its mind and the OT players are having full breakdowns in their group chat, Lin Jiang is just... sitting there. Calm. Sending one message to Du Lun. Reposting the roster with 'Let's move forward together.' The author gives us three paragraphs of pure internal stillness after pages of external pandemonium, and it's devastating. And then the Shen Ju section—the flashback sequence slides in so naturally, almost like a dream memory. The ranked game, the keyboard curse, the two-hour ban, the collar pulled up. It's all connected. The author doesn't tell us directly that Shen Ju is disappointed in himself. We FEEL it through the imagery. The collar hiding his eyes. The phone buzzing with Du Lun's message. The final line—'Could you squeeze in with Song Zhixu for now? When I get back, I'll rent the apartment'—cuts off mid-sentence, and I was genuinely left wanting more. That kind of structural abruptness is risky, but it works here because it mirrors how real life interrupts your thoughts.
... Read More
Okay so this book just threw me into the deep end right away and I wasn't ready. You've got this massive esports climax happening—75-minute game, substitute mid laner, everything on the line—and then *bam*, he gets attacked by a fan, blacks out, and wakes up years in the past with his old hotTake ID still active. That's not just a plot twist, that's a full narrative earthquake. What I love is how the author doesn't explain the time travel mechanism at all. You don't get “he hit his head and now he's back in 2018.” No, you just get the disorientation, the muscle memory kicking in, the mouse clicking before his brain catches up. It's almost like the author trusts us to figure it out ourselves, which is refreshing. The meta shift subplot is also brilliant setup—Lin Jiang had to change his playstyle from carry to utility because the game changed, and then when the meta shifted *back*, nobody remembered who he originally was. That's not just gaming lore, that's a commentary on how quickly the industry discards its legends. The Alike confrontation at the end of this batch? Chilling. “Your era is over. This is my time now.” That's the kind of line that makes you immediately want to turn the page. But here's what really got me—the author never lets us forget that Lin Jiang's current self has the memories and the regret of his future self. Every decision he makes now is weighted with knowledge of what goes wrong. That dramatic irony is *chef's kiss*. He knows Alike will betray him. He knows KUG will fail. He knows his hands will shake in crucial moments. And yet he has to figure out how to change all of it without looking like a complete freak. The pacing in this batch is aggressive—no filler, just pure narrative propulsion. I read all four chapters in one sitting and forgot to pee. That's how hooked I was.
... Read More
The stakes here are enormous and the author makes sure you feel every ounce of them. On the surface, this is a sports story about an esports team trying to improve. But the real conflict isn't about winning games—it's about survival, identity, and whether people who've been written off can suddenly be believed in. OT finished dead last in Spring Split. They're the team everyone ignores. Their fans post perfunctory good luck messages and scroll away. The hashtag initially gets no traction because nobody thinks anything interesting will come from this roster. And then Lin Jiang joins them and suddenly the entire league is in chaos. For Lin Jiang specifically, the stakes are existential. He's a top-tier player who could've gone anywhere. Instead, he chose the worst team in the league. What does that say about him? What does that mean for his career? The author doesn't spell it out, but you can feel the weight. 'This was the path he had chosen.' Those aren't words of confidence—they're words of acceptance. He doesn't know if this will work. He only knows he committed. For the OT players, the stakes are even more personal. They've spent years being the team nobody takes seriously. Now their captain is literally the player they've all dreamed about. What happens when expectation meets reality? Shen Ju's entire arc in this passage is about that tension—he's worshipped Lin Jiang from afar, but now he has to SHARE a room with him, PLAY under him, BE judged by him. The external pressure is mounting too. Du Lun is negotiating with KUG's fans who might lash out. The operations department can't even agree on how to announce the roster. The league is watching. Every mismatch, every loss, every mistake now carries extra weight because the narrative has shifted so dramatically. And underneath it all, there's this unspoken question: what if Lin Jiang's perfection was always an illusion? What if the moment he steps into that game, everything changes? The author leaves that hanging like a blade over the entire section.
... Read More
There is this one scene that keeps bouncing around in my head and it is not the big dramatic reveals or the contract signing. It is the moment when Lin Jiang sits in Du Lun's office and glances out the window, taking in the full picture of this tiny, barely-holding-it-together team. The author describes the office as the same one from OT's early days, with outdated equipment and an old-model coffee machine that Du Lun insists is actually pretty good. And Lin Jiang looks at that coffee machine and says something completely deadpan: "The coffee is really good." DU LUH: he is literally sweating through a tight suit while trying to impress an industry giant in a room that screams we are one bad season away from disappearing, and the guy compliments the coffee. The contrast is hilarious but also kind of heartbreaking if you think about it. This tiny office *is* the whole world of OT — understaffed, underfunded, running on hope and Du Lun's sheer panic. But then Lin Jiang comes in like a ray of light and the author frames it almost poetically: his presence is so out of place in that dim room it feels surreal. It made me imagine this entire esports ecosystem where the big clubs have glass stadiums and sponsors everywhere, and then over here is OT with their ancient coffee maker and Du Lun playing five roles because he has to. The worldbuilding here is doing so much work without ever stopping the story to explain itself. You *feel* the gap between the two worlds just from that one office visit.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or