Secret Heaven - Reviews

Secret Heaven
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this about Levin right off the bat — he is hands down one of the most emotionally wrecked husbands I have EVER encountered in fiction, and I am HERE for it. Like, think about it from his perspective. His wife has been in a coma for ten days after losing their baby to puerperal fever caused by a quack doctor. She wakes up, doesn't recognize him, and the first thing she does is demand he turn around so she can verify whether she actually gave birth by inspecting her own chest like it's a mystery to solve. And what does he do? He gets hurt, tries to gently encourage her to leave because he thinks that's what the 'old' her would want, and then she just... grabs his hand and tells him they're starting over. I literally gasped at that moment. This man who had clearly been through absolute hell — watching his wife suffer, grieving a lost child, probably hearing her curse him out during those recovery days — is just standing there looking like he can't believe his luck. And then the mastitis scene happens and he looks like his entire soul left his body. The dynamic between them is devastating and kind of beautiful. She sees through his self-sacrificing behavior and calls him out on it. He's so used to being the person who absorbs pain that he forgets to ask for anything for himself. Classic toxic-but-unintentional martyr energy. I need to know what happened during those ten days of her coma and the months before. What did she say to him? What did he endure?
... Read More
'Even in the final moments of my life, it was his face I thought of.' THIS LINE. I NEED A MOMENT. Cordelia is literally dying, her neck being crushed, and her one thought is Nathaniel. Not revenge, not fear, not anything else—just him. And then when she wakes up and sees him asleep beside her, the tenderness of the scene just DESTROYS me. She kisses his cheek to wake him up. She feeds the horse because he usually does it at dawn. She's picking strawberries and raspberries to bake him a pie. All these domestic, quiet moments right after an attempted murder—and somehow they feel even more powerful than the action. And Nathaniel? The man who could command supernatural creatures, who rode through forests at night to save her, falls asleep without even letting go of her side. Then Cordelia wakes up and first thing she does is call out 'Darling...?' and when he doesn't answer, her immediate fear is that he left. He was there the whole time. He never stopped being there. I'm literally shaking. Their love isn't loud or performative—it's in the small things, the staying, the waking up beside each other, the kiss that literally restores her life force. That last image of Nathaniel crying gold tears? I am NOT fine.
... Read More
CAN WE TALK ABOUT WHAT JUST HAPPENED WITH THE BAPTISMAL NAME REVEAL?? I literally gasped out loud. So Cordelia, who has been consumed by doubt about whether this man is truly her husband, decides to get close to him physically and emotionally after waking up. She asks about nicknames, and he casually drops that his baptismal name is Nathaniel. Nathaniel! Like an angel's name, she says, but there's nothing angelic about the secrets this man is keeping. And here's the painful part—he knows EVERYTHING about her. Her baptismal name is Alice. She laughs and hugs him while internally screaming because she realizes the terrifying asymmetry: he knows her name, her history, everything, and she knows NOTHING about him except what he chooses to tell her. That power imbalance is suffocating. But then there's the whole Levin vs. Nathaniel thing. Is he Levin? Is he Nathaniel? Which name belongs to the real husband? The text says "the roots of their relationship were beginning to shake" and honestly, Cordelia's reaction is so heartbreaking because she CHOSES to ignore it. She told herself as long as she doesn't speak that cursed name aloud, maybe everything will be fine. She's actively choosing comfort over truth, and that breaks my heart more than anything else in this chapter. Their kiss afterward felt less romantic and more like two broken people desperately trying to hold onto something before the floor disappears underneath them.
... Read More
The atmosphere in these chapters is just *impeccable*. Let me talk about the sensory details because the author really knows how to paint a scene. The opening assault takes place in a forest at twilight—the 'crimson twilight' is such a specific, haunting color choice. It's not just dark, it's blood-red, which mirrors what's happening to Cordelia. Then Nathaniel arrives and suddenly the environment shifts: shadows pour out from all over the forest, swarming around Levin's corpse. Not just shadows—they seem almost sentient, almost protective. And then this massive creature slithers out of a black carriage, making a 'Guuuuh' sound, and Nathaniel verbally shoves it away like it's a nuisance. The worldbuilding here is so efficient—three paragraphs and we learn that this forest is alive with supernatural entities, there are rules about who belongs where, and Nathaniel clearly has authority over them. Then the domestic contrast: back at the house, the garden with blooming flowers, the raspberries and strawberries, the soft bedding, the dawn light filtering through curtains. The author moves from gothic horror to cozy intimacy without losing either tone, and that contrast makes both sides hit harder. The world feels enormous and dangerous, but it also has places of warmth and safety—and that's what makes it feel real.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the atmosphere in these chapters completely shifts depending on whether you've read the journal entries yet or not. Because on a first pass, the bathroom scene reads as this warm, intimate moment—steaming water, herbal scents, him gently washing her scars, this tender caretaking energy. It's cozy. It's romantic. You're like 'aww, they're healing together.' But then you read the journal and suddenly that same bathroom scene has this completely different AFTERIMAGE. Those scars on her head that he's carefully washing away? They weren't from an accident. They were from HIM. The man who 'spat in her face' and 'the violence began.' Every moment of tenderness in that bath now carries this ghost of the violence that came before it. The worldbuilding around their house is also interesting—it's clearly a place that holds both comfort and trauma for her. The fireplace with burned paper remnants? She's been burning her journal entries. That visual of firewood mixed with ashes of her own past is haunting. She's actively destroying traces of her memories, trying to erase the evidence of how bad it was. And the recurring motif of water—bathing, washing, cleansing—takes on this double meaning. She's literally washing away dried blood and scars, but she's also trying to wash away her past. Except the journal entries keep appearing no matter what. The past isn't something you can scrub off. The domestic spaces (bed, bathroom, garden she imagines) contrast sharply with the implied violence of their earlier life together. It's a world where warmth and danger occupy the same rooms, which feels very true to how trauma survivors experience their own lives.
... Read More
Okay, I need to process what just happened because my brain is still reeling. So Cordelia finds this pouch she wasn't supposed to open—classic trap, right?—and inside is a letter written in HER handwriting describing an entirely different Levin. The one in the letter has red hair, buck teeth, and a hooked nose. Presses down on her stomach during labor. Mocks her. This is NOT the golden-haired, beautiful Levin she's been waiting for. And then she loses consciousness and wakes up ten days later to find the REAL Levin by her bedside, weeping, saying "This is already the third time." Third time?? What does that even mean?? The pacing of this reveal is absolutely vicious. We spend the entire first chapter watching her tear herself apart waiting for him, preparing soup and meat pie and everything, and then BOOM—the man she's been loving might literally not be the man she thinks she's loving. The parallel between the letter and her waking reality is chef's kiss level horror. She sees him crying and can't even ask the question that's killing her because his tenderness disarms her. That ending line about the roots of their relationship beginning to shake? That's not foreshadowing, that's an eviction notice. I kept going back to re-read the letter scene because I couldn't believe what I was reading. Who writes something like that? About themselves? And why does it have HER handwriting? The plot didn't just twist, it folded itself into a pretzel and stabbed me in the heart.
... Read More
I need to talk about the breakfast scene because it is SO understated and it killed me. She's acting like she forgot everything that happened the night before—pretending the nightmare never existed, clinging to him in the bathroom, showing him her scar and whining about it like some stupid trivial thing. And his response? Just… endless gentleness. 'Because I love you.' That's it. She asks why he looks more pained than she is even though it's HER hand that's hurt, and he just says that one line like it's the most obvious thing in the world. Then he pulls her onto his lap and they share this moment where they both admit they've thought the same thing—that maybe if they could just be physically close enough, words wouldn't be necessary. I literally had to pause the book. The fact that they're both hiding things from each other but somehow still find their way back to this stupidly tender intimacy? The way she kisses the base of his neck and laughs about it, so forced and so real at the same time? And then he teases her about it turning into an intimate scene with him saying 'I'll always love you. You mustn't forget that' while they're literally being intimate?? The emotional whiplash from that scene to the next chapter where he leaves and gets attacked is UNFAIR. I'm not ready for what's about to happen to these two.
... Read More
I'm genuinely shocked at how much atmosphere Anna packs into these chapters. The storm isn't just background decoration—it's basically a CHARACTER. When Kitty throws the box into the darkness and stands frozen in the torrential rain, the prose literally wraps around you. 'Her hair, drenched and clinging messily to her face, was swept around by the fierce wind.' You can FEEL that. You can feel the cold seeping into her bones, the mud sucking at her shoes, the way her body betrays her by going limp the moment she collapses. The transition from outdoor chaos to indoor warmth is handled so brilliantly. One moment she's thrashing through a blackened, rain-lashed landscape, and the next she's submerged in hot water with Levin hovering over her like some kind of anxiety-ridden guardian angel. The bathtub becomes this almost womb-like space—enclosed, hot, intimate—where the external world (the storm, the letters, her spiraling thoughts) can't reach them. It's such a clever use of setting to mirror emotional states. And the forest! The path that becomes 'nearly indistinguishable from a pool of muddy water'—you can almost see her stumbling through it, white breath escaping her lips, running toward a man she's just discovered might have loved someone else. The imagery of Skoll, his horse, perceptive enough to gallop steadily through the storm while its mistress trips and falls—there's this whole layer of animal sensitivity that contrasts with human emotional chaos. Honestly, some of these descriptions are so vivid I kept pausing to imagine them as film frames. The rain-lashed night, the golden eyes catching lamplight, the milky-white liquid spreading through bathwater like some strange offering—this book READS like cinema.
... Read More
Okay so let me just… process this for a sec. Cordelia has this entire nightmarish breakdown after seeing this ghostly golden-eyed Levin watching her through her miserable marriage, and then REAL Levin catches her and just—breaks too? Like, he's the one holding her, and THEN he's the one whispering 'Please don't leave me' through tears. Who is this man?? He knows something about her, obviously. He definitely knows about her past because he says 'Don't try to remember anymore.' That's not husband-energy, that's something else entirely. And yet he's also the one who kisses her cheek every morning, who strokes her palm and kisses her scars like she's the most precious thing in the world. The contrast is making my head spin. Is he protecting her? Is he guilty? Or is he genuinely in love and this secret just happens to be catastrophic? Also the part where she thinks 'He's not really the man who was my husband back then, are you?' and then immediately feels guilty for doubting him? THAT'S the toxic cycle right there. She's been abused by Nathaniel and now she's punishing Levin for not being him, while simultaneously feeling terrible about it. I hate this for them and I love it.
... Read More
This prologue is packed with symbolism and I want to talk about the biggest one: the secret box of memories versus the body that refuses to be forgotten. The very first line establishes the central metaphor — Cordelia's memories before her illness are like a box that must never be opened recklessly. But the joke is, the box is already open. Her body remembers everything her mind has lost. The pregnancy scars, the milk production, the soreness — these are physical texts written on her flesh that no amount of amnesia can erase. The body keeps the score, as they say. Then there's the milk itself, which is such a loaded symbol. It represents motherhood, nurturing, life-giving — and also loss, because the child she produced it for is dead. It's literally leaking out of her uncontrollably, just like grief leaks out of people when they don't have words for it. Cordelia treats it practically (asking Levin to help manage it), while Levin treats it like a crisis. That contrast says everything about how differently they experienced her suffering. And Levin's comment about vows being meaningless? That's the thematic crux. Vows are promises made in a moment of clarity — but what happens when clarity fails? When the person you vowed to love becomes a stranger? Cordelia's answer is radical: she renews the vow voluntarily, without memory as justification. She chooses love without the evidence of shared history. Isn't that what the whole novel is going to be about? Whether love survives when the reasons for it are taken away?
... Read More
"It's not like we haven't seen everything. What's with that reaction? Is it strange for milk to come from the chest of a woman who's given birth?" — I literally screamed reading this. Cordelia's voice is SO distinct and I adore her for it. She's direct, slightly exasperated, and completely unapologetic about needing help even when it makes Levin squirm. That character voice is instantly recognizable. And Levin? His dialogue is this perfect contrast — softer, more hesitant, but when he speaks his truth it lands like a hammer. "The child went to a good place." Four words and suddenly the whole room changes temperature. No elaboration, no extra emotion, just absolute certainty that carries so much weight because we know how much pain is underneath it. The banter throughout is what really sells this though. The playful back-and-forth about him quitting his job, her teasing about being clingy, the whole 'I put you to sleep too easily last night' line that has Levin basically melting — it all feels like real couple energy. Not performative romance novel dialogue, actual people who know each other's buttons and press them affectionately. Even the non-verbal communication in the prose reads as dialogue. The way Levin rubs his cheek where she kissed him, the honey-colored eyes, the pale ears turning red — the narrative voice is doing so much conversational work without a single word being spoken. That's skilled writing, fr.
... Read More
The pacing in this batch is absolutely vicious and I am here for it. Let me trace it for you because it's masterful. Chapter 5 starts inside Cordelia's head—nightmare, disorientation, Levin catching her. It's slow and claustrophobic, all internal monologue and confusion. We stay with her for a long time, and I mean LONG time, just processing what she thinks happened. Then Chapter 6 pivots HARD into domestic warmth—breakfast, intimacy, soft dialogue, the 'I love you' exchange. You're completely off guard because it feels like the story is finally breathing. Levin leaves, she gives him the whistle, there's this tiny moment of warmth at the goodbye. And then—BANG. Gunshot. The whistle screams. And suddenly we're in full survival mode. She's running through an unknown forest, the whistle sound gets weaker, the birds stop singing, the light is turning red again—that's not accidental imagery, by the way—and she thinks she sees Levin but it's actually NATHANIEL. The chapter ends on him grabbing her hair and pinning her down. FROM PEACE TO TERROR IN LIKE TEN PAGES. The author doesn't even give you a breath between 'I love you' and 'large hand tangled in her hair.' I read the last page three times because I couldn't believe what just happened.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or