Sea Monster Alliance (BL) - Reviews

Sea Monster Alliance (BL)
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I keep coming back to that flashback. Not the romantic one — the other one. The one where Xia Yi walks in on the producer and the minor character and just… picks up his script and leaves. This is the key to understanding everything about Xia Yi. The author isn't just dropping this as random character history. This is the foundation. “They say Xia Yi is no different from a dead person.” That line has been floating around this story since chapter one and now it lands like a brick. Xia Yi doesn't react. He doesn't gasp. He doesn't feel nauseous. He treats human intimacy like furniture — something that exists in his space but isn't his problem. That's not detachment. That's survival. In an industry where nothing can be spoken of, where people get replaced overnight, where the minor character became the lead and Xia Yi just… acknowledged it and moved on — how do you stay sane? You become a ghost in your own life. So when the Siren says “you are mine” and Xia Yi can't even process it because his body is betraying him? It's the ultimate violation of his coping mechanism. He's spent his whole life treating everything like it doesn't matter, and now something is happening that absolutely, irrevocably matters, and he can't escape it because he's literally being held in the air above an ocean with no script to pick up and walk away with.
... Read More
I'm going to be honest with you — I stayed up way later than I should have reading these chapters. Not because of cliffhangers or explosions, but because the author has this weird rhythm that makes you just... keep going. It's not urgent pacing. It's magnetic pacing. Chapter 57 starts with Xia Yi waking up from the best sleep he's had in... ever? The detail about not waking up suspended at a strange angle like an astronaut is both funny and tells you everything about how disoriented his body has been. And then immediately — back numbness. Physical consequence. Grounded. The transition from waking to decision to action to the dolphin arriving is seamless. There's no scene break, no chapter divider energy. He gets up, walks to the shore barefoot (still not wearing clothes because the wet-shirt-at-night logic is undeniable), and the dolphin just... appears. With a tin can. This is how you do a happy coincidence that doesn't feel lazy — because the reader has been waiting for food, for help, for a sign that this guy isn't completely alone, and the dolphin delivers. The structure of this entire section is essentially: solitude → observation (by the Siren) → vulnerability (the bath scene) → connection (the dolphin). It mirrors the emotional arc perfectly. We go from lonely island survival to the hint of something more, whether that's romance or friendship or something stranger. The pacing never rushes but also never stalls. Every beat earns its place. The author trusts the reader to sit with quiet moments — like Xia Yi hugging the dolphin's head — without needing to immediately pivot to the next crisis. And honestly? That trust is why I kept reading. Because I knew I was in good hands. Even the ending just... trails off mid-thought about the tin can, and I immediately wanted the next chapter.
... Read More
Let me linger on one image from this batch because I think it holds the whole novel together. The sonar pulse. Xia Yi raises a perfectly reasonable question—what if the Siren has parasites?—and the Siren's answer is essentially: nothing survives repeated sonar exposure. The creatures that live on sea monsters are specially adapted to something that would liquefy ordinary life. They exist in an environment that should be uninhabitable, and they've become something else entirely through adaptation. I keep coming back to this as a metaphor for Xia Yi himself. He fell into the sea intending to die. The ocean should have killed him. Instead, he's adapting. He's developing sonar-resistant qualities—learning to communicate with mythical creatures, navigating ecosystems, finding reasons to surface instead of sink. The parasite question was really him asking: can I still be clean? Can I still be untouched by this world? The Siren's answer is no, and also: no one is. Not anymore. Xu Qishen losing his glasses and becoming 'some kind of master' through sheer misperception is the land-side version of this theme. People reshape themselves based on what others project onto them. The captain holding half a photograph—grief reducing a charismatic man to a hollowed-out shell, yet he keeps moving. Annie shedding her former self like sunburnt skin. The cleaning fish business itself is a symbol: mutualism as transaction, care as something that comes and goes on schedule. But Xia Yi and the Siren are building something that doesn't fit that model. Something that persists beyond the work contract. Something that, like sonar-resistant parasites, shouldn't exist but does.
... Read More
I need to talk about Siren and Xia Yi because WOW. The moment where Siren grabs Xia Yi's hand and Xia Yi realizes he can't exert force — that's not worldbuilding, that's ROMANCE. Or at least the ghost of something that could become romance, and I am HERE for it. Let me explain why this hits so hard. Throughout the entire sequence, Siren is constantly weighing his options, and EVERY calculation comes back to the same answer: Xia Yi's safety matters more than anything else. He could wipe out all those people on the deck in seconds. He could control the sound waves, create shockwaves, end this threat permanently. But he doesn't, because Xia Yi is THREE FEET AWAY. That restraint is so much more intimate than any kiss scene I've read in these types of novels. It's not about physical proximity — it's about the fact that Siren has literally reorganized his entire threat-assessment algorithm around one person. And then after the water wall collapses, when they're diving underwater and Siren pulls Xia Yi up with him, there's this moment where Siren blocks most of the explosion force and Xia Yi still coughs up blood. That detail! The author could have made Siren perfectly protective, but instead they show us that even Siren's best effort isn't enough — he's trying his absolute hardest and it still isn't perfect. That's more emotionally honest than any "I would die for you" dialogue could ever be. What kills me is the ending of chapter 68, where Xia Yi just... swims away. Not dramatically. Not angry. Just... away. And Siren follows but "didn't dare swim too close." That distance between them — physical AND emotional — is everything. Xia Yi is asserting his independence, but he's also clearly unsettled by whatever he's sensing in the water. And Siren is caught between wanting to be close and needing to give him space. I'm not even a person who usually ships characters this hard in apocalyptic fiction, but this? This is hitting different. The author isn't spelling it out — they're just showing us two people who keep choosing each other in increasingly impossible situations.
... Read More
I need to talk about the dolphin because THIS CREATURE is the emotional core of this entire chapter and I am not okay. Picture it: Xia Yi, stranded on a rock, half-drowned, probably dehydrated, mentally unraveling from isolation and supernatural stalker stress, and this dolphin just... appears. Not to eat him. Not to abandon him. But to NUDGE him toward safety. To play with him. To distract him from his own thoughts for literally ten minutes at a time. The scene where Xia Yi tries to push the dolphin away and fails every single time is devastating because it mirrors his relationship with the Siren. He can't push THAT one away either. Both creatures are affectionate, persistent, and ultimately harmless despite being predators. The dolphin's round innocent eyes that make it impossible to stay mad? Classic manipulation, but the kind that feels like love. And then there's the Siren absence. Xia Yi hasn't seen him since the dolphin arrived. Is that because the mermaid is respecting boundaries? Because he's hurt? Because he's jealous of the dolphin? The narrative never confirms, which makes every glance at distant white waves feel charged with unspoken longing. Xia Yi HOPES the Siren has left because he feels guilty about accepting food from a non-human on that island. Guilt mixed with hope mixed with... what? Wanting him to stay? The emotional beats here are all understated. No grand confessions, no dramatic revelations. Just a man slowly learning that connection takes many forms — the dolphin's playful nudges, the Siren's silent watching, the distant boats he's desperate to avoid. Each represents a different kind of relationship, and each makes him feel something slightly different. The dolphin makes him smile. The Siren makes him anxious. The humans make him defensive. And somewhere underneath all of it, he's just... tired of being alone, but terrified of what comes next. "What to Do When I Become a Koi" — the author's other work title suddenly makes SO much sense in this context.
... Read More
I need to talk about Xia Yi and the Siren because something shifted in this batch and I'm not over it. Remember when Xia Yi first fell into the sea? His plan was literally to die. Not to survive, not to adapt, just to check out. And now? Look at him. He's having full conversations about fish hygiene habits with a mythical sea creature who could crush him if he wanted to. The trajectory of this relationship is absolutely wild. What struck me most was the internal monologue where he realizes: there simply were no other mermaids. And that's when the whole dynamic changes. He could have insisted the Siren go find others—could have used that as an excuse to maintain distance—but he deliberately doesn't bring it up. Not out of kindness alone, I think. Out of his own selfishness. He needs the Siren to stay. He won't admit it, not even to himself, so he frames it as 'the Siren is different from me.' As if that absolves him of wanting this connection. And the Siren? The guy literally deflects a parasite concern by mentioning sonar pulses, then immediately pivots to 'you just keep talking to me' like he caught Xia Yi trying to make an escape route. The man is dangerously perceptive for someone who doesn't have arms. The fish cleaning station scene is genius worldbuilding that also mirrors their dynamic—those small fish show up when needed, do their job, and leave without obligation. But Xia Yi and the Siren aren't like that. They're stuck together in ways neither of them fully wants to acknowledge.
... Read More
I need to address the dialogue in this section because it's doing something radically different from typical fantasy novel conversation. The Siren doesn't really explain things directly—he throws fragments of knowledge at Xia Yi and expects him to connect the dots. 'Thomas said...' 'Abiseth said...' He's basically letting oral history do the heavy lifting instead of delivering exposition himself. It's brilliant because it makes the Siren feel like a curator of stories rather than a textbook narrator. Xia Yi's voice, meanwhile, is this perfect counterweight. Short, confused, occasionally defiant. 'Then why do you hate that guy for their deaths?' Simple question that opens up this entire philosophical can of worms. And his internal monologue—'He couldn't explain. Not just linguistically, but he couldn't even understand it himself.' This admission of cognitive dissonance? That's honest writing. Most characters in fiction pretend they understand themselves perfectly. Xia Yi knows he doesn't, and that self-awareness makes him feel real. The giant squid's dialogue is pure chaos energy though. 'Hahaha, I found the ship. Neither the Siren nor Xia Yi were here, so the ship is mine now!' This is peak alien psychology meeting petty possession. The humor comes from how casually Abiseth shifts from genuine excitement to defensive greed. 'Even if you're alive, the ship is still mine!' Like these are separate concerns. The voice is unmistakable—you'd know it was Abiseth even without the name tag. And the author's narrative voice? It slips between third-person limited and something almost omniscient without warning. Sometimes it's firmly in Xia Yi's head, sometimes it drifts to historical context, sometimes it just observes. This fluidity creates a dreamlike quality that fits the oceanic setting perfectly.
... Read More
The opening scene where Xia Yi jumps into the freezing sea at midnight hits different. There's this raw, aching loneliness in it. He's alone on an island, trying to master powers that won't cooperate, shivering because his fire went out, and his only companion is a dolphin who scolds him with nudges. 'Xia Yi looked up, stunned, at the aircraft carrier towering over eighty meters high, too afraid to intervene.' That 'too afraid to intervene' says everything. It's not just fear of the ship—it's fear of his own inadequacy. He can make ice, maybe water, but he can't stop a leviathan from reshaping his world. And yet, there's warmth in these small moments. The dolphin sticks close, shaking but protective. Xia Yi soothes it with a touch, and for a beat, it's just two scared creatures in the dark. The apocalypse strips everything back to survival, but the author keeps threading in these quiet connections—the siren's message, the octopus's misguided gift, the shared glances with Li Shao and Annie on the shore. It's not romantic; it's something deeper. The hunger for companionship in a broken world. Xia Yi isn't lonely because he's isolated; he's lonely because everyone he knows is either gone or as confused as he is. And still, he tries. He tries to control steam, to build a routine, to not completely lose his mind. That resilience is what makes his emotional journey so gripping. We root for him not because he's powerful, but because he keeps going anyway.
... Read More
The New Caledonia reveal. Just one line from the young man — “That was seventy years ago!” — and suddenly the entire plot timeline gets rewired in my head. A mermaid sank a Spanish ship with claw marks on the necks and chests of the sailors. Four arcs of blood. This wasn't a one-time event, this was something that happened decades ago and apparently nobody in the international community cared enough to investigate properly. Xia Yi's reaction is everything: “Has the international community covered up this matter?” Because of course she thinks that. Of course the first thing that crosses her mind isn't “oh my god a real mermaid” but “why did no one else document this?” The pacing in these chapters is also doing something clever. You have the slow, methodical process of island life — building boats, farming, the patient rhythm of survival — and then BAM, this story about a killer mermaid from seventy years ago drops in like a grenade. The young man tells it almost casually, the way you'd tell a story about a big fish you almost caught. But for the reader, it's a massive lore reveal. And the unresolved thread about where this other mermaid has been all along, whether she's been spotted by other ships, whether the world knows about her — this is clearly setting up a much bigger conspiracy or quest. The plot isn't just “Xia Yi finds a mermaid and deals with it.” It's “Xia Yi finds a mermaid and realizes the world has been lying about mermaids for a century.”
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is weirdly perfect because it's deliberately imperfect. The young man's English is described as similar to Xia Yi's level, struggling with complex sentences, using the simplest vocabulary possible. And instead of making him sound stupid, the author makes him sound earnest. “When we saw stranded dolphins before, we watered them like this…” He can't find the right words but he keeps trying. The gesture-heavy, stumbling communication feels so真实, so close to how actual cross-cultural conversation works when neither party is fluent. And then there's the work chants — “They shouted rhythmic chants while working, like singing.” One sentence, and suddenly you hear the whole island. The author doesn't write out the chants, doesn't try to invent a language, just lets us know that these people have a rhythm to their labor and it sounds like music. Meanwhile the Siren barely speaks at all. She says her name. That's it. And yet her presence dominates every conversation around her. Xia Yi does most of the talking internally, narrating her own confusion, her own fears, her own desperate hope that the Siren won't actually drag her to the ocean. The narrative voice is so closely aligned with Xia Yi's perspective that you almost forget the Siren has her own interiority — until she does something unexpected, like refusing to eat dead food or mentioning Abiseth. The asymmetry in who gets to speak and who gets to be heard is itself a theme.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this one line that just wrecked me. The siren says something along the lines of 'you won't eat each other after mating, right?' and Xia Yi nearly chokes on his crab soup. The telepaths lose their minds. Professor Lin has to explain that yes, in many species, females literally eat their mates after reproduction—spiders, mantises, snakes, moths. And apparently this siren is the same way. This is BRILLIANT plot design. Because up until this point, you're reading it like a survival story with a weird romance subplot. Xia Yi is on an island, cooking crabs, avoiding the sirens, and you're like 'aww, will they get together?' And then BOOM—the person he might bond with has an evolutionary instinct to consume him after they mate. That's not just a twist, that's a complete genre shift. Every time he gets closer to her emotionally now, there's this lurking dread underneath. And the fact that the Professor—this supposedly serious academic—has to deliver a whole lecture on animal mating cannibalism to a room full of telepaths who are just sitting there trying to do their jobs? The tone whiplash is incredible. It goes from 'gross moment finding a condom in the sea' to 'hilarious octopus trying to play matchmaker' to 'existential horror about biological determinism' and somehow all of it works together. Also the Meta-plot layer with the global telepaths is so underutilized in most novels but here it's doing heavy lifting. Xia Yi has no idea that half the human civilization is tracking his every sound wave. He's just living his life on this island thinking he's alone, and meanwhile Professor Lin and crew are building a whole theory about him. The dramatic irony is gorgeous. The survival plot is tight too—ice ability used as a magnifying glass to start fire, crab cooking method, finite fuel supply on the island. Nothing feels wasted. Every detail serves either character, plot, or atmosphere.
... Read More
The dialogue here is so sparse it's almost brutal and I respect it so much. 'Xia Yi!' — that's basically all we get from the Siren in the middle of a hurricane, and it carries every ounce of panic and love and desperation. And then the internal monologue where Xia Yi thinks 'If Siren let go of him, could they perhaps escape' — it's not even a question, it's him making a calculation in his head while half unconscious. The narrative voice is this beautiful blend of intimate first-person proximity and this almost mythic, omniscient quality when it opens up into the sirens' history. One moment you're right inside Xia Yi's spinning, bloody, exhausted head and the next you're reading about centuries of mermaid folklore like it's a documentary. '—Mermaids wouldn't even step ashore willingly' — that em dash followed by a tiny aside, it's such a Xia Yi thought. Dry, slightly absurd, completely human. And then later: 'Being alive, being able to live beside the person you love, how rare a thing it was.' That's the whole book in one sentence. Not dramatic. Not overwrought. Just... true.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or