Let me just say: the dialogue in this chapter is sparse but devastating, and I think that's intentional.
The survivors on the island? Their conversations are functional. 'Are we going to reclaim the aircraft carrier?' 'Jason, don't joke around!' They sound like real people in a real crisis—panicked, repetitive, slightly irrational. Jason being told not to joke when he's clearly trying to lighten the mood with something horrifying is such a human detail. That's not scriptwriting, that's observation.
But the real dialogue masterclass is what happens BETWEEN Xia Yi and the Siren. Almost nothing is spoken. 'Calling his name softly, like the tide.' 'The voice of the Siren.' 'Faintly ethereal and beautiful singing.' The Siren communicates through spiritual fluctuations, through touch, through presence. When words would diminish the moment, the author refuses to use them. And that restraint IS the voice.
Even the sanatorium section has no real dialogue—just a soft-spoken woman coaxing children, children who don't respond, adults who ask questions and get silence. The absence of speech IS the speech. These are people who have lost the ability to communicate, and Xia Yi remembers it. He was the 'best condition' child, the one who could still observe, still notice the wall patterns and the silent ball game. But even he couldn't speak his way out of that place.
The author's narrative voice throughout is this eerie blend of clinical precision and lyrical surrender. Sometimes it reads like a medical report ('His long hair, soaked, stuck to his back and chest') and sometimes it reads like poetry ('The joy and satisfaction, the intense feeling of love, all repeated incessantly in Xia Yi's mind through spiritual fluctuations, without words, without precise vocabulary'). That tonal range is exceptional.