Says He Hates Her - Reviews

Says He Hates Her
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let me just... okay. The plot twists in these chapters are actually ridiculous in the best way. Sierra walks in with the explicit goal of bringing up DIVORCE, right? Like that's the mission. That's the entire reason she's having this conversation. And then what happens? Nothing. Absolutely nothing. Because apparently Ahin has zero chill and the night before devolves into... well. You know. And now she's panicking about possible pregnancy over tea like some kind of chaotic Victorian-era protagonist. The irony is SO thick I can barely breathe. She came to end the marriage and somehow the author weaponized her own body against her plan. And then—plot twist number two—she's sneaking around the training grounds like a gossiping Victorian housewife, hiding behind trees, observing people. For what? To make sure Ahin rescues Claudia? In the original story he does, but this time he's stuck in palace negotiations and isn't there. So SHE has to step in. Of course she does. She can't just sit still. And then she trips! Right in front of him! The universe has a sense of humor I cannot deal with. She was trying to be the hero, running toward the training grounds, and her shoe catches on dirt and suddenly she's in his arms again. Everything keeps dragging them back together. Also—the cliffhanger at the end where Sierra points dramatically at the fight and says something's wrong? Chef's kiss. The author left us literally mid-action with Ahin's face like a grim reaper. I need to know what happens next immediately.
... Read More
I HAVE BEEN SITTING HERE FOR TEN MINUTES JUST STARE AT THE CEILING because the breakfast scene absolutely destroyed me in the best possible way. Let me walk through this. Sierra is pretending to sleep. Why? Because she can't handle the intimacy. Ahin comes in, notices she's awake anyway, and instead of backing off—which would have been the SAFE choice, the NOVEL TROPE choice—he does something completely unexpected. He feeds her. Piece by piece. And when she tries to dodge, when she braces herself to bite his hand because that's what she'd do if THIS were a trap—that's what her years of trauma response tell her to do—he just... keeps going. Gentle. Patient. "Is it good?" "Without bothering to hide the suspicion in her eyes, Sierra accepted a few more pieces of bread from Ahin." — THIS LINE. I read it three times. The suspicion, the acceptance, the fact that she does both at once. This is what their entire relationship is now. Suspicion and acceptance existing in the same breath. And then the forehead kiss. The most casual, domestic, DEVASTATING gesture. "You look lovely when you eat well." She can't even respond. She just sits there processing the fact that the man who made her life hell for years is now making her breakfast and calling her lovely. The CP chemistry here is OFF THE CHARTS because neither of them knows how to be honest. Ahin can't say what he feels, so he SHOWS it through actions. Sierra can't trust the actions, so she OVERTHINKS them. It's agonizing. It's perfect. I'm not okay.
... Read More
OKAY so the scene where the wet nurse says the word "heir" and Sierra's entire face changes? That was PEAK. One second she's relaxed, drinking tea, gossiping happily about bedchamber maids and Ahin's supposed INCOMPETENCE (honestly I laughed out loud at this part—she really believes Ahin doesn't know how to handle women?? The girl had ONE experience and already forgot??), and the next second her expression HARDENS like someone hit the brakes on her entire emotional state. Because an heir means permanence. An heir means they're actually stuck together. An heir means all her divorce plans just got infinitely more complicated. And the wet nurse doesn't notice at ALL, which made me want to shake both of them simultaneously. This woman has been watching them for YEARS and thinks they're getting along SO well because they produced evidence of physical intimacy. Sierra is over here thinking "I am going to die if this man and I have a child together." But then the most heartbreaking part: Sierra's hand moves from her solar plexus—where stress is literally burning her up—to her lower abdomen. Just resting there. Rubbing it slowly. Like she's already imagining the worst-case scenario. The author made me FEEL that specific anxiety in my chest. That terrifying mix of "what if" and "I never even wanted this" and "why is my body reacting to HIM of all people." And yet—AND YET—when she's watching Claudia get cornered by those knights, her first instinct isn't self-preservation. It's running toward danger. Because somewhere underneath all her panic about divorce and heirs and marital obligation, Sierra genuinely cares about other people. She couldn't just watch. Even when she's terrified, even when she's overwhelmed, she moves forward. That's who she is. And honestly? That's why Ahin can't stay away from her. He sees it too.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or