The dialogue in this section is absolutely razor-sharp, and I want to focus on how each character's voice reveals their true nature.
Gu Xizhi's speech patterns are fascinating. Listen to this: 'Godfather, Godmother, Xizhi cannot be so selfish. With the border still unsettled and godfather having lost an arm, if war breaks out, the imperial family will still need to rely on General Lu.' She's framing her own marriage as a patriotic act. She's not stealing someone's fiancé—she's SAVING the family from an awkward political situation. The self-reference as 'Xizhi' instead of 'I' adds this layer of performative humility. She's not a person making a request; she's a humble servant submitting to a greater cause.
And it works. Shen Zhengsheng and Ji Wan are visibly moved. The dialogue makes you understand WHY—because on the surface, her logic is impeccable. She's being selfless. She's considering everyone else. Who could argue with that?
But then compare it to Bai Ji's voice. 'Master, Mistress... my lady has suffered an immense injustice! The Second Young Miss is the one who betrayed her own sister—she deserves to be struck by lightning!' This is raw, emotional, unpolished. She's sobbing. She's using the exact same phrase that Gu Xizhi pretended to believe in ('may lightning strike such a person'). The irony is devastating, and Bai Ji delivers it without any rhetorical finesse—just pure, unfiltered outrage.
Shen Jiasui's dialogue is the most controlled of all. When she steps forward and says 'Father, Mother, you need not consider me. Since Xizhi is willing to marry and Lu Yunzheng is so devoted, let Xizhi have her wish,' she's performing the role of the magnanimous sister. But the narration tells us her eyes are red-rimmed and her smile is forced. Her words are generous; her expression tells the truth.
Lu Yunzheng's single speech—'I swear here and now—Lu Yunzheng will take no other woman in this lifetime. I will never take a concubine, nor ever betray her!'—is so earnest it's almost tragic. He means every word. He's not a liar. He's just blindly in love with the wrong person, and his sincerity is what makes him the most dangerous character in the room.