I keep coming back to the name thing and I can't stop thinking about it. Shen Xishan. His master named him at age three. He's used it for two decades. It's his public self, his cultivation identity, the one tied to the Path of Emotionlessness. And then Shen Ce, the secular name, the one that belongs to the kid before the sword. Song Xiaohe calls it 'vulgar' and he doesn't correct her. He just... accepts the hit. And she goes 'He lied to me again' because in her framework, giving you a name and then saying it's not the one you think is still a lie. That's such a character-specific way to parse reality. She's not a logician. She's a girl with sharp ears and a heart-shaped sense of justice, and to her, the NAME IS THE PROMISE. If you tell me your name is Xishan, then Xishan is your name, and if I look up Xishan and don't find you, you LIED. I think there's a whole theme buried in the naming conventions of this world that the author hasn't fully stated. Everyone's name is a label, a rank, a title. Snow Ruxuan. The Four Little Immortal Maidens. Dual-sect disciple. Steward. Master. Junior brother. Nobody is just a person, they're a function in a hierarchy. And Song Xiaohe, who fails her assessments and gets sent back and forth between sects like a ball in a pit, is the one person who refuses to be just a label. She's 'the clumsy one' to the inner sect, 'the dual-sect disciple' to the outer sect, 'Xiaohe' to Auntie Yuzhen. And she FIGHTS the labels. When the crowd sneers, she doesn't accept the nickname. She demands they say it to her face. When Shen Xishan gives her Shen Ce, she doesn't file it away politely. She files it under 'He lied to me again.' I think the Path of Emotionlessness is also a naming thing. You remove your emotions, you remove the part of yourself that has a name that MATTERS. Shen Xishan is a title. Shen Ce is a kid. And the fact that he practices emotionlessness means he's supposed to not care which one he uses, but he DOES care, because he corrects her idiom usage, because he gets irritated when she pushes him aside, because he says 'Do you like me?' and then rewrites her answer. He's not emotionless. He's just... bad at letting the emotions have a name. And the funeral. The whole 'entire Immortal Alliance is preparing his funeral' hangs over everything like a name that's been assigned to a person who might not be dead yet. You're getting named. You're getting a headstone. But Song Xiaohe is saying NO, that name, that identity, that life, is not finished. I think that's the emotional core of the whole subplot and I haven't fully processed it yet. Or maybe I'm just spiraling at 1am. ...Probably.