Promised as a Dating Sim, How Did It Turn Into an RPG? - Reviews

Promised as a Dating Sim, How Did It Turn Into an RPG?
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I cannot stop laughing at Joseph Joestar's entrance. The man arrives by HELICOPTER. A sixty-eight-year-old showing up to a hospital by helicopter to discuss paternity. The narrative describes him perfectly: "aged but well-preserved, the kind of silver fox who must have been handsome in his youth." And then Higashikata Tomoko slaps him twice without saying a word. Whack. Whack. And he just stands there taking it because he's guilty. But the real comedy gold is when he pieces together his own absurd theory. He storms off, comes back dragging a high school boy in a DK uniform, and announces with complete confidence: "It's Jotaro's, isn't it?! You two go to the same school, you're around the same age! You snuck around, tasted forbidden fruit, and ended up with this kid!" Jotaro's response—"What the hell are you even saying, you old bastard?"—is the perfect deadpan hit. The author's humor here is fantastic. Joseph is treated as this dramatic, almost mythic figure arriving in a helicopter, and then he immediately reduces himself to a bumbling grandfather figure connecting random dots. The contrast is hilarious. And Nianzi's internal monologue throughout—"What to do? Every time the system prompts a choice, an answer is mandatory"—this meta-awareness of being trapped in game logic gives the whole scene this weird, self-aware tone that keeps it from getting too heavy, even when it's dealing with abandoned children and paternity disputes.
... Read More
Look, I'm going to be honest - I respected this author for making the stakes feel low in the most grinding way possible. No dragon is coming to eat her. No final boss is charging. The conflict is: she has 350 yen, no memories, no clue who her nine romance targets are, and she doesn't know if the game even has a time limit or if she's stuck grinding through college and grad school forever. "Would it end after one year, or would she have to keep grinding through post-graduation? The thought exhausted her." THAT's my tension source. Not "will she die" but "will she spend three more years washing dishes in a café attic while trying to figure out who a two-year-old is to her." And now she's got a baby in her custody that she literally stole from a stroller. The external conflict just multiplied by four. She can't go to the police (she committed a crime). She can't leave him (the target lit up, ignoring it might ruin the mission). She can't afford to keep him (350 yen, discounted food, zero allowance). And the internal conflict is doing its own thing on a separate track. Every chapter she's suppressing these violent impulses. "They'd make great company at the bottom of Tokyo Bay" - that's about the pervert, fine, justified anger. But the pattern is: child noises → rip tongues. Stray cats → kick. Injured people → "help them meet their end." The stakes here aren't plot. They're "does she lose control and become the monster her name says she is?" Because if the system is tracking her choices and those choices keep trending toward the dark... what does that do to the romance mechanic? What does it mean to "complete a storyline" for a character who's basically a feral cat in a human shell? I keep thinking about option D. "Attempt theft." It's always there. Always in the menu. Always the one she's closest to picking. And the fact that she picks it, casual as anything, and then gets a little thrill - "If stealing was an option, she'd rob every NPC blind" - tells me the line is thinner than I want it to be. What I don't know yet: does Shunan actually help or hurt her survival? A two-year-old in a storage-room attic with no food money is either a mission asset or a death sentence. And I don't know which one the author is pulling the strings toward. Maybe both. Maybe that's the point.
... Read More
Okay so I keep going back to that weird little baby subplot that just randomly appeared and I cannot believe the author actually made it work. Like, Nianzi picks up some kid from a street, gets falsely accused of kidnapping, and the whole Joestar family is basically doing an interrogation montage. And I expected it to be a throwaway scene, right? A quick "oh she's actually fine" beat. But no. The baby is STILL unresolved by the end of this chunk. Joseph is still muttering "it's definitely not me, I've never been to a hostess bar" and Holly is spinning the most charitable story possible about Nianzi bringing a toddler home because "a child that young would've had to spend the whole night in a cold police station." And then Jotaro drags everyone back to "why did you LIE this afternoon?" and Nianzi goes "none of your business." Boom. The baby is now a ticking mystery on top of the DIO threat on top of the Stand revelation on top of the parasite thing. The plot is literally stacking unresolved threads like plates in a tower and I'm scared it's all gonna crash. What I really want to know: is the baby connected to DIO? Is the mother Shiokawa even a real person or another layer of the conspiracy? The way Joseph keeps circling back to "let me make this clear, it's definitely not ME" while everyone slowly realizes the baby is genuinely unrelated to him is doing double duty as comedy AND as a way to keep the reader engaged while the bigger DIO plot simmers. I also think the reveal that Nianzi can SEE Stands but doesn't know what they ARE is a genuinely smart narrative move. It creates this perfect misunderstanding engine. Jotaro sees her looking at Star Platinum and goes "you're one of DIO's people." Joseph sees the logical gap and goes "how could a normal person defeat one of DIO's men?" And Nianzi is just... vibing? Asking "what's a Stand user, is that related to seeing ghosts?" The plot is essentially running on miscommunication and I love it. But here's where it gets slightly annoying: the DIO backstory Joseph gives is literally "vampire who stole our ancestor's body, now he wants to kill all Joestars." Cliché? Yes. Surprising? No. The author KNOWS it sounds cliché and the narration even says "it sounded like a rather clichéd story, nothing surprising" which is... a bold choice. They're basically winking at the reader while telling them "yeah we know, moving on." I get it, it's exposition compression, but I'd have loved ONE small twist in that paragraph. Something specific. "The bloodline feud" is so vague it might as well say "ancient grudge." And then the flesh bud reveal at the very end is doing that great thing where it recontextualizes everything. Nianzi found a parasite on the unconscious boy earlier and dismissed it, but now she connects it to her OWN nightmare. The plot just quietly hands you a new thread while you're not looking. So: is the baby a red herring, or is it the key to the DIO endgame? I genuinely don't know yet and that's keeping me turning pages.
... Read More
The system forces Nianzi into this impossible triangle every time and it's genuinely tense. With Shunan: choose A and she gets arrested, choose B and she breaks the kid's heart, choose C and she's basically gaslighting him with false hope. She picks B—the "truth" option—but even that feels wrong because the game itself is built on manipulation. Then with Joseph: insist the child is his and tank his affection points by lying, admit you stole the child, or stay silent. She picks silence, which is... honestly the most human choice? She doesn't know what she doesn't know yet. Maybe Joseph has an explanation. Maybe he remembers another woman. And then Jotaro shows up and the whole board flips. A seventeen-year-old romanceable character—finally someone normal-aging! The stakes just went from "how do I navigate paternity fraud" to "oh god now there's a actual peer romance option." Nianzi's internal reaction—"nearly moved to tears. Good news—finally, a normal character had appeared"—tells us everything about how degrading the other options feel. The tension isn't just about what she'll choose romantically; it's about surviving a game where none of the available paths feel dignified. Every choice carries the risk of hurting someone or being caught. The suspense works because we're never sure if Nianzi's strategy will actually protect anyone, or if she's just delay
... Read More
"She suspected she might be a sociopath. Was this her true self, or a side effect of the transmigration? The sinister thoughts crowding her mind likely explained her default name, Xie Nianzi ('Wicked Thoughts')." Okay. THAT. That right there is doing so much work on the thematic level and I can't stop circling back to it. Because the whole premise is an otome dating game. Romance. Sweet. Flowers. Butterflies. And her actual name translates to "wicked thoughts" while her actual class is Rogue and her actual special ability is Mage Hand and her actual default impulses are murder fantasies. The genre and the character are in direct opposition. And I think the author is using that dissonance to ask a question nobody in otome fiction usually asks: what if the romance target doesn't want to be romanced in the way you expect? What if the "love interest" is a two-year-old who stares at you silently while you feed him pudding? What if your own mind is the antagonist? The recurring motif of the "unawakened" ability keeps bugging me too. It's sitting on her sheet like a locked chest. The whole game is built around unlocking things - romance targets are black boxes labeled "???", her memories are gone, her special ability is dormant. Everything is withheld. Everything is a key waiting for the right lock. And the choice system before every action (A, B, C, D) is another layer of that. Even in her moments of agency she's being prompted. "Attempt theft" is option D. Of course it is. The game is telling her who she is in the menu design. But underneath all the game-mechanic surface stuff, I think the real theme is about identity without memory. She doesn't know who she was. She doesn't know who this body belonged to. She's building a self from stats and survival instincts. And the "wicked thoughts" aren't just flavor text - they're the question of whether you can be good when your wiring is broken. When you understand right from wrong but can't feel the difference. She says "I still understood societal norms, right and wrong, and basic morals—which is why she kept resisting these urges." That one sentence is the whole thesis of the character. Cognition without emotion. Morality as performance. And she's supposed to do a ROMANCE ROUTE with that. I need to know how that even works.
... Read More
'Tonight's schedule? A: Watch the shopping show and go to bed early. (PS: Energy boost the next day.) B: Help out at the café. (Reward: Slight increase in dexterity proficiency, 10 EXP, 1,000 yen.)' I read that twice because I thought I misread it. Here we are, Nianzi just got back from Sendai, met a vampire's human mother, had an entire subplot thread about a 120-year-old bloodsucker, and the narrative is like 'hey want to choose between watching TV or helping at the café?' It's so absurdly domestic. And she's like 'who goes to bed early?' and picks B for the EXP, and I thought okay great, let's settle into this cozy rhythm, let's get some breathing room after the Shiokawa meeting. And then the door chime. And then 'less than fifteen minutes until closing.' And then the green uniform, the red hair, the cherry on the tongue. The pacing shift is SO violent. One paragraph you're watching a guy reheat tonkatsu and the next you're holding a knife behind your back while some kid tells you he wants the Joestar family blood as an offering. The author basically takes your feet off the ground and drops you into a hostage situation in like four lines. The 'fifteen minutes until closing' detail is doing so much work too, it's this little clock ticking that makes the café feel sealed in, no more walk-ins, no escape, just two people and the kid and the boss in the kitchen. Claustrophobic in the best way. The only thing that slowed me down was the old man's shopping show tangent. I get it's worldbuilding, I get it's setting up the ghost scroll, but I was already mentally skipping when he started going on about 'limited quantities act fast.' Like bro, I am in a vampire-adjacent thriller, can we maybe skip the complaint about his grandson's TV purchases. I know the author needed to seed that detail for later but it landed in the middle of a tension-building sequence and I just wanted to flip the page faster. The rest? The rest I was reading at 2am with my phone torch on. The fifteen-minute window closing. The cherry rolling on his tongue. 'No rush.' Oh he said NO RUSH. While there IS rush. That's great writing.
... Read More
One sentence, and I'll break down why the dialogue in this section works better than I expected. Because honestly? I was bracing for the supernatural stuff to get too pretentious, too 'listen to me I am an ancient vampire' energy. And the red-haired kid DOES do that, he's all theatrical, 'I want the blood of the Joestar family as an offering to that person,' rolling the cherry around like he's in a villain origin anime. And it's fun, I'll give him that, it's a good contrast to everyone else's register. But the actual glue of the scene is Mr. Mikawa going 'Here we go again, another one of those... These otaku kids these days are always like this. Back in my day, everyone watched Doraemon and at most fantasized about having a memory bread.' And I just stopped. Stopped reading because that line is SO perfectly deadpan. He's not scared. He's not confused. He's mildly exasperated, the way you'd sigh at a kid asking for a table at a restaurant that's already closed. He reduces a potential blood sacrifice to 'another otaku episode' and I respect him so much it hurts. Then there's Nianzi's voice, which is this constant split: externally she's 'Welcome! Today's options are up there. Pick something.' Polite, efficient, customer-service tone. Internally she's 'I palmed a knife. I'm holding it behind my back. This guy's a threat assessment and I'm treating him like a regular.' And 'Thanks, Uncle' to Mr. Mikawa, which is so casual, so grounded, against the backdrop of 'my body might be a Joestar descendant and I might kill a 120-year-old vampire if we clash.' The gap between what she says and what she's thinking is where all the character lives. The old man's shopping show rant is the least interesting voice here, pure filler dialogue, but it does set up the ghost scroll so whatever. The cherry detail is almost tactile, you can HEAR him putting it in his mouth, slow, deliberate, performing malice like it's a dance move.
... Read More
I am SO done with the plot structure here. Like, genuinely, I'm throwing my phone against the wall because they just dropped this twist casually in the middle of a hospital scene and I could not keep up. So we go from Nianzi worrying about her criminal record and not getting caught by police, to suddenly a 68-year-old American man named Joseph Joestar who apparently knocked up TWO women in different countries and neither of his kids know about each other. And the second kid is a 2.5-year-old who keeps showing up at the protagonist's location like he's a stray cat that imprints on you. The system pings a new romanceable character and it's THIS GUY. A 68-year-old. In an otome game. And Nianzi's internal monologue is basically 'am I supposed to court a man who looks like a retired college professor with a white beard?' I mean, the plot is doing so many things at once. The main thread is Nianzi clearing her name after getting falsely convicted of assault, the subplot is this whole 'found family' thing with Shunan, and then BAM, Tomoko calls the old man and the whole family tree gets revealed. It's chaotic. It's also weirdly coherent once you stop to think about it. The author planted the physical resemblance between Shunan and Josuke way earlier (same character model, shared design notes) and now pays it off with Tomoko's suspicion. 'What happened five years ago was originally a beautiful memory for me.' That line hit different when you realize it's a 16-year-old's first love turning into this mess. But honestly the thing that got me is Shunan's backstory. He was pushed out of a stroller by a jealous coworker while his mom was working. A two-and-a-half-year-old who was literally abandoned at a bus stop in a snowstorm by a hospital and just... walked to a stranger? And now he's calling Nianzi 'Sister' and saying 'I want to stay with you' in this eerily calm voice. The plot is stacking impossible things on impossible things and somehow it still works because the emotional logic holds. But I keep thinking, does Joseph even know there are TWO kids? Because his reaction on the phone was pure panic, 'Oh… Oh my god!! You have a child?!' like he thought it was settled. And now he's coming to Japan to 'resolve things in person.' What does that even mean for a 68-year-old. He's showing up at a hospital where two of his secret kids are essentially being raised by their moms and a confused high school girl. Who's the father's lawyer here. I need a spreadsheet. Is this a courtroom drama next or a family reunion disaster movie. Either way I'm staying.
... Read More
Okay so I was reading this section and I genuinely dropped my phone because the Mage Hand reveal hit me from the completely wrong angle. I thought for sure it was going to be this invisible cheat skill she could use to pull off heists while nobody's looking, right? Classic iekaisi power fantasy. And then Josuke just goes, "Big sis… that see-through hand you used to help us earlier… what was that?" And the whole thing unravels. Not just for her — for Shunan too. Both boys can see it. Tomoko saw it but covered for her son by calling it a fever hallucination. So now the entire "stealth thief" subplot she's been planning just got infinitely more complicated because literally every NPC in the room knows what she did. What I actually love though is how the plot pivots here. She's not like, devastated. She immediately recalibrates: "I could still pull off small, unnoticed thefts or use it to attack people from a distance. No one would know it was her." That's... actually a smarter move in some ways? It keeps her anonymous even if the skill itself is known. And then there's the whole "romanceable characters are toddlers" problem brewing underneath all of this. She's spending a weekend with Shunan and Josuke because they're on the list, and she's internally screaming about it. The plot keeps stacking these little impossibilities on top of each other — she's a high schooler holding a two-year-old, helping a mother with her sick kid, and somehow this all needs to feed into her romance game progress. And the fact that Shunan and Josuke look like copy-paste models? "Was it just her imagination, or did Josuke and Shunan look almost identical? Like a copy-paste of Shunan, just two years older." That's such a lazy game-dev detail that somehow became a plot point. Did the author intend that as worldbuilding (the game reuses assets) or is it foreshadowing for some twin/family connection later? I need to know. Because right now it just makes the whole "distinct personalities" thing feel really off. What's the point of having two romanceable kids who look the same and act the same? One's a mute baby and the other's a feverish kid who can barely open his eyes. They're doing literally the same role in the story and I'm starting to suspect the author is setting up some identity mix-up twist down the road.
... Read More
One sentence first: the image of this nearly transparent ghostly hand floating out of a high schooler's pocket while snow falls and a stranger's car is stuck in an icy rut is doing a LOT for me. It's so visually specific. You can see the whole thing — the straining, the car rocking slightly, the spectral hand pushing upward in unison, the gas pump engagement, the window rolling down. It reads like a shot sequence in a film. Slow push on the hand, wide shot of the car lifting, close-up on the driver's face when it works. Then the temperature contrast is just relentless. "It's freezing out there—get in!" And suddenly Nianzi is in the back seat rubbing Shunan's chilled cheeks to warm them up. The whole scene migrates from this cold, stranded-in-the-snow exterior to the warm interior of a moving car with two kids in the back and a woman driving like she's in a Gran Turismo game. "She pressed the accelerator and sped toward the hospital like a race car driver" — the tone just shifts from quiet snow-stranding to this almost manic speed. And then the hospital, which is... not really described. It's just "swiftly handling the paperwork before sending her son to the treatment room." The hospital is a non-place. Just a corridor to the next beat. Which honestly fits the genre because the real scene is the car, the cold, the human contact. The hospital is where you stop feeling and start talking. What I'm getting at is the snow. It's not just set dressing. The snow is what traps them, what forces the interaction, what gives Nianzi the excuse to help and also the excuse to get in the car and be in Tomoko's personal space. Without the weather event, none of this happens. And the fact that it's cold enough that a toddler gets dangerously chilled sitting outside while his mom struggles with the engine — that's not just atmosphere, that's the ticking clock for Josuke's fever. The environment is actively making the stakes worse. I think the author is doing good work with "weather as plot" here even though it's three paragraphs of setup. The frozen rut is the inciting incident for the entire scene. Everything else flows from that one stuck car.
... Read More
The spatial design of this confrontation is doing so much work. Think about it: a hospital. Fluorescent lighting. Tiled floors. The kind of place where you're already vulnerable, maybe sick, maybe grieving. And into that sterile, public, *neutral* space, Joseph barges in screaming about Egypt and DIO and paternity. The setting itself creates the wrongness. You're not in a private space where you can yell. You're in a hallway where a Middle Eastern man is literally 'hurrying over' because he heard the commotion. The walls don't have doors. Everyone is listening. And the 'air froze' moment when Shunan says Daddy. One sentence. No description of the frozen birds outside, no metaphor about time stopping. Just: 'The air froze.' Three words. The whole hospital goes silent. Tomoko's arms uncross. Avdol's 'unreadable' expression snaps into focus. Joseph's ecstatic shout breaks it open. The physical staging of who's where—Nianzi beside Shunan, Jotaro locked eyes across the room, Tomoko arms-crossed judging from the side, Avdol appearing from 'down the hallway'—it reads like a theater blocking diagram. Everyone has an angle. I also keep coming back to the 'thick lashes, naturally curly black hair, broad shoulders, towering over 190cm' paragraph. It's written like a fantasy novel's love interest introduction except it's happening in a hospital gown-adjacent context. The dissonance is the point. She's appraising a living person with the eye of a collector and the narration doesn't even blink. 'Every detail hit her aesthetic sweet spot.' As if he's a painting in a gallery she's walking past. And then immediately the system overlay slaps her with a negative number and the fantasy collapses into mechanics. The worldbuilding here is the *system itself* layered over a very grounded, very Japanese (very JoJo) domestic space. Two realities coexisting in one hospital corridor. The 'Middle Eastern man hurried over from down the hallway' also does a lot of quiet work. He's not introduced with a name, not described with importance. He just... appears. Functional. Part of the furniture of Joseph's life. And then he's suddenly the one who sees Shunan and goes 'He looks exactly like…' before getting shut down. The worldbuilding of Joseph's entourage is done in three sentences. Efficient.
... Read More
"No, absolutely not me!" Okay. There. That's the line. That single line carries like forty percent of the emotional weight of this whole section and I am not exaggerating. Joseph Joestar has been doing this little sputtering denial since the baby showed up and every time his denial gets slightly more desperate, slightly more specific, and slightly more embarrassing. "I've never been to those kinds of places, and I don't know that Ms. Shiokawa!" He's naming the woman. He's clarifying the location. He's doing a whole paragraph of legal-sounding testimony while his daughter is calling him "Dad" with that particular weary tone only a child uses when the parent has become absurd. And Nianzi's voice in all of this is... the funniest counterpoint. She's doing this "Oh interesting, can you elaborate on Stands? I really want to understand!" while everyone is in the middle of a hostile confrontation. She's just... not in the same emotional frequency as them. Jotaro says "you're one of DIO's subordinates" and she goes "Hold on, what's a Stand user? Is that related to seeing this ghost?" The mismatch between his icy accusation and her genuine academic curiosity is so funny it almost undercuts the tension, which I think is intentional. The author wants you to laugh here so the next paragraph, where the parasite is revealed, hits harder. Then Holly's dialogue is this soft, protective, slightly over-explaining thing: "Dad! If she'd taken the baby to the police, they wouldn't have found his mother that same day. A child that young would've had to spend the whole night in a cold police station—how heartbreaking!" She's doing the emotional labor for the whole scene while Jotaro is doing the intellectual labor of suspicion and Nianzi is doing the emotional labor of not caring and Joseph is doing the emotional labor of being embarrassed. Everyone's in their lane and the dialogue snaps because nobody is performing for the audience, they're just reacting to each other. Avdol's lines are the most clinical and that's his whole voice, just dry and pained. "This boy has been parasitized for months. Soon, his brain will be completely consumed. We can't save him." No flourish. No "oh what a tragedy." Just the fact and the resignation. And Jotaro gets one sharp line, "Enough. We'll just ask the woman directly later," and I love that it's efficient, zero patience, zero warmth. His voice in this book is basically three words maximum per sentence and I'm fine with that. It's become his character trait now. The writing style overall is very "tell you exactly what the character is feeling via system notification" which is a weird choice, like "Kujo Jotaro expresses disapproval." Read that out loud. It's so clinical. But it fits this game-mechanic framing so it works within the logic of the story. I just can't help but laugh at Joseph every single time.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or