Please Raise Me - Reviews

Please Raise Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me just say this clearly: the fairy tale book is the single most important object in this entire story. Not the wine. Not the cake. Not even Hyunho himself—at least not yet. The book. Because everything about this chapter orbits around the question: who gets to read to the child? Sohyun tells us why she reads: "My stepmother always read to him. Now he doesn't have a mother to read to him, so I read instead." She's performing maternal love through narrative. Every bedtime story is a Brick in the foundation of a child who lost his mother. But then Seunghyuk reads. And he's terrible at it. He reads in a flat tone. He refuses to do the grandmother voice. He brags about his company valuation to a four-year-old. And yet—Hyunho falls asleep gripping his sleeve. The symbolism is almost painful. Blood relatives who abandoned him. A stepmother who reads because she chose to, not because she had to. And Seunghyuk—dry, distrustful, emotionally stunted Seunghyuk—who somehow becomes the person the child holds onto in his sleep. "Not all mothers read books." Seunghyuk says this line and it lands like a thunderclap. His mother didn't read to him. His brother's wife didn't read to him. But Sohyun reads to Hyunho every night. And in doing so, she is building something that neither of them ever had. The text ends with Sohyun convincing herself she walked to bed alone, rewriting the moment because she can't yet accept that family isn't about blood—it's about who picks you up when you fall asleep at the dinner table.
... Read More
Can we talk about how psychologically complex Seunghyuk's internal monologue is here? This man is literally at war with himself and the author doesn't let him off the hook for a single second. Let's trace the arc in this batch. It starts with him being the reliable, responsible figure — lifting Hyunho, planning dinners, making sure Sohyun has appropriate wine. The Uncle persona is intact. Then comes the pool scene, and something fractures. He sees her in that rash guard and his brain short-circuits. The narration gives us his exact thought process: "At that moment, Seunghyuk clearly recognized that she was a woman. But thinking he shouldn't look at her that way, he unconsciously ignored it, but once it was imprinted..." THAT LINE. That's the whole conflict in one sentence. His mind knows it shouldn't happen. His body disagrees. The word 'imprinted' is doing so much heavy lifting there — like once he saw her this way, he can't unsee it. It's permanent. And then the aftermath is absolutely brutal. He goes to the bathroom, turns on COLD water (classic avoidance tactic), and refuses to masturbate because 'my pride won't allow that.' Pride. Not morality. Not ethics. PRIDE. This man is fighting his own biology with nothing but ego and willpower, and honestly? It's kind of heartbreaking how hard he's trying. But here's where it gets interesting — the author doesn't paint him as some villain or even a flawed hero. He's portrayed as someone genuinely confused. "Given his age, Seunghyuk had met women before." He's not inexperienced. He's just never felt THIS. The fact that he's bewildered rather than angry or predatory makes him sympathetic. Sohyun's side of the equation is equally fascinating. She's not passive. When she gets the wine, she says "How much does wine like this cost? Wait, should I know the name first?" — she's aware of her position, aware she might be receiving gifts she shouldn't. But she also drinks it anyway because "lucky me." There's this delicious tension between her financial/social vulnerability and her growing agency. And Hyunho? Don't forget him. He's the living proof of their bond — the reason they're together, the reason Seunghyuk has to hold back, and also the source of Sohyun's guilt when she starts fantasizing about her boss. The triangle is: Guardian / Ward / Child. Every layer adds complexity. The relationship dynamics in this section are so well-woven that you feel every character pulling in different directions simultaneously.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about this one moment because it absolutely wrecked me. Sohyun tries so hard to be Hyunho's family—she's doing everything right, waking up early, making breakfast, chasing a naked six-year-old around the living room—and and Seunghyuk just casually drops this bomb on her: 'You're not Hyunho's family. Not by blood, not legally.' Like he's commenting on the weather. And then he reframes her entire presence as employment. A caretaker. Wages. Three times the normal rate because obviously money can replace love and belonging. But here's the thing that got me—right after that cold moment, we see Seunghyuk at the breakfast table watching Sohyun help Hyunho eat. He notices how devoted she is. He remembers the ER incident when Hyunho couldn't breathe from anxiety because Sohyun went away for a school trip. And internally he thinks: Hyunho is only six. I was dropped into a strange place at that age too. He might need a little more time. He doesn't say any of that out loud, obviously. That's not his style. But the fact that he's *noticing* her devotion, that he's recalibrating his timeline because of her—that's huge for a character like him. The gap between what he says and what he feels is basically the entire emotional engine of this story. And I'm living for it.
... Read More
'Will the magpie like me?' This innocent question from a five-year-old opens a thematic can of worms that the entire novel seems built on. The magpie—a creature associated with good fortune in Korean folklore—becomes a shorthand for hope, for the idea that something wonderful might arrive and change everything. But then Sohyun has to correct him: 'It's not actually a magpie. It's your uncle.' The magic dissolves into something far more complicated. Both boys in this story were abandoned by their mothers. Seunghyuk at six, Hyunho probably even younger. The parallel is razor-sharp: 'Seunghyuk had been abandoned by his birth mother and brought to his father's house when he was six—one year older than Hyunho.' But where Seunghyuk learned to survive by hardening himself ('he'd soon get used to living alone. Like himself'), Hyunho is still fragile, still reaching for hands to hold, still needing his noona's voice to feel safe. The property waiver incident is loaded with symbolic weight too. Sohyun wants to sign away Hyunho's inheritance because she believes love shouldn't be measured in wealth. Seunghyuk points out the irony: she has no right to waive what isn't hers. But beneath that legalistic exchange lies the deeper question—what does a child actually inherit when they join a family? Blood? Money? Trauma? 'The cost of raising you is nothing but a speck of dust compared to that.' Seunghyuk reduces Sohyun's love to a speck of dust. And yet—that speck of dust is the only thing Hyunho has ever truly counted on. The novel keeps asking us to weigh the immeasurable against the measurable, and neither scale seems adequate.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author uses physical space to tell the story, because it's not subtle and I respect it. Let's start with the entryway scene. Sohyun and Huiyoung walk in, Hyunho is waving from the end of the hallway in pajamas, and Seunghyuk appears. The spatial arrangement here is so loaded—Hyunho at the far end, closest to Seunghyuk; Sohyun in the middle, flustered; Huiyoung shrinking away. It's a physical map of who belongs in this house and who doesn't, and Huiyoung literally making herself small because she knows she's intruding. Then the living room: 'the plates with leftover snacks, cups, and empty beer cans.' This is the first time we see Seunghyuk's pristine environment disrupted by Sohyun's life. The mess is literally evidence that someone lived joyfully in his sterile space. And his reaction—'slow motion'—tells us he's processing this as an anomaly, not a violation. The bedroom door at the end. This repeated motif of doors—opening, closing, knocking—is the spatial language of the whole story. Sohyun has spent the entire narrative walking on eggshells around this house. Now she's knocking on his door like it's normal. Like she has a right to be there. The setting itself is showing us her emotional journey without a single line of exposition.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or