Plain Immortal - Reviews

Plain Immortal
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so I have to talk about the inciting incident here because WOW. The whole setup is brutal and beautiful at the same time. This family—poor fishing folk in Gusu County—has a twelve-year-old son with a cursed illness where his tears turn into blue stones, and they're drowning in debt to the Whale Gang and the county constable. The plot moves from 'maybe we can survive this winter' to 'we have to send our kid away as an indentured servant' and then Su Chen OVERHEARS it and just… disappears. That ending hit me like a truck. He leaves behind his savings (forty-fifty copper coins he'd been hoarding), a full fish trap, and bows three times to the boat before paddling into the fog. Meanwhile his parents find the trap and realize what happened. The tension in those final lines—Father Su screaming 'Son~~ come back!' and Mother Su's heart-wrenching cries echoing on the water—this is peak narrative engineering. The author sets up a world where poverty isn't just background flavor, it's the actual antagonist. The 'heaven's hate' disease subplot, the ginseng dependency, the lifelong servitude contract system—it all converges into one devastating choice. And Su Chen's decision to leave on his own terms rather than be sold? That's not passive victimhood, that's agency carved out of absolute desperation. Also the detail that his name 'Chen' means dust—the lowest thing, easiest to survive—feels like the author is setting up some major irony or thematic payoff I haven't even reached yet.
... Read More
One sentence. Just one sentence early on and it completely changes the emotional temperature of everything that follows: 'The rule of eliminating one person every six months weighed heavily on them, pushing them to never relax for a moment.' That's it. That's the hook. And suddenly every bow, every early wake-up, every bowl of tea carefully brewed at dawn — it's not diligence, it's terror. These are twelve and thirteen year olds who have figured out that the game is: work yourself to death or get killed by the game. I keep coming back to Zhang Tieniu. Here's this kid who makes a vulgar joke about the Lower Dantian being connected to his 'family jewels' and the whole courtyard erupts in laughter — and then Li Kui slams the table and suddenly everyone is terrified. That emotional whiplash! One moment they're laughing like kids, the next they're shaking. It's exhausting just reading about it. What gets me most is how normal this all is for them. The text mentions matter-of-factly that without the Medicine King Group, these kids would be married off by fourteen or fifteen, living ordinary lives. They chose (or were chosen for) this path knowing the elimination rule exists. There's a tragic optimism to it — they're desperately grasping at the chance to become martial artists, to be someone, because the alternative is invisibility. Su Chen memorizing the three Dantian theory with intense focus — that's not ambition, that's hunger. Raw, desperate hunger. And I find myself both rooting for him and aching for these kids. There's no childhood here. Just survival dressed up as cultivation.
... Read More
"I will cook you one big pork leg, no, two!" - I swear I actually smiled at this. Two pork legs. That's all Su Chen had to offer his new acquaintance and it came from the heart. After everything he'd been through, he was already thinking about giving back. That moment hit me harder than any epic sword fight. But the emotional core of this whole section? It's about hope as survival. The kid fell in the water, yeah, but those fishermen didn't laugh - they pulled him out, the parents changed his clothes, uncles built a fire. Even in failure, there's community. Then Tieniu powers across and earns that roar of approval from the crowd. Success feels communal here, not lonely. Su Chen's fear of freezing to death if he fell though - that terror was so real. "There wouldn't be any dry clothes to change into or a fire to warm himself by. The thought of freezing to death was terrifying." I felt that in my chest. Single kid, no safety net, one chance. The stakes weren't abstract - they were literal survival. And then the ending - curling up on that straw mat, stomach full of two coarse buns, realizing he'd made it. No longer scavenging for work, no longer getting insulted by city ruffians. The peace he felt wasn't triumphant, it was quiet. Exhausted. Real. I couldn't stop thinking about how the author made me care about a kid who'd only been in the story for three chapters. That's emotional writing.
... Read More
The stakes in this passage are everywhere and I love it. Not just the obvious 'cross the bridge or go home' test, but the quiet, grinding stakes underneath. Butcher Zhang risks everything on this trip. If his son fails, he hasn't just wasted time — he's exposed his deception to Owner Wang, who already views him as beneath notice. The shame would be permanent. He's betting his son's future AND his own dignity on three days of testing. Zhang Tieniu? He's the comic relief until you realize this chubby kid has never had to fight for anything in his life, and now he's being asked to hang from icy chains for a pork leg. The disconnect between his motivation and the actual danger is terrifying. Su Chen walked out of the city with one copper coin and a bag of buns he was too hungry to eat yet. What happens if he fails? He goes back to fishing. Back to being invisible. No safety net, no backup plan, no one coming to get him. And that guard at the bridge — 'At worst, they'd just get frostbite; no one's going to die' — casual as you please. To him, these kids' lives are a rounding error. The power imbalance isn't just social, it's physical. The bridge doesn't discriminate between the desperate and the determined. It just tests grip strength and cold tolerance. The author never tells you what happens next. That's the masterstroke. The suspense isn't in knowing the outcome — it's in knowing that failure means absolute nothingness for everyone involved.
... Read More
Oh my god, the dialogue in this chapter is SO good. Let me start with High Manager Zhang—this man has a voice that commands. When he scolds those two guards: 'Lazy good-for-nothings! One of you was supposed to be on duty at all times, not take naps together!' Cold. Precise. No wasted words. And then he punishes them: 'Return to the Disciplinary Court for three lashes each! Now go rouse all the boys in the compound and prepare them for becoming disciples.' You can hear his voice in your head. stern, authoritative, unyielding. But here's the thing—the author lets us see underneath. This man started as an outer disciple too. He says so himself: 'Even I started off as an outer disciple that entered the Hall of Affairs. After decades of service, I am now in charge of executive matters in the estate.' That admission—his voice softens just slightly, reveals his humanity, makes him more real. Then contrast that with Su Chen's inner voice. He doesn't speak much—he's quiet by nature—but his thoughts are rich. 'He had once been the son of a fisherman from Zhou Village, and now, as an outer disciple of the Medicine King Group, he was content with the life of ease it provided, free from bullying and want.' That's not dialogue—it's narration, yes, but it carries the weight of his entire emotional journey in one sentence. And Zhang Tieniu—oh, this guy's dialogue is perfect. 'Brother Su, sisters and brothers, we are all disciples of the same master—let's look out for one another!' Proud. Loud. Sincere. But then the narration undercuts it: 'He used to look down on Su Chen, a small fisherman in Zhou Village, and didn't pay much attention to him. Now that they were both outer disciples of the same group, they were equal and thus more polite.' The words say one thing, the context says another. That's literary dialogue at its finest—what's spoken and what's left unsaid. The five kids chatting, introducing themselves—Yang Caizhi the shrewd accountant's son, Qin Huihui the snake-gatherer's daughter, Kong Xinqiao the beekeeper's child—all with distinct voices, all revealing their backgrounds through how they speak. And Su Chen? Mostly listening. His silence speaks louder than anyone's words.
... Read More
"Bone-chilling winds whistled through the gaps in the thatched roof of the firewood shed on that freezing winter night. Through one of the holes, one could glimpse the dark sky dotted with stars." I need to just sit with that sentence for a moment. The image is so specific—you're literally looking up through a hole in a roof at stars, shivering in a pile of dry grass that prickles your skin. This isn't some generic fantasy setting; it has texture, temperature, smell. The Heaven Falcon Inn scene is equally vivid: the rich aroma of wine and meat, the brocade-robed martial artists, the hierarchy visible in who sits where and who gets served first. Owner Wang yanking Ah Chou's ear while wealthy customers laugh and clap—this is a world where social hierarchy isn't just described, it's performed in real time. The beggar encounter at the start also matters more than I initially gave it credit for. Three or five members per group, territories carved out like ganglands, the leader protecting his "precious flower-patterned porcelain bowl" like it's treasure. This tells you everything about Gusu County—displaced people everywhere, lawlessness, the poor preying on the poorer. The evening chill setting in, the thin garments offering little warmth, the realization that tonight might be his last if he doesn't find shelter. Every sensory detail works together. The world doesn't feel painted on; it feels lived in.
... Read More
Oh my god, the way Su Chen just completely sidesteps all that courtyard drama is chef's kiss. I literally laughed out loud when he saw Wang Fugui bribing the cook and just... kept eating his coarse bun in the corner like none of that affected him. Most protagonists would've either flexed back or seethed silently, but Su Chen? He just wanted food and warmth. That's such a defining character moment - you know exactly who this kid is after one scene. And let's talk about Zhang Tieniu for a second. The kid who ate all that pork meat and powered across that bridge on pure instinct? Su Chen promising him TWO pork legs was genuinely heartwarming. It showed Su Chen's gratitude before they'd even exchanged three words with each other. Meanwhile, Tieniu's dad Butcher Zhang - I love how he just bellowed with pride instead of being some scheming parent. These two have such natural chemistry; they're clearly going to be allies later. But what really got me was how Su Chen size up the social hierarchy and immediately chose not to play. When he saw Li Jiao - the delicate girl he spotted at the pier - he figured she must've gotten in through daddy's favors. Smart kid. He doesn't resent her, he just files it away and stays in his corner. That's not bitterness, that's survival instinct. The contrast between the ten silk-clad youths and everyone else wasn't just set dressing - it was the author showing us that the Martial World has the same class system as the ordinary world, maybe worse because now you're learning to fight with those biases built in. Su Chen's refusal to engage told me everything I needed to know about who he'd become.
... Read More
There are so many layers in this chapter that I didn't even notice on the first read. Let me try to unpack some of them. The steaming white buns. They cost one copper coin. That's it. That's the entire distance between Su Chen and survival. He licks his lips, pats his rumbling stomach, badly wants them—and can't afford them. The buns are a symbol of everything he's missing. Basic warmth, basic food, basic dignity. And the fact that he ate his half-loaf of bread on the way to this city? That's the past leaving him behind. He came to Gusu County hoping for a fresh start, but he's already spent his resources before he even began. Then there's Han Mountain Daoist Temple. The text says Su Chen was born over a decade ago and the abbot, Daoist Han Shan, diagnosed his illness and even gave him his name. This kid's fate was touched by this temple before he even understood what it was. And now he's walking past it, dressed in patched clothes, daring not to enter. He bows from afar, offering a token gesture of gratitude, thinking he'll come back when he's wealthy. But will he? Or will the temple remain a symbol of everything he can't reach? And the social abyss between Su Chen and Li Jiao—that's probably the biggest symbol of all. She's in fur, he's in rags. She laughs at him, then looks down on him. The text literally calls it a "social abyss." That word is doing a lot of work. It's not just that they're different classes. It's that the gap is so wide it might never be crossed. But stories like this always prove that wrong, don't they? The abyss is the whole point. It's what drives the narrative forward.
... Read More
I need to sit down. The goodbye between Su Chen and Ah Chou is one of those moments that just quietly destroys you. No dramatic music, no grand speeches — just two teenagers on a busy street, wind blowing, each heading toward different dreams, and Ah Chou is literally crying while handing over money he saved for a MONTH. 'Why are you being polite?' Bro, neither of you are being polite, you're both just refusing to accept that the world won't be kind to either of you. The line that killed me though was Su Chen accepting just one coin and saying 'I'll buy some buns on the way.' He doesn't refuse it outright because he knows refusing would wound Ah Chou more than accepting would hurt his pride. That's not naive — that's emotional intelligence most adults don't have. And then they run off in opposite directions into the cold wind. Two fishermen's boys from nowhere, trying to become something. The fact that this story treats their friendship with this much tenderness while everything else around them is so cutthroat? That's what makes it work. It's not romance, it's not family blood — it's the choice to be someone's person in a world that gives you every reason not to.
... Read More
Okay, let me tell you about patience as a narrative device, because the author absolutely nailed it here. First you get the morning rush - sixty kids trying the bridge, high energy, chaos, a boy falls, crowd panics, fishermen rescue him. Fast pace, lots of movement. Then - Su Chen sits down and waits. And waits. And waits. An entire morning passes. The author deliberately slows us down, makes us feel that boredom, that anticipation, alongside our protagonist. Then noon comes. The sun peaks. Ice melts. Su Chen eats his three buns, warms water in his mouth, stretches, and GO. The transition from stillness to action is sudden but earned. We've been waiting with him, so when he moves, we move with him. The crossing itself? Thirty meters of desperate climbing, arms trembling, ice in his bones. Fast again. Then he reaches the other side - barely standing, limbs shaking - and the pace deliberately slows as he walks down those hundred steps, unties his rope, avoids the guards. Every movement calculated, exhausted. Then BAM - the courtyard. New characters, new tensions, social hierarchy on display. The author pulls back to wide shot again, lets us absorb the scene. By evening, gates close. By dinner, we're feeding a hundred starving kids. The pacing never drags because each section serves a different purpose: tension, relief, worldbuilding, character revelation. Most importantly - no chapter ends on a cliffhanger, but the whole section builds toward something. Su Chen has survived the test. Now what happens next? That question carries us forward.
... Read More
"Shut your mouth! Do you think we can sell our child?" — Father Su explodes, but I swear the worst part of this scene isn't the argument, it's how quickly he goes silent after. This man who rages about selling their own flesh and blood... he eventually accepts it. Let me just say that hit me hard. The Su family dynamic is this gorgeous, tragic portrait of love strained to its absolute breaking point. Father Su smoked his pipe in silence for most of the scene, the ember glowing red in the dim light—that image alone tells you everything about a man who loves his kids but is being crushed by circumstances he can't fix. Mother Su is the one who voices the unbearable truth: 'If he falls ill again, what then? How would we survive?' Not 'should we send him away' but 'how do we keep him alive.' And then Su Chen. Oh my god, Su Chen. This kid who barely cried all his life, who saved every copper coin trying to ease his family's burden, who heard his parents discussing selling him and didn't even feel resentment—he felt relief mixed with terror. 'His parents no longer wanted him!' His first reaction is not anger at them, it's GUILT. That's character depth right there. He kneels on a soaked bamboo raft and bows three times. He leaves his savings for his siblings. He doesn't cry because crying means dying. The relationship between Su Chen and his parents before this was clearly built on quiet sacrifice from both sides—the parents sacrificing everything to keep him alive, him sacrificing his childhood to stop being a burden. Now that contract is severed, and the tragedy is that nobody here did anything wrong. Everyone loved each other. That's what makes this so brutal.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or