I want to talk about the Cold and Aloof Girl, aka Number Three, and I want to start with how irrationally protective I felt when Xin Xiu was handling her. Because Number Three is NOT warm. She's in the farthest corner, keeping her distance, refusing to engage, and her first contribution to the group dynamic is basically "I will not acknowledge my own discomfort." She's lying there tossing and turning, creating noise, and when Xin Xiu asks if something's wrong, her response is "I won't turn over anymore." Which is not an answer. That's a deflection wrapped in defiance. And I get it. I really do.
Then she cracks. Just a little. And what comes out is not anger at her parents specifically, it's this deeper, uglier self-question: "is it because I'm not good enough?" That line hit me in the sternum. Because she's a kid. A small, probably five-or-six-year-old kid, and she's already internalizing abandonment as a personal failing. The author writes it almost throwaway-like, mumbled, half-asleep, but it's the most emotionally dense sentence in the whole batch. She's not performing hurt for the other kids. She's just... bleeding a little in the corner while everyone else is giggling about lotus seeds.
And then Xin Xiu's response is so perfectly calibrated. Not coddling. Not "oh honey it'll be fine." Just leaning back against a giant lotus seed, staring at the sky, and dropping: "They might not want you, but the immortals do." Four seconds of comfort that reframes the entire situation without a single pitying word. And the Proud Young Master chiming in with "It's because they're foolish, not because we're not good enough!" is actually the funniest and most emotionally accurate beat here. Because a kid saying it flatly, with zero nuance, lands differently than if an adult said it.
What gets me is that Number Three grabs Xin Xiu's arm during the giant firefly scene without asking permission. She's been maintaining her distance all night and the first time she physically connects with another person in the group is out of sheer terror. Not comfort. Not affection. Fear. And the author doesn't make a big deal of it. She just... clings. And that tells you everything about what this kid's baseline state is.
Does anyone else think Number Three and Xin Xiu are going to become the most quietly intense pair in this book? Not flashy. Not the kind you ship in fanart. Just... two people who recognize each other's jagged edges and don't flinch from them?
I keep rethinking that single sentence. "They don't want me... is it because I'm not good enough?" As a reader, I want to shake this kid and say no, honey, they just weren't fit for the job. But I also know that's not how the world works for her. And the author doesn't give her a clean resolution. She just sits up, accepts the reframe, and the scene moves on to the firefly disaster. No soft music. No hug. Just... forward.