Man or Tool - Reviews

Man or Tool
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about how the pacing in these chapters operates because it is genuinely masterful. The author gives you these beautiful, slow-burn domestic moments—George cooking, Amber reading, the rain stopping and the sun coming out—and then drops an entire royal retinue onto the front porch like nothing happened. There's this rhythm to the chapters that I found myself loving. Chapter 17 is this incredibly intimate, almost painfully slow night scene between George and Amber. Just two people in a bedroom talking about childhood trauma and why they're scared of being alone. It drags in the best possible way. Every line of dialogue feels weighted, every pause meaningful. I was savoring it. Then Chapter 18 opens with Amber boarding the train and the prose becomes almost lyrical: 'the salty breeze, the sea along the tracks, the seagulls flying over the sparkling water, the colorful rooftops clustered along the coast.' This beautiful, hopeful imagery. And then within hours of her departure, someone knocks on the door and the entire story pivots. The transition from Amber's POV to George's POV also works really well structurally. We see the world through Amber's eyes first—this small village, this quiet life, this person she's growing to need. Then we flip to George alone, cleaning books Amber read, organizing her things, getting tips at work. He's building a life here. And then the knights arrive and that life is about to shatter. What's clever is that the author keeps both narratives moving simultaneously. While we're in Napolia dealing with royal politics, Amber is presumably in the capital dealing with her father's news. Two parallel tensions building. It's like the book has two engines and both are firing at once. The only note I'd make is that Chapter 19 cuts off mid-revelation about the second prince's scandals, which is clearly a cliffhanger designed to make you immediately grab the next volume. I respect the manipulation.
... Read More
Okay so I gotta be honest - when Amber first touches the d*ldo in broad daylight, my first thought was 'this is gonna go somewhere weird.' And it did. Like, really weird. The way she rationalizes it - 'no point in worrying, let's go!' - is so Amber. She just moves on because that's what she does. Then she's up at night unable to sleep, all her remedies failing, and she's like 'I'm just too lazy' to get warm milk. Classic procrastination. But then she goes for it again, and this time... George appears. I was not expecting that timing. The whole scene where he's holding his organ and she's trying to catch her breath is both ridiculous and kind of tense? Like, what is this even, and why am I still reading. The plot moves from weird to weirder in a way that makes you want to see what happens next. Also the line 'Do d*ldos get etiquette lessons these days?' made me laugh out loud. This author knows how to keep you turning pages.
... Read More
The tension in these chapters is built on two parallel conflicts that are about to collide, and the author is letting us sit in that dread for exactly as long as possible before detonating everything. On one side, you have Amber's personal stake: her father's letter, her unresolved feelings about Reynold, her fear that she's become dependent on someone she can't afford to lose. She's carrying this internal conflict about whether she can actually move forward or if she'll keep running in circles. And the external pressure—the trip to the capital, whatever news her father has—adds urgency. On the other side, George's entire existence is about to be ripped apart. He found a quiet life, someone who makes him feel safe, a purpose beyond just surviving. He got a job. He made friends. He's falling in love. And the very moment Amber steps on that train, dozens of knights show up claiming he's a prince. The stakes couldn't be higher: he has to choose between the life he built with Amber and the identity he never asked for but apparently belongs to. What makes this genuinely stressful is that the author has made us care about both sides equally. We're not just watching a romance interrupted by plot—we're watching two people who genuinely help each other survive, and something massive is about to disrupt that. George whispering 'I'll wait for you' before she boards that train is the most hopeful and most terrifying line in the passage. Hopeful because he promises to stay. Terrifying because he literally cannot know what's coming. And then there's Merin, just standing there offering tea to armored men, completely blindsided. Her stakes are lower but her emotional investment is real—she's watched this amnesiac man become part of their family, and now strangers are claiming he belongs to a completely different world. The conflict isn't just about George and Amber; it's about everyone whose life he's touched. The suspense is working overtime here. Every scene after the knights arrive is loaded with dramatic irony because we know something Amber doesn't, and we're counting the hours until she finds out.
... Read More
'A heavy weight enveloped her, and the familiar scent of the man filled the air.' That line gave me chills. Not because it's scary - because it's so sensory. The whole transformation scene is weirdly intimate. And later when Amber looks between her legs and sees... whatever it is, the text doesn't shy away from describing it. 'Something darker and reddish was embedded' - I'm sorry but that's such a specific visual that now I can't unsee it. The kitchen scene too, with 'the sizzling sound was especially pleasant at night' - it grounds everything in a real place even while the plot is going crazy. And when she's searching for clothes and finds nothing, the emptiness of that moment contrasts with how full the room already is with George. The author clearly knows how to paint scenes.
... Read More
Okay I know this sounds extra but hear me out. Amber is reading a book called 'Everything You Can Do with Chicory' while George plants chicory seedlings. The text literally says the subtitle promises simple, varied recipes, and she loses interest instantly. But the symbolism is kind of unavoidable—chicory is bitter, it's useful, you don't waste any part of the root. George is bitter, he's useful, and Amber is learning not to waste any part of him. He's being 'planted' in her garden literally and figuratively. And then there's the whole theme of usefulness versus personhood running through this entire passage. Amber sent him to work because 'doing nothing all day is the problem'—implying his value is tied to productivity, even if that productivity is sexual. But George flips it. He negotiates. He performs. He turns the garden into a space of his own choosing. The chicory metaphor extends to the village itself—Napolia is this rough, unpolished place where Amber is trying to plant roots after her life in the capital was uprooted by the broken engagement. She's trying to figure out what she can 'do' with this new life, just like the book promises to explain what you can do with chicory. Except the book is boring and real life isn't. George knows that. That's why he's the one thriving while Amber is the one sweating.
... Read More
I didn't think I'd feel anything for a magical penis-person but here we are. When he grabs her clothes looking 'like a dog waiting for its owner or a lost child,' I actually felt sorry for him. And then Amber, being soft-hearted toward animals and kids, answers kindly without thinking. Their dynamic is already so... domestic? Like, they're sharing a meal, he's calling her Master, and she's worried about finding him clothes. Meanwhile the text says 'his solid body pressed her down, and arms slowly stroked her back' and then 'Master' and I'm just... what year is it? The way she keeps saying 'he's so s*xy right now' before she even really knows him is interesting. Is she projecting? Is she lonely? I don't know but there's something genuine in how Amber handles him even when she's confused. And George asking 'If I learn, can I do this too?' about cooking feels almost innocent.
... Read More
What kills me about these chapters is how the stakes keep escalating without anyone raising their voice. The external conflict is minimal—just a weird man with amnesia and a grandmother who's suspicious. But the internal stakes? Those are nuclear. Amber's conflict is beautifully rendered. She's protecting George, but she's also protecting herself. Every lie she tells Merin is a piece of armor. "He's my boyfriend"—said with eyes darting, voice full of conviction she may or may not feel. Is she convincing her grandmother or herself? The ambiguity IS the conflict. George's stakes are even higher. If Merin discovers what he truly is—a purpose-built object, a non-human entity—everything collapses. "If my presence ever causes trouble for Amber, I'll leave without being asked." That's not humility; that's survival strategy. He's already calculated his own disposability. "He's not a bad person." Amber defending George while internally thinking 'No, he's fine because he's a dildo'—this interior monologue reveals the terrifying gap between public performance and private truth. She's living a lie and she knows it, but the lie feels more honest than any truth she's told before. Merin's suspicion is the slow-burn external conflict. She's been reading people her whole life. "Still, he seems nice, but the whole lost memory thing bothers me." The grandmother instinct kicking in, the protective grandmother energy that's been building since Gavin's grocery store complaint. She's not convinced, and we know it. The stakes in the bedroom scene are maximal. Merin walking in on Amber and George—not the physical intimacy, but the emotional exposure. Amber flustered, George completely unbothered. That power dynamic shift! He's been caught in his most vulnerable moment and he doesn't even flinch. That's either confidence or complete emotional detachment. Which is it? "Is that so?" Merin's response to Amber blushing about their sex life—that's not just teasing; it's testing. She's measuring how happy her granddaughter actually is, how genuine this relationship seems. The stakes of that conversation are enormous: will Merin accept George, or will she become the obstacle that forces Amber to choose between love and family? Gavin's unresolved tension adds another layer. Drunk, making a scene, gone—but why did he come? What does he want? The author knows we're waiting for that answer, and every chapter that passes without resolution raises the stakes. Something is coming. And the illness—Amber's cold, her recovery, George's careful distance: "I don't touch sick people." The physical vulnerability of sickness as metaphor for emotional vulnerability. When Amber is weak, George becomes caretaker. When she recovers, he becomes... what? Lover? Protector? The shifting roles ARE the conflict. "But watching George, she became more and more sure. Maybe she could go all the way with him." This realization carries the weight of every previous betrayal. She's risking hope again, trusting again, opening herself to potential devastation. That's the highest stake of all—not being found out, but being hurt again after promising herself she wouldn't dream of a future. The conflict isn't dramatic. It's domestic, intimate, almost unbearable in its quietness. And that's why it works.
... Read More
Can we just talk about this scene where George tucks Amber in and she finally opens up about Reynold? Because that was genuinely one of the most emotionally honest moments in the entire book. She tells him she used to like that awful fiancé, that she was obsessed with marriage because her mother died and her father broke, that she wanted to recreate the happiness she had as a child. And she says 'That's why I needed you, George. After, I could at least sleep.' I actually had to put the book down for a second. That is SUCH a vulnerable thing to say. She's basically telling him that he's become her safe place, her reason for peace. And the way she couldn't bring herself to say the next part out loud—the part about not wanting to be apart from him? That silence between them was louder than any dialogue could have been. But what really got me was George's reaction. He didn't panic or try to fix it or make some grand romantic declaration. He just... looked anxious. Truly anxious. Because he doesn't remember who he was before, and suddenly she's telling him she depends on him, and he's terrified of whatever comes next. The quiet 'I don't want to lose you' before she falls asleep is the kind of line that lives in my head rent-free. And Merin and Grandmother being left behind together? I was genuinely worried about that dynamic at first, but it turned out fine because George has already built this rapport with everyone. Merin making tea to celebrate his tips, the two of them bantering—there's such warmth there. George even jokes about earning with his looks now, which is wild considering he was so proper when he first arrived. The contrast between how Amber treated people at the start versus now is remarkable. She came in all guarded and independent, and now she's letting people in, starting with George. That progression feels earned.
... Read More
So Amber runs away. That's the plot's opening salvo, and it takes forty-plus chapters of implied backstory before she actually says it out loud to someone. And when she does, it's not dramatic. It's not a sobbing breakdown. She's standing over George, looking down at him, and she just... tells him. Casual as weather. 'I actually ran away. I was chased here. Because of my broken engagement. My fiancé cheated.' One sentence each. No padding. No 'and then this terrible thing happened and I felt so hurt.' Just facts, delivered like she's reading a grocery list. That restraint is what makes it hit. The author could have gone full melodrama—flashbacks, tears, the works—but instead Amber's voice stays detached, 'as if talking about someone else.' And that distance is the whole tragedy. She's so far removed from her own pain that even she doesn't seem to realize how much it still matters. The structure around this confession is also smart. First Gavin tries to confess to her, which forces Amber to define what she wants (friendship, safety, no surprises). Then George removes her from that situation without asking questions. Then the sunset conversation where George offers her the choice—human form or not—and she chooses him as he is. Only then, in that aftermath of mutual understanding, does she finally admit why she's really here. It's a slow burn that rewards patience. The rain acts as a narrative pressure valve—trapping them together, removing all distractions, forcing the conversation inward. By the time Amber speaks her truth, the reader has already sat through hours of quiet moments with these two, and that confession lands because we've earned it. The chapter doesn't end on the confession either; it ends with George's internal realization that he's needed. That's the real plot move—the external event (Amber telling her story) triggers an internal revolution in the second lead. Two arcs completing each other in one scene.
... Read More
I need to just sit with this single moment for a second. The dinner ends, they're getting ready to leave, and George quietly moves behind Amber and drapes the shawl over her shoulders. Everything about that gesture is intimate—close proximity, his voice low, the physical touch—but it's also genuinely caring. He noticed she was cold or uncomfortable and acted on it without making a scene. Then he whispers right after: "Praise me later. Not just 'good job' or 'nice.'" And Amber is too drunk to respond properly, cheeks flushed, and ends up saying thank you behind his back like it's some awkward confession. BUT THEN—Gavin appears. Right between them. Offers his hand. And Amber takes it. Without even realizing she's doing it. The text says she didn't notice George's smiling gaze following their joined hands. THAT IS DEVASTATING. Like, on one level it's just comedy—Amber is tipsy and clumsy, typical Amber energy. But on another level, she's choosing Gavin's hand in that moment and George is watching it happen with a smile that could mean a dozen different things. Jealousy? Amusement? Resignation? The romantic tension in this book is not subtle but it's also not cheap. It's built on THESE tiny gestures—the shawl, the whisper, the hand offer, the joined hands. And I was sitting there like what does this MEAN. Because Amber clearly has feelings for George but her history with Gavin keeps pulling her into different directions.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or