It Wasn’t an R-Rated Game - Reviews

It Wasn’t an R-Rated Game
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I keep coming back to the dress. Not just because it gets torn, but because it means SO MUCH in this passage that I can't stop thinking about it. The Empire dress is introduced as an act of rebellion. Natalie chose it deliberately—comfortable, cool, fashionable,打破传统 (no, I need to write in English). Breaking tradition. Women wearing dresses without corsets in summer. Bella recommends it. It represents bodily autonomy, practicality, a quiet rebellion against the suffocating layers women were expected to endure. Bella even gives a passionate speech about how men can remove their outer garments in summer while women must suffer in multiple layers. The dress IS the argument. Then Everitt weaponizes it. "You're the insane lady-in-waiting who made that innocent child wear such a nightgown-like dress." In his hands, the dress becomes evidence of immodesty, proof of moral corruption, justification for his violence. He didn't just tear fabric—he used her own rebellion as the excuse to punish her. The dress that was supposed to liberate her becomes the thing that ENDS up exposing her. The moonlight is complicit too. It catches the sheer fabric, makes it nearly transparent, turns what Bella chose as comfort into a trap. Fashion history and female choice become ammunition in a man's hands. There's also the corset as a symbol—mentioned repeatedly but never worn. The corset represents the old order, the restrictive expectations, the physical pain women endure for propriety. Bella refuses it. Everitt demands it, not for her comfort but for her control. When he grabs her and comments on her curves, he's punishing her for existing without the constraints he believes women need. And the gold earrings Natalie gives her? That's a different kind of symbol—female support, material generosity between women, a gesture of care that contrasts sharply with Everitt's violation. Natalie wants to raise Bella's salary. She wants to protect her. The women in this story are trying to lift each other up while the men are tearing things apart. The dress survives the night. The dressmaker promises to repair it. But Bella? She's not sure she can repair herself. And that's the heaviest symbol of all.
... Read More
Can we just stop and appreciate that Bella and Natalie have spent DOZENS OF SUMMERS together? Dozens. That's not background flavor text—that's the entire emotional spine of this story right there. And yet the text makes you feel the fragility of it too. Natalie only learned Bella's name a few days ago. The hierarchy is invisible until it slaps you in the face. I literally cannot unsee the scene where Bella stands behind that long chair, trembling but still fighting back, throwing around the Princess's name like a shield. 'Do you think she would want a man who assaulted her lady-in-waiting?' She's betting everything on a bond she's terrified might not go both ways. And that bet? It terrifies me more than any monster ever could. Then there's Leon. A guy who gets genuinely happy about learning Natalie likes berries and clench his fist in the air like a golden retriever who just found out you're taking him for a walk. Bella's little thought—'perhaps Leon might be a better fiancé candidate'—felt so tender and so wrong at the same time. She's trying to make herself root for someone else because the alternative is facing Everitt alone. That's love wearing the costume of self-preservation. The wine was sweet. She finished one glass and picked up another. The simplest sentence hiding the deepest exhaustion.
... Read More
The shift in atmosphere between these two scenes is chef's kiss. You start in this absolutely idyllic tea room—Florian singing on stage, tea pouring, Leon and Natalie whispering to each other like two lovesick teenagers, Bella sipping her tea with her eyes closed feeling all warm and fuzzy. It's so explicitly described as 'healing' too, which honestly made me appreciate how intentional the author is about giving us these breathing moments. The summer garden roses, the music, the soft light—it all paints this picture of a storybook palace afternoon. And then IMMEDIATELY after, boom, you're in Everitt's office and the entire tone has flipped. He's working during his vacation, surrounded by paperwork, this full-fledged office setup in what should be a summer retreat. The stark desk, the candle, the wax seal—it's all so cold and administrative compared to the warm tea room. And then the physical space closes in on Bella. First he snatches the letter back, then he steps closer, then he pulls her into his arms, then his hand is under her dress. The proximity escalates paragraph by paragraph until you can feel Bella backing into the table leg, trapped. The author doesn't use fancy language here, just raw spatial tension—each sentence makes the room feel smaller and smaller. I kept glancing at the word count between these scenes like 'are we really still in the same book?'
... Read More
Okay so this Blake situation is driving me absolutely insane. The man kisses Bella's hand—wait no, he *licks* it. He literally described it as something 'soft and moist briefly licked the back of her hand' and Bella felt an electric current. That is NOT a normal gentlemanly hand kiss. That is predatory behavior disguised as courtly manners. But here's what really gets me: the way he immediately pivots to Natalie. One second he's making Bella's life miserable at the ball, then the *exact moment* Natalie walks in, he's all sweetness and light, dancing with perfect precision, whispering in the princess's ear while smiling. And Bella catches him looking at her mid-dance—his eyes narrow, lips part like he wants to say something, then he shuts it all away. Who does that? Then there's Natalie, who I thought was just this sweet anime-style princess, but she's clearly got layers. The way she holds Bella's hand, looks up with those 'playful' eyes, and basically commands her to wear the Empire dress again—it's gentle on the surface but absolutely firm underneath. Like, 'I'm asking nicely but you have no choice.' And then after Bella leaves, she mutters to herself: 'There are still three more left.' Three more what? What is she planning? And Leon! Golden hair, blue eyes, seems like the wholesome option, gives Bella a paperweight tailored to her hair color. Charming, polite, offers to send a dance instructor as a joke. He's literally a fairytale prince in human form. But in these stories, the nice guy is sometimes the most complicated route isn't he? I need to know what Blake is actually thinking. That look he gave Bella during the dance—it wasn't just lust. There was something else there. Recognition? Guilt? Or is he just a bastard who enjoys tormenting her?
... Read More
This is the scene that wrecked me. Bella watching Blake dance with Natalie. She's standing near the wall, watching them spin across the floor, and she literally 'bit her lip firmly' and thought 'bastard.' Her heart *ached.* Not because she's in love with Blake—the text is pretty clear she finds him repulsive—but because seeing them together brings back the fantasy version from the game. The game Blake she used to like. She tries to hold onto that old memory, and then immediately it's shattered by remembering 'the face looking down at her with l*st-filled eyes.' She can't have the nice fantasy anymore because the real version ruined everything. And then she turns away and nearly bumps into Leon. Of course. Right when her heart is breaking over one guy, the other one appears with golden hair and kind blue eyes and a perfectly tailored gift. It's almost cruel how the universe works in these stories. What killed me was Bella's internal monologue about not knowing how to dance. 'For all the future balls she would attend, rather than standing in a corner every time, dancing with strangers might be better for her mental health.' She said that. She just sat there and admitted it out loud to herself. That's not just about dancing—that's about feeling like an outsider at her own life, watching everyone else connect while she's stuck on the sidelines watching the people she's tangled with dance with other people. The sweetest moment was honestly just Leon being genuinely warm. Not calculating, not plotting, just smiling and making a joke about sending a dance instructor. Bella couldn't help but smile back. Even in the middle of all this emotional chaos, a little kindness lands differently.
... Read More
Can we talk about how little Blake says versus what he actually communicates? The dialogue here is sparse but devastating. 'Quiet. Don't scream.' 'It's your fault.' 'You'll like it even more soon.' Each line is a knife twist, delivered with this calm, almost conversational tone that makes it so much worse. Meanwhile, Everitt barely speaks at all—just watches, sets down his teacup, stares. His silence screams jealousy or pain or something primal. And Bella's internal voice? Perfect. She's frantic, analytical, nostalgic for the game's harmless versions. The narrator stays tightly close to her POV, so we're never allowed to escape her panic. Even the servant's laughter—'Oh dear, hahaha'—feels layered. Is it malicious? Amused? Or just background noise to someone else's plot? The author's choice to withhold Blake's motives through dialogue alone is masterful. We're left guessing, unsettled, constantly re-reading those few exchanges to decode what's really happening. It's terrifying how effective this restraint is.
... Read More
I have to talk about the worldbuilding details in this chapter because they are so much richer than I expected going in. Yes, this is a romance novel with male leads and a summer palace and all the tropes, but the small details make it feel genuinely lived-in. The moon tea scene alone — Bella sneaking off to a doctor, covering her face with a veil, and the doctor's response? 'There's not a single person here who isn't drinking this tea.' AND then he casually mentions 'they're all so vigorous.' I fell out of my chair. The author is building this world where casual sex is normal between the nobility and their guests, except apparently not for Natalie. That silence from the doctor, that normalization of everything — it tells you SO much about the social structure without any exposition dump. And then the hair-styling scene. The intricate details of Mari braiding Natalie's hair, the pearl decorations, the power dynamics between the three women in that room. You can literally see the palace. You can smell the incense. This isn't just a backdrop, it's a living, breathing space.
... Read More
I need to talk about Leon first because his dialogue is SO distinctive. 'Even the largest and most fragrant rose in the summer garden would pale beside Your Highness'—okay that's a LOT of complimenting but it feels right for him. He's the pretty prince who says pretty things and means them. The fact that he then asks about borrowing Bella privately and it turns out he just wants to THANK her for dessert advice? That's the kind of wholesome twist that makes you want to hug him. Classic Leon energy. Then Everitt's voice is completely different—short, sharp, almost interrogative. 'Who are you?' 'Do you like any man as long as he's male?' These aren't questions seeking information, they're weapons. Every sentence from him is designed to dominate the space and control the conversation. And Bella's internal monologue is honestly the funniest part. She goes from 'Florian's route would be nice too' to full existential panic in three paragraphs. Her voice shifts depending on who's around—gamer-bro commentary when she's alone in her head, proper servant-speak when talking to nobles, and then pure terror when Everitt corners her. One line that stayed with me: 'The Princess was his only dance partner.' Everitt says it so casually, like he's just stating a fact, but it carries so much accusation. He's not asking if Blake is her lover—he already knows and he's making her confirm it by omission. That's some elite-level psychological manipulation wrapped in a simple observation.
... Read More
I swear I wasn't prepared for how much emotional whiplash this book is going to give me. We open with what sounds like straight-up adult content—mans, thrusting, tears, bedposts—and then we land in this gorgeous, sunlit world where a woman named Han Si-yeon watches her favorite game character come to life and her immediate thought is simply "Wow, this is really a dream. I don't want to wake up." That contrast hit me so hard. The opening scene is all about bodily violation and loss of control (Bella trying desperately not to make sound, gripping a pillow, worried someone might hear). And then the flashback lands you in this almost naive, childlike wonder at seeing 2D characters breathe. It's jarring in the best way—the book is already telling you that romance and intimacy in this world are not going to be innocent. But the emotional core that's really doing things to me is Bella's relationship with Natalie. There's this motherly, almost desperate tenderness in how she describes the princess: "cotton candy-pink hair and smooth white skin," "sky-blue eyes that turned up at the corners like a cat's." She's built this entire emotional attachment to a pixelated version of this girl, and now she gets to watch her exist in real time. When Natalie smiles faintly during the dance with Leon, Bella doesn't just observe—it's personal. She's invested. She wants Natalie to be happy, and that investment is what's going to make whatever tragedies come next unbearable. The ball scene is where it really lands emotionally. Picture this: Bella, who has played this game a hundred times, who has controlled every romantic decision, is now reduced to hiding behind a pillar with a glass of champagne, watching the people she loves interact in ways she can no longer dictate. She superimposes her maxed-affection memory of Leon onto the real man and her cheeks flush. Not because she's attracted to him—because she's watching her digital daughter share a tender moment with someone her player-self chose, and she can't intervene. That helplessness is the most romantic tragedy I've encountered in any novel this year.
... Read More
I think this is the most important turning point for Bella's understanding of where she stands in this whole mess. Everything up until this chapter she's been trying to make sense of things — the world, the game, the male leads — but now she has concrete, painful proof that she is NOT seen as herself. Blake explicitly told her they look alike from the moment they met, and this scene confirms it in the most devastating way possible. What kills me is that Bella wasn't even resisting. Her body responded. Her mind was somewhere else. And he used her knowing full well who she was supposed to be.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Everitt because holy hell. This guy is the most terrifying character in the entire book and I am NOT over it. On the surface, he's introduced as this cold, rigid grand duke who's apparently warm only to his woman—very tropey setup, right? You'd think you're getting the brooding protector type. But then BAM, chapter 7-14 absolutely murders that impression. The scene on the balcony is unhinged. He grabs her butt—JUST GRABS HER BUTT, no warning, no consent, nothing—and then TEARS her dress open in front of the full moon like some kind of Victorian supervillain. And his dialogue afterward?? "Br*asts worth displaying. Very large and pretty." That's not a threat, that's not even a warning, that's a man who genuinely cannot imagine anyone existing outside his control. What's wild is how casually he shifts from cold aristocrat to full-on predator. One moment he's commenting on the night view, the next he's pressed against her, wrists pinned above her head, telling her to SCREAM so everyone can hear. The power imbalance is so extreme it's almost surreal—he's a Grand Duke, she's a lady-in-waiting with no family backing her at this ball. She physically can't escape. And then he LEAVES. Just walks away like he ordered a coffee and didn't actually terrorize someone. That's the most chilling part honestly. For him, this was a minor interaction. For Bella, it's a full psychological assault. Meanwhile Blake is this whole other vibe—shy smile, proper manners, asks permission to dance. The contrast between the two male leads here is SO sharp. Blake notices her resemblance to Natalie and makes a polite comment. Everitt notices she's not wearing a corset and decides to violate her on a balcony. These are not the same species of person and the book knows it. Also—Bella's internal voice after the fact is everything. She's sobbing, raging, calling him a "crazy bastard" while also being haunted by how good his voice sounded. That's such a realistic trauma response. Your brain doesn't just switch off because something awful happened. The fact that she's worried Blake was ALSO looking at her chest? That she's now paranoid about EVERY male gaze in that room? That's the aftermath of violation sitting right there in her thoughts, uninvited. I need a minute.
... Read More
Okay so let me just start by saying—Bella telling herself 'I'm not enjoying this' while her body is literally betraying her at every touch? The author did THAT on purpose. I felt my face get hot just reading it and I'm not even romantically involved in any of this. The whole Blake situation haunts me. She just... she thought she covered the mark. She actually believed she could hide what happened between them. And then Everitt notices it INSTANTLY and of course he brings up Blake by name like 'oh so you're still hung up on him?' The way Bella's heart sinks the moment he says those words—'The Princess was his only dance partner'—you can literally feel her realize she's just a substitute in everyone's eyes. Meanwhile Leon over there being all sweet and asking for Bella's advice on how to talk to Natalie, and she's sitting there smiling while her whole world is falling apart inside. The contrast is killing me. Also can we talk about Everitt saying 'I never thought being kicked away while being called crazy would feel better'? That line though. That is a man who has been hurt and is now lashing out in the most destructive way possible. He's not the villain here, he's just a broken person making everyone else's life worse. And I HATE that I kind of understand him.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or