Is there anything wrong with Alpha marking Alpha? - Reviews

Is there anything wrong with Alpha marking Alpha?
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
"What the f*ck? Is he that stupid? He pinched his own face, squeezing out the silly smile, but when he let go, it reappeared again." I love this scene so much. The entire chapter takes place in one apartment — the bedroom, the kitchen, the doorway between them — and yet every detail is so vivid I could see it on screen. Yu Chengsong washing vegetables, looking up, catching his own reflection in the glass, losing control of his face. That's the kind of visual writing that doesn't need fancy settings to land. Just a guy in his kitchen on a Tuesday morning, grinning like an idiot because today is the person he loves's birthday. And the cake description! "red strawberry jam surrounding it in the shape of teardrops and a circle of evenly sized strawberry slices, with y and g and happy birthday written on the strawberries." Even the cream-writing can't hide Yu Chengsong's naturally elegant handwriting. The author put all this care into describing a cake that exists only in the story, and I felt it. The morning light, the porridge steaming, the doorbell ringing, the way Yin Gu walks from the bedroom and his mouth curls up — this world feels lived-in, not constructed. You can smell the century egg congee.
... Read More
Okay so this kitchen scene. Just—just sit with me for a sec. Yu Chengsong cuts a piece of tomato and tries to feed Yin Gu because he's worried he's going to starve himself after fainting, and Yin Gu just opens his mouth like it's the most natural thing in the world. "But Yin Gu didn't take it. To be more precise, he didn't take it with his hands." That line hit me like a truck because it's not just about tomato, it's about trust, it's about the unspoken agreement between them that they don't need formalities anymore. And then the whole meal—Yu Chengsong cooking for someone, really cooking, not just heating things up—and Yin Gu sitting there eating like he's memorizing the taste. "The food that Yu Chengsong cooks is different from the food in restaurants. It's the taste of home cooking, full of homely flavor and warmth." YES. That's the entire emotional thesis of this novel right there. Then the watermelon scene where they're shouting at each other through the walls and it's so loud the neighbors can hear everything. "But it feels great." That one sentence. That's Yin Gu experiencing what it means to not be alone in a way he never has before. I literally pressed pause on my book.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this immediately: Yu Chengsong is absolutely cracked in the best way possible when it comes to how he navigates his relationships, and the contrast here is everything. With Zhou Zheyu, he's all jokes, physical comedy, throwing candy, letting himself be dragged into elaborate schemes about sewing stuffed toys and skipping class. He's loud, he's goofy, he's fully present in the friendship. But the second he's alone with Yin Gu? The text literally says his intelligence drops. Love really does that to him. And I think what's brilliant about this passage is how Yu Chengsong's internal monologue reveals someone who is completely aware of his own vulnerability but chooses to embrace it anyway. He thinks about how he'd rather be a total fool for someone than end up with no story at all. That is not a light commitment. That is someone who has looked at the possibility of years of regret and decided the risk is worth it. Meanwhile, Yin Gu is doing his own thing in the background - asking about Zhou Zheyu with this dry amusement, then later waking up and instinctively grabbing Yu Chengsong's pajamas. The power dynamic here is so interesting because on the surface, Yu Chengsong seems like the one pursuing, the one planning gifts and overthinking his chances. But Yin Gu's actions in those quiet moments suggest he's already let Yu Chengsong all the way in. That line, 'No need to go out,' said while still half-asleep and clutching his boyfriend's clothes, is not the words of someone who is unsure. It's the words of someone who has already claimed this. The relationship between these two has this beautiful asymmetry where Yu Chengsong is still in the planning and hoping phase while Yin Gu has basically moved in, emotionally if not literally. And then there's Zhou Zheyu as this comedic Greek chorus commenting on everything, which honestly makes the whole thing feel even more real. Because that's how life is, right? You have your dramatic friend making noises in the background while your actual heart is doing this quiet, terrifying thing.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this one moment where Yin Gu walks into the living room with a pillow and just… sits next to Yu Chengsong on the sofa. It sounds small, right? Like nothing. But I actually had to put the book down for a second. The way Yin Gu complains about the kid grinding his teeth at night, totally casual, like he's already accepted sharing this space, like he's been here half a month and his pheromones are literally everywhere now—and Yu Chengsong is sleeping on a couch in another man's home and feeling like he's soaked in sandalwood. That line hit me so hard. And then Yu Chengsong gets up and walks toward the bedroom without even explaining why, and Yin Gu calls after him 'what are you doing?' and then the chapter just cuts off. I was sweating. The romance in this book doesn't do grand confessions or dramatic declarations. It does this—it does quiet proximity, someone choosing to sit beside you on a creaky sofa at 2am because you both can't sleep, and the fact that Yu Chengsong's first instinct when his world falls apart is to text Yin Gu instead of running anywhere else. That's devotion. That's the whole thing.
... Read More
Okay so can we just talk about how Yin Gu doesn't say a single word of comfort when Yu Chengsong is unraveling? He just... presses the back of his hand. Grabs it with his palm. That's it. That's the entire conversation. And yet it hits harder than any speech ever could. This dynamic is everything. Yu Chengsong spends the whole chapter wrapping himself in self-deprecation — calling himself a devil, laughing at his own trauma like it's a joke — and Yin Gu just stays there, grounded, present. The contrast between Yu Chengsong's chaotic need to perform indifference and Yin Gu's quiet certainty that none of that nonsense is true? Chef's kiss. And then the line where it says: "Compared with the right time and place, talking requires more harmony among people." Yin Gu IS that safe space. He's not just some love interest subplot — he's literally the person who makes it possible for Yu Chengsong to finally breathe out a truth he's been carrying since he was six. That's not romantic filler, that's narrative architecture. What else am I supposed to feel about this other than absolutely wrecked?
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is absolutely ruthless and I respect it so much. We open with peak comedy energy—Jia Manning weeping over skirts, Yu Chengsong's deadpan "Lao Li should pay you a salary," her spiraling into white-cut-black fanfiction territory. I was laughing, fully engaged in what felt like a lighthearted school comedy. Then the bell rings, they walk to the playground shade, and within three paragraphs the tone shifts so hard my stomach dropped. This isn't a slow drift into darkness. It's a door opening and then closing behind you. One moment it's about uniforms and the next it's about bone-breaking contracts and a boy who hasn't eaten properly in four months because his mother holds the purse strings like a weapon. What I find brilliant is how the author uses the classroom scene as a pressure valve. All that absurd energy from the skirt negotiation gets released through Jia Manning's maniacal excitement, and then Lao Li's voice about exercise books and monthly exams provides this false sense of normalcy before the real conversation starts. It's structural misdirection at its finest. And the cliffhanger—ending on a sentence that literally breaks off mid-thought. "If I don't want the other party to know it's me, then I ca—" That comma hanging there like a wire about to snap. I would have understood if the author just finished the sentence and moved on, but no. They chose to cut it. Because they know exactly what they're doing. Also worth noting: the transition from the uniform comedy to the underworld plot happens almost casually. No chapter break, no scene divider. Just two guys walking to a shady spot beside the playground and the whole world changes. That's confident pacing.
... Read More
I need to talk about this one scene because it keeps looping in my head. Yu Chengsong is burning up, half-asleep, and there's something cooler next to him. So what does he do? He grabs Yin Gu and pulls him close. No hesitation. No "wait, is this appropriate?" Just pure instinct. And Yin Gu? Yin Gu doesn't flinch. He just adjusts their position from being hugged to HIM doing the hugging, and lets Yu Chengsong use him however he wants. "So comfortable." Yu Chengsong thinks this in his head and I wanted to SCREAM. This man is operating purely on subconscious need and Yin Gu is just... there. Accepting it. Providing comfort without being asked. But then the whole thing flips. Later, when Yu Chengsong is actually IN his susceptible period and losing control, his first instinct isn't to push Yin Gu away — it's to drag him into the infirmary with him. "I need to be quarantined immediately." He says this while literally pulling Yin Gu out the door. He knows he's dangerous. He knows he should be alone. And yet his body betrays him every single time he tries to create distance. This is the most honest relationship portrayal I've read in a long time. It's not about grand confessions or dramatic moments. It's about a sick person grabbing the nearest cool thing and that thing willingly becoming their ice pack. It's about fear and desire existing simultaneously. "I may be in my susceptible period. I want to bite as soon as I see the neck right now" — said while holding onto the person he wants most. The tension between "I should protect him" and "I need him" is absolutely wrecking me. Is this love or is it biology? Does it matter when his hand won't let go?
... Read More
There's a line that keeps haunting me: 'He feels like there is a stone in his heart, it was heavy and uncomfortable. He really wants to smash his heart and the stone inside together with one punch.' Then a few paragraphs later—'Snap—the stone was broken into pieces.' What just happened? Yin Gu knocked on the bathroom door and asked if he was done showering, and suddenly the stone cracks. I know what that means. It's not that the pain is gone. It's that for one second, human warmth interrupted the heaviness. The sandalwood pheromone imagery throughout this batch isn't just atmosphere—it's about being surrounded by someone's presence so thoroughly that it becomes a kind of shelter. Yu Chengsong sleeps on a sofa that smells like Yin Gu and feels 'inexplicably hot,' and that heat isn't just physical. It's the warmth of not being alone in your wreckage. The recurring motif of 'nowhere to go' is doing heavy lifting too. Hotel, friend's place—that's all the world offers. The story keeps asking: what does home mean when your actual home is a place of violence? And the answer, apparently, is: it means someone who leaves the light on and buys strawberry cake.
... Read More
The worldbuilding in this scene is SO subtle I almost missed it until it hit me. We get this one line about Alpha pheromones filling the room with orange soda scent, and suddenly the whole sensory experience of the scene changes. The bed is literally described as 'a mountain of oranges' — that's not just a smell, that's a PHYSICAL sensation the author is giving you. And then Yin Gu dreams he's walking through a pile of oranges and one bigger than him falls on his chest. Which is ALSO what happens in reality because Yu Chengsong rolls over and punches him with his arm. The dream and reality BLUR together. Also the moon coming out from behind clouds, the light blue curtains with white cloud patterns letting in faint light — the author is painting this entire bedroom scene like a film frame. I can SEE it.
... Read More
I have never understood someone's feelings for another person quite like I understand Yu Chengsong in this chapter. The guy asks Yin Gu if he wants to eat anything with this nervous little adam apple movement, gets told just strawberry cake and a casual "whatevers fine babe," and then proceeds to mentally craft the most elaborate birthday gift possible. The bear selection scene is everything. While every other customer is grabbing the cute brown and yellow bears—the bestsellers, the obvious choices—Yu Chengsong wanders to the corners and finds two gray bears that nobody wanted. One with a band-aid on its forehead and gauze on its hand, another with gauze wrapped around its chest and leg. "It's injured bears," he corrects Zhou Zheyu. "And it's bears that no one wants as well." He sees himself in these battered, forgotten things. Or he sees Yin Gu. Or both. The parallel is so thick I could spread it on toast. And then the sewing. Oh god the sewing. His fingers get pricked six times. He almost cuts the bear with scissors six times. Zhou Zheyu has to physically restrain him, hugging his waist, calling him "Brother Song! Father Song!" Like some desperate prayer. Yu Chengsong threatens to burn the whole thing. Takes a cigarette break. Then picks up the needle again. "If it's not easy to do, then so be it. The easy ones can't show his passion... f*ck it!" This man is unhinged and I love him for it. Then Yin Gu starts texting at 10 AM, noon, 3 PM. Three calls. Each one more intimate than the last. And when his finger gets bloodied right as the phone rings—he answers without looking at the caller ID. He already knows. He always knows. The vulnerability of someone who would literally bleed over a stuffed animal for another person is something I can't recover from.
... Read More
The dialogue in this passage is absolutely delicious, and I need to talk about how the author uses voice to do double duty — making you laugh and then making you cry with the same paragraph. Yin Gu and Yu Chengsong's conversations are like nothing else. The Pacific Ocean bit alone is worth the price of admission: "If you are moved, just release an ocean." / "Love you." / "Where's the ocean?" / "In my heart. It's like the Pacific Ocean, with turbulent waves, full of love." This is peak sweet-couple energy, but it's also genuinely funny. Yin Gu is clearly the more poetic one, and Yu Chengsong plays along with this competitive affection: "Your ocean is also in my heart. It's locked inside and can't be released." They're basically courting each other through metaphors and I am here for it. But then the dialogue about Zhou Zheyu's crush is where the humor really shines. The girl deleted him because "he talked too much, affecting her speed in doing her homework." That's not a romance subplot — that's a comedy sketch. And Zhou Zheyu's dramatic response — "I didn't even cheat in the exam this time" — is perfectly rendered teenager energy. He's trying SO HARD and it's not working, and the author lets him have his moment before immediately pivoting to the couple feeding each other candy in front of him. "F*ck, my eyes!" Zhou Zheyu covers his face. "You two can have fun, I'm going to buy milk tea for my white moonlight, ai." The "ai" at the end? Iconic. This kid is suffering and he knows it, and he's dramatically acknowledging his single status like a true romance novel extra. Then the phone rings and the tone shatters. "Comeback home!" — no greeting, no warmth. Just a command from someone who has weaponized their own pain. And Yu Chengsong's reply: "What are you crazy about?" The casualness of it tells you everything about how normalized this abuse has become in his life.
... Read More
I need to process what I just read and I think the only way to do that is to talk about what this passage is really underneath all the dialogue and drama. On the surface, this is a school-life story with a romantic subplot and a family crisis. But strip all that away and what remains is a story about how grief warps people — and how the survivors are expected to carry it. The dead brother, Yuanyuan, is the ghost in every room. He doesn't appear physically, but he controls everything. His death anniversary is the day the mother decides to threaten suicide. She holds his photo while wielding a knife. She tells Yu Chengsong that if she dies, she'll go "accompany" him — as if dying is the only way to be reunited with the child she mourns, and as if her living son is somehow less worthy of her love because he survived. The knife itself is such a loaded symbol. It's a fruit knife — ordinary, domestic, the kind of thing you'd find in any kitchen. It's not a weapon of war or revenge. It's a tool that became a threat in a home where love and danger occupy the same space. The blood on her arm is visible but the wound "not visible" — which feels like a metaphor for this whole situation. The damage is there, but you can't always see it. And the exam — "I took an exam yesterday. The final exam." — this is Yu Chengsong's explanation for missing the anniversary. Education, achievement, moving forward in life — all of it is framed as betrayal by a mother who wants her living son to grieve in exactly the way she needs him to grieve. The irony is devastating: he was taking an exam, something that should be a cause for pride, and it's being used against him as proof of his neglect. The summer vacation setting is also significant. Summer represents freedom, new beginnings, youth — and right when the characters step into it, the past drags them back. There's no escaping grief just because the seasons change.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or