OK I need to vent about Shi Chengying because this character absolutely wrecked me. Imagine getting first place every single month exam, dominating your grades, being admired by everyone — and then failing the one test that matters most. The college entrance examination. Just...crumbling at the finish line. That's Shi Chengying's tragedy and it's devastating.
Chu Qiyu's internal monologue about Shi Chengying is where the emotional weight really lands. At first, he believed Shi Chengying was just a privileged problem-solver who got lucky. 'Shi Chengtying is just a problem solver, he's also just a problem solver who couldn't bear pressure and ended up squatting at home.' But then the doubt creeps in. 'When Chu Qiyu was reborn, because he had seen Shi Chengying, who was worthless before his rebirth, he especially looked down on Shi Chengying and thought Shi Chengying was a waste.' Wait — what does that mean? That Chu Qiyu remembers a PAST LIFE where he judged Shi Chengying harshly, and now in this rebirth, those old prejudices are resurfacing?
The most heartbreaking detail: Shi Chengying became 'apathetic' after the exam. Not angry, not depressed — just empty. The spark that made him top of his class just...went out. And the worst part is that Shao Shenyang, someone Chu Qiyu initially admired as 'the best one in the grade,' also ends up looking up to Shi Chengying anyway. 'Even if he is a waste, he is also a waste with a high intelligence, so it's normal for him to be able to trap him?' That line about being 'trapped' by someone worthless — it speaks to the gravitational pull Shi Chengying has, even in his broken state.
And then there's Shao Shenyang's perspective, which is its own kind of ache. He stayed at school on weekends not just to study, but because 'Shi Chengying will also stay in school and study with him!' There's this whole unspoken devotion in Shao Shenyang's actions — the anxiety about studying alone, the relief of having Shi Chengying nearby, the belief that 'when he talked or something, he felt that he was in a better mood.' This is the kind of quiet, one-sided emotional dependency that novels do SO well.
I genuinely wondered while reading — is Shi Chengying truly broken, or is he performing brokenness? Is his apathy a shield or a surrender? And what does Chu Qiyu's growing doubt say about his own ability to judge people?