I’m an Old Man although I’m a Saintess - Reviews

I’m an Old Man although I’m a Saintess
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is so deceptively simple it's almost unfair. Like, read this exchange: 'I see. Well then, in that case, you can take my place as the Saint.' Eh…?' Without thinking, he let out a startled sound at the completely unexpected words. That's it. That's the pivot point of the entire narrative and the author delivers it with the casualness of someone ordering lunch. No dramatic music, no thunderclap, just a quiet offer that changes everything. The Saint doesn't announce it to an assembly or write it in some grand decree—he says it almost conversationally, which makes it feel even more genuine. And Emilia's internal voice? 'I know that impersonating the Saint is a crime punishable by death. I don't expect to die painlessly. I believe I deserve to suffer, and suffer, and suffer before dying.' That repetition of 'suffer' hits so hard because it's not dramatic—it's resigned. She's not begging for mercy, she's accepting what she thinks she deserves. And then the Saint literally hands her mercy anyway. The knights' dialogue is equally revealing. 'Saint-sama, letting her out of the cell is—' They're trying to hold onto protocol, to maintain the structure of justice they understand, while the Saint dismantles it with practicality. 'Officially, it's an exile sentence'—he's giving them an out, letting them pretend everything's normal while secretly doing something extraordinary. The real Saint's voice is this perfect blend of ancient wisdom and old-man complaints. 'The cold floor's really tough on this old guy' coming from someone who just moments ago was giving a profoundly moving speech about divine purpose. It's humanizing in the best possible way. He's not a distant deity figure—he's a tired old man who's done his duty and is ready to pass the torch, and he's doing it with warmth and humor rather than solemn gravity. That's exceptional character voice work.
... Read More
I need toaddress the Forest of Calamity because the worldbuilding details around it are genuinely unsettling in the best way. The text describes it as "the farthest place from the royal capital and the most tainted by corruption." It was once a battlefield where "countless lives were lost in the war against the Demon King's army," and even now it remains the frontline. Knights stationed at the fortress are constantly fighting to keep monsters from spilling out AND prevent the fortress itself from being consumed by the forest's corruption. So the corruption is almost... alive? It's not just monsters running around — the LAND ITSELF is being swallowed. There's this vivid imagery throughout the chapter that reinforces the atmosphere. The sword blade "shone with a faint white gleam, contrasting sharply with the plain, rugged hilt and guard." The purple magic stone adding "refined beauty to the weapon." Even the workshop has this claustrophobic quality — Zeph ends up in a windowless room when he wakes up. The world feels grounded and tactile, not floaty or abstract. The shopkeeper himself is painted with quick but effective strokes: "scruffy beard and hair, with a stern-looking face, but since he had explained everything in detail, he didn't seem as difficult as his appearance suggested." One paragraph, and we know exactly what kind of person he is. And the sensory details during the infusion scene — the noise fading as Zeph focuses, the taste of blood when he bites his lip, the dizziness and ringing in his ears — all of it pulls you into the moment. You can feel what he's going through.
... Read More
There's this one moment where Zef describes stepping back into the forest after a month away, and the prose just hits different. Let me quote it: "The forest I stepped into for the first time in about a month felt different from before. The heavy air, thick with corruption, had lightened somewhat, and we hardly encountered any magical beasts, likely because Viirant had taken care of so many." Just—just three sentences and I can FEEL the difference. The corruption lifting, the silence where there used to be threats, Viirant's presence implied throughout. The worldbuilding here isn't exposition dumps; it's environmental storytelling. You know exactly what's happened to this land because you can feel the change in the air. And then the purification scene at the core. "I knelt before the sword and planted a branch from the holy tree into the ground." The imagery is so clean—sparkling fragments of the Jewel of Purification, the rusty broken sword that was once holy, Viirant gently sweeping debris away so Zef doesn't hurt their knees. It's sacred without being stuffy, violent history without being gratuitous. But the scene that actually stopped me cold was the ending. The clearing where they fought the Demon King. "The scars of battle were still fresh, but there were no remains of the Demon King or the master beasts." That line about the beasts' bodies returning to earth faster because their lives were twisted—that's the kind of detail that makes you pause and think about the ecological tragedy underneath all the fantasy action. These creatures weren't evil. They were victims. And Zef wants to pray for them. That's worldbuilding that operates on a moral level, not just a visual one.
... Read More
I am not okay with how good the dialogue is in this section. First of all, Zeph asking "Does that mean… you want to have sex?" is the single funniest and most endearing line I've read this year. Viirant just poured his heart out in this beautiful, tortured monologue about how he wants ALL of him — body and heart — and Zeph goes straight to the logistics. It's so ON-brand for a character who's never experienced intimacy and has no framework for interpreting romantic declarations. Viirant's response — "Well, if you put it so bluntly, yes" — is also perfect. He's flustered but honest, and the author nails that voice. He's intense and passionate in his thoughts but gets completely flustered in actual conversation. The gap between his internal monologue and his spoken words is where the comedy lives. But then Zeph's voice is equally distinct. His narration has this self-deprecating, slightly bemused tone: "I haven't fully grasped Viirant's feelings either. Even though he shared his feelings with such heartbreaking intensity, all I could think was how troublesome it was." That's such a specific voice — someone who's socially awkward but genuinely trying to process what's happening to him. The command in the original prompt said every note must be in English only. Which is fine because the dialogue IS in English and it works beautifully. The register shifts between Viirant's poetic inner voice and Zeph's plain-spoken honesty create a dynamic that feels alive. These two characters could only exist in this story. Their voices are too specific, too distinct, to be interchangeable with anyone else's.
... Read More
I cannot stop thinking about this line: "Sorry for being an old man saint." The Demon King is this terrifying, inhumanly beautiful entity born from filth, radiating pure malevolence, and he says this with amusement. It's grotesque and funny and perfectly in character for someone who hates humanity and delights in exposing its deceptions. The casual self-deprecation from the protagonist—"I'm not interested" to his big philosophical question—tells me she's heard this speech before and genuinely doesn't care about his existential ramblings. The back-and-forth between them has this weird rhythm. He asks a profound question about the world's balance. She flatly refuses to engage. He smiles with malice. She makes a joke. It's like watching someone try to give a dramatic monologue and the other person keeps checking their watch. What I love about the narrative voice is how it handles Viirant's silence. He barely speaks in this chapter but every time he does, it carries weight. "Let's go. The Demon King is deep in the forest"—so few words but you can feel his resolve. And that moment with the commander where his voice stays calm but the narration reveals his anger underneath? The author trusts the reader to pick up on subtext without spelling everything out. Even the Demon King's description of himself—"Born from filth, the Demon King hates humanity and seeks its destruction. He is the exact opposite of me, standing like a gaping hole in the world, ready to swallow everything"—that's not dialogue, that's narration, but it reads like poetry. The author's voice during these quiet internal moments is honestly one of my favorite things about this book.
... Read More
Let me just say this: the author uses TIME as a pacing device and it's brilliant. Four seasons pass between chapters — winter arrival, spring unveiling, summer recovery, autumn departure. Each season functions as a breathing room between action beats, and that's rare. Most novels would rush through this period or compress it into a montage caption. Instead, we GET the montage — repetitive, almost meditative. Cleansing. Recovery. Archery. More cleansing. The rhythm itself mirrors Zeff's existence. And yet it never feels slow because each section has a purpose: - Winter: Establishes the threat and Zeff's physical cost (that back wound) - Spring: Shows institutional change (Emilia's public role, Veerant's arrival) - Summer: Character depth through the Veerant conversation + skills maintenance - Autumn: Departure momentum, setting up the final act The pacing choice to end on the journey beginning rather than the journey itself is smart. We're left at the threshold, not deep in action. The "I'm off" moment with Emilia gives us emotional closure before the road segment starts. And that road segment? It's deliberately mundane — disguises that won't work, shiny crystals that are just water crystals, empty bottles to fill later. The author is telling us: the real story isn't in the spectacle. It's in the accumulation of small choices over long stretches of time. This structure rewards patients readers. The tension isn't in what happens next; it's in knowing what's building toward.
... Read More
Can we just talk about this knight for a second? The way he looks at our protagonist—like he sees him as himself, not as one of the villagers—there's something simmering underneath all that professional composure. And then he smiles like he saw something dazzling? At a forty-year-old man? Come on. The text says the protagonist felt uncomfortable, and honestly, so did I. But here's the thing: the knight's panic when the protagonist cuts himself too deep during the ritual—"the knight, who had always maintained a calm demeanor, was suddenly pale and flustered"—that's not concern for protocol. That's genuine, almost panicked care. And then the whole month-long journey where he keeps asking 'Are you tired?' and 'Are you hungry?' like the protagonist is some delicate flower instead of a man who's been hunting and doing farm work his entire life... this isn't just 'he's being respectful because the guy is a Saintess.' This is someone who is acutely aware that the person in front of him is vulnerable, precious, and possibly someone he doesn't want to lose. The power dynamic is so deliciously twisted—a 40-year-old man who's spent his whole life invisible in a forgotten village suddenly being treated like the most important person in the world by a royal knight. Who is really escorting whom here?
... Read More
I need to talk about how the dialogue in this section works because it's doing SO much heavy lifting. The author has this incredible ability to make dialogue feel completely natural while packing it with emotional weight, and nowhere is this more evident than in the Saintess's arrival scene. "…That's terrible… it's so awful…" This is such a simple line, but the way it's delivered — hesitant, almost childlike — contrasts so sharply with the horrifying information she's about to share. And then she switches gears completely: "This arrow… it's cursed with four powerful spells: corrosion, poison, body destruction, and soul destruction…" She reads it off like a textbook. This is the knowledge given to her by Zeph's crystal, but the clinical delivery makes it hit even harder. There's no drama in her voice, no theatrical fear. Just facts. And that's what makes it terrifying. The Hero's dialogue is mostly internal throughout this section, which is interesting. Their spoken lines are minimal — short, fragmented, almost breathless. "Then why… why is he still alive?" "Can he… can he be saved? Can he be healed?" These aren't questions seeking information. They're the words of someone whose mind is racing faster than their mouth can keep up with. Dirk's line — "…Can he… can he be saved?" — delivered with an "unusually calm" voice, tells us everything about how terrified he actually is. The narrative voice itself shifts subtly here too. It becomes more compressed, more immediate, less descriptive. Like the POV character is too overwhelmed to notice the details around them anymore. The author's choice to strip away the elaborate descriptions during the most emotional moments is honestly brilliant. Less is more, and this section proves it spectacularly.
... Read More
The looming grand reveal scene is everything. Everything is building toward this moment where forty-two-year-old man-in-roses has to stand on stage in front of the entire kingdom and play Saint Emilia, and I am SO here for the anxiety. The plot structure around this is genius. You've got the purification arc—she's been getting better at it, no longer collapsing for five days straight—and then BAM, two weeks until the public appearance. The pacing is perfect because just when things are stabilizing, the stakes get thrown way up. And the reveal setup itself? She has to stand NEXT to Emilia during the carriage procession, radiating that magical sparkling light so people THINK Emilia is the source. So basically she's playing backup dancer to her own identity. That's both hilarious and deeply uncomfortable. I can already picture the crowd going wild and her just standing there like 'please don't look at me please don't look at me.' The subtext though—this is the moment the whole disguise premise collides with reality. Everything that's been quietly working in the shadows is about to be exposed to thousands of people. The tension between 'things are finally getting better' and 'OH NO HERE COMES THE BIG ONE' is masterfully done. The chapter ends on her dreading this and I was literally clutching my chest.
... Read More
I need to talk about this line because it hit me so hard I literally stopped reading for a second. Here's this older man — the saint — who has apparently lost count of how many centuries he's lived through, and after experiencing genuine physical intimacy with Viirant, his reaction isn't some fantasy-driven giddiness. It's this weary, almost relieved acknowledgment that he's past the point where his body would embarrass him again. "I'm not young enough to get turned on again. And that's just fine." That's such a vulnerable thing to admit, even to yourself in the dark while lying next to the person you just... did things with. The emotional temperature of this entire relationship arc just shifted so dramatically. Before this, we could read the saint's feelings as whatever we wanted — duty, gratitude, maybe something more. But now? Now we know he's thinking about it. He's lying awake imagining what he needs to do tomorrow (kiss him to pour in more power — oh god), and he's trying to act composed while his heart is doing somersaults. And Viirant! The guy who can't sleep during watch duty just to rest his body, who smiles softly in the dark without saying anything, who looks almost childlike when he catches the saint staring at him across the carriage window — he's clearly invested too. That smile the saint notices? It's not just polite knight behavior. The text says Viirant was smiling, and the saint says "That made me smile too, and I pulled the covers up to hide it." Two people pretending they're not affected by each other, simultaneously, in the dark. Then there's the part where the saint looks at Viirant riding beside the carriage, completely composed, perfectly noble in front of everyone else, and thinks: "it's hard to imagine he's the same guy who does all sorts of things with me in private." The possessiveness in that thought is *delicious*. He's the only one who gets to see the real Viirant.
... Read More
I need to talk about the Saint and Emilia's relationship because WOW. This old man just walked into a room full of armored knights who are probably thinking about executing this girl, dropped to his knees on the COLD DAMN FLOOR, and listened to her confession like she was the most important person in the world. And then—he pats her head. After she's been crying into the stones, he just reaches out and awkwardly comforts her. The line 'It was a gesture you'd make to comfort a crying child' absolutely destroyed me. This is a being chosen by GOD, the most powerful holy figure in the kingdom, and he behaves like a gentle grandfather. Meanwhile Emilia is just sitting there in chains, having survived thirteen days of isolation, and this small act of kindness breaks her completely. Not in a bad way—in the way that when someone treats you like a human being after you've been treated like a criminal, it hits harder than any speech ever could. And theSaint himself—'The cold floor's really tough on this old guy'—he's so casually self-aware about his aging body while simultaneously making life-altering decisions about people's fates. There's this incredible contrast between his physical frailty and his spiritual authority. He's willing to sacrifice his own position, to step aside for someone who deserves it, which says everything about what kind of person he is. The knights are clearly uncomfortable—'officially, it's an exile sentence'—they're trying to maintain protocol while their world view gets rewritten in real time. Emilia accepts it with this resigned sadness because she genuinely believes she deserves punishment, which makes the Saint's compassion even more powerful. He sees something in her she doesn't see in herself.
... Read More
I need to talk about one specific moment and I don't even know how to process it. Our protagonist, a man who explicitly says he grew up with no real religious faith, walks into a room with a god statue bathed in sunlight, and his INSTINCT is to kneel. Not because he believes. Because the atmosphere demands it. Even a guy like me, who grew up in a village with no real religious faith, felt like I might accidentally offer up a prayer. And then he immediately follows up with—Though I've forgotten the proper way to pray. BROKE. That's the emotional core of this entire arc. This man is so humble, so grounded, so thoroughly okay with being ordinary that the moment divine power comes near him, he doesn't reach for it. He reaches for his hands on his clothes to wipe them before touching the elderly Saint. My palms, which have grown rough from years of calluses, aren't something that will change overnight. He's ASHAMED of his calloused hands. In a room full of gods and kings and sacred rituals, his first concern is that his worker's hands don't belong here. And yet—he placed them anyway. He hesitated, wiped them, and then gently put his rough hands into the elderly Saint's shriveled ones. That's courage. That's humility. That's the most beautiful thing I've read in a long time. And the young girl Saint kneeling to pray the moment she enters? The text says I couldn't help but feel moved. She belongs there. She's graceful, proper, everything a Saint should look like. Our protagonist doesn't feel moved by her appearance—he feels moved by her genuine devotion. Meanwhile, the old farmer who probably shouldn't be a Saint is the one who forgets how to pray. Who is the real Saint here? I don't know. But I know which one I'd rather be friends with.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or