If One Covets That Which Shines - Reviews

If One Covets That Which Shines
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There is a scene where a woman gives Cordelia a mulberry pie and tells her to share it with her husband, and Cordelia's internal reaction is basically a short-circuit. She says yes, but the second that woman leaves, she wipes the smile off her face and rubs her forehead. Luna watches. Cordelia knows exactly what Luna thinks. And she doesn't care. This woman—this kind, baked-goods-offering villager—has no idea she just handed Cordelia a mirror. Share it with your husband. Share it. Like they are a real couple. Like they share things. Like they are allowed to. And then the SCARS scene. Cordelia sees Ian's bare torso—every scar, every mark of a violent life—and her first reaction isn't disgust. It's shock. And then she approaches him. Slowly. Offers him bread. Then the pie. And Ian, in a moment that made me want to scream, interprets this as PITY. "Because they feel sorry for me." HE THINKS SHE PITIES HIM. After that entire sequence where she saw his body and didn't recoil, didn't mock him, didn't call for guards—she offered him FOOD. And his brain translates it as: she's being kind because she feels bad for me. Meanwhile, Cordelia is sitting there absolutely FUMING but she can't even identify the emotion. She's annoyed but WHY? Did he do something wrong? She can't parse it. And Ian is genuinely confused why she's upset. They are TWO PEOPLE SO CLOSE THEY COULD TOUCH but completely on parallel emotional planes that never intersect. She's frustrated because she cares and hates that she cares. He's broken because he genuinely believes the worst possible interpretation of every kind act. The CP chemistry here isn't in grand declarations. It's in the silence between them. The moment on the beach where he touches her hair and immediately apologizes like he's committed a crime. The way she walks faster than usual afterward—not angry at him, but fleeing from the intimacy of the moment. The footprints being washed away by the sea, leaving nothing behind. I'm not crying, you're crying.
... Read More
Okay so this whole sequence is basically one long plot device—the house being inspected as a metaphor for the marriage being examined. But it works because the author doesn't tell us that; they show us through Cordelia's actual behavior. She starts off rigid, defensive, cold toward Ian. Then she sees the floor plans, and suddenly she's imagining bookshelves, music rooms, tearing out doors. The plot pivots right there—we realize she's not just looking at a building, she's running through what her life could look like if it were restored. And the twist isn't a shock; it's a slow reveal. We keep getting little moments where her composure cracks. Like when she says “Am I allowed to do that?” and her voice goes all sharp, like she's bristling at him for suggesting she take charge. But then later, at the market, she's smiling at the shop owner, saying “My husband” smoothly, playing the role perfectly—and Ian's the one who flinches. That's the real plot movement. It's not two people falling in love; it's two people realizing they've been misreading each other the whole time. The coup backstory is dropped in casually, not dramatically. We learn Michael's rebellion was dressed up as an abdication, and everyone sees Cordelia as lucky to have married the pirate-slaying hero. But the reader knows better—we've seen her alone, in her room, pressing her fingers to her temples because of headaches since the coup. That subplot about her grief and resentment is carried entirely through physical detail, not exposition. By the end, when she's staring at the spot where he left and letting out a quiet involuntary laugh, saying “What on earth… strange man,” we realize the plot has been building toward her seeing him differently. Not as the lowborn husband she was forced to marry, but as someone capable of warmth, ease, genuine connection—with others, sure, but maybe also with her, if she'd let him in. That's solid plot architecture. No melodrama, just steady, patient unraveling.
... Read More
Okay so this entire sequence goes from brutal to… almost tender? And that shift is what makes it stick in my head. Let me walk through why this plot beat absolutely wrecked me. Everything leading up to the wedding night scene is pure pressure valve release denied. Cordelia's father explodes, Ian takes a punch meant to send a message, the former king is silenced with cold threats about never seeing his daughter again. Then the wedding happens like a speed-run tragedy—no banquet, no guests, just three people in a chapel and white cloth tied around wrists like shackles. The reader has been holding their breath this whole time. And then Ian says: "You don't have to sleep with me tonight." I actually gasped. Not because it's romantic in some cheesy way, but because after EVERYTHING—after the violence, the political maneuvering, the brother's cruel smirk telling them to "make sure the wedding night is properly seen to"—Ian offers her an out. He's playing a dangerous game here. Michael explicitly wants him to take her. Ian is choosing to interpret that command loosely, and he knows it. What's brilliant about the plot structure is that this moment doesn't resolve the tension—it reframes it. We thought the conflict was "will she be assaulted?" Now the question becomes "why would a man in his position risk his king's wrath like this?" The stakes shifted from physical danger to something far more complicated. "It's true that I'm a filthy wretch and lowborn" — and then he trails off. That unfinished sentence is the most powerful thing in the entire chapter. He's about to explain himself and stops. The narrative refuses to give us easy answers, and that restraint is so much more effective than any monologue could be. The subplot with Michael is equally well-woven. His threat disguised as courtesy, the way he watches Ian carry Cordelia out with an unreadable expression—every interaction between these three characters carries layers. The former king's rage, Michael's cold calculation, Ian's quiet defiance. Three men, three approaches to power, all orbiting this girl who wants none of it. I re-read the ending three times. The author could have had Ian deliver a neat speech about honor or duty or whatever, but instead he cuts himself off mid-thought. That's not sloppy writing—that's the kind of choice that makes a scene unforgettable. The plot doesn't wrap things up; it opens a door we weren't expecting, and now we're desperate to see what's on the other side.
... Read More
This passage has some of the most vivid sensory writing I've read in a while, and it's not even trying to be pretty. The house is described almost clinically—mold-stained carpets, rotted damp wallpaper, floors in decent shape despite everything. But those details aren't just set dressing; they're doing thematic work. The building looks like a disaster at first glance, but the pillars stand firm, the foundation holds. That image stays with me. Then there's the market scene, which is so alive I can practically hear the noise. Cordelia's flustered by the crowd—she's used to quiet solitude, to the palace, to being surrounded by people who know their place. Here she is in a packed village market, plain gray dress, headscarf hiding her golden hair, trying to play ordinary. And Ian's right beside her, no uniform, no armor, just dressed like a laborer, leaning close to talk to her over the clamor. The shop owner scene is perfect worldbuilding too—he jokes, calls Ian “my lord,” offers a discount, and Ian refuses, saying it would be a poor start to his lordship to fleece locals. That moment tells us everything about who Ian is without a single line of internal monologue. He's not performative about his power. He doesn't want bribes or special treatment. He wants to do right by the people who live here. And Cordelia overhears all of it, watching him laugh and joke, soft and easy, and she's stunned. Because this is the same man who treats her like ice. The contrast between how he is with strangers versus how he is with her—that gap is where the scene does its real work. The sea breeze, the salty tang, the way the water glittered blue beneath the midday sun—all those details ground us in place. This isn't a generic estate; it's Delfrin, a real village with real merchants who've lived here for generations. You can feel the salt on your skin, hear the haggling, smell the stale air inside the house before they step out into the fresh breeze. The world feels inhabited, not constructed.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or