I Was Mistaken, But Please Hold Me - Reviews

I Was Mistaken, But Please Hold Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to process what just happened on that balcony because honestly I was sobbing. Liane sitting there all alone while people gossip about her behind her back—'Perhaps she's having a secret rendezvous somewhere secluded with one of the men'—and she just takes it. She doesn't even fight back, she just lowers her head and feels guilty FOR HER FAMILY'S NAME. I literally shouted at my phone. And then Oscar shows up DRUNK and blocks her path and I was so mad I thought I was going to explode. Who does this to a girl?? 'Playing dumb... honestly... Is it true you only deal with marquises and above?' BRO. She's just trying to survive this event. Meanwhile Tristan is in there with Adel being all charming and Liane has no idea what's happening. The contrast was KILLING me.
... Read More
Okay so the opening scene hit me like a truck. I was reading along and Liane is sneaking into some guy's bedroom, he's feverish, she climbs into bed with him—totally convinced this is some kind of intentional setup—and then!! BLINK! She wakes up in her own bed and it was a DREAM. My jaw literally dropped. But here's the thing: the author then IMMEDIATELY undercuts that relief by having her overhear maids talking about a poison attempt on the duke. Like, the dream might have been prophetic? Or maybe her subconscious is picking up on something she doesn't consciously know yet? Either way, I am SO confused and I love it. And then the double-reveal about the hair color—she thinks she was with a black-haired man, but Lucille says the Duke is blonde. Wait, so WHICH man did she actually sleep with? Was the dream real or not? Is she losing track of reality because of stress? The plot is weaving multiple threads together here: the poisoning attempt, Arman's creepy escalation, the mysterious night encounter, and Liane's desperate plan to flee. I can't tell what's real and what's not, and that uncertainty is making me NEED to keep reading. Also the fact that she already sent a letter to her mother's old nursemaid and got no reply—that's such a small detail but it creates this ticking clock. She's running out of options.
... Read More
The stakes in this story escalated so fast I kept forgetting to breathe. Let me list what Liane is up against: her father is DEAD, her stepmother is arranging marriages she doesn't want, her stepbrother ARMAN is trying to sexually assault her and is explicitly threatening to ruin her reputation if she resists ('Who would be in more trouble if you screamed, you or me?'), someone tried to POISON the Duke, and she might have accidentally slept with the wrong person on the worst possible night. And she's considering FAKING HER OWN DISAPPEARANCE to escape all of it. That is not a small decision. If she leaves and gets caught, she's dead. If she stays, Arman will get his way. If she goes to the nursemaid and nobody's there, she's stranded with no money and no protection. There's literally no safe option—only dangerous ones with different risk profiles. What makes me genuinely worried isn't just the immediate threats though, it's the information gap. Liane doesn't know who poisoned the Duke. She doesn't know if the man she spent the night with is the Duke or someone else. She doesn't know if the nursemaid is even alive. The author has built this web of uncertainty where every character is potentially an ally or a threat, and Liane is navigating it completely alone. The scene where Arman says 'I can keep you by my side as my plaything' after threatening her reputation—that's the kind of line that makes your blood boil. He's not just violent, he's CALCULATING. He's thought about this. He's planned how to own her. And that's what terrifies me most about this story.
... Read More
Let me just say—the author's pacing choices in this chapter are INSANE. We open with Tristan finding Liane's name on a list, smiling at it, putting her pledge and the hair ornament together like a little treasure. THEN we cut to the banquet with a full hour already gone and she's NOT THERE. The tension of 'where is she?' followed immediately by the reveal of Emilio carrying her in a pale emerald dress—that's such a sharp tonal shift from cold calculation to warm rescue. Then the Camilla scene where Adel deliberately provokes Liane? Peak middle-act energy. The author keeps the stakes climbing: first social danger (gossip), then physical danger (Baron Montfort scandal), then emotional danger (trapped in Tristan's study with his fiancée walking in), then existential danger (overhearing her reputation destroyed). By the time Oscar shows up drunk on the balcony, I was like 'this girl cannot catch a break and I am HERE for it.' The chapter structure is basically a Rube Goldberg machine of escalating discomfort and every single scene pushes Liane further into a corner. And that last line—'You won't even give me a'—the cliffhanger mid-sentence?? I literally threw my phone on the bed.
... Read More
The pacing in these opening chapters is absolutely ruthless and I mean that in the best way possible. Chapter 1 opens with what seems like a sensual romance scene, you're thinking 'okay this is a romantic fantasy,' then BAM—the dream reveal, and within the same scene the poisoning subplot drops. No breather. No 'and so the next morning...' Just straight into danger. Then it cuts to Arman. Liane's stepping into her study for a quiet moment and suddenly she's being cornered by her stepbrother who's lost all control. The scene escalates FAST—from unwanted touching to torn buttons to blood on his forehead—and then Lucille saves the day. But instead of letting us exhale, the chapter ends with Liane saying she needs to LEAVE, that she can't stay, and we're left hanging on her plan to run away to some unknown address with no guarantee anyone will be there. What I love about the pacing is that every scene has a turn. Nothing sits still. The night scene → the poison revelation → the hair color mystery → Arman's assault → the decision to flee. Seven chapters and we've gone from 'maybe a romance' to 'she might need to fake her own disappearance to survive.' The author knows exactly how to stack threats on top of each other so the reader never feels safe. I stayed up way too late reading this.
... Read More
The stakes in this section are what kept me turning pages at 2 AM, no joke. On the surface it's a love triangle, but that's way too simple. This is about survival, autonomy, and the terrifying intimacy of abuse. Arman's conflict with Liane isn't external — it's internalized control masquerading as passion. He's not fighting anyone for her affection; he's fighting her independence. Every demand, every physical escalation, every manipulation ('You seem to know very well how to make me angry') is designed to make her complicit in her own captivity. The stakes for Liane aren't abstract — they're literal. Her body is the battlefield. The bruised wrist, the fear in her eyes, the way she shrinks into herself — these aren't romantic tropes, they're evidence. But then Emilio enters and the stakes shift again. Now there's an external threat to Arman's control, but it's not the kind of rescue Liane necessarily wants. Emilio says he'll escort her to the banquet, that he's aware of her injury, that he met with her doctor. He's positioning himself as protector, but he's also asserting his own claim. And the stakes for Emilio are different — he's a man who deals in shadows and secrets, and yet here he is, unsettled by something he can't quantify. The gambling salon flashback establishes that he operates in a world of violence, but Liane's vulnerability terrifies him in a way that business conflicts never have. The highest tension moment for me was when Emilio says 'I said I'm aware that Lady Liane Aspel was injured' and Arman's mouth falls open. That's the moment the secret becomes public between them. Arman knows Emilio knows. Emilio knows Arman knows he knows. And neither of them can un-say it. The power balance has shifted irrevocably. I'm also worried about Liane. She's playing a dangerous game — accepting Emilio's help while staying in Arman's house. The handkerchief exchange felt like a promise, but promises between these three people have catastrophic history behind them. What happens when Arman finds out she gave it to him? What happens when Emilio decides that waiting isn't enough anymore?
... Read More
I need to talk about this one scene because the author completely killed it. When Liane walks into the greenhouse garden, the imagery just... stops you in your tracks. Large exotic trees, plants everywhere, and Tristan is at the CENTER of it all, leaning back in a chair at a white table with his fingers laced together, watching her enter. This reads like a painting. A portrait of power — he owns the space, he owns the silence, she has to walk through the garden to reach him like she's entering his domain. And earlier, the encounter on the path — there's something so cinematic about how the sunlight filters through leaves and casts painterly light and shadow across Tristan's face. 'Beneath dark black hair, pale skin untouched by the sun.' You could FRAME this description. The wide-brimmed white hat Liane wears becomes this shield, this barrier she's desperately clinging to, and when the wind catches her handkerchief and it lands on his boot — that moment is pure choreography. Everything lines up. The contrast between scenes is what makes this world feel alive. You have the crowded, noisy riding competition grounds that Liane is actively avoiding, then the quiet forest path, then the overwhelming green glass cathedral of the greenhouse, then back out to the wooded trail where Arman ambushes her. Each location has its own temperature, its own mood. The Hartfield estate itself functions as this strange neutral ground — not her home, not his territory, but somewhere in between where both men (Emilio and Tristan) exert different kinds of protection and control over her. When Emilio drapes his jacket over Liane's torn shoulder, there's this domestic tenderness that comes out of nowhere and completely disarms you. Silver hair, quiet concern, the way he checks if she's crying. The estate becomes this sanctuary from Arman, but also a cage — she can't stay forever, and tomorrow she has to go to the Granville ducal estate, the place where Tristan waits. Every location in this book is doing double duty as both setting and emotional state.
... Read More
This is the kind of pacing that makes me want to underline entire pages. The chapter opens with three men at a banquet discussing rumors—and it's easy to see why some readers might find that opening a bit slow, but trust me, it's essential groundwork. Cedric, Damien, and Tristan are having what seems like casual conversation, but every line is loading information. When Tristan asks about Lady Aspel, his reaction to the word 'stepsister' is almost imperceptible—he just stops swirling his wine glass. That's the author saying 'pay attention here.' We don't get exposition about Tristan's feelings for Liane; we get this tiny physical beat. Then the structure pivots sharply. We shift from the banquet hall to Liane boarding the carriage, and suddenly the prose becomes claustrophobic. Her fear, the shortness of breath, the way she can't stop thinking about Tristan's blue eyes. This section is shorter, more compressed, which mirrors her anxiety. Good pacing isn't just about fast versus slow—it's about matching the rhythm to the emotional state. The meeting between Tristan and Liane is structured like a dance. They circle each other, test the water, retreat. She offers the pledge. He examines it but sets it aside. She tries to leave. He stops her with that invitation to the banquet. The scene has this incredible push-pull rhythm that keeps me engaged even though very little 'happens' on the surface. And then—Emilio's arrival to escort her. Another structural shift. We get his internal monologue, his skepticism, his grudging concern. The carriage ride with Liane is quieter, almost domestic, which contrasts beautifully with the tension of the previous scene. The final descent down the staircase is where the pacing accelerates almost imperceptibly. Tristan moves toward them. Nobles part like the Red Sea. The prose gets tighter, sentences shorten. By the time he speaks to Liane, the reader is already holding their breath. That's masterful structural control—the author builds momentum without ever breaking into action or dialogue-heavy drama. What I particularly appreciated: the author knows when to let silence do the work. The long pauses, the unspoken thoughts, the way Liane's knuckles go white clasping her hands—these moments of stillness are where the real narrative weight lives. Some authors would fill every gap with exposition or internal monologue. This one trusts the reader to sit with the tension.
... Read More
I want to start by saying something really simple: the stakes in this book are so high that I genuinely forget these are fictional characters. Liane isn't facing a dragon or a curse. She's facing something far more terrifying — a life where every available door leads to ruin, and she has to choose which door to open. Her father is arranging a marriage to a baron old enough to be his father. Arman wants to defile her before that even happens. Her only plan involves drugging a man she's never met and hoping he takes her in. This isn't a romantic comedy setup — this is survival, and the author never lets you forget it. "If she returned to the count's estate, marriage to the baron would be unavoidable. Or she would be defiled by Arman before that even happened. It was one or the other." That sentence is the entire thesis of Liane's conflict. One or the other. No third option. No happy ending handed to her. And yet she still tries. She still makes a plan with Lucille. She still shows agency in a world that keeps trying to strip it away. Tristan's conflict is different but equally intense. He's being poisoned (or so he thinks), his estate's security is compromised, and this woman who may or may not be part of a scheme just saw him at his most vulnerable — literally and figuratively — and vanished. Is it love? Is it a plot? Is it something else entirely? The author refuses to give us easy answers, and that uncertainty is what makes the tension so relentless. And Lucille — of course Lucille is the one holding everything together while Liane falls apart. She takes a job as a maid, she prepares love potions, she drags her mistress through the night, she buys bread with her wages. But then, right when you think she's safe, men in dark robes block her path on the street. The stakes just escalated again and I am not prepared for what comes next.
... Read More
Can we appreciate how DELICIOUSLY rotten Adel's dialogue is in this chapter? 'I very much like the dress you're wearing today, my lady. The design is so fashionable and refined.' SWEET. POISONOUS. And then immediately pivots to 'From Lord Emilio, who accompanied you today?' like she's just making casual conversation. This woman is a SNAKE and she KNOWS it. The way she weaponizes politeness is exactly what makes her terrifying—I kept waiting for her to smile wider and somehow it got more threatening with every line. Then Liane's response style! She's all 'Oh yes thank you' and 'Yes' and 'Pardon? No it's nothing like that'—her dialogue is this fragile, flustered thing that makes her feel so real. She's not giving anyone ammunition but she's also not fighting back. Meanwhile Tristan's dialogue in the study is this completely different register: 'My lady, is there something you need to hide from in my estate, where you are a guest of mine?' He's all controlled, low, deliberate. And the moment Adel walks in and says 'What brings you here, Lady Aspel?' with that forced smile—THE DIALOGUE SHIFTS so sharply between these three people that you can TASTE the power dynamics. Oscar at the end? 'Playing dumb... honestly...'—his voice is so careless and entitled it made my skin crawl. Every character speaks differently and it's not just accent or vocabulary, it's worldview.
... Read More
I need to talk about the coin scene because I have not recovered. Liane drops a coin, takes a few hurried steps after it, and looks up into Emilio's face. He picks it up from the toe of his shoe, opens her hand, and sets it back in her palm. Then he takes her hand AGAIN to check if her wrist is healed. FOURTEEN CHAPTERS into this and I am still shook by how casually romantic that entire exchange is. She's blushing. He's smiling with just the corners of his mouth. And Lucille is right there watching like 'what IS this atmosphere?!' But here's what really gets me—the way Liane tells Emilio she's going to a country villa with no fixed return date, asking him to keep it secret. She's trusting him with something vulnerable. She says 'I was worried that if I couldn't reply to any letters you sent, you might worry like before'—and THAT is a relationship that exists outside of anything happening right now in the present moment. There's history there. There's care there. And then there's Liane's internal monologue about avoiding Tristan: 'how wonderful it would be if that night could truly be as though it never happened.' That night. The moonlit bed. The blue eyes. She's not just embarrassed—she's carrying something real, something that changes the geometry of how she moves through every social space. Every time their eyes meet across a banquet hall, it's not just awkwardness. It's the weight of something that happened that she can't pretend away, even though she wants to. The most devastating moment for me though is Arman's scene. 'D*mn it, where did she go!' slamming his fist, drinking water like he's trying to swallow something down, the sand slipping through clenched fists metaphor. This is a man who views Liane as property, and even his 'helplessness' at losing her is possessive, not protective. It makes every tender moment between Liane and the other men feel so much more significant by contrast.
... Read More
There's something so delicious about the way this story is structured—Liane keeps running, and somehow every man in this story finds a different path to her. The hide-and-seek metaphor Tristan comes up with is literally the spine of this whole arc. Let me tell you, the reveal about Pastia had me sitting up straight. Tristan, who I thought was just politely discussing wine estates with his soon-to-be fiancée, casually notes that Pastia borders the Aspel estate, and THEN his carriage rolls past a tree-lined path and he spots Lucille's back disappearing behind a building. One minute he's playing the perfect gentleman at Adel's request, the next he's quietly dismantling the mystery all on his own. And not only that—he already hired investigators before and still couldn't find her. The fact that he stumbles onto the answer by sheer proximity to Adel's wine project? That's some elegant plotting right there. What really got me is the parallel with Arman. His whole scene in this batch—slamming his fist, drinking water in gulps, the helpless sand-through-fingers feeling—is such a clear contrast to Tristan's methodical approach. Both are searching for Liane, but one is consuming and the other is... well, we're starting to see what the other is. The layering of three separate search trajectories (Arman's rage, Emilio's gentle concern, Tristan's quiet determination) all circling the same missing woman is the kind of plot construction that makes you want to re-read chapters just to track who knows what. The detail about Liane not even using the count's carriage makes me appreciate how thorough she is. Three weeks without a trace, and yet Tristan's own observation that she has a "peculiar habit" of picking someone and hiding from them—that's the kind of narrative voice that tells us Tristan has been paying attention in ways he probably hasn't admitted to himself. Also, Adel practically handing Tristan the map to Liane's location while talking about "husband" and wine estates is either the most oblivious maneuver in fiction or the most brilliantly ironic. Either way, I love it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or