Okay so the sack scene. The SACK SCENE. I am still not over this. Eclise literally drags a squirming, wet, red-stained sack in front of Rodi — who is now, what, eight? Nine? — and asks her to decide whether the old orphanage director gets fed to dogs or fish. This is either the most unsettling thing I have ever read or the most genius plot move in the history of this novel, and I genuinely cannot decide which.
What makes it work is the pacing. The author doesn't rush us into the horror. We see the sack first — squirming, making sounds like "rough breathing or groans of pain," tiny pleas for help." The prose stays clinical, almost detached, the way Rodi herself stays eerily still. And then the reveal hits: this is the director. The same director who hoarded food, who stole adoption money, who told teachers to boil scraps in water. Rodi remembers all of this — the author carefully plants those memories right before Eclise asks his question — and she answers without hesitation: "Do the most painful one." Because the director should hurt as much as they made the children hurt.
The brilliance here is that Rodi isn't traumatized. She's not crying or shaking. She's calm, resolved, almost relieved. And that somehow makes it worse — and better — than if she had broken down. The author trusts us to sit with that discomfort instead of offering a clean emotional exit.
Then, because this story clearly can't let us stay in the dark, the next scene is Rodi proudly reading her Imperial language practice to Eclise, calling him "Boss Boss," completely unbothered. The tonal whiplash is incredible. It's like the narrative is saying: yes, evil exists, yes, a child witnessed something brutal, but life goes on, and this child will be fine because the people around her are weirdly, dangerously competent at keeping her safe.