His White Moonlight Turned Out to be Me - Reviews

His White Moonlight Turned Out to be Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is doing something I didn't expect—it's creating this massive gap between what characters are saying and what they actually mean. Almost every conversation is happening on two levels at once. Take Zheng Xue and Xu Yu's exchange about Su Yuanjiu. Zheng Xue is completely gung-ho, excited about the viral video, joking about Kapow network ship culture, asking whether Xu Yu likes him. He's performing friendliness, performing casual interest. But Xu Yu's responses are minimal—humming, short answers, looking away. The reader knows WHY (Xu Yu literally cannot look at himself in mirrors anymore), but Zheng Xue has no idea. That dramatic irony is killing me. Then there's Yun Jie, who actually sees through things. "What's going on? This isn't like you." That line—so simple, so direct—comes right after Xu Yu gives her the most dishonest answer in the book. She doesn't push. She lets it go. But she notices. And that's what makes her character so valuable in this story. The bar invitation scene is also incredible because of what's NOT said. Zheng Xue suggests Xu Yu sing another song for his customers. Xu Yu says sure. But we know Xu Yu has been struggling with his voice, with his ability to perform, and this casual suggestion lands with such weight because we understand the subtext: you can still do this, you can still be normal, or at least pretend to be. Even the briefest exchanges carry enormous emotional weight. 'Did you have to pay a penalty?' 'Some, I borrowed money from my brother.' That's it. That's a whole backstory in four sentences.
... Read More
The pacing here is masterful. Remember how the previous chapters built tension with that mysterious encounter at the banquet? This chapter pays it off in the most casual way possible. Su Yuanjiu calls. He's direct. Professional. Gives Xu Yu his number. Then hangs up. That's it. No dramatic confession, no 'we need to talk,' no cliffhanger dialogue. Just... business. But the real payoff comes in the aftermath. Yun Jie SCREAMS after he hangs up. Xu Yu notices she's holding her breath. The contrast between Su Yuanjiu's controlled professionalism and Yun Jie's complete meltdown is comedically perfect. Then the chapter shifts gears entirely—we go from post-banquet excitement to serious business planning. Studio location, work schedules, song preparations. Nearly two hours of discussing logistics. It's almost tedious, which is actually brilliant pacing. The author is showing us that life goes on. Contracts get terminated, managers get excited, but eventually you have to figure out where to rent office space. Then BAM—the XYY/JSS revelation hits right when we think we're settling into routine. And the chapter ends with Xu Yu alone in his bedroom, scrolling through Weibo, discovering Su Yuanjiu's fanbase is ninety percent male celebrities. That's a hook that demands the next chapter.
... Read More
I need to talk about this moment where Xu Yu is sitting alone in the corridor while everyone else is partying inside. Like, literally everyone. Three girls are hiding at the end of the hallway taking photos of him, and the second they catch his eye they pretend to look elsewhere. Do you know what hurts? That he doesn't even react to it anymore. He just turns back to his drink. This man has been reduced to someone who can't even be bothered by fans—or whatever those girls were. The loneliness here is suffocating. He's 21 years old, about to turn 22, and he's staring at a drone flying back and forth for no reason because his own life feels equally pointless. The color of the city lights reflected in his eyelashes should be romantic, right? But it's not. It's just background noise to his depression. And the fact that the only real human connection we see is with his assistant Sister Yun on the phone—she's the one helping him fight for his freedom. No friends at the party, no family, no romantic interest (yet??). Just him and a woman on a headset trying to untangle him from a bad contract. The Zhou Jie rumor is particularly painful because it's not just about his career. It's about his body and his choices being used as marketing tools without his consent. "He was not the only one who visited Zhou Jie's home" — this line hit me hard. He didn't even go there that day but they're still painting him as someone who belongs in that narrative. I really hope this story gives him the happiness he deserves.
... Read More
Okay so I have to talk about this absolutely delicious little secret subplot that ran underneath the entire chapter. Xu Yu literally cannot figure out why his song comments exploded overnight. He checks with Zheng Xue, he checks with Yun Jie, he even checks himself — and the reader just sits there dying because we KNOW. Su Yuanjiu is the one. He sent people. He organized it. And Xu Yu is over there genuinely impressed that the song is just... popular on its own merits. The dramatic irony is immaculate. It's such a perfect example of how this story does its plotting — never showing the obvious answer directly, letting the audience ride on knowledge the protagonist doesn't have. That moment when Xu Yu sends the WeChat asking Zheng Xue and Zheng Xue denies it, and Xu Yu doesn't even consider checking Su Yuanjiu because apparently that's not even a thought that crosses his mind? Chef's kiss. The author is playing 4D chess here and I am here for it.
... Read More
There is a scene in Chapter 64 that I cannot stop thinking about. Xu Yu is at Su Yuanjiu's office, late at night, and the author describes the city outside the window in this devastatingly simple way. The skyline is all scattered lights, like someone spilled stars across black paper, and Su Yuanjiu is sitting at his desk still working, still pretending the evening is just another evening. The atmosphere in that room is so thick you could cut it with a knife. I want to talk about how the author builds worlds not through exposition but through sensory accumulation. This office has been established over dozens of chapters, and yet in this moment it feels completely new because we are seeing it through Xu Yu's eyes at a time when his relationship to Su Yuanjiu has shifted fundamentally. The lighting is important, low and warm, casting long shadows, making everything feel slightly unreal, slightly dreamlike. There is a desk lamp that illuminates only part of Su Yuanjiu's face, and the other half stays in darkness, which feels almost symbolic but the author never leans into it heavy-handedly. The sound of the city outside is muffled, distant, creating a bubble where only these two exist. Even the temperature matters, the way the air conditioning hums quietly, making the silence between them more pronounced. And then there are small details like the half-empty coffee cup, the papers stacked neatly but obviously worked through recently, the jacket draped over the back of the chair, all of these mundane objects become charged with meaning because of who is in the room with them. The bathroom scene later is equally atmospheric, and I will not spoil it but the author uses mirrors and reflections in a way that made me notice my own reflection in the dark screen of my phone while reading it. This is environmental storytelling at its finest.
... Read More
I need to talk about this children's song because I refuse to believe it's just a random request. "The Snail and the Oriole" - let me translate the deeper meaning here, because this song is doing SO MUCH WORK in this scene. A snail climbing slowly, methodically, carrying its entire home on its back. An oriole, bright and fast and free, singing from branches high above. And the lyric: "Once I climb up, it will be ripe~" What is ripe? What fruit? What happens after the climb? The song is about patience, about the relationship between the slow and the fast, about reaching something that hasn't yet been ready. And Xu Yu is singing this to Su Yuanjiu, who is watching him with this hungry, confused intensity, trying to remember something he can't quite grasp. The mole under Xu Yu's earlobe is another symbol I can't shake. It's small, almost invisible, but it's the one detail Su Yuanjiu latches onto. In a sea of blurry memories, this tiny dark spot becomes his anchor. It represents how memory works - not in grand gestures or dramatic moments, but in fragments. A mole. A sound. A feeling of warmth. These are the pieces we hold onto when everything else fades. Then there's the Lego set. Xu Yu built it. He took individual pieces and created something whole, something satisfying. But he hasn't put it away. It sits on the coffee table, existing in this liminal space between completion and abandonment. Is this Xu Yu himself? Built but not yet stored? Finished but not yet claimed? And the guitar - leaning against the sofa, ready to be picked up. An instrument of expression that sits in silence until someone needs to say what words cannot. Xu Yu picks it up casually, as if music is as natural to him as breathing, and pours everything he can't say into those children's song lyrics. The wound itself is symbolic, obviously. Something that happened in the past that still hurts when you move a certain way. Xu Yu avoiding exercises that strain it. Walking carefully. Living with damage that's healing but never fully gone. And Su Yuanjiu bringing medicine - not fixing it, just helping it heal, staying nearby while it does its work. Everything in this chapter is about things in progress. Climbing. Healing. Remembering. Recording. Building. The fruit isn't ripe yet. The memory isn't whole. The relationship isn't named. But everything is moving toward ripeness, toward wholeness, toward something that can finally be claimed.
... Read More
Okay so this whole chapter is just dripping with unspoken tension between Xu Yu and Su Yuanjiu, and I am HERE for it. Let me start with the most devastating detail in this entire scene: Su Yuanjiu noticing the mole beneath Xu Yu's earlobe. This isn't just a casual observation - it's the key that unlocks something buried deep inside him. The text literally says "The memory was so distant that Su Yuanjiu struggled to merge the two fragments together." FRAGMENTS. Plural. This man is trying to reconstruct a记忆 from his past and Xu Yu's face is the missing piece he can barely hold onto. And then there's the whole "Mr. Su" thing. Su Yuanjiu making Xu Yu say it three times? That's not just about titles, friends. That's power dynamics, that's intimacy disguised as formality, that's someone who wants to hear Xu Yu acknowledge their connection while keeping it contained within safe boundaries. "Got used to it?" "Will there be a next time?" These aren't casual questions - they're tests. Su Yuanjiu is mapping out the terrain of this relationship and he's doing it with this terrifying patience. Xu Yu on the other hand... he's so oblivious but also so perceptive in the weirdest ways. He notices Su Yuanjiu watching him. He notices the redness of his ears. He offers water without knowing what else to do as a host. And then he sings. Just completely trusting, completely vulnerable, strumming a guitar and singing a children's song while Su Yuanjiu records every second of it like he's capturing evidence. The home visit dynamic is genius. Su Yuanjiu claiming he only has ten minutes and then staying longer because he clearly doesn't want to leave. Xu Yu sitting rigidly beside him, feeling lost about what to do as a host, wondering if he should disassemble and reassemble the Lego set again. These two are both desperately trying to maintain composure while everything around them is quietly unraveling. And that ending with Zheng Xue calling about the show? Xu Yu lying that he went to record when really he just sang for one person in his living room? The layers. The betrayal of truth. I love it.
... Read More
Okay I need to just sit with this for a moment because the strawberry moment in these chapters is honestly one of the most tender things I've read recently and I'm still processing. So Su Yuanjiu notices the TV isn't working — or rather, he notices Xu Yu hasn't even bothered to fix it. The TV's been unplugged, probably overdue on payments, and Xu Yu just... keeps working on his model ship. Doesn't even look up. Su Yuanjiu reads that silence like a book. He knows Xu Yu hasn't been happy since the recording day. And instead of asking directly, instead of making it a big thing, he just says "It's okay, I'll ask someone about it tomorrow" and goes to wash fruit. Then comes the strawberry part. Xu Yu asks if Su Yuanjiu likes strawberries too, but immediately backpedals — "Never mind. I know you don't have to answer me." That little hesitation, that defensive reflex — it tells you everything about how Xu Yu carries himself. He's used to people not caring, used to not being owed explanations. And Su Yuanjiu's response is just... "Can't I like strawberries?" So simple. So perfectly him. But then the REAL moment. Xu Yu says his hands are dirty and he'll eat the strawberries later. And Su Yuanjiu reaches out — and Xu Yu thinks he's going to touch the strawberry, but instead Su Yuanjiu just grabs two toothpicks from the box and hands them over. That level of attention to what Xu Yu actually needs in that moment, not what he said he wanted? That's the kind of thing that makes my chest ache. And then there's Ji Zhouchuan on the other end of the phone, all excited about collaborating with Xu Yu, saying "I really like him" and "the more I listen the better it gets." Su Yuanjiu just locks his phone and looks down at Xu Yu — this quiet, almost protective gesture. Like he's taking in the full picture: the boy who got screwed over on a stage, who still makes beautiful music, who doesn't even know yet that someone out there is fighting for him. I keep thinking about that ending where Su Yuanjiu says he'll find an opportunity for them to meet. He's been holding onto this connection like a secret treasure. And Xu Yu, completely unaware, is just sitting there finishing his puzzle, eating strawberries one toothpick at a time.
... Read More
There's this recurring motif of doors in this chapter that I think deserves more attention. Doors closing, doors opening, doors being held—the entire sequence seems built around this imagery. Xu Yu closes the door on the first meeting. It's a protective gesture, almost instinctive. He sees Su Yuanjiu and retreats, literally shutting the moment away. But then he has to open it again. The second time he enters, he's choosing to face whatever is on the other side. The elevator doors become this powerful symbol of transition and forced proximity. They open slowly, creating this liminal space where Xu Yu and Su Yuanjiu are alone together but surrounded by other people who are afraid to engage. The doors represent the boundary between public and private, between professional composure and personal desire. When Su Yuanjiu says 'Goodbye, Mr. Xu' as the doors open, it's almost Ritualistic. He's using formal address in an intimate moment, creating this tension between what's said and what's meant. The doors closing at the end—separating them once more—feels almost cruel, like the universe keeping them apart even as it brings them together. I also can't ignore the phone call that starts everything. The phone as a symbol of connection, of destiny knocking. Yun Jie receives this call, and suddenly their lives change direction. It's almost fateful—the way the author frames it suggests this wasn't random. Something brought them to that building at that exact time. The title cards we see too—'Mr. Awkward' becomes 'Mr. Su,' transforming from joke to reality. Language itself becomes a tool for distancing and then connecting. Xu Yu never stops being formally polite ('Hello, Mr. Su'), but the subtext screams everything words won't say.
... Read More
Can we just appreciate how the author writes atmosphere? When Xu Yu gets home, fills the bathtub, stands naked checking water temperature — there's this whole sequence of him being alone in steam, in darkness, in this liminal space between his public persona and private self. And then that window! "Beyond it was his bed... the windowpane reflected Xu Yu like a mirror." I've read this passage five times because it's so visceral. He's looking at his own reflection, almost as a stranger, while the phone rings. And the cocktail party corridor scene! "Excessively long and straight" — the author uses architecture to make us feel Xu Yu's vulnerability. He's exiting, thinking he's safe, but the men are coming. The close button pressed repeatedly, the doors shutting just in time, and then that doubt: "But perhaps Xu Yu was mistaken." Is he paranoid? Or is someone really watching him? The ambiguity makes the scene so tense. Also the office scene with Sister Yun eating takeout — it grounds everything. Not every moment needs to be cinematic; sometimes it's just two people in an office sharing food, and that's what makes the world feel real.
... Read More
There's something quietly urgent underneath all of this. Xu Yu wrote a song two years ago that he barely got to perform. The company won't let him pursue music properly. He's doing variety shows that nobody watches because, as the narration dryly notes, it's "similar to going to work" and doing it regularly makes it feel insignificant. This is a person whose artistry is being managed into oblivion. And then Su Yuanjiu—the guy in the JSS building, clearly someone with power and connections—starts watching, starts engaging, starts trying to set up an introduction through Ji Zhouchuan. The stakes here aren't exploding or dramatic, they're the slow-burn kind. What happens when someone with influence actually notices an artist who's been suppressed? What does Xu Yu stand to gain, and what might he lose in the process? The author isn't telling us yet, but the tension is already there—in the gap between Xu Yu's quiet persistence and Su Yuanjiu's growing interest. Also, the fact that Su Yuanjiu has to ask "Do you know Xu Yu?" and gets a flat "no" back, then immediately offers to introduce them—that feels like the first move in something bigger. I'm invested.
... Read More
I need to talk about Xu Weichi calling him on his birthday. This hit me right in the chest. So his brother lives overseas, works at a company, has no idea how the entertainment industry works — to him, Xu Yu is just "working." But somehow he remembers the birthday, calls at an odd hour because of time zones, and when Xu Yu mentions he's unhappy at his job, the first thing he asks is "Do you need money?" Not "Are you sure?" Not "Think about this." Just... "How much do you need?" And then he transfers money the next day without hesitation. And Xu Yu! He pretends everything's fine, tells his brother he's fine, hides his struggles... but when his brother says "If you are unhappy, do not do it," he just nods and accepts it. I've never read such understated but powerful sibling love. The author doesn't make it dramatic or sentimental — it's just... there. Steady. Like the window reflection scene where Xu Yu sees himself in the glass after his bath, then receives the call. His hair covering his eyes, tired from all this work, and then this moment of connection across the ocean. I literally had to put the book down and breathe for a second.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or