Five Cases - Reviews

Five Cases
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is so natural it almost doesn't feel written. Every character has a distinct voice and I never had to re-read a line to figure out who was speaking. Lu Hui's lines are sharp and fast—'You bastard,' 'Cultured scoundrel,' 'My rates are pretty high'—there's this constant edge to his speech that says he's always three steps ahead and slightly amused by everyone. Ji Fanyang matches him perfectly but in a warmer register. 'For how much, I'll sell my pots and pans to support you' is such a clean line—it's funny, it's affectionate, and it reveals character in one sentence. The Wei Congjia phone call is great too. 'Are you in a hurry to be reincarnated?' That's the kind of line that makes you laugh out loud because it's exactly how someone would tease a colleague who's being impatient about evidence. And the narrative voice itself—I love how it doesn't over-explain. When Lu Hui says 'I've died once. What's there to be afraid of?' the text doesn't pad it with internal monologue about his trauma. It just lands and you feel the weight. What really surprised me though is how the dialogue carries subtext without becoming pretentious. The entire hot pot scene is people talking about completely surface-level things—how they met Liu Wei, whether Lu Hui is joking about the engagement banquet, what they want to eat—but every line is doing double duty. The author trusts the reader to catch what's underneath. That's a skill most web novel writers don't have.
... Read More
There's something profound happening beneath the crime procedural surface here. The entire Liu family saga is really about blood ties twisted by greed and betrayal. Liu Kai mourning his son Liu Huairui while his other son Liu Wei turned criminal – it's a tragedy of choices. But Lu Hui reframes it: "Life is like a play. If Liu Huairui died at the hands of Wen Hu's gang, wouldn't you even have someone to hate?" That's such a sharp observation about how humans need villains to process grief. The symbolism of the dishwasher at the end is surprisingly powerful. After everything – murder cases, drug trafficking, comas, death – Lu Hui goes to buy a household appliance because he was kicked out for not washing dishes. It represents choosing domestic peace over danger, commitment over solitude. Remember how Wei Congjia said Lu Hui's decorating style is "buying a sofa and a bed"? That's him trying to build a home, a place to belong. The hospital scenes are steeped in mortality imagery too – breathing masks, trembling fingers, the finality of death. But then there's the embrace on the bench: "I like you. Spend a lifetime with me." After all the violence, that promise feels radical. The recurring motif of doors is interesting too – Liu Kai's ward door, the house door slamming on Lu Hui, the car door. Opening and closing, entering and leaving, connection and separation. Even the bet about whether they'd get together mirrors the larger theme of choice versus fate. Do people control their lives or are they bets placed by others? Lu Hui and Ji Fanyang choose each other deliberately, repeatedly. That's the real story underneath the case files.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are layered in the best way possible. On the surface level, it's a murder investigation — people are dying, bodies are turning up in lakes, there's a missing girl. Standard thriller fare, sure. But dig one inch deeper and you've got inheritance wars, family betrayal, witness tampering, and a paralyzed man whose secrets are about to spill everywhere. What makes the conflict genuinely gripping is that nobody is clean. Liu Wei is clearly implicated in something terrible. Liu Huaizhou is hiding who he really is. Du Chengwu was in witness protection for a reason — he knew things. Wang Jing had evidence that got her killed. And Du Huan Yue, the missing daughter, is apparently the key to unlocking everything. She's the last living piece of evidence and she's gone. Then there's Lu Hui's personal stake, which is deliberately vague but clearly enormous. Someone killed someone before — and Lu Hui is implicated. The line 'whom I killed before' literally sent chills down my spine. Is he saying he committed a killing? Was he defending himself? The author won't tell us yet, and that agonizing delay is masterful tension maintenance. The conflict between Liu Wei and Liu Huaizhou is particularly delicious because it's not just external — it's familial. These are siblings who should be on the same side but clearly aren't, and the inheritance of Liu Kai's estate adds a financial motive that makes everything even more poisonous. By the end of this chapter, every character has a secret, every alliance is suspect, and I am completely invested in finding out who survives this.
... Read More
This chapter is haunted by death. Not dramatically or melodramatically — just quietly, persistently, like something undercurrent beneath every conversation. Lu Hui survived the paper mill fire at fifteen. Ji Fanyang should have died in that lake. Both of them nearly died within these chapters — Lu Hui jumped into the water to save someone, Ji Fanyang is already anticipating his next attempt at murder or whatever it is he's planning. They keep coming back from the edge, and the story seems to be asking: why? The watch is such a loaded symbol. A waterproof watch — purchased specifically to endure water, to survive immersion. But it's also an expensive watch, something you don't buy casually. Ji Fanyang wore it while lying next to the man he tried to kill and the man who tried to kill him back, and it ticked through every second of their conversation. It's a promise, almost — a silent vow that he's prepared for whatever comes next, for however many lakes Lu Hui might jump into. The double bed is another thing I can't stop thinking about. Two people, separate spaces on the same mattress, neither willing to give ground but both choosing to share it anyway. Ji Fanyang says he doesn't like sharing territory. And yet here he is. Every boundary they have is also a bridge. And that line — "Maybe we're both living for something inevitable" — it captures the whole philosophy of these two. They're not survivors by accident. Something keeps pulling them back, something they haven't even named yet. Fate? Obsession? Love? The author isn't saying which one, and honestly, the ambiguity is the point.
... Read More
The structure here is doing some clever things. We start with Ji Fanyang discovering the notebook - intimate, slow, grief-weighted. Then it snaps sharply into Lu Hui's perspective with his parents, full of tension and hostility, and then just as we're caught up in that hostage dynamic, it pivots again to Song Qinchuan's world, lighter on the surface with classroom banter but underneath carrying all this weight. The chapter manages three completely different emotional temperatures without feeling chaotic, which is impressive. The transitions between these threads create this push-pull effect where you're never quite comfortable. Just when you settle into Song Qinchuan's cafeteria scene with Fengya, you get that moment where Song Qinchuan rubs his watch strap and thinks of "the gentle young man" - and suddenly the whole scene darkens without the author having to say a word about it. The chapter ends with Ji Fanyang telling Director Gao he's resigning. That's the kind of button that makes you immediately open the next chapter. It's not a cliffhanger in the traditional sense - nothing explodes, no one dies - but the emotional consequence is so clear that you have to know what happens next. The pacing respects the reader's intelligence enough to not over-explain.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author uses the interrogation room setting because honestly it's doing SO much work here. This isn't just some generic "police station room" backdrop - it's a pressure cooker where every detail serves the psychological warfare happening between these characters. The tea cups are interesting. Lu Hui drinks tea to soothe his throat, he snatches Ji Fanyang's cup to gulp water like he's extinguishing fire, he makes Liu Wei's interrogator pass him empty cups. This repeated motif of drinking, of quenching, of consumption - it feels almost primal against the clinical setting. The room becomes this space where civility is maintained through rituals (tea, formal address, the click of the door) while everything below the surface is rotting away. The door itself matters. That final click when Lu Hui and Ji Fanyang leave Liu Wei alone in silence - you can almost hear it echoing. The physical separation of bodies in that room mirrors the emotional chasm between who Liu Wei thought she was and who she actually is. And I love that despite all this heavy dialogue, the author never forgets to ground us in the physical space. The table, the chairs, the phone Lu Hui uses to text Huang Zili - these mundane details make the extraordinary revelations feel terrifyingly real. It's clinical, cold, fluorescent-lit maybe, but underneath it all there's this palpable heat of emotion that the author generates purely through subtext and atmosphere rather than melodrama.
... Read More
There's something so quietly cinematic about this entire chapter. It starts at a little stall grilling fish — flames, smoke, the crackle of skewers over fire — and then it moves into this wooden house by the back mountains, a double bed, stars visible through a window. The physical world in these scenes feels so grounded and real, you can practically smell the charcoal and feel the damp from Lu Hui's soaked clothes. But what really makes these scenes work is how the environment mirrors everything happening internally. Lu Hui's entire body is soaked from jumping into the lake to save someone — he takes off his wet shirt and shorts, wraps himself in a blanket, stares at the ceiling beam. You can feel that exhaustion, that raw vulnerability, like he just did something irreversible and now he's sitting with the aftermath. The wooden house itself is interesting too. It's simple, almost temporary. Lu Hui says he's on a 'business trip' that he didn't report to his school — consider it a teaching accident. This place functions as a liminal space where both of them can just exist without their usual masks. No pretending, no schemes, just two people who survived things they shouldn't have. And the lake. Always the lake. First Lu Hui jumps in to save Ji Fanyang, then they're lying in bed and Lu Hui casually mentions he's 80% sure Ji Fanyang would have been thrown into that same lake in the back mountains anyway. The lake becomes this recurring threat, this gravitational pull that keeps dragging them both toward danger. It's almost like the setting itself is a character — beautiful, dangerous, impossible to escape.
... Read More
"It seems like you treat me as a news station every day." I literally laughed at this line. Fengya's voice is so distinct—he's the gossip source, the info broker, and the way he delivers information feels completely organic. He doesn't just dump exposition; he makes it feel like a casual lunch conversation where facts slip out between bites of fried liver. The dialogue throughout these chapters has this sharp, economical quality. No character wastes words. When Huang Zili says "If I don't do well, Uncle Lu will skin me alive," it's funny AND it tells us something about their social dynamics in one line. And Song Qinchuan's responses—so controlled, so deliberate. "Quite an interesting name." "You're thinking too much." He never reveals more than he needs to. The author has given each character a rhythm that's instantly recognizable. Even Liu Wei's playful energy comes through in her dialogue—"Fanzhe, how can you be so gentle?"—while his responses to her are performative warmth that we, the readers, have learned to read between the lines of.
... Read More
The banter between Lu Hui and Ji Fanyang is legitimately some of the best I've read. Like, the way they slide between jokes and devastating honesty in the same sentence is a talent. "You deliberately drank too much, can't get it up." — Ji Fanyang delivers this line with zero filter and I am OBSESSED. That's not just humor, that's intimacy. Only someone who knows you that well can roast you that hard and have it land as affection. And Lu Hui's response? "I thought you'd be happy with a beautiful woman's invitation. I didn't expect you to let go of the opportunity." Then the pivot: "Feelings? Who goes to a bar for feelings?" — Classic deflection. He's clearly feeling things and immediately covers it with sarcasm. Ji Fanyang calls him out instantly: "You have the nerve to say that about me, what about you?" The mutual exposure through dialogue, chef's kiss. Then the bank card password joke: "Tell me your bank card password." "You're dreaming; I've left it to my sister. You won't get a penny!" This is two guys who have shared everything—including an apartment—pretending like money is a barrier between them. The comedy writes itself because the love underneath makes it real. Wei Congjia's voice is distinct too—"The fierce devil looks scared; that's rare" — that's someone who knows Lu Hui's reputation and enjoys poking the bear. And then immediately shifts to business mode when mentioning the appointment letter. The author gives every character a recognizable mouthfeel. The line that stops working for me though is the cut-off at the end. Wei Congjia starts advising Lu Hui about Director Wang and the text just... ends mid-sentence. Was that intentional cliffhanger or did I get cut off?
... Read More
The dynamic between these two is absolutely infectious and I need to unpack it. Lu Hui pretending he doesn't care about everything while literally caring about everything and Ji Fanyang playing the straight man who is also absolutely unhinged underneath. When Lu Hui is on the phone with Chief Gao putting the phone between his shoulder and his ear putting on socks like this is just another Tuesday after rescuing his partner from a lake and Ji Fanyang snatches the phone and sprays ocean perfume on his wrist because apparently even phone calls with law enforcement require fragrance and I cannot stop laughing. Their banter about the guitar and the faked death is basically a marriage of five years compressed into three lines of dialogue. But underneath all the joking Lu Hui says he is going to dig up their ancestors graves for revenge and something shifts isn't it he is still carrying that weight even after coming back even after being pulled from the water and Ji Fanyang beside him treating him like fragile glass without ever saying it out loud. The way Wei Congjia threatens to call their sister because they won't stop is such a perfect observer moment that confirms these two are basically public menaces wherever they go.
... Read More
Okay, so let's talk about how this whole arc wraps up. The Liu family case is basically the final boss of this whole storyline. You've got betrayal, switched goods, a dying patriarch, and a brother who got caught – it's all tied up so neatly it's almost satisfying. The bet subplot with Wei Congjia was such a clever touch though. I love how the author uses that pool to show everyone's invested in Lu Hui and Ji Fanyang's relationship without having to spell it out. And then Lu Hui actually loses two hundred bucks because Ji Fanyang kissed him? That's both hilarious and kind of perfect. It shows how unpredictable their moments are – even when they think they're about to die in that warehouse, love still happens. The resolution at the hospital with Liu Kai was brutal but necessary. Lu Hui telling him "I have no regrets about killing Wang Yinyin" and then walking out? Chills. It's not just about solving the case, it's about closure for both characters. And the ending where Lu Hui gets kicked out for not washing dishes? After all that drama, it's such a grounded, human moment. They won the case, they won each other, but now they have to do chores. Classic. The pacing throughout these chapters felt right – the canteen scene, the drive to the hospital, the quiet moment on the bench, then back to the bureau. It all flows naturally from high tension to domestic comedy. I really appreciate how the author doesn't overstay the resolution. Once the case is solved, we get the emotional payoff quickly, then the funny ending beat. No dragging it out. That's good storytelling.
... Read More
The stakes have been quietly escalating through all these chapters and I want to highlight why this particular sequence works so well for tension. On the external level, we have a body in a lake that connects to a missing persons case involving twins, a paralyzed Liu Kai, a Liu family in chaos, and the Lands' team waiting for any excuse to investigate. Lu Hui has already 'died once' according to Wei Congjia—what does that mean for his next move? The personal stakes for him are enormous because if this goes wrong, he's not coming back from whatever happens in Zhongchuan. But the more interesting conflict is the one happening RIGHT NOW at the hot pot restaurant. Everything between Lu Hui and Ji Fanyang is charged with unspoken tension. They're about to go undercover together again, they're traveling to another city where real danger awaits, and yet they're eating shrimp and making jokes about friendship day. That contrast IS the conflict—the emotional intimacy building between them exists alongside the life-or-death situation they're walking into. The author doesn't resolve either one. Both are hanging in the air. The stakes for the Liu family are also escalating—their secret is about to be exposed through Du Chengxian's body, and they're cornered. Lu Hui says 'They'll be desperate, and we can get more clues' which means he knows desperation leads to mistakes. That's the whole game. And Fan Zhe dying is the moral weight behind all of this. 'Fan Zhe can't die for nothing' isn't just a plot point, it's an emotional anchor that makes every decision feel heavier. What do you think happens when they actually confront the Liu family?

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or