Farming? That’s My Old Profession! - Reviews

Farming? That’s My Old Profession!
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The author's description of this village is genuinely outstanding. Let me paint the picture they built: you've got Song Xia and Shen Huaijing traveling for TWO FULL DAYS from dawn to dusk, passing through county seats, getting bumpier and bumpier until they arrive at this mountain hollow surrounded on all sides by peaks. Only one dirt road connects them to the outside world. Thirty or forty households. That's it. This isn't a picturesque countryside retreat — this is isolation, and the text makes you feel every mile of it. But here's what really sells it: the sensory details. The peasants in the fields with rolled-up trouser legs and straw hats staring curiously at the carriage. The children swarming up like little animals, then scattering when the women yell at them. The tattered broken tiles on the roof that Song Xia immediately suspects the steward's 'repair' claim didn't cover. The water well inside the courtyard — such a specific, practical detail that grounds the whole scene in reality. And the neighbors! The author gives us three distinct women who feel like they stepped out of a real Chinese village in any dynasty. Sister-in-law Shan'er with her silver hairpin and booming voice who immediately rallies help. Sister Wang in patch-upon-patch grey with hollow cheeks and calloused hands. Sister-in-law Liu with upturned shrewish eyes and a wooden hairpin, all competitive energy. Each one has a different relationship to the house — Shan'er is genuinely warm, Liu is performative, Wang is quietly envious. This isn't background decoration; this is a living, breathing social ecosystem that Song Xia has to navigate. The tile-roofed house being 'noticeably grander than the surrounding village homes' is such a smart detail too. It immediately establishes that even in exile, Shen Huaijing's family status creates visual hierarchy. The house is both a privilege and a target.
... Read More
I have to give massive credit to the dialogue writing here because every single character has a voice that is immediately distinguishable, and I don't say that enough in web novels. Sister-in-law Shan'er is the standout. Her entrance is pure energy: 'Hey there, sister!' 'Psh, what respects or no respects!' 'Oh goodness! Why did both of us go ahead and eat ours!' She's loud, warm, decisive, and she physically whirls around fetching her husband before anyone can protest. You can hear her voice before you even see her name in the text. She's the kind of neighbor who would carry you a bucket of water without being asked and then loudly tell everyone about it. Then you've got Sister-in-law Liu, and her dialogue is basically passive-aggression with a side of performative generosity. 'Well aren't you eager to play the good Samaritan, Shan'er.' 'I didn't say I wasn't going to help! Look at that mouth of yours!' She's the woman who will 'help' you move so she can stand in your courtyard and make everyone else look bad. Classic. And Sister Wang? Her dialogue is almost nonexistent because she barely speaks at all. 'It's sweet!' is basically her entire contribution, and it's perfect because it tells us everything about her — she's honest, simple, and genuinely moved by small things. Her silence speaks volumes next to the other two. The bantering between the women outside the gate before Shan'er even appears is also brilliant worldbuilding through dialogue. You learn about marriage customs, economic status, gender dynamics, and village gossip all through what amounts to women yelling across a field. And Shen Huaijing's single line — 'I am Shen Huaijing, Song Xia's husband' — is perfectly calibrated. Polite, formal, brief. He doesn't overshare. He says exactly what's needed and nothing more. That's a character who chooses his words like weapons.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or