Evil Mother - Reviews

Evil Mother
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so first of all, can we talk about how this story sets up the entire premise? You've got Meng Jin spending thirty paragraphs getting dressed for a blind date, which should be boring—right? But it's not. Because every detail about his mom nagging him, his failed dates, his professional reputation—it's all building this portrait of a guy who is deeply competent at his job and utterly lost when it comes to anything resembling romance. And then BOOM. Tang Xiaoguo calls. Homicide. Case closed on the dating front, open on the murder front. The structural move here is genius because the blind date isn't just a subplot device—it's the narrative mechanism that connects him to the victim's scene. He literally drives from Starbucks to the crime scene. The parallel is delicious. Also, there's this tiny detail that sent me spinning: Zhao called earlier saying "nothing major" and then hung up hurriedly. When Meng Jin gets the call from Tang, he immediately thinks: *he's done plenty of prep today; everything's under control.* And then the case drops. The timing is too clean. I'm already suspecting that Zhao knew something before the official call came in. That hesitation in his voice—"Captain Meng… Nothing major"—that's a plot thread I am absolutely going to track. The body itself is wrapped in plastic like a mummy. Shallow pit. Kidney wound. All of these details are breadcrumbs, and the author is placing them deliberately without over-explaining. I like that. The contradiction between "wrapped to hide the smell" and "buried shallowly in a public park" is exactly the kind of puzzle that makes you flip pages. Who wants the body found? Who doesn't? The fact that the killer both concealed AND exposed is a contradiction that screams "there's more to this than we're being told."
... Read More
Okay, I need to just... process what I just read. Meng Jin is such a mess and I love it. I love that the author doesn't make this obvious or neat. The man literally cannot process being ignored by his high school rival and shows up at an airport like he's meeting an internet date. And then? Long De gives him exactly zero attention. Not even a “long time no see.” I actually said out loud “bro what did you expect” to my kindle. But here's what got me: the dream. He dreams about Long De mocking his test scores, and then the narrator tells us “In reality, Long De had never mocked him.” That line hit me like a truck. It means Meng Jin's entire fixation isn't even about what actually happened—it's built on fear, insecurity, and a decade of imagining himself as the underdog. That's not rivalry. That's obsession dressed up as competition. And Long De? The guy says he came back “specifically for this case,” with this tiny curl of his lips, and then drops the most casual “Yes” when asked if he has a personal connection. Personal connection. TO WHO? TO MENG JIN? I don't know. I don't know anything. But my heart is racing. The fact that Zhao Yunzhi is just happily munching on a paper bag in the mall while these two men have a silent emotional earthquake happening around him is honestly the funniest thing in literature.
... Read More
The structural engineering in this batch is something I want to dissect, because the author is playing with time in ways that reward careful reading. We open with the investigation thread — Zhao Yunzhi and Meng Jin going through call records. This is the hook, the procedural element that grounds us in mystery. Then we cut to Jennie's dream, and suddenly we're in something much more psychological. The transition is jarring in the best way — it forces us to slow down, to inhabit Jennie's interiority before the external plot catches up. From there, the pacing accelerates through her morning routine, then slows again at the breakfast table where Ms. Huang outlines the day. This is the calm before the storm. The author deliberately gives us a moment of normalcy — steaming porridge, a schedule, mundane details — so that when Jennie arrives at the auction, the performance feels earned rather than rushed. The auction scene itself is where the structural genius really shows. It moves in real time, scene by scene, and every beat builds: the media barrage, the donation speech, the children on stage. But beneath the surface action, the author is planting ticking bombs. The watch that belonged to Liu Tianshi. The ten-times-value sale. The whispered rumor about a secret child. Each detail is a story beat that will pay off later. Then the evening — returning to the sanatorium, changing out of the performance costume into pajamas, the button-system that connects her to Ms. Huang. The pacing here becomes almost meditative, lulling us into a false sense of security before the phone rings. That phone call is the structural pivot point. Everything before it was setup; everything after it will be consequence. And the fact that Jennie's rule is "never sleep with unresolved issues" — that she must find a solution before bed — creates a brilliant narrative constraint. The chapter effectively ends with a deadline: solve this before you sleep, or don't sleep at all. The Li Zizi scene at the end operates as a counterpoint structurally. While Jennie is isolated in her sanatorium suite, Li Zizi is in a villa with Shen Kuo, loose and unrestrained. The juxtaposition of these two women — one performing grief alone, one performing innocence with a lover — creates a double narrative that makes the whole book feel twice as dense.
... Read More
The stakes in this batch are layered like an onion, and I'm not sure I've even reached the core yet. On the surface level, Liu Tianshi is dead. That's the inciting incident, the thing that sets everything in motion. But the real conflict isn't about murder; it's about inheritance. Who gets Fangzheng Group? Jennie has the shares, but she doesn't have security. The rumors of a secret child aren't just gossip — they're a tactical threat. If Liu Tianshi had offspring, Jennie's position collapses. This is exactly the kind of low-grade anxiety that keeps readers turning pages. Jennie's internal conflict is equally compelling. She has spent decades building Fangzheng from a toy factory into an empire. She believes, with religious certainty, that the highest seat belongs to her. But the midnight phone call suggests that her control is an illusion. She can blacklist numbers, she can perform grief at auctions, she can eat five-yuan breakfasts and donate ten-times-value watches — but she cannot silence the people who know what she did. Zhao Yunzhi and Meng Jin represent a different conflict axis. They're hunting for truth in a world where everyone is lying. "Someone's definitely lying" — this line isn't just observation; it's a diagnosis of the entire narrative ecosystem. When nobody can be trusted, investigation becomes the only moral imperative. Li Zizi and Shen Kuo operate on a completely different stakes level. They lied to the police. They sold their bodies and their silence. Their conflict is survival versus complicity, and it's fascinating because they seem almost blissfully unaware of how deep they're in. "What if the police find out we lied?" Shen Kuo asks, and Li Zizi can barely respond. Their ignorance might be their greatest vulnerability. The escalating tension comes from the fact that all these conflict threads are converging. The murder investigation is closing in. The inheritance is contested. The blackmail is active. And Jennie's rule — never sleep with unresolved issues — means she's forced to keep fighting, keep solving, keep eliminating threats, until one of these threads snaps. My prediction? The secret child rumor is the trigger. Not because it's true, but because someone wants it to be believed. And once belief spreads, Jennie's performance architecture collapses.
... Read More
The pacing in this chapter is a rollercoaster, and I love every second of it. It starts slow, almost comedic. The parrot, the drinks menu, the butler's professionalism—it's like a sitcom before the horror movie hits. You're relaxed. You're smiling at the bird's repetition. Then Li Zizi appears, and the tone shifts. She's glamorous, mysterious, dangerously aware of her own allure. The conversation with her unfolds like a detective novel: questions, evasions, reluctant confessions. You're leaning in, trying to read between her lines. And then—bam—the phone rings. This is where the author shows real mastery. The international scam call, the persistence, the annoyance building until Meng Jin finally checks the message. Each ring adds tension, each ignored call raises the stakes. By the time he reads that first text, the reader is already braced for impact. But the image? The corpse? The Western officers? The caption? That's not just a cliffhanger. That's a paradigm shift. What I find most impressive is how the author uses the phone notification as a structural pivot point. Everything before it is contained within the villa, within Li Zizi's world, within the murder investigation we thought we understood. Everything after it spills outside those boundaries—into America, into twenty-year-old cases, into something that connects Liu Tianshi's death to a larger conspiracy. The chapter ends not with resolution but with explosion. Countless questions swirling in Meng Jin's mind. Impatience bubbling beneath his calm surface. The old habits die hard. And the reader? We're not ready to put the book down. We need to know what happens next. We need to know who sent that message. We need to know why an American murder case mirrors Liu Tianshi's death so perfectly. Author, you monster. I'll be reading until dawn.
... Read More
"Officers, if you have any questions, feel free to ask. I'll answer everything to the best of my ability." Said with such humble politeness while radiating pure controlled power. I laughed out loud. This is what I live for—dialogue that does double duty, where every sentence is performing two jobs at once. And Meng Jin's voice? Perfect. Dry, impatient, observant. His internal monologue about suspects who voluntarily give up information being a gift is so character-specific—you can hear the man who's been a cop long enough to appreciate efficiency. When he says to Zhao, "Spend less time reading fashion magazines and more time on Baidu" after flicking a cigarette three meters into a trash can? That's a MAN. Not a single wasted word. Jennie's dialogue is where it gets interesting though. Her answer about why they're estranged: "My husband wanted to have another child. But I'm older now and can no longer bear children, so he found a younger woman to have a child for him." Read that again. She doesn't say "infertile." She says she "can no longer bear children." There's a difference. One is medical; the other sounds like she's carrying some unspoken weight about what happened. And the way she delivers it—with a bitter smile—is devastating. She's not defending herself. She's stating facts like a contract clause. The dialogue never explains too much. It trusts the reader. That's rare.
... Read More
I need to talk about the scar. Like, I need to talk about it RIGHT NOW because it's the most devastating metaphor in this entire chapter and nobody's telling me why I'm emotionally wrecked. He walks out of that luxury store looking like a wealthy heir — if it weren't for the ugly scar on his face. Let me repeat that. He transforms completely. The clerks who were sneering at him in his stained clothes are now looking at him with admiration. Money does what money does. But that scar. That scar is like a brand. The narrator literally compares it to a criminal's branding from ancient times. And then the moment where he actually touches it and decides to flee. He's standing across the street from a high-end club, considering going in, and passersby just LOOK at him and he bolts. Why? Because he knows exactly what will happen — people will pity the poor guy in nice clothes who doesn't belong, then they'll figure out who he really is, and their compassion will curdle into something vicious overnight. "The poor are truly despicable" — he says this about OTHER PEOPLE, not himself, which is such a rich self-delusion because he's the one making the calculations, the one deciding he's not worthy of that world. He goes back to the restroom, changes into his old clothes, packs the luxury items carefully. The tragedy is that NONE of it matters. The clothes were never his. The transformation was always temporary. The only thing he can't change is what's on his face, and maybe that's the point — some marks aren't just physical, they're existential. Meanwhile in the nursing home, Guo Yingying is describing a nightmare where she's chased by a tiger and Liu Er, falls off a cliff. She can't hear his responses. He can't truly reach her. They're both trapped in different versions of the same prison. And she says the line that ended me: "Brother, why do you suddenly want to find my biological parents?" Her voice casual but strained. She's testing him. She's always been testing him. How long has she known he wasn't doing this for her?
... Read More
The pacing here is deliberately deceptive. We open with what feels like a slice-of-life scene—parents raising a child, neighbors gossiping, a boy struggling to carry groceries. It's warm, human, almost peaceful. Then the bicycle appears. The injury. The confrontation. The police station. And suddenly we're in investigation territory. This structural pivot is genius—the author uses a mundane accident as the wedge that cracks open the past. The Old Yu sequence slows things down intentionally, giving us space to process and theorize. But then Zhao Yunzhi drops his theory about Lin Jiancai's manipulation, and the pacing accelerates again. The chapter ends on an almost comedic note with Meng Jin teasing Zhao Yunzhi about his phone use and confidentiality breaches—but it's a false ending. We're meant to feel like the investigation is progressing, when really, we've just entered deeper mystery. The author controls reader engagement through this rhythm: slow domestic scenes, sudden violence, methodical investigation, rapid-fire theorizing, then a pause that isn't really a pause. It's exhausting in the best way—exactly how a real investigation feels.
... Read More
There's a recurring visual motif in these chapters that I can't stop thinking about, and I want to unpack it because I think the author is doing something intentional beneath the procedural surface. The Lin Kun case photo—body wrapped like a mummy in cling film, blond-haired blue-eyed American police surrounding it, red maple trees in the background—this image is haunting precisely because it's so visually specific. Mummification. Preservation. Something dead being kept intact, displayed for whoever finds it. And then the second killer sends this exact photo a week later as a deliberate link, which means the killer understands the symbolism himself. He's not just copying a method; he's communicating through it. The cling film becomes a message in a bottle, and the red maples become part of the signature. Then there's the courier label. The recipient address printed darker than the rest, smudging when rubbed, almost certainly handwritten to look like print. This is such a rich symbol on multiple levels. The killer is literally rewriting the rules of communication—forging addresses, manipulating systems, embedding messages in plain sight within bureaucracy. The smudging ink suggests impermanence, but also the difficulty of gripping truth. You touch it and it falls apart. The condom results revealing JY instead of Liu Tianshi's DNA operate similarly—a surface reading (Li Zizi cheated) that immediately complicates the deeper narrative. Nothing in this story is what it first appears. Even the bureaucratic rejection of merging the cases mirrors the thematic obstruction: truth exists but institutional barriers keep it separated, just as the Lin Kun case was buried for twenty years until Long De's memory accidentally uncovered it. Shen Kuo's desperate gratitude and eventual refusal of Meng Jin's ordinary car also feels symbolically charged—dignity versus survival, the performance of status even when you've lost everything.
... Read More
Okay, let me just... I had to put the book down for a solid ten minutes after the flashback sequence. Everything I thought I knew about Jennie Yang got flipped upside down and then set on fire. We've been following this conspiracy puzzle with the fake Guo Tiandi and He Saibing's pregnancy, and the police think they're playing chess — Zhao Yunzhi leaning back with his feet on the table, completely relaxed — but the author just drops this nuclear bomb of backstory and suddenly none of it matters anymore. Because the real villain isn't some shadowy mastermind pulling strings from behind the scenes. It's Jennie Yang herself. She tried to strangle her own newborn. She left a baby to die in the rain. And now she's sitting in her mansion pretending to be the gracious mother, while Liu Er is hugging her and promising to be a good son, completely unaware that the woman holding him is the same woman who decided his life wasn't worth living twenty years ago. The plot twist here isn't just that she has a secret — it's that she's actively living a lie every single day with Liu Er under her roof. And the author plays it so casually, almost dismissing it with "her fa" trailing off at the end, which is basically a masterclass in not overstating the obvious because readers are already screaming internally.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this body-swap theory because it literally won't leave my head. The idea that Liu Er and Guo Tiandi might have switched places as kids? Genius-level plot construction. Think about it—Jennie hid an illegitimate child for thirty years, which already tells you she's capable of extreme secrecy and manipulation. Then her legitimate son dies in a horrific car accident, body burned beyond recognition, and suddenly we're supposed to believe that was actually Liu Er? Come on. The author drops this quietly through Meng Jin's investigation but it hits like a truck. What really sold me is the XYY syndrome detail—that's not just random medical info, it's a plot device that creates doubt about identity. If Liu Er had a rare chromosomal condition, wouldn't that show up in medical records? And yet the DNA samples were conveniently destroyed. The author is basically whispering to us: something is very wrong here. But then Jennie Yang pulls this public confession move that completely flips the board. She admits to the illegitimate child openly, which should theoretically solve the mystery, but instead it makes everything more confusing. Is she trying to legitimize Guo Tiandi as her heir? Or is she creating a distraction? The plot thickens and I am here for it. Who else predicted that ending? Didn't think so.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the metaphor Meng Jin uses: 'This case was like a bottomless pit—the deeper they dug, the more chaotic it became.' And the circle analogy: 'Inside the circle were the details they had uncovered; outside it lay the unknown. The more information they gathered, the larger the circle grew, and the unknowns multiplied.' This is the central theme of the entire novel, isn't it? Every answer births three new questions. The kidnapping of Hosei Bing, the murder of Liu Tianshi—on the surface, no link. But the theme suggests everything is connected in ways we can't yet see. The child in Hosei Bing's stomach becomes a symbol of that unknown. Is it a hostage? A motive? A legacy? Jiang Jin's deduction that Jennie Yang ‘doesn't want the child to be born' points to a theme of erasure. People trying to wipe out the past, the evidence, the future. And Andy's arrival? He represents the external force that will expand the circle further, bringing new variables. We're all just staring into the pit, waiting for something to look back.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or