Okay, I need to talk about Ma Shangting because this girl is making me SO uncomfortable and I can't tell if she's just a dumb teenager or straight-up evil. Let me lay this out.
So Qiao Duoduo gets bitten by an elite rat on her thigh—loses a third of her HP, could've been way worse—and the whole thing happens because Ma Shangting literally steps IN FRONT of her when Duoduo tries to protect her. Not away. Not freeze. She MOVES toward Duoduo, blocking her path, and then gets bitten instead. And then everyone—including Huoyang, the boyfriend—assumes Duoduo was shielding Ma Shangting. The narrative literally flips on its head and Duoduo is the one who looks reckless.
"Only Qiao Duoduo suspected that Ma Shangting had done it on purpose."
That line hit me like a truck. Because Duoduo is the ONLY one who saw it. Everyone else has this completely fabricated version of events where Duoduo is the hero who got hurt trying to save someone, and Ma Shangting is the fragile little girl who needed saving. But Duoduo knows she was the one who moved to protect Ma Shangting, and Ma Shangting's reaction was... wrong. Deliberate. The text says she "didn't stay put or flee; instead, she stepped toward Qiao Duoduo, blocking her path." That's not panicked behavior. That's not clumsy. That's calculated.
And then Su Ning drops this bombshell about Ma Shangfei trying to enter her room TWICE. First night, knocking at dark asking to be added as a friend—refused. Morning of, showing up again telling her not to be "willful" or act like a "spoiled girl" if she wasn't sick. Duoduo's summary of Su Ning's reputation is brutal: "Lucky, nanny job. Rich, rents at the tavern. Show-off, recommends breakfast. Unreasonable, rejects Ma Shangfei."
"That I rejected Ma Shangfei. Twice."
So Ma Shangting probably heard all of this. She knows her brother got rejected twice. She knows Su Ning is this rich, lucky, unapproachable person who won't even give her brother the time of day. And Duoduo is Su Ning's "extra life"—the person closest to her. The motive is basically written on the wall.
What kills me is that Huoyang is so naive about all of this. "Unless he saw things firsthand, he was naive, kind, stubborn, and indulgent." He loves his sister and he'd never believe Duoduo's accusation without proof. Which is exactly why Duoduo and Su Ning are planning to test her tomorrow. "Seeing is believing."
I'm sitting here going back and forth—maybe Ma Shangting is just a jealous kid who tripped? But no, the text is very specific about her body language. And Su Ning's reaction at the end—"What a pity"—that's not concern. That's someone who's already decided this girl is a problem that needs solving.
I just hope Duoduo is smart enough to stay careful. Because if Ma Shangting is this cunning at her age, she's not playing around.