Don’t Abandon the Black-Haired Beast - Reviews

Don’t Abandon the Black-Haired Beast
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Oh my god, the moment Selene turns that corner and sees him—I literally gasped. Let me rewind a second because the setup here is *chef's kiss*. She's already on edge, already trying to avoid the main hall, already calculating every exit route like a trapped animal. And then—bam. The emperor himself, alone on the stairs, and he comments on the household's manners before she even speaks. The irony is almost unbearable because SHE'S the one who's supposed to be the threat, the anomaly, the thing that could unravel everything. What's brilliant about this chapter is how the plot threads converge so unexpectedly. Selene thought she was safe far away from Offenburg politics, tending to a count's daughter, gathering herbs, maintaining her fragile normal life. But the plot doesn't give a damn about her plans. The new emperor—Adrian Offenburg—has arrived, and fate has dragged them into the same corridor at the same moment. Every other character in this scene is operating on incomplete information: Grita doesn't know Selene is terrified, Sheldon doesn't recognize her, and Adrian himself seems unsure of what precisely drew him to pause on those stairs. That final line—Sheldon seeing her and thinking 'her face looked familiar, but he did not know her'—is the kind of plot detail that keeps me up at night. Familiar but not known. Someone who has crossed his path before without registering. This isn't over. It's barely begun.
... Read More
The structure of this reveal is genuinely masterful. Let me walk through how the author builds to it because it deserves respect. First, Eos plants the seed of doubt early—why didn't the magic work on this child? He was hovering between life and death, yet recovered completely. That's the first loose thread. Then we get a whole middle section that's basically misdirection: the village trip, Emil feeling at peace, thinking the imperial palace probably thinks he's dead, feeling safe. The author makes us feel safe too. We're lulled into Selene's perspective, into the warmth of their routine. Then—the missing instrument. Eos left it, it's gone, and the only person who could have taken it is Emil himself. He hid it. That single detail flips everything. And then the antidote scene: three years of care, three years of trust, undone in seconds as his white hair bleeds black and his eyes turn crimson. What I love is how the reveal doesn't just change what we know about Emil—it retroactively changes how we read every previous scene. That moment in the village where he pressed his hand to his chest fighting contradictory emotions? Was that guilt? Was that the weight of deception? The author knew exactly what they were doing, and it paid off spectacularly.
... Read More
Can we just talk about Selene's internal spiral for a moment? Because the author wrote it in a way that absolutely wrecked me. When Selene first lays eyes on Adrian, his smile—"the smile that folded his eyes into gentle curves while still trying to hide the pleasure in them"—that is Emil's smile. That is a boy who survived abuse by learning to make himself small and endearing. And Adrian has that exact same smile wrapped around eyes that are "entirely Offenburg's": cruel, arrogant, dangerous. The overlap haunts her. It haunts the reader. Because Selene LOVED Emil—no, she STILL loves him, buried under layers of trauma and fear—and now she's staring at a man who wears his brother's expression like a mask she can't distinguish from reality. "I suppose they resemble each other as brothers of a sort." That line is devastating. It's so casually dismissive, as if acknowledging their familial resemblance might diminish the emotional earthquake happening inside her. But it doesn't diminish anything. If anything, it makes it worse—because now Adrian isn't just a random terrifying emperor. He's connected to THE person she protected, the person she couldn't save, the person she still thinks about when she tries not to. And then—"a deep, woody scent reached her. Wet wood, a scent that brought the Ida Forest to mind. That too resembled Emil." The author is layering sensory memories on top of emotional confusion until Selene can't tell where the past ends and the present begins. She's caught between two versions of the same man: the gentle boy she raised, and the ruthless emperor who grabbed her jaw like she was something to inspect, not someone to address.
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is doing such important work that I want to really examine it, because on the surface it's almost nothing. Two people barely speaking to each other, lots of silence, lots of ellipses. But the subtext is carrying everything. Selene's voice is warm, slightly self-deprecating, with this cadence that feels like someone who's spent years talking to frightened children. 'Oh, oh! What a fright.' 'Good grief, what a start.' Her speech patterns show she's comfortable in her own skin — she laughs at her own mistakes, she admits when she's flustered, she offers without demanding. Even when she's worried, she talks to him gently: 'You are a patient. Go lie down in bed right now.' That's not authority, that's care disguised as mild scolding. His voice is nearly absent, and that's the point. He speaks in fragments — 'I'll do it,' 'Yes,' 'I like it.' Each word is measured, economical. When he says 'I don't want to go back' under his breath, it's the longest thing he's said and it's directed at no one. The contrast between their speech patterns tells us everything we need to know about their histories. But the real dialogue genius is in what the narrator gives us. 'Selene did not realize the meaning of what she had just said.' That's not dialogue — that's the author stepping in to show us the gap between what was said and what was meant. And 'He bit down on his lip, afraid he might cry' — that's the narration doing the emotional heavy lifting that the characters can't articulate. The most powerful exchange is arguably the one that doesn't happen at all: the moment where she says 'I won't throw you out for not working' and he just nods. She thinks she's being kind; he hears something entirely different, because for him, worth has always been tied to utility. Their languages literally don't overlap.
... Read More
I need a minute. The entire second half of this chapter is just Adrian alone in his room, and the way he narrates his own longing broke me. 'He had endured by chewing on that one name alone. Selene.' Ten years. TEN YEARS of him holding onto that single name while she moved on and forgot him entirely. And the worst part isn't even the betrayal—it's the tender way he still pictures her. The fingers that traced his scars, the guilty flush on her face. He wanted her to see him, to remember him, and instead she looked at him like a stranger. 'She doesn't recognize me?' He asked himself. God. The emotional cruelty of someone who has loved for a decade and received nothing back. But also—the way he ends it? 'Whatever Selene may think, our ending will not change.' That's not romance, that's obsession dressed in silk. I'm not sure if I'm swooning or terrified.
... Read More
The stakes here are doing triple duty and it's exhausting. On the surface: Selene is a disguised witch serving an emperor who would kill her if he knew. But the author layers it so thickly. There's the political danger—the history of Offenburg witches being hunted. There's the personal danger—Adrian already knows something is off about her and he's playing with his food. And there's the historical echo: Medea fell for an Offenburg and died for it. Selene is walking into the exact same trap across five centuries and she doesn't even realize it yet. Every moment of closeness between them raises the stakes because the closer they get, the more likely Selene is to accidentally reveal herself, and the more Adrian has to lose when he finds out. The author made me sweat without putting a sword to anyone's throat.
... Read More
This chapter is a rollercoaster and I respect the author for not giving me a single breath. It opens with tension in the bath, peaks when Selene sees the scars, explodes when she sees... everything below the waterline, and then—she RUNS. And Adrian follows with this incredible pivot from embarrassed servant to alone-in-a-dark-room unraveling. The Medea backstory is dropped right in the middle of Selene's panic spiral like 'by the way, falling in love with an Offenburg got my entire species enslaved.' It's so efficient. Then we cut to Adrian watching her flee and the emotional whiplash continues. The chapter structure itself mirrors the relationship—tight, claustrophobic spaces giving way to vast historical context, then back to raw intimacy. The pacing never lets up and I'm just here living in this fever dream.
... Read More
'Not a single one had closed. Her magic clearly was not reaching this child.' This line hit me like a physical blow and I need to sit with it for a minute. The wounds are the obvious symbol — the scars from old abuse, the fresh whip marks, the throat injury that could have silenced him permanently. But I think the deeper symbolism is in what the author calls them: 'a body so covered in wounds' that Selene initially wonders if his tongue was cut out. Every scar is evidence of a story we're only beginning to understand, and the fact that they won't heal — not even with witch magic — suggests that some damage operates outside the normal rules of this world. The name 'Emil' functions as a powerful symbol too. In a world where he's been treated as disposable imperial property, receiving a name is an act of radical recognition. It's not just identity — it's the assertion that he exists as a person who can be known. When he says 'I like it,' that tiny flicker of pleasure is the first genuine emotion we see on his face since he appeared. The name is a key, and it's opening a door that's been locked for a very long time. But I keep coming back to the forest. Ida Forest — 'the far western edge of that vast empire.' It's a liminal space, neither fully human nor fully magical, neither safe nor dangerous. It exists on the margins, just like the witches who live there. And it's in this in-between place that something impossible happens: an imperial child and a witch form a bond that transcends the ancient hatred between their peoples. The forest itself becomes a symbol of what's possible when the rigid structures of power temporarily dissolve. The domestic objects — the blanket, the soup, the clothes, the fruit — they're all symbols of normalcy that neither of them has ever truly had. A clean blanket tucked around a child. Fresh fruit sliced and arranged prettily. These aren't luxuries; they're proof that a different life is possible. And yet Selene's bathroom is a complete disaster, which feels like the author's way of saying: the future is uncertain, the world is messy, but we're trying anyway.
... Read More
Okay so the scene where Selene grabs Emil's hand on the way back from the village? I literally had to put the book down for a second. This woman has lived for centuries, surrounded by other witches who literally despise humans, and yet here she is walking through a market holding a human boy's hand like it's the most natural thing in the world. And Emil—oh god, Emil. He stares at her like she's the only person in the universe. The text says 'in all the world, only she remained' and I just... the devotion in that kid is terrifying and beautiful at the same time. But then later when she calls him her 'apprentice' in front of everyone and he feels this weird ache in his chest because part of him wants to be more to her but he can't say that, he has to bury it—that's the kind of heartbreaking subtlety that makes this relationship hit so hard. He's sitting on a secret that could destroy everything, and he's just trying to hold onto these moments where she looks at him with warmth. And the ending of this batch—when he drops to his knees and sobs 'I'm sorry for being Offenburg' while she's standing there like a lifeless doll? That's not just drama, that's two people who genuinely care about each other being torn apart by forces neither of them chose.
... Read More
Okay, let me just— that bath scene. Where Selene discovers Adrian's scars? I had to pause the book. The author drops this revelation that those aren't battle wounds at all but traces of buse, childhood whipping, inflicted ON THE SON OF THE FIRST EMPRESS. Who does that? And then Adrian's reaction—calling her insolent but immediately pulling her hand to his lips—is such a masterclass in unreliable narrator energy. He's testing her, manipulating the moment, and we as readers get this gorgeous juxtaposition: Selene sees someone vulnerable beneath the emperor's armor while Adrian sees a chance to draw her closer. The plot is building these layers like an onion and I am wheezing.
... Read More
The Ida Forest is such a gorgeous concept and I need to talk about it. It's described as the LAST place the vanished witches stayed until the very end, and ALL that residual power soaked into the land itself. That means the trees, the creatures, the grass — everything there is basically saturated with old magic. And the animals can COMMUNE with witches. This isn't just background scenery, it's a living ecosystem built on centuries of witch energy. But the REAL mind-blower is the pond. A gate. A literal portal to the witches' land sitting right past her cabin. She doesn't go through it, but she says 'just knowing it was nearby put her at ease.' That one line hit me so hard. She's literally living on the threshold between two worlds — human village below, witch domain nearby — and she exists in that liminal space by choice. Her cabin is invisible to humans thanks to wards and rumors, but the only visitors are small animals. The isolation is complete, but she's not lonely. Or at least, she's figured out how to be alone without feeling it. The contrast between the cozy ramshackle exterior and the well-ordered magical interior mirrors Selene herself: looks like a harmless village doctor, actually is an ancient being who could level the whole place if she wanted to.
... Read More
Okay so I just had to sit with this chapter for a bit. The emotional whiplash here is INSANE and I need to talk about it. On the surface, this is a cat-and-mouse scene between Selene and Offenburg—she's hiding her magic, he's sniffing around like a predator who knows something's off. But underneath? This is about the ghost of a boy named Emil. Every time Adrian looks at Selene now, he's not just seeing a witch who tricked his soldiers. He's seeing the hands that once bandaged HIS finger, the face that used to look at him with genuine worry when he was nine years old and scraped his knee. "That technique... is the same as ever." He says it so casually, but my heart actually LURCHED. Because what he's really saying is: I remember you. I remember who you were when you thought I was just a messy kid. And Selene—oh god, Selene. She keeps trying to survive this encounter, but every time Adrian touches her arm or grabs her wrist, I swear the narrative itself holds its breath. The tension isn't just romantic, it's layered with twelve years of unresolved history. She loved him once (as Emil), she saw him as a child, and now he's the Emperor who could have her burned alive, and she can't stop herself from panicking around him because part of her still sees the little boy who begged her to fix his finger. There's this one moment where Adrian recalls the past—the clumsy hands, the worried face—and suddenly the narrative slips into first-person thought from HIS perspective. That shift hit me like a truck. He's not just observing her; he's RELIVING something. And then the next thought that follows is absolutely devastating: "And yet you threw him away, Selene." THREW HIM AWAY. Like she chose the sisters over him. Like she chose magic over the boy who trusted her. And now here they are, and she's flustered and trembling and he's... what? Hurt? Angry? Both? The emotional stakes in this single scene are so high I couldn't breathe. Does he know she never really abandoned him? Or does that matter anymore?

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or