Do Not Believe in That Romance - Reviews

Do Not Believe in That Romance
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay first of all - Carlson Turner is my new favorite character and I need everyone to understand why his dialogue is perfect. When he says 'Oh, right. Where exactly would you like to go? It'd be nice to know the destination at least' - that's not just exposition. That's a guy trying to play along while secretly taking notes. His voice is this perfect blend of earnest knight and sharp investigator. He's pretending to be casually interested in Beatrice's hobbies while actually mapping out everything she knows. And the way he mimics killing someone by sliding his hand across his neck when talking about Azrael? That's such a natural, human gesture. You can HEAR the casual familiarity in his voice. 'Without Adam around, that's honestly a relief. If it weren't for you, our commander would've been...' *chopping motion* He's testing her reaction. Is she proud? Flattered? Manipulative? Beatrice just plays along - 'I hope Sir Azrael thinks about me' - sweet, innocent voice, absolutely calculated. The dialogue between them is this dance. Every line has two meanings. When Carlson asks 'Aren't you... the Crown Prince's...?' he's probing. When Beatrice gives that bitter smile and says 'Do you truly think so?' then 'Never mind' - she's redirecting. She wants him to pity her, not question her. And it WORKS. He buys it. You can see him softening in real time. But the best part is how the author handles the silence. After Beatrice's 'I hope Sir Azrael thinks about me,' there's this pause. Carlson 'awkwardly smiling and scratching his neck.' He doesn't know how to respond to that level of vulnerability - or is it vulnerability? The author uses physical description to fill the gaps where dialogue can't. That's masterful voice work. Everyone speaks differently: Carlson is brisk and practical, Beatrice is layered and controlled, Azrael's absence is felt through how others reference him.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author controls tension across these chapters because it is WICKED. We start slow. Beatrice in the greenhouse, spring flowers, casual conversation with Carlson. It feels like a slice-of-life moment. You're settling in, thinking this might be a gentle character study. Then they go to the dressmaker's shop - still low stakes, right? Just shopping, talking about Azrael, flirting with the idea of romance. Carlson asks if she's interested in their commander. She plays coy. We're still in 'comfortable reading' territory. And then she asks about shoes. AND THEN - she leads him to the river. AND THEN - corpse. The pivot from 'let's browse some fabric' to 'look at this dead body floating downstream' happens so fast my stomach dropped. But here's what's brilliant: the author doesn't rush the buildup. Every scene before the discovery serves a purpose. The dressmaker conversation establishes Carlson as Azrael's eyes and ears. The shoe shopping shows Beatrice's calculation - she's curating her image. The walk to the river feels almost idyllic before everything shatters. Then CUT TO Azrael at the investigation headquarters. Reports, documents, waiting for a messenger bird that never comes. The clock is ticking. He's getting restless. We're building that dread - something is wrong, we can feel it. And then the chapter ENDS with the coachman saying 'Miss Delphinium hasn't returned.' Cut to black. Cliffhanger. The structure here is: domestic scene → social scene → outdoor scene → discovery → parallel investigation → cliffhanger. Each section escalates. The pacing never lulls. I went from 'nice spring day' to 'god help us all' in the span of three pages.
... Read More
Let's be real — the first chapter is a masterclass in tension-building. We open with a DEAD BODY. Not just any body — a mutilated one, with flowers arranged on its face. Immediate hook. No setup, no worldbuilding preamble, just: here is a crime scene and a woman who is clearly not normal. Then we cut to the ambush. Same night. Same rain. Azrael gets hit from behind, tries to chase the attacker, fails, accepts his death — and THEN Beatrice appears. Two threads cross in the rain. The serial killer saves the investigator. The pacing here is sharp. Every paragraph pushes forward. Chapter 1.2 shifts to recovery mode, which could have dragged, but the author keeps it moving by having Azrael immediately transition from 'barely conscious' to 'surveying the room like a hawk.' The tension never fully drops — it just changes frequency. The newspaper scene is a smart pivot. Beatrice had it lying around specifically for him. It's a plot device that also reveals character — she's been waiting, she's been reading about his cases, she knew exactly what would catch his attention. And ending on the crime scene investigation? Perfect. We get fresh details about the ninth victim — the position of the body, the rain not washing away blood, the facial mutilation pattern — and the chapter cuts before we learn anything conclusive. The investigation is just beginning and we're already hooked. My only complaint: Carlson exists and I need him in every chapter. 'Did you get into a brawl with a drunkard?' This man has survived nine serial killer incidents and still thinks his commander got beat up by an alcoholic. The pacing of his comic relief timing is impeccable.
... Read More
Can we just take a moment for Adam though? This man is literally holding Beatrice's hands, listening to her talk about her own execution like she's describing the weather, and he just... stays. "Your master is a murderer" — she says this to him, fully aware he knows, fully aware he's not leaving. He's described as a "foolish man who couldn't abandon her even though she had gone mad and killed people." My heart. Meanwhile, Azrael's whole dynamic with Beatrice is so tangled — she saves his life, touches his face checking his fever, whispers "you" like she wants something no one else can give her, and then immediately covers it with a joke when he flusters. She calls him by title but asks if she's being rude for worrying. He tells her to hide next time instead of letting her risk herself. These two are walking around each other like moths around a flame and neither will admit they're already burned. And Carlson is out here shipping the Commander with someone who belongs to the Crown Prince. Comedy gold, but also tragic if you think about it.
... Read More
Carlson Turner might be the most naturally conversational protagonist I've encountered in ages. Watch how he works a room—literally. He walks into the estate, meets a group of servants carrying heavy boxes, and within thirty seconds he's picked one up and said 'Come on, what kind of knight would I be if I couldn't carry something like this?' That's not manipulation, that's just genuine warmth wrapped in self-deprecating humor. And it WORKS. The servants lower their guards immediately. Compare that to Adam, who speaks in clipped, careful sentences like every word has been vetted: 'You certainly ask a lot of questions.' 'As I said, her mind is not entirely sound.' 'Do not pay attention to it.' Adam's dialogue is a fortress. Carlson's is an open door. But here's what's fascinating—the author lets Carlson's casual chatter accidentally uncover REAL information. He asks about ghosts as a JOKE and Ayla spills an entire backstory about the previous maid who quit because she 'started hearing voices and seeing things.' He mentions the doctor offhandedly and a servant corrects him with 'he arrived about five months ago'—which Carlson immediately uses to piece together that Beatrice's supposed recuperation timeline doesn't add up. The dialogue feels so natural that you forget the author is using it as an interrogation tool. Even Carlson himself doesn't seem fully aware of how effective he is. 'I was just kidding. Surely there aren't actual ghosts here, right?' ...and somehow that exact phrase is what makes Ayla CONFESS everything. Brilliant writing.
... Read More
Let me just say this: the sensory writing in this passage is unmatched. The very first thing I noticed was the sound. When Azrael opens the box, it makes this crinkling noise—paper on paper, ribbon sliding free—and you're suddenly in the room. You can hear the investigators murmuring behind him, you can hear his own heartbeat pounding in his ears. The author doesn't tell you he's panicking. You HEAR it. Then the carriage scene. April 6, 1899, 2 AM. The innkeeper was too terrified to touch it. An intelligent horse driving a carriage back to its shelter like it had somewhere to be. That image—this horse, this mechanical precision, this corpse waiting inside—stayed with me. The scratches on the carriage door. The strange odor that made Azrael grimace. The lantern light cutting through darkness, revealing Thomas's face, the ring on his finger, the wilted chrysanthemum in his hand. Each detail was a brushstroke. And the basement. Water droplets from the ceiling. Cold brick walls and floor. Flickering lights. The smell of oil and blood and something older—damp earth, maybe, from the mountain path above. Robert sharpening that axe in the corner, the dull blade smeared with flesh. Beatrice sitting calmly while ropes cut into her wrists. When Azrael throws the lantern, the shards scattering, the oil catching fire on Robert's face, the way the flames illuminated the basement before spreading to his skin—I could feel the heat. I could feel the smoke. The mountain cabin itself was once a resting place for coachmen. Now it's a prison. The transformation of ordinary spaces into something sinister is a recurring pattern in this story, and it works beautifully. You never forget where you are. The geography feels real—narrow basement corridors, locked windows, the distant sound of twelve knights approaching on a mountain path. This isn't a vague fantasy setting. It has texture. It has weight. It has water dripping from ceilings.
... Read More
Let me just start by saying I do not trust either of these people and I am HERE for it. Azrael wakes up after almost dying and his FIRST instinct isn't 'who saved me' or 'I need to report this' — it's 'let me survey the room and figure out where I am like I'm still on patrol.' The man is so deeply embedded in his investigative habits that even barely conscious, his brain is doing threat assessment. Which honestly makes me kinda respect him? But then Beatrice — oh my god. She kneels in front of his bed like he's some kind of religious artifact. 'My name is Beatrice. From now on, we'll be seeing each other quite often.' She's literally introducing herself to a man who can't yet sit up without holding his head. And the most terrifying part? She means it. 'I intend to love you from now on. Until you love me wholeheartedly.' She says this with the same tone someone would use to say 'I'll water your plants while you're away.' Like obsession is just a daily chore. 'I hope you'll be like them, loving me so deeply that you'll blind yourself to the truth… even just a little.' THEY DON'T EVEN KNOW EACH OTHER AND SHE'S ALREADY PLANNING HIS DOWNFALL. But here's what's fascinating — Azrael doesn't freak out. He doesn't call security. He says 'thank you' and then immediately goes to the crime scene. He treats her like a slightly eccentric noblewoman who happens to have saved his life. The man has the emotional response of someone ordering coffee. And Carlson, bless his red-headed heart, walks in and immediately asks about Azrael's injuries like nothing serious happened. 'What's with the bandages on your head? Did you get into a brawl with a drunkard?' I swear to god this guy is gonna be the comic relief that somehow survives everything.
... Read More
There's so much going on beneath the surface of this opening and I need to unpack it. The flowers. Beatrice brings CHrysanthemums — traditionally funeral flowers in many cultures — to a mutilated corpse and arranges them on his face. This isn't just aesthetic. It's ritual. She's performing grief she doesn't feel for people she destroyed. The drying blood being absorbed by the stems? That's intimate violence dressed as tenderness. Every time she places flowers, she's marking her work. The rain is another massive symbol. 'It rained every year during this season.' Rain that washes away evidence. Rain that drowns sound. Rain that turns blood into pink rivers. But here's the thing — at the crime scene, the rain STOPS. 'It rained continuously until the night before. Yet when the body was found, there were no traces of blood being washed away.' The killer controls the weather. Or rather, the killer controls WHEN the rain falls, so the evidence remains. Red eyes and white hair — Beatrice's descriptions repeatedly emphasize these. 'The color of blood' for her eyes. White hair that cascades like something out of a painting. She's positioned as otherworldly, almost angelic, which makes her violence more disturbing. An angel who kills isn't monstrous — she's DIVINE. And that's exactly the message she's sending. Azrael's title itself is loaded. 'Azrael Hyacinth.' Azrael is the archangel of death in Islamic and Christian tradition. Hyacinth is a flower — another botanical reference connecting to Beatrice's floral motifs. The investigator who investigates death is named after death itself. This isn't accidental naming. The author is building a cosmology where killer and hunter are mirrors. 'I intend to love you from now on. Until you love me wholeheartedly.' Love as control. Love as blindness. Love as the mechanism by which the killer consumes her prey. The theme here is clear: this story is about the violence of obsession, dressed in the language of romance.
... Read More
This entire passage is about how grief manifests—and how the living deal with it (or fail to). The ghost story is the most obvious layer: servants hear screams and sobbing at night, a previous maid quit after seeing apparitions, everyone agrees the Countess's spirit haunts the villa. But Carlson, being a rational investigator who's seen countless corpses, immediately dismisses it. 'If vengeful spirits existed, he would have met one by now.' And yet—what if the ghosts ARE real, just not in the way anyone thinks? The Countess died in childbirth. The daughter was sent to recuperate at the very place where her mother died. The father preserves her room exactly as it was while neglecting his living daughter. Who's the real ghost here? Beatrice, who 'has never smiled' until recently, who sleepwalks through corridors like a person already half-dead inside—that's the haunting. The Earl is haunting his own home, trapped in a cemetery of memories, and Beatrice is collateral damage. Even the doctor arriving FIVE MONTHS after Beatrice supposedly came for recuperation is symbolic: the family only sought help when the symptoms became impossible to ignore, not when they began. And the sleeping aids? She can't sleep because she's living in her mother's death. The third floor being restricted, the locked Earl's room versus the unlocked Countess's room—these are all physical manifestations of emotional walls. The author isn't just writing a mystery; she's writing about how trauma moves through generations and how houses remember what people try to forget.
... Read More
I'm not even going to pretend I handled this emotionally. Beatrice—pure white hair, calm as stone, watching Robert sharpen that blood-caked axe—she didn't cry. Not once. And that somehow broke my heart more than any scream could have. When Robert presses the blade to her neck and she LEANS INTO IT, saying ‘You shouldn't harm your precious hostage,' I literally sat there stunned. She's playing him. She KNOWS he needs her alive. And she's absolutely fearless. ‘Did you make good use of the chrysanthemums I bought? I wonder if Mr. Thomas carried them well.' What. A. Scene. She's interrogating her own kidnapper like they're having tea. But then—the tremble. When Azrael finally appears and Beatrice's shoulders start shaking, I realized something devastating. She'd been holding it together for HIM. For Azrael. Every second of composure was a performance because she knew he was coming and she needed him to find her alive. The moment her gaze meets Robert's after he's subdued and she smiles faintly—that's not triumph. That's relief so deep it bypasses everything else. And Azrael kneeling before her, saying ‘I apologize for being late'—I couldn't breathe. After everything, after the hair, after the carriage, after nine bodies on his conscience, he shows up and his first words are an apology. Not ‘are you okay.' Not ‘I've got you.' Just… sorry I'm late. Like he failed her personally. That's love. Not romantic love necessarily—something deeper, more ancient. A knight's devotion to someone who saw him when no one else did. The red ribbon. It's everywhere. On Beatrice's hair. Wrapped around Thomas's corpse. Tied on the package. It's the killer's signature, yes—but it's also a wedding ribbon. A gift bow. The killer is dressing murder in the aesthetics of affection. And Beatrice, the one with the white hair and the steady voice, is the only person who turns that symbol back on its head. She wears the red ribbon's threat like armor.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about the opening moment because it stuck with me for days. Azrael picks up this package—simple paper wrapping, crinkling sound—and when he opens it, there's a lock of pure white hair tied with a red ribbon. Beatrice's hair. That's it. No note, no demands, just… her hair. And I swear that was more terrifying than any graphic description could be. The author doesn't even explain who sent it. You're just dropped into Azrael's panic and you feel it. Then the carriage comes back by itself. Driverless. An intelligent horse guiding it home like some grotesque delivery service. And inside—Thomas Hill. Wrapped in that same red ribbon like a present. The neck was barely attached because the axe was dull, which is such a specific, horrifying detail. It means the killer wasn't proficient. Or wasn't trying to be clean. It was messier than that. Brutal. And the twist? Robert isn't a victim. He's the killer. The Netheren Street Serial Killer all along. I literally gasped. All those missing persons, the nine previous murders, and Robert was playing them like instruments. The way Azrael pieces it together—Beatrice's hair, Thomas's corpse, Robert's carriage—all connected to him personally. Convenient tools. That line hit me like a truck. But the real structural genius is how the killer's pattern shifts. The previous nine cases had a certain method, a certain elegance. This time feels different. Slower. Almost careless. Is that intentional? Is Robert losing control, or is this another layer of the design? Azrael himself wonders: ‘Perhaps this too is part of the culprit's design?' And I couldn't shake that uncertainty. The plot kept me up reading because I genuinely didn't know who to trust or what the killer's endgame was. By the time Beatrice says ‘Sir Azrael is different' with that eerie smile, I was completely invested. Who IS she, honestly?
... Read More
I cannot stop reading this section. Let me explain why. The chapter opens with Robert the coachman testifying about the barrel—slow, methodical, almost documentary-like. It feels like a standard detective procedural moment. You think you know where this is going. Then BOOM. The timeline snaps together. The mountain path explains the bruises. The warehouse timing overlaps with Azrael's attack. It all clicks and suddenly the reader is leaning forward because the pieces are moving faster than they expected. Then we cut to Beatrice and Adam walking down the street, and the entire energy shifts from procedural to psychological thriller in about three lines. One moment they're walking, the next she's saying she hopes Azrael dies for her. The tonal whiplash is intentional and it works perfectly because it mirrors how Beatrice herself operates—calm on the surface, unhinged underneath. And then the chapter pivots again into the missing persons crisis. Three people gone in one day. Two received forged letters from Azrael himself. The pace accelerates further because every paragraph introduces a new complication: Robert and Thomas are missing, the letters implicate Azrael, the culprit knows his handwriting, and now Beatrice too. By the time Azrael steps outside and hears the commotion about a suspicious package at the headquarters, my heart was literally racing. And then the chapter cuts off mid-sentence with 'There's no'—classic cliffhanger. What's impressive is how the author controls the tempo. The Robert testimony section is deliberately slow and detailed, which makes the Beatrice scene feel like a release of tension, which then gets immediately swallowed by the rising panic of three missing persons. The structure is basically a series of escalating waves, and each wave crashes higher than the last. The transition from the quiet flower shop trail (white-haired woman, chrysanthemums) back into the chaotic headquarters scene is also smooth—the author uses the dead end of the carriage investigation to transition into the next burst of action. If I had one tiny critique, the gap between April 1st and April 5th is just a line break. I wanted more there. But honestly, the payoff is so good I forgive it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or