Okay, I need to sit with the birthday flashback for a moment because it quietly destroyed me.
The scene starts almost casually—playing marbles, cherry-stealing from the kitchen, Lanen complaining about having to stay home while her family goes on a boating holiday. She's twelve. He's her manservant. Everything about their dynamic is already there: the power imbalance she doesn't fully grasp, the familiarity that looks like friendship but carries something heavier underneath.
Then Cedarwood asks what people usually do on their birthdays. Just that. Not "what do you want"—"what do people usually do." As if he has no framework for this concept at all. He knows his own birthday vaguely, somewhere in winter, and when Tommy shows off his pocket watch gift, he genuinely doesn't understand the excitement.
So Lanen tells him about her lemon pie, the scented soap, the chapel, and the nun who gives her two eggs. And Cedarwood's response is this devastatingly matter-of-fact line: "Two eggs can buy you a pouch of barley."
She had asked him what he wanted for a birthday gift. Something other than eggs or barley. And instead of answering directly, he gives her back the marble she rolled to him—the rough blue one with air bubbles, worthless, the kind you'd lose after one game and never look for. But earlier the text tells us: the boy kept it in his hand for no clear reason other than that she'd given it to him.
His conclusion about why he asked about her birthday: "he was curious about what was precious to her, what his lady would hold dear."
That is the most Cedarwood thing ever. He doesn't know what to give someone he cares about, so he researches the concept of "precious" by listening to her describe what she treasures. Two eggs. Barley. A lemon pie.
And years later, he's doing the exact same thing with her escape. Preparing snacks she likes. Buying cigarettes she needs. Anticipating every variable. His language for caring is always practical, always indirect, always disguised as something else. "I promise," he says when she asks him to take responsibility for her running away. Not "I won't let you go." Just "I promise."