By Your Side, Where You Hate Me - Reviews

By Your Side, Where You Hate Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
"Belongs to us as a couple?" And then Rupert just loses it completely. I need to talk about how this entire sequence is engineered—because on the surface it's a domestic dispute over money and a hotel deed, but by the time the chapter ends, everything you thought you knew about this marriage has been upended. The setup is brilliant in hindsight. You get the explosive confrontation first, Rupert's drunken tirade about being looked down upon, the way he circles back to the same wound over and over—father-in-law favored his daughter, the textile business failed, he's a joke. Then the assault happens, and for a second I thought this was just going to be a brutal scene about abuse. But then the author flips it. Rupert tries to violate Yvonne and physically can't perform. Not metaphorically—literally. And instead of any mercy or hesitation from him, he doubles down and blames her. "You probably think I'm a pathetic man." This is where the plot goes from standard marital drama into something far more psychologically intricate. And then—the cut. After Yvonne is left alone sobbing in that bedroom, the narrative pivots to her visit to the abandoned hunting ground, where we learn about Theodore, the first love she abandoned, who died in war. She thinks her suffering is punishment. She thinks she deserves it. And the absolute gut-punch: she's waiting for him to come back from the dead to ruin her life, because catastrophe would be a kind of mercy compared to this slow death she's living. But here's what really got me: the final scene with Hugo Wenner. New character, new location, gunshots, birds falling. It feels completely disconnected from the Yvonne-Rupert thread, but I'm suspicious. This author doesn't drop scenes like that for nothing. Hugo is clearly someone significant, and the fact that he's in a massive mansion shooting birds—a parallel to the hunting ground imagery, a parallel to the violence that just happened in that bedroom—this structural echo is too deliberate to ignore. The plot isn't linear. It's braided.
... Read More
'Yvonne's heart burned black.' That line has been running through my head like a mantra. Let me explain why this hits so hard. Yvonne spent seven years believing Theodore was dead. She grieved him. She moved on. She built a life with people who despise her, all while guarding that one precious place — the hunting ground — as the last physical connection to the man she lost. And then HE walks in alive. Not as the gentle Theodore, but as Hugo Wenner, a man whose love has curdled into something sharp enough to cut. The moment their eyes meet across the crowded room, the author writes: 'His gaze fixed on one spot, as if iron drawn to a magnet.' That's not just physical attraction, that's the gravitational pull of two souls that were never meant to separate. But the tragedy is that neither of them can access that truth anymore. Hugo can't remember love without feeling betrayal. Yvonne can't see her Theo without seeing a stranger determined to destroy her. And the worst part — the part that made me genuinely ache — is Yvonne realizing that even if Theodore came back, the man who loved her is dead. What stands in his place is someone who uses cruelty as armor. She wanted him to return to save her, but not like this. Not as a weapon pointed at her heart.
... Read More
Let me just say—the pacing in these chapters is absolutely razor-sharp. We start with Yvonne doing something incredibly mundane: writing a reply to a proposal, sealing it with wax, stamping it with the hotel seal. Calculator in hand, ledger open. This is a woman who finds comfort in routine, in numbers, in control. And then Silvia bursts in. The interruption shatters that calm immediately. The author doesn't ease us into the emotional turbulence; she just throws us in. Silvia's demands, the coffee, the pleading, the mention of Theodore's name (indirectly, through Hugo Wenner) —it all accelerates so quickly. Then they walk to Chester Street. Thirty-minute walk from the hotel, quiet morning, shops opening. The pacing slows down almost lethargically here, making us settle into the atmosphere. And that's the trap, isn't it? The calm before the storm. We think nothing dramatic will happen on a Tuesday morning shopping trip. And then—there he is. The pacing EXPLODES. Yvonne runs. She crosses a busy street. She bumps into people. She shouts a name she's buried for years. The sentences get shorter, more urgent. “Theo, Theodore…!” Just the name, repeated, desperate. And then—stop. The alley is empty. Time seems to freeze. “There's no way the dead Theodore could appear here, how foolish…” The prose goes quiet again, heavier this time. The final section with Caroline and Silvia getting ready feels almost surreal in its normalcy. Of course they're discussing hair ornaments while Yvonne's world is crumbling. That contrast is the author's signature move—juxtaposing the intimate with the mundane, the devastating with the trivial. The chapter ending on that shoe in the alley is pure cliffhanger energy. But it's understated. No dramatic flourish. Just a shoe. That restraint makes it infinitely more powerful.
... Read More
I need to talk about Rupert Greenwood because my blood is literally boiling. This man is a walking red flag wrapped in a title. He shows up to a banquet, gets ignored by society, and instead of owning it or working on himself, he takes it out on his wife? Of course he does. When Yvonne tries to help him by mentioning his connection to the Rosier family, he snaps at her in front of everyone. Then he hides behind a pillar and accuses her of butting into men's conversations—like she's the problem. The audacity. The absolute gaslighting. And the worst part? He mentions Marianne by name right before walking away. His mistress. In front of his wife of seven years. Like she's nothing. Like their entire marriage is disposable to him. Meanwhile, Yvonne is quietly crumbling. She followed him because she cares. She tried to help him gain respect through her own social capital. And what does she get in return? Abuse. Coldness. Public humiliation. I felt so much pain watching her wipe her tears and force herself back into the crowd. She's surrounded by people—her mother-in-law, her sister-in-law, even her husband's whole family—and she feels more alone than ever. ‘They showed not the slightest interest in her.' They treat her like an employee who increases their wealth. The emotional abuse here is so layered. It's not just Rupert being cruel—it's the entire social system that enables him. But also—and this is what keeps me up at night—what is Theodore doing here? The text says Yvonne ‘cruelly abandoned' him. What happened? Why did she leave a man she calls ‘the only lover of her life'? And now he's alive and staring at her across a crowded ballroom? I need answers.
... Read More
I need to just sit with this scene for a moment. Yvonne sees Theodore—a man she believed was dead, a man she hadn't cried for in her dreams because she assumed he couldn't forgive her—and she just RUNS. Not gracefully. She pulls up her dress hem, ignores social conventions, bumps into strangers, doesn't apologize. This isn't the composed hotel manager we've been watching all chapter. This is a woman who has carried grief for years and suddenly gets a crack of hope. The line “The name she hadn't called for so long flowed out like tears welling up” is absolutely devastating. She shouts “Theo, Theodore…!” into a street full of people and he just keeps walking. The indifference of his back growing more distant… god. And then the alley. Empty. Just like her hope. “There's no way the dead Theodore could appear here, how foolish…” She's blaming herself immediately. That's the trauma talking—she can't accept that maybe he IS alive and just didn't recognize her, or deliberately avoided her. No, it's easier to believe she imagined it. Meanwhile Silvia is inside the dress shop picking accessories, completely unaware that her sister-in-law just had her world upended. The contrast between their emotional states is brutal. One woman is chasing a ghost; the other is chasing a wealthy husband. Both are chasing something they can't quite grasp. And that final image—the shoe stepping out of the alley after she's left—I lost it. Someone was there. Someone watched her run into the shop. Did Theodore follow her? Or was it someone else entirely? My heart actually ached reading that.
... Read More
I cannot stop thinking about the dialogue in these chapters because every line is doing double, triple, sometimes quadruple duty. Let me break down what makes it so brilliant. Take Hugo's famous line: 'Because something I have desired for a long time—an excessively long time—to the point of weariness, is currently in this Greenwood family.' On the surface, he's answering Caroline's question about what brought him there. To anyone watching, it could mean anything — a business partner, a romantic interest, even the hunting ground itself. But Yvonne knows exactly what it means, and that's the entire point. The author has created a dialogue system where what is said and what is understood live in completely different worlds. Hugo's rejection of Silvia's hand kiss is another gem — 'a simple handshake seems more appropriate' — delivered with such polished politeness that it stings twice as hard. Meanwhile, the Greenwoods' dialogue is almost comically vulgar in its greed. Caroline: 'If only you could build a bridge between Lord Wenner and me using this hunting ground deal!' This is a woman literally trying to sell her sister-in-law's emotional trauma as a business opportunity. The contrast between Hugo's coded elegance and the Greenwoods' crass transparency tells you everything about who belongs in this world and who doesn't.
... Read More
Okay let's talk about how this author writes dialogue because it is genuinely masterful. The conversation between Rupert and Yvonne behind the pillar? Perfect. Absolute perfection. Rupert's voice is so distinct—narcissistic, deflected, deeply insecure. ‘What gives you, a woman, the right to butt into gentlemen's conversations!' The fact that he blames her for helping him? That's classic abuser language, and the author nails it without ever being preachy. Then Yvonne's response—so soft, so defeated. ‘Rupert, I just wanted the gentlemen to respect you a little more…' She's literally apologizing for caring about him. And his reply? ‘Do you have to act so superior and break my spirit to feel satisfied…!' He turns her kindness into an attack. The dialogue here is so natural it hurts. Every line reveals character. Rupert's neuroticism, Yvonne's exhaustion, the power dynamic—all captured in three exchanges. And then the social scene with Lord Allen? Brilliant contrast. The way the gentlemen's attitudes flip when Yvonne mentions the Rosier connection—‘Interest that hadn't been there before seeped into Lord Allen's eyes.' The dialogue exposes their hypocrisy instantly. ‘My husband has a thoughtful side to him.' He says this about Rupert, who just spent five minutes being ignored and mocked. The social maneuvering in the dialogue is razor-sharp. And Hugo's lines—sparse, cold, arrogant—contrast beautifully with everyone else's verbose social performance. ‘I will consider your repeated rejections of my acquisition proposal as something I haven't seen yet.' That's not just business talk. That's a man who's used to getting what he wants. The author's voice handles intimacy, cruelty, and social satire all in one chapter without breaking stride. Incredible.
... Read More
This section of the story is structured around two parallel power struggles and I love how they mirror each other. On one side, you've got Caroline and Silvia trying to take Yvonne's dress — a small, domestic-level power grab. On the other side, you've got Hugo Wenner trying to get the hunting ground from Yvonne — a larger, economic-level power grab. Both are about extracting something from her that she refuses to give up easily. The dress scene is deceptively simple but it sets up so much. Caroline asks for Yvonne's opinion on Silvia's hair ornaments, but really she's sizing Yvonne up. She notices the dress immediately — "That's a dress I haven't seen before?" Her tone is pure displeasure, like Yvonne having a moment of happiness annoys her. Then the switch request: Caroline frames it as selfless concern for Silvia but really it's about control. Silvia "licked her lips" at the dress — that detail is disgusting and telling. What saves Yvonne from having to switch is... time pressure. Not courage, not solidarity, just the fact that Rupert bursts in and complains about being late. The universe basically intervenes because the characters can't do it themselves. I found that kind of bitter funny. Then the Hugo thread gets introduced through Yvonne's letter exchange. Her reply where she offers to let him USE the hunting ground but not buy it, with the strict condition about the cabin, is such a smart move. She's being diplomatic while still holding the line. And Hugo's response — "After meeting and talking with me directly, I'm certain your thoughts will change, madam" — is almost comically arrogant. He's used to getting what he wants and can't imagine someone saying no. The chapter ends with James noting Hugo's new habit of checking himself in the mirror constantly. This is a man who never cared about appearances before and now he's nervous. Because Yvonne Rosier is attending his banquet. The plot is building toward a confrontation and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
Okay, so the dynamics in this section are absolutely BRUTAL and I need to talk about it because there are three women locked in this toxic triangle and the power shifts are fascinating. First, Caroline. Yvonne literally describes her mother-in-law's insecurity as "landmines—impossible to predict when or where they might explode." And that line hit me so hard because it's not just description, it's survival advice. Yvonne knows exactly how to walk through her own house without setting off a bomb. And yet—she still slips up on the word "education." Of course she does. It's the one thing she can't control because it's genuine. Her father actually DID give her noble education, and Caroline's entire identity is built on not having had that. When Caroline explodes, she's not really angry at Yvonne. She's angry at herself. "No matter how uneducated I might be, do you think I wouldn't understand even that level of social conversation!" The tragedy here is that Caroline is both the abuser AND a victim of her own insecurity. She was a mistress who rose to countess, and every interaction with Yvonne reminds her that she'll never truly belong to that world. So she takes it out on the one person who's vulnerable: Yvonne, whose father just died. But then there's Marianne. And this is where it gets messy. Marianne is everything Caroline isn't—confident, sexual, unapologetic about who she is. But she's also deeply aware of her place in the hierarchy. When she says to Yvonne, "I've often heard about you from 'Ru'" — she's testing her. And when Yvonne calmly replies, "Unfortunately, I cannot say I'm pleased to meet you," Marianne feels it like a physical blow. She says it herself: "That woman... is she looking down on me?" The most chilling moment though is Rupert's behavior. He's the common thread binding all three women together, and he's completely broken. The fact that he was willing to cheat but got mad that Marianne was being disrespectful to his wife — not because he felt guilty, but because her behavior reflected poorly on HIM. That's not love. That's ownership. And Yvonne knows it. She's still standing there in the middle of it all, asking him to be a husband, and he can barely look at her without seeing her as the reason he can't function as a man.
... Read More
The dress in this passage is doing so much symbolic work. Silvia wants a Markel-style dress from Madame Roland's boutique. Five million gold. Not because she loves fashion, but because it's armor for a battlefield she's entering—the banquet where she hopes to secure a wealthy husband. The dress is transactional. It's a costume for performance. Meanwhile Yvonne's world is built on appearances too. The Rosier Hotel seal on her letters. The calculated kindness she shows Silvia. The composed manager who never breaks down in public. But her appearance is a prison, not a costume. She's trapped behind the role of competent widow and dutiful sister-in-law. Theledgers and calculators Yvonne returns to throughout these chapters represent order, predictability, control. Numbers don't disappear into alleyways. Numbers don't betray you. When Theodore appears, those numbers mean nothing. Her entire controlled world shatters in an afternoon. The glass windows are another brilliant symbol. Reflections vs. reality. We see Silvia's desires reflected in the shop window, and we see Yvonne's grief reflected in the same medium. Glass separates and connects simultaneously. It shows us truths while remaining fundamentally transparent—easy to look through, impossible to touch. The sealing wax on Yvonne's letter is interesting too. Brick-red. Final. Once it hardens, the message is sealed, the intent committed. There's no taking it back. Just like Theodore's death was once final—until it wasn't. And the alleyway itself—a place where things go to disappear. Where hope can vanish. Where a man's shoe can appear and then retreat into shadow. The alley is the subconscious of the story, really. The hidden spaces where truth lurks just out of sight.
... Read More
The sensory contrast in this chapter is relentless and I think that's intentional. It opens in a bedroom that feels claustrophobic—heavy with alcohol fumes, the physical space shrinking as Rupert invades it, the texture of Yvonne's torn bodice, the blanket she grabs to cover herself. Every detail is tight, suffocating, pressed against the skin. You can feel the heat of Rupert's anger and the cold of Yvonne's shock occupying the same room. Then the cut to the hunting ground and the temperature drops forty degrees. The rain has cleared the air. Plane trees display vibrant green. Withered grass crushed beneath her feet. Cobwebs on the headboard. Dust on the wooden table. A tobacco leaf box and an old book left behind like artifacts. This place is alive with absence—it's not decayed, it's preserved in the exact moment before abandonment. And Yvonne moves through it like a ghost visiting her own grave. "The scene of the deserted hunting ground was desolate and bleak. With each step, withered grass beneath her feet was crushed in the rainwater... resembling Yvonne's desolate state of mind." The author literally tells us the landscape mirrors her interior. Is that too on-the-nose? Maybe. But then it works anyway because the image sticks. And then—the Saint River at dawn. Factories emitting smoke. The black automobile cutting through morning light. Gunshots shattering the quiet. Hugo Wenner in a white shirt and navy scarf, Winchester rifle in leather-gloved hand, standing in a vast pale green plain. The transition from the intimate violence of the bedroom to this open, almost mythic landscape is jarring in the best way. The gunshot echoes the emotional violence we just witnessed, but here it's clean, controlled, purposeful. Bird falls. Another bird falls. The violence has aesthetics now. That shift from chaotic domestic cruelty to ordered, almost ritualistic hunting tells me everything I need to know about who Hugo Wenner is before he even speaks a line.
... Read More
Every time I reread this section, I keep coming back to the hunting ground. It's not just a plot device—it's Yvonne's last tether to something that belonged to her, to memories she constructed before Hugo showed up and rewrote her entire story. The family wants to sell it, Rupert begs and then threatens, Caroline calculates, Silvia is treated as currency. The land itself becomes a symbol for autonomy, for self-possession, for the one thing a woman in this world can't afford to lose. And Hugo knows it. That's why he's patient—he doesn't need to physically take anything from her; he just needs to make everyone around her hungry enough to hand it over. The mirror scene hits me the hardest though. Yvonne looking at herself, 'beautiful, but not a trace of vitality,' recognizing that she's become the villainess in someone else's revenge drama. She calls herself a 'cold-hearted villainess who had coldly rejected her lover' and I think that's the tragedy at the center of this whole book: she's internalized the narrative written about her and can't see herself as anything else. The hunting ground will be sold, the rain will fall, and she'll keep performing the role fate has assigned her. But I have a feeling Hugo's script has holes in it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or