Okay so let me just… sit with this for a second. Shin. MY GOD. The man was Chloe's pet, as she literally called him, picked from the slums and raised to be her personal butler, and he BETRAYED her. He gathered evidence. He sided with Momo. And yet — yet — when the prince orders him to be Chloe's guard, there's this entire layer of conflict I'm just obsessed with.
He thinks he's getting away from her, but he's being pulled RIGHT BACK. And Chloe? She knows. She says 'do you still remember the day we first met?' like she's pivoting mid-conversation but really she's dismantling him. She calls out how she used to treat him — 'this man is ever diligent pet' — and then, right after that, she thanks him. Not sarcastically. Not manipulatively. Actually. For keeping her company when her father was busy and her brother was distant.
And Shin's just sitting there in this horrible position where loyalty and grudge are at war inside him. Meanwhile, Leddorio is watching from the sidelines, muttering 'it's far too late for that,' because he sees Chloe's vulnerability as weakness. Darck? Darck says 'maybe if she'd been a little more cuter I would've spared her a worry.' THIS MAN IS JUST WRECKED. His comparison between Chloe and Momo is so brutally revealing — he'd kill for Momo, but Chloe 'deserves it.' That's not sibling rivalry, that's pure, unfiltered contempt masked as honesty.
But here's what keeps me up: Chloe PULLS THE BLANKET over Shin during the bandit attack. 'At the very least, at this moment, I need you by my side.' Even after everything he did, even knowing about the brooch, she's STILL protecting him. What is that? Is it manipulation? Is it genuine? Or is it just habit — the habit of someone who always took care of the people around her, even the ones who turned on her?
I need to know what Shin's face looks like when he realizes she saw through the brooch the whole time and said NOTHING.