Banished Villainess – Under Observation! - Reviews

Banished Villainess – Under Observation!
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about this scene. Leddorio confessing to Momo in the church dining hall while she's trying to eat her lunch — it's both desperate and kind of beautiful in a broken way. He literally lays it all out: "My heart had discarded Chloe just for you, and yet, would you still not choose me in return?" And Momo's response? "It hurts.." She pushes him away but then immediately deflects into talking about her sacred powers and her duty. She doesn't even answer the question about who's in her heart! Then she drops the Locke Glinda bomb like it's nothing and the reader is just sitting there screaming internally. This is the kind of love triangle that makes me want to shake the characters. Leddorio is genuinely sweet — he remembers little things like Benny working hard, he listens to complaints, he says "You are not alone, sir." But he's also so blind to the fact that Momo clearly has feelings for someone else. And that someone else is apparently a childhood friend who got taken in by an Earl house. The emotional whiplash in this chapter is unreal and I'm not okay with it.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is honestly a masterclass in subtext and I want to focus on the smallest moment that hit me the hardest. Dai says: 'Really feels like I've heard it somewhere before, Chaco Brown hmm.' And the prince responds: 'What do you mean? If there's truly somebody with that name, it might cause the person trouble.' First of all — the fact that Dai has this vague sense of recognition is doing SO much narrative work. The name 'Chaco Brown' is clearly significant, and the fact that the prince immediately senses danger in it shows he's not completely oblivious. There's history here that we haven't fully uncovered yet, and the author is carefully planting seeds. But what I also love is how each character's voice is distinct. Chloe's dialogue with Pastor Grace is warm and casual — 'Hey, what do you mean by statue?' — she's already adapted to this commoner way of speaking. Shin's dialogue with the prince is formal, clipped, laced with restrained emotion. And the prince? His dialogue is almost always in single commands. 'You are to seduce Chloe.' He doesn't explain, he doesn't negotiate. He just tells. Even when Dai groans trying to remember something, the prince 'ignored Dy [Dai] who was groaning, seemingly trying to rack his brains to remember.' He doesn't even acknowledge the effort. The narrative voice outside the dialogue is also doing interesting work — it's observant and sometimes almost ironic. 'It was natural for him to do so, thought the prince.' The prince's own narration of others' reactions as 'natural' while being completely detached from their actual feelings is a beautifully subtle character revelation.
... Read More
The structure of these chapters is doing some serious heavy lifting and I want to talk about how the author uses the mirror device to control pacing in a way that keeps you constantly turning pages. Every time we're with Chloe and things start getting calm or cozy — she's happily working at the inn, chatting with Pastor Grace, using her powers to maintain the barrier, feeling genuinely appreciated for the first time — BOOM, we cut to the mirror and the prince drops some absolutely devastating plot development. It's like the author is playing tug-of-war with your emotions and intentionally making you choose which world to feel sad for. Chloe: 'Maybe it was a mistake for me to have been born as an aristocrat.' She's happy. She's found warmth. She's content. Prince: 'Before you make it to the convent, you are to seduce Chloe.' ...Oh. That contrast is devastating pacing. The sections with Chloe have a lighter, warmer rhythm — dialogue flows naturally, there's humor, physical labor, community. Then we shift to the observation reports and the tone becomes clinical, cold, manipulative. The prince speaks in short, commanding sentences. Shin's responses are fragmented and distressed. The structural shift itself mirrors the emotional shift. And that ending — 'You said it yo' — the text cuts off mid-sentence, which I assume continues into the next chapter. Classic cliffhanger that makes you desperate to keep reading.
... Read More
Okay. Okay. Let me just sit with this for a second because my chest hurts. Locke. Locke Locke Locke. The boy who carved his name on a tree that was immediately cut down? The boy who still remembers THREE YEARS ago that Momo promised him she'd never let herself be replaced and if she ever did, he'd have to stop her? And he KNEW. He actually suspected for three years and pretended not to notice while everything fell apart around him. "I should've noticed at that time." - Locke literally says this out loud, in plain text, and I nearly threw my phone across the room. Not because it's dramatic in an over-the-top way, but because it's so quiet. So understated. He's describing how Momo walked into the church three years ago and suddenly spoke differently, suddenly read ancient books that priests couldn't touch, and he felt something was wrong but said nothing. The promise between them - just Momo and Locke, nobody else knows, nobody else can know - that's devastating on its own. But the real dagger? He didn't want to face the truth. "I kept averting my eyes from it, not wanting to face the truth." He loved her so much that even the suspicion was painful, and he chose denial because the alternative was losing his childhood friend. Three years of that. Three years of watching the girl he loved become someone else and doing nothing. And now here he is, sword pointed at someone wearing Momo's face, saying he'll "accept" the imposter... only to reveal the promise and draw his blade. His face is full of sorrow the entire time. He doesn't WANT to fight her. He wants to save her. There's a difference. Meanwhile Leddorio is just standing there watching this unfold, and I love him so much for it. The way he watches Locke with this mix of sympathy and confusion - he doesn't fully understand the depth of what Locke is going through, but he can SEE it. He can see the pain behind the mask. That moment where Leddorio realizes this is a promise only between Momo and Locke, and he can't possibly know about it? His silence says everything. And Momo herself - the real one, wherever she is - the only trace we get of her is this single promise made before the divine power assessment. She knew something was coming. She asked Locke to be the one to stop her if she ever lost herself. That's the most terrifying thing in the entire chapter. She saw it coming. She prepared. And she couldn't prevent it anyway. Who is the real Momo right now? Is she trapped somewhere? Is she the one controlling this body, or is this an imposter entirely? Locke's line 'Where did my childhood friend go?' hits different when you realize it might be literal. I don't think she's gone. I think she's buried. And Locke is the only one who knows how to dig her out. Also can we talk about how Leddorio and Chloe's relationship keeps showing up as this steady background hum while everyone else is having emotional breakdowns? Chloe rides in on a winged white horse through an explosion of sacred magic and saves everyone? That woman has been patient. THREE CHAPTERS of waiting and she still shows up exactly when needed. I love her so much and I need more of her alone.
... Read More
The dialogue in this batch is doing SO much heavy lifting and I want to appreciate the craft. Chloe's speech is the standout. Listen to this: "It is only right that I, who is neither suited to be the queen, nor deserving of the title of the Saintess, to face the consequences of my sins." The grammar is deliberately imperfect—she's not a polished politician, she's a woman who has fallen from grace and is clawing her way back. The rawness reads differently than, say, Keith's dialogue: "I happen to have this recording right here you see..." —smooth, casual, almost bored. He's holding all the cards and he knows it. Then there's the internal monologue that cuts through everything. Momo's thought: "You said I'm the only one, and yet you're having a date with Missouri!" This is pure, unfiltered, teenage heartbreak. It's written in first-person immediacy while everything else is third-person omniscient. That shift in voice makes it hit like a punch to the gut. And Leddorio's brother just saying "Don't say that brother. After all, he was there as your substitute because you left the capital" with that casual, impudent tone while the narration tells us Leddorio is "staring daggers"—the contrast between what's said and what's felt is the author's signature move. Every line is doing double duty.
... Read More
The conflict in these chapters operates on so many levels simultaneously and it's genuinely exhausting just thinking about it. On the surface, it's a love triangle — or rather, a love square, because you've got Masumi, her husband Soma, Sei, and now Momo all tangled up. But the real conflict is internal, and that's what makes it so much worse. Sei has given up on having a normal life. He knows he can't have Masumi. He's accepted that Missouri is just a political arrangement. He's wallowing in this self-created narrative of tragic romance. And then Momo shows up and SLAPS him — literally and metaphorically — saying "If you keep doing that to everyone, the lady you have truly fallen with will not look your way, you know!?" Here's the thing that makes this conflict so devastating: Momo isn't even wrong. Her words pierce through his carefully constructed defense mechanisms because they hit on a truth he's been avoiding. All his wandering, all his meaningless encounters with other women — it's not freedom, it's self-destruction. He's punishing himself for loving someone he can't have, and in the process, he's making himself unlovable to anyone who might actually care. The stakes here aren't life-or-death in the traditional sense. There's no dragon attack, no war, no assassination attempt. But the emotional stakes feel just as high. Sei's entire identity is built around this forbidden love. If he lets go of it, even for a moment, what's left? A hollow man married to a doll, visiting random ladies, pretending he doesn't care. And the irony — the absolute gut-punch of irony — is that Momo, this commoner girl he barely knows, is the first person who actually SEES him. Not the noble second son, not the tragic romantic, just... Sei. And he can't even accept that kindness without immediately turning it into another layer of his suffering.
... Read More
"It hurts! Stop it!" I read that line five times because it's so simple but it just DESTROYS me. This woman — former saintess, abandoned by her prince, living under a borrowed name in a mountain lodging — was literally just trying to do something nice for someone. She baked cookies. She wanted to feel useful. She wanted to be KIND. And this guy reaches for her hair like it's a prop in his mission to expose her. The fact that the magic ADHERES to her scalp makes it worse. It's like her new identity is literally sticking to her whether she wants it to or not. And then the mistress — this older woman running the lodging — just SMACKS Dai with a rolling pin without hesitation. Protective instinct over pure plot mechanics. And then Dai yells about having "Momo" so he can mind his own business, completely missing that Momo is RIGHT THERE watching this unfold on a mirror screen. The emotional whiplash of that moment — vulnerability, violence, misplaced loyalty, surveillance — it's exhausting just to write about. I kept feeling like I needed to sit with it.
... Read More
Okay so let me just... this plot is layers upon layers and I genuinely cannot process how much is going on in these four chapters. Prince Yello swoops in, claims Chloe is Chaco Brown, forces her back to the capital as saintess substitute—wait, what? And it turns out he already knows everything about her? Like, actually everything? That scene where he's like 'You should have realized that considering that I came all the way here' gave me CHILLS. This guy is playing 4D chess while literally everyone else is moving pawns. But the real plot bombshell for me was the dragon moment. Prince Keith rides in on a literal SKY DRAGON named Citrin, gift from his fiancée Canaria. And Leddorio's internal monologue about what the dragon REPRESENTS—Corundum Kingdom backing the 2nd prince—is such a clean exposition drop without feeling forced. The political chess game is REAL and I am HERE for it. Also Momo's hatred is becoming such a central thread. She's sitting there glares daggers at Chloe while Chloe's over here having the time of her life riding a dragon like a total gremlin. And then Momo brings up the sacred rainbow bird as if to say 'only THAT would fit a true saintess.' Is she implying Chloe is a false saint? Or is she actually trying to summon/identify the bird? Because the text says something about the prince feeling like she was 'trying to emphasize something' and I need answers NOW. Keith watching the watchers by leaning behind a wall while everyone observes Chloe is the most villainous thing I've ever seen. He's playing everyone. The chapter ends on 'It appears that her ladyship does remember my face. Does she not, Lady Chloe Sereknight' and I am SCREAMING. WHO IS THIS PERSON? Why do they know Chloe's real name? What's the actual plan here?
... Read More
The sibling rivalry between Leddorio and Keith is absolutely fascinating and it's not even the main conflict — it's simmering beneath everything. Keith shows up uninvited and drops this bombshell about marrying Momo like he's discussing the weather. The way Leddorio physically tries to push him back out of the room says everything about how much this threatens him. And Keith's line "If older brother was that worried, he should have had her imprisoned rather than banishing her away" cuts right to the heart of the political stakes. What makes this conflict so compelling is that everyone's stakes are different. Leddorio sees Chloe as a threat to Momo and needs to monitor her. Keith sees an opportunity — both political and personal. Momo is caught in the middle without really choosing anything. And Chloe is just trying to survive while being watched by people who think they understand her but don't. The subordinates chiming in about loyalty being separate from love adds another layer — even the people supposed to be unified are fractured. The rising tension isn't just about whether Chloe will be discovered. It's about what happens when two princes with competing claims on the same future collide. Keith calling Momo "my fiancée" in front of Leddorio's entire retinue is basically a power move wrapped in a compliment. And the fact that nobody can outright stop him because "we will become family anyway whoever she decides to marry" — that line is so diplomatically violent. The stakes here aren't just romantic, they're about power, succession, and who gets to tell the story.
... Read More
I need to talk about Shin because HOLY. This guy is a masterpiece of repressed emotion. Watch how he walks this razor's edge between duty and desire. When Chloe teases him about being jealous of Locke, his reaction is NOT what you'd expect from a typical loyal servant character. Let me quote this: "Not because she was related to Miss Momo… but how the lady is acting so overly-familiar with him." CHLOE IS THE ONE HE'S JEALOUS OF, not Momo! The man is so deeply in love with his mistress that he's possessive of HER attention, not Momo's. And then he immediately backpedals with "I have overstepped my bounds" like a panicked deer. The prince literally hears this and is SHOOK. But here's what gut-punched me—Chloe's reaction. She doesn't flirt back. She doesn't dismiss it. She goes completely still. The text says she was "petrified." For a character who's been manipulative and calculating throughout, this is the first time she's truly been caught off-guard emotionally. And Shin? He's not performing. This wasn't part of the seduction mission anymore. That's when I knew his feelings were real. Meanwhile, Locke and Momo's backstory is tragic in the best way. He remembers a "clumsy airhead" childhood friend, but she's now the Saintess-Queen. The gap between who she was and who she's become—he's mourning that loss while everyone else is fighting over the current version. Classic tragic misunderstanding trope done RIGHT.
... Read More
So the author is playing this really smart structural game across these chapters where we keep cutting between Chloe's POV and the prince's POV, and I need to discuss how well it works because honestly it's one of the strongest pacing choices in the entire book. Let me break it down. We start with the prince's camp—their whispered conversations, their manipulative planning. Then we cut to Chloe, who is immediately established as competent and self-directed. She refuses the carriage. She proposes staying at the church. She identifies the barrier problem. She explains why Momo can't handle the dungeon. Each of these beats comes with quiet confidence, and the transition between the two perspectives creates this delicious dramatic irony where we know what the prince is plotting while also seeing Chloe outmaneuvering him without even trying. The pacing also benefits from the natural tension between these two timelines. The prince's scenes are tight, conspiratorial, full of hushed dialogue and sneering observations. Chloe's scenes breathe differently—they're practical, grounded, occasionally dryly humorous (her reading of the prince's harassment as romantic interest is genuinely funny). The switch between these modes prevents either from becoming monotonous. And that author's note at the end? "The narrator seems to switch from third person to the first prince's out of nowhere"—which confirms this deliberate structural choice. The author isn't accidentally jumping perspectives; this is intentional narrative design. The result is that by chapter fourteen, I'm not just invested in whether Chloe survives, I'm invested in watching the gap between her understanding of events and the prince's understanding widen. The pacing doesn't rush this tension—it lets it simmer. Which means when the next conflict hits, it'll probably absolutely wreck me.
... Read More
Can we just talk about how uncomfortable this whole scene with Keith makes you feel? He shows up, uses a sacred magic silence spell to have a private conversation, and the FIRST thing he says is basically "Momo is going to be punished." Like he's not even pretending it's up for debate. Chloe's the one who sealed her away, and Keith is already framing her as the one who should take credit for the Saintess title. He's not asking what she wants. He's telling her what's going to happen. And Chloe? She just sits there and takes it. She explains everything — the past life, the player vessel, the personality separation — and when Keith throws the church angle at her, she doesn't fight back. She tries. She says "She was not the one who did it, sir!" but it's not a real fight. It's the protest of someone who knows the system won't listen. What's terrifying is that Keith isn't even a villain. He's just a guy doing what he thinks is necessary. He's the crown prince — he has to think about the kingdom, the church, stability. Momo became a witch, scared people, banished nobility, collapsed caverns. Even if it wasn't really her, the damage is real. The stakes aren't abstract. Real people are hurt. Real institutions are threatened. That's what makes this conflict so good. It's not good vs. evil. It's order vs. mercy, and both sides have points. Keith could be right. The church COULD justify what they're doing. And that uncertainty — that nobody gets to feel righteous here — is what keeps you turning pages.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or