Annette - Reviews

Annette
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are absolutely terrifying because they're so subtle. On the surface, it's a dinner party. Everyone's eating, drinking, making jokes. But underneath? Every word is a test. Every compliment from Volker and Dietrich is an attempt to recruit him. Every question from the vassals is measuring his loyalty. Reingart's conflict isn't just internal anymore—it's external, immediate, and dangerous. If he sides with one brother, he alienates the other. If he remains neutral, he risks offending both. And through it all, he's watching this woman who can't understand half of what's being said, wondering if he should do something, anything, to help her. But what would helping her cost him? She's the Emperor's gift. Speaking for her, translating for her, acknowledging her humanity—it could mark him as sympathetic to prisoners of war, as someone who questions the natural order. In a world where bastards aren't acknowledged and princesses aren't heard, where might he fall? Where would his loyalties place him? The scene with the brothers asking about northern women is particularly chilling because it reveals the full scope of what's at stake. These men are discussing sexual violence as if it's a casual topic—because for them, it is. And Reingart, who has fought alongside them, who has received their mockery and their false friendship, realizes that staying silent is survival. But how much of your soul do you sacrifice to survive? And that ending! "If it became known she was..." What would happen if anyone knew the Countess was actually a princess? Would Reingart be implicated? Would she be punished? The tension is unbearable and I cannot stop thinking about it.
... Read More
I need to talk about the cats. Just—cats. The book opens by telling us Annette is afraid of CATS. Of all things. A domestic housepet. This isn't random worldbuilding, people. Cats are territorial, unpredictable, they scratch when you try to hold them too tight. They're also associated with witchcraft and omens in European folklore. Annette's fear of cats is the story's first symbolic hint that her life is governed by invisible, unpredictable threats that she can't reason with or control. Then there's the bonnet. That 'spotless white' bonnet she stole from a maid? White = purity, which is what she's being told she HAS to perform while being systematically violated. But it's also BLINDING—she wears it to hide her face, to become invisible, to disappear. Only Reingart knocks it off and SEE HER for the first time in months. And the color white appears everywhere: the bonnet, the candle she carries (a fragile light in darkness), the pale moon she gazes at before her nightly self-harm ritual. Light and whiteness as symbols of both hope and exposure. But the most powerful symbol is honestly the BEDROOM ITSELF. The Count keeps her in the marital chamber as a spectator to his affairs—not as a wife, not as a person, but as WITNESS. The bed, which should symbolize intimacy and partnership, becomes a theater of humiliation. And she can't leave. She's trapped in the very space meant for connection, made to watch connection happen without her. Every night, the same cycle. The author also does something brilliant with the prayer scene—'O Hervantes, God of Judgment. I earnestly beseech you to punish the filthy usurper.' Annette PRAYS for her abuser's death, then immediately asks to be punished along with him for having such thoughts. That's not faith—that's religious trauma weaponized against herself. The gods aren't saving her; they've been turned into another instrument of her oppression. And yet—there IS a glimmer at the end. Reingart, who speaks her language, who came home from war, who notices things. He might be the first person who sees her as HUMAN rather than prop or prisoner. But I'm terrified of what his arrival means. Because in stories like this, when a hero appears, the villain ALWAYS notices.
... Read More
Let me just sit with this for a moment. The moment Annette realizes Reingart is touching her body without permission — that her entire life as a noblewoman, even stripped of her princess title, has never allowed a man this close, not even her husband — and it hits her in the middle of trying to escape for her life. The fact that the author makes us feel this through silence, through the heat of his palm, the grip on her arm, the faint scent of incense on his chest... that's not romanticized noncon, that's a character realizing exactly how powerless she is in this moment and it changes something inside her. "Her skirt was still tangled around the man's legs." This line. Just this one line after all that running and caught-breath and terrified staring. The physical closeness is almost accidental but it's charged with everything neither of them is saying. And then Reingart's POV! Oh my god. After she leaves, he stands there for a LONG time. He can't leave his spot because he's worried she'll come back out. And then he catches himself grinning like an idiot and actually scolds himself for it. "Are you laughing? In this situation?" The man is a battlefield veteran who's killed countless people and yet here he is, haunted by the feeling of a woman's breath on his fingers and the weight of her arm in his hand. "I just need to watch carefully for a while. Let it flow like nothing happened." He tells himself this like it's strategy. But the way he lingers in the darkness, smelling flowers, going over every detail of that encounter — this man is NOT fine with letting it flow like nothing happened. Their power dynamic is SO complicated. He has all the physical power, she has all the social power (technically), but neither of them fits neatly into those categories anymore. She's a nobody princess married to a count. He's a knight of common birth who's being told to become the count's greatest vassal. They're both playing roles someone else wrote for them. And the fact that he speaks her language — her real language, not the court language of Trisen — and THAT's why she finally unloads everything on him? That's the author telling us something important about trust. She doesn't trust nobles. She doesn't trust the Emperor. She trusts the one person who speaks to her like she's a human being. Also the line "He's a knight. A man a head taller than her with longer legs and a muscular body. There was no way she could shake off such an opponent. But if she was going to die anyway" — ANNETTE RAN. She literally ran for the first time in her life. This woman who spent four months living as a caged noblewoman sprinted through a moonlit castle like her life depended on it. Because it did. I need to talk about the flashback briefly though because it completely reframes everything. Lederhart — her childhood friend, the most honorable knight on the continent — BEHEADED THE KING. With the sword of his oath. And Annette still believed he would protect her even as the palace fell. The betrayal isn't just political, it's personal. It's intimate. And I wonder if that's why she reads Reingart's fear as truth instead of deception. Because everyone she trusted has already proven they'll cut her down.
... Read More
There's a reason the blacksmith scenes keep appearing. The forge, the furnace, the hammer striking iron — this isn't accidental imagery. The entire text is obsessed with the question of transformation under pressure, and it's asking whether people are forged or broken. Reingart is literally heating metal in a furnace while metaphorically heating up around this woman he can't acknowledge. The iron starts cold, then glows orange from the edges inward. Slow, inevitable, irreversible. He's afraid of getting used to comfort — of being softened. But his softening is happening anyway, in the smallest ways: skipping dinner to avoid her, then skipping dinner because he's worried about her. One contradiction after another. Annette's arc is the darker side of the same theme. The text asks directly: "Will I adapt like that too? Will I keep living here, cursing my enemies and burning their names? And if I don't live that way?" She's watching the maid — a tool for amusement, discarded when no longer useful — and seeing her own reflection. The coldness of the manor, the numbness she's developing, the way she told herself she'd rather die than submit — and yet here she is, surviving by adapting. The most devastating symbol in the whole passage is probably the candlestick. Annette walking back down the corridor gripping it until her knuckles turn white. Light in darkness. A small flame she's carrying through the cold. It's the opposite of the forge — not transformation through fire, but endurance through cold. Two different kinds of survival, two different kinds of strength. And that question hanging over everything: what happens when the person who hurt you is also the person who makes you feel alive? The text isn't answering it yet. It's letting the fire burn.
... Read More
I need to talk about the scene where Annette writes her nightly curse letters and then burns them in the fireplace. I read this part like four times. FOUR TIMES. Because the way the author describes it—'like a queen burning traitors at the stake'—that image just destroyed me. She's sitting alone in her room, writing down three names with such precision and hatred, pressing especially hard on 'Gallant Rothe,' her own husband. Her husband. The man she married. The man she's been abandoned by. And then the most devastating line hits: 'She hoped this letter she sent every night would catch the god's attention, that her daily pleas would annoy him enough to grant her wish.' Annoy him enough. She's bargaining with God like a child bargaining with a parent. This woman who was once a princess, who dreamed of ruling alongside her perfect Duke Ferbrante—now she's reduced to whispering 'kill him' inside her prayers because she can't even say it out loud. The tragedy of her daily routine being 'decidedly sacred and the only enjoyable time' makes my chest hurt. That's not okay. That is NOT okay for anyone to feel like cursing her enemies is the only joy she has left.
... Read More
Okay, so let me just talk about Annette for a second because my heart is literally aching for her right now. She was a princess—actual princess—who used to have a whole staff of noble ladies-in-waiting and she couldn't have even imagined saying 'thank you' to a maid. And now? She's sitting in her room, polite to the servants, trying so desperately to win their favor like it matters. The contrast is brutal. She used to be the chatty princess, right? Everyone in the palace called her that because she wouldn't stop talking. Now she's essentially mute because nobody understands her and nobody wants to talk to her. And Reingart—oh my god, Reingart. That moment when she's lying in bed after he spares her life and thinks about his eyes, how they wavered even though they were cold during the day. She keeps asking herself whether she can trust him. But here's the thing that got me: she STILL decides to trust him. Even after everything—the betrayal, the fallen kingdom, the men who killed her family—she whispers to herself 'I'll trust you. Your promise to keep it secret.' She's so careful about trusting but she still does it anyway. That's not weakness, that's actually incredibly brave in the most painful way.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or