A Horror Game Steeped in Immorality - Reviews

A Horror Game Steeped in Immorality
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let me just— eleven servants murdered in the morning?? That is such a bold move by the author. I mean, obviously we're used to nighttime kills in these horror games, but NO, the killer just decided to flex during broad daylight and commit TWELVE murders (including the first one mentioned at the start). This is a complete pattern break and it immediately told me something is off about how this killer operates. Also the fact that Daymond was in BED with the protagonist until noon completely exonerates him, which is... wait, is that the red herring or the real twist? I need to sit with this. And then the side mission about Selena? Finding a dismembered maid in the dead of night while the main murderer is supposedly out there somewhere is genuinely insane logic but also perfect for this genre because it forces the protagonist into the most vulnerable position possible—alone in a bloody mansion with limited time. The mission design itself is almost cruel, which honestly fits the tone. And don't get me started on the ending where Selena literally throws herself out the window and the radar doesn't show up. cliffhanger city.
... Read More
Okay but did she actually JUST ASK to RUN AWAY with her brother? Like, one minute she's hyperventilating in a closet surrounded by murder evidence, and the next she's grabbing Lionel's hand and whispering, “Should we... run away?” And he's just like, “You are my everything. I'm not giving up anything; I'm choosing to live my life by your side.” I'M SCREAMING. The stakes were already insane—daily missions involving massages that could get them killed, a murderer roaming the halls, this creepy system talking to her—but somehow deciding to ABANDON EVERYTHING and flee into the night felt like the ultimate escalation. They packed gold, jewels, clothes, food, snuck out through the back gate while the guards were distracted, and hopped in a carriage at dawn. And then on the ride, instead of relief, she's just... haunted. Wondering if this was smart, wondering if they can actually survive like this. That moment when she catches her reflection and sees Lionel watching her lips? Chilling. He says something about resenting being her younger brother, like he wishes he'd been her twin or even been in the womb with her. THAT IS NOT ROMANTIC. That is obsessive and terrifying, and she knows it.
... Read More
The voice in this chapter is genuinely hilarious. Like, right in the middle of a horror sequence she's out here saying things like "Like it's some weather forecast" and "What the f*ck, where did the time go" and when she's literally drowning in corpses she starts comparing herself to a kid digging for clams. The tonal whiplash between pure terror and casual swearing is exactly what makes this book enjoyable. She's not some delicate heroine who screams and faints—she curses, she adapts, she gets weirdly philosophical about maggots being protein. And her internal monologue when Selena gives her that grotesque fake smile? "That's supposed to be a smile?" COME ON. The narrator's attitude is a survival mechanism and it's brilliant writing. Then she says to the reanimated corpse "Hang in there, Selena. Be careful not to lose your limbs next time." I was wheezing. The author clearly understands that humor in horror isn't tonal inconsistency—it's character.
... Read More
I literally screamed when she opened that box. Six hours of crawling through corridors covered in blood and corpse mess, and for WHAT? “You've obtained ‘Seaweed Stem,' good for your body and tasty!” My heart actually broke for her. The system is so cruel—it shows these glowing boxes, makes you pick like it's some game show, and then hands you seaweed. She just slumped to the floor staring at it, all those dark memories rushing back. And the worst part? The hallway cleans itself instantly. All the blood and bodies just vanish. It's like the house doesn't care what happened here. Then Lionel appears out of nowhere, pulls her into his chest, tells everyone to leave, and just holds her while she sobs. I swear to god the shift from “dead bodies everywhere” to “I won seaweed stem” to “brother is holding me while I cry” is so abrupt it made my head spin. But honestly? It worked. I was right there with her, crying over the absurdity of it all. That line about the morning sun wrapping around them? Perfect ending to the whole nightmare sequence.
... Read More
There's a lot going on symbolically in this chapter and I think the strongest thread is the motif of mirrors and reflections. Right after the intimate scene, Leah catches her own reflection in Lionel's blue eyes — "I gazed at my reflection in the blue of his eyes." That's such a loaded image. She sees herself through him, completely absorbed into his perception. Later, when she's running back to the mansion terrified, she looks at her bloodied hand and the shattered glass from the window. The glass becomes this moment of truth — fragmented, sharp, dangerous. But the ultimate mirror moment is at the end. The camera captures the crime scene and the reflection in it is HER. Not Lionel, not some external villain, but Leah herself covered in blood. The camera — a device for recording reality — becomes a device for revealing self. This is the book saying: you can look everywhere for the monster, but the monster is the one holding the lens. The recurring motif of the radar is also significant. It's called the "You Can Do It Too Radar" — which on the surface sounds encouraging but is actually deeply ironic. It points to danger, but the danger isn't where you expect it. The technology that should provide clarity actually provides the opposite. The items the system keeps giving her (camera, spear, radar) are all tools for investigation, but they keep leading her to impossible conclusions. And the blood. So much blood imagery — her cut palm from the glass, the blood on her clothes, the murdered servant, the corpses. Blood as evidence, blood as identity, blood as the thing that can't be washed away no matter how many times she tries. The clapping at the end... what does that mean? Mechanical. Detached. Almost childlike in its absurdity. Like her psyche is literally breaking apart in real time.
... Read More
So Daymond and the protagonist have been sleeping together and he's being all sweet, cleaning her up and whispering love. But here's the thing—when she wakes up to a massacre and finds out he COULDN'T have done it because he was with her, she literally just stares at the ceiling while he's branding her with kisses. She's so emotionally checked out at this point. And then Lionel shows up every single morning just to keep her company?? These two men are orbiting her and neither of them is the killer, apparently, which means the real threat is someone else entirely and that's somehow more terrifying. The protagonist's relationship with Daymond feels physical but increasingly hollow on her end. She's going through the motions. Meanwhile Lionel's there like a good boy who actually notices she moved to the annex. I just hope someone here is secretly evil because the emotional stakes need to go somewhere. Also the way she says "He whispered his one-sided love to me"—that implies she doesn't feel the same, or can't. Tragic honestly.
... Read More
I'm going to talk about dialogue because honestly the way Lionel speaks is the most memorable thing about this entire passage. His lines are a masterclass in creepy-romantic energy. Let me just list some favorites: "No one maintains dignity in front of livestock." — Said after they literally just had sex in a public carriage. This man's priorities are immaculate. "You don't need to be embarrassed." — After she's mortified. He just erases her feelings with one sentence. "I wouldn't mind dying by Sister's hand." — This is supposed to be romantic and it IS, and that's the problem. "I'll make a knife myself, with a handle that's soft to the touch... Just until then, please..." — He's being threatened with a broken bottle and he's TROUBLING HIMSELF about whether the grip will be comfortable. THIS MAN. The narrative voice of the narrator (Leah) is also distinct — very interior, very reactive, constantly oscillating between desire and terror. Her dialogue with Lionel shifts from breathless moans to full-blown accusations, and the transition feels earned because the writing never lets us forget that fear and attraction are occupying the same space in her head. The system messages are such a weird but effective counterpoint to the human dialogue. "[The system operates with precise standards and equity.]" Said like a customer service rep. While the actual characters are having psychotic breaks. And that ending — the clapping. No dialogue. Just the sound. It's the most dialogue-free moment in the entire chapter and somehow the most devastating. Sometimes the author knows when to shut up.
... Read More
There are symbols stacked so thick in this passage I barely know where to start. The orange letters first. Orange is the color of warning - road signs, hazard tape, emergency alerts. Everything the system announces is wrapped in this color, and then blood literally floods over it. The game's rules are stained with violence from page one. The system says "The mansion will be drenched in the carnage of the murderer" and then the very next image is blood pouring over text. That's not coincidence. The game and the violence are inseparable. Then there's Daymond's black leather gloves. Every time they appear, they signal domination. The text specifically notes how the glossy leather accentuates his powerful grip, how the sound of white fabric being crushed against black leather sounded almost like a scream. White and black, victim and predator, innocence and corruption - it's all there in those gloves. And when he finally rips them off to bite her, to kiss her, to touch her bare skin - that's when the mask comes off. The gloves were his armor as the controlling father figure; without them, he's just a raw, predatory animal. The cigarette smoke is another layer. It billows over Leah's face the moment she wakes, choking her, disorienting her. Smoke obscures vision, hides truth. Daymond operates in this haze constantly - you never know if his threats are real, if his lust is genuine, if any of this is performance. Even his line about feeding her his semen every night while she slept - was that always happening? Or is that another lie designed to shatter her sense of reality? And the line "Only I can enter the hole I've made" - what is that if not a perversion of creation itself? A father claiming ownership over the very body he brought into the world. The symbolism of biological origin twisted into sexual possession is just horrifying and brilliant.
... Read More
There's something deeply unsettling about how the protagonist treats Selena's corpse. She sews her back together mechanically, like it's just a task, and then Selena thanks her and jumps out a window. The symbolism here is wild—Selena represents all the disposable people in this mansion, the servants whose deaths barely register in the bigger picture. The protagonist has to touch and handle and physically assemble these broken bodies, and in doing so she's confronting the literal cost of the game. The blackened tongue stuffed back into Selena's mouth, the haphazard stitches, the way she tells herself "they were just protein struggling to live"—this is about dissociation as survival. You have to stop feeling to keep going. And the fact that Selena's gratitude manifests as self-destruction? That's on brand for horror. The living throw themselves away. The dead just want to leave. There's also the crows gathering outside, drawn by the smell—classic omen imagery, and the birds circling like witnesses to everything this house has swallowed.
... Read More
There are some really heavy thematic layers here that I don't think we should just skip over. The system itself is the biggest symbol in play. Remember how the narrator noted that the system never asked her to be "mentally prepared" for anything like this before? The system started as just a game mechanic but it's clearly evolved — daily missions, escalating sexual content, threats of GAME OUT. It's not just giving orders anymore, it's reshaping her moral compass piece by piece. The mission system functions as an external force corrupting natural human bonds, turning sibling relationships into commodities to be managed and completed. Then there's the substitution motif that keeps coming back. Lionel literally says it: "Are you letting me touch you as a substitute for Mom even now?" The mother is dead or absent, and both children are using each other to fill that void — first emotionally (touching her breasts as a child to stop crying), then sexually. The substitution goes from comfort to obsession, from innocent to depraved, and the text keeps blurring that line on purpose. The bruise on Leah's wrist is another symbol I can't let go of. She tells him not to leave marks, knows Lycan would freak out, but Lionel leaves one anyway. Every single day. It's a brand, a claim of ownership, something visible that proves what happened between them. And when she rubs it in the bathwater and it only gets redder? That's the inevitability of their situation — there's no washing this away. And Lycan's bleeding hand — what does that represent? Violence, yes, but also sacrifice. He's willing to destroy himself (and others) for her. The 97% threat level isn't just a game number, it's a ticking clock on how much more abuse the world can take before someone breaks. The story keeps asking: who is the real monster here, the brother who wants to possess his sister, or the system that forces them into this?
... Read More
I need to talk about Lionel because THIS MAN IS CRAZY and I'm obsessed. First, he shows up right after her breakdown and just... holds her. No questions, no judgment. “It's alright, sister. Everything's okay.” He doesn't ask what happened, doesn't demand details. He just wraps his arms around her and lets her sob into his chest while the servants retch in the background. Sweet. Protective. Then a week later, he's still there, bathing her, feeding her, watching over her like she's the most precious thing in the world. But when she asks to run away? That's when the real Lionel comes out. He agrees immediately, doesn't hesitate, packs the gold and jewels, arranges the carriage—all while she's barely functional. And then on the ride, he just... unravels. “I resent being your younger brother,” he says, crying, saying he wishes he could have been her twin or even been in the womb with her. THE AUDACITY. He's confessing inappropriate feelings while sobbing and his body is literally reacting to her scent. And she knows it. She notices his “front bulging” and feels guilty but also responsible because of those damn daily missions. The power dynamic is SO twisted—she's using him for survival, but he's using her for something far darker. And yet... I can't stop rooting for them. Even as the scene gets increasingly violent, there's this strange tenderness underneath. His tears, his whispers, the way he kisses her eyes while she's in pain. It's toxic, yes, but also achingly human.
... Read More
Okay so I NEED to talk about this reveal because my jaw was literally on the floor. The whole game we're fed this misdirection that Leah Albert is the killer, right? Our protagonist is standing there facing this monstrous version of herself, covered in blood and clapping like a maniac, stabbing herself in the face. And then she solves it by saying the SYSTEM'S NAME instead of accusing anyone. Not 'the murderer is Leah Albert'—she calls out the game itself. That is SUCH a smart way to win. It's not a conventional 'I found the clue' moment; she had to understand the META nature of the whole thing. The system orchestrated all the murders using her face. She literally couldn't name 'Leah Albert' as the killer because... it was HER face, but not HER doing it. Genius. The way the system dissolves after being named—the dialogue box shattering into unknown languages is such a cool visual for 'the game is over.' But here's what keeps me up at night: if the system is gone, why is she STILL here? The logout option appears but she's not leaving. What's the catch? And more importantly—was Daymond part of the system or was he genuinely locked away? Because if the system manipulated him too, that changes EVERYTHING about their relationship going forward.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or